Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Another thing non-authenticists ought to avoid is too much reliance on the King James Bible's account for an accurate description of the events surrounding the suffering, death and burial of Jesus Christ. If John 19:40 (about the burial customs) is an accurate account, then so, presumably is John 20:12 (in which two Angels appear to Mary Magdalene). Why not?


OK, say we agree that the Biblical accounts are highly unreliable and discard them. What evidence do you have for any of the events surrounding the alleged crucifixion? What evidence do you have for the existence of Christ?

Furthermore, we really have little idea what the burial customs really were, or how they might have been amendable in the case of a) a convicted criminal or b) the imminence of the Sabbath. If they were completed on the evening of Jesus's death, then we must ask ourselves why the women went back two days later, for example. Archaeological evidence is extremely meagre, and written instructions either date from hundreds of years before, or tens of years after, the events of the crucifixion.


OK, say we have no idea what the usual burial customs were, or what was done in the burial in question. How will you connect the cloth to this particular first century burial?
 
theprestige:
The radiocarbon dating is a real thorn in the authenticist side, but it is not, to them, fatal, and I think I am being fair to them if I say that they deal with it in terms of a preponderance of evidence. If nine friends tell you a car is blue, and one says it is red, it is probably fair to say that he may be mistaken. If he produces a photo of the red car, then one might still think that it has been recently resprayed, or that he simply took a photo of the wrong car. The point is not that his evidence would normally considered faulty, but that the weight of the alternative evidence is considered preponderant. In simple terms, that also applies to the the authenticists view of the Shroud. Curiously, exactly the same logic was used by the authors of the paper on the radiocarbon dating, to account for some anomalies in the results, so the general value of such reasoning should not be rejected. The non-authenticist view, of course, is that none of the nine friends is particularly reliable, being either blind, drunk, guessing, lying, or relying on another unreliable source, so that there is no good reason to question the red photo.

Lucian:
"The image on the cloth doesn't look the way one would expect a dead body lying on its back to look." Really? One the contrary, it looks exactly as one would expect a crucified body to look, if it had been carried in a state of rigor mortis from cross to tomb and its arms pulled into position for burial. You disagree? Well, of course, but disagreement is not enough, is it? Not on this forum, it doesn't. Have you any evidence? Mine is Pierre Barbet's Doctor at Calvary, Fred Zugibe's The Crucifixion of Jesus: A Forensic Inquiry and that entertaining little article I mentioned above. What's yours?

JayUtah:
Thanks for your comments, and indeed advice. There is a new article on academia.edu by a scientist whose early peer-reviewed work on X-rays and lasers quite independent of his Shroud studies surely entitles him to be called so, but who nevertheless believes in the authenticity of the Shroud. I think I shall use that as the basis for more considered Shroud discussion on a new thread, if I'm allowed.

Slowvehicle:
Risibility is a god thing, I suppose. Still...

Do I present sindonist claims without disclaimer or rejoinder? Try reading my posts.

In rejoinder to a discussion about special pleading regarding the unique circumstances of the creation of the image, you apply the same reasoning to the far from unique circumstances of the radiocarbon dating of the cloth. In the absence of any 'normal pleading' it is not 'special pleading' to suppose that a crucifixion victim might have been buried in a state of rigor mortis or on a pile of herbs and spices. Considering the large numbers of ancient cloths which have been satisfactorily dated, it is indeed 'special pleading' to suppose that one of them is incorrect without very certain evidence to support it. (Disclaimer: I personally think that the arms were painted or rubbed or imprinted in that position for artistic decorum. However, there are others who disagree, and their views are not contemptible.)

I agree with what you say about rigor mortis. I made that very point. The arms would have to be forcibly brought together to prepare such a body for burial. (Disclaimer: I personally think that the arms were painted or rubbed or imprinted in that position for artistic decorum. However, there are others who disagree, and their views are not contemptible.)

As for the bible, it cannot be used as positive evidence of inauthenticity unless it is generally accepted to be accurate (or at least this particular bit of it). The big Christian arguments against authenticity in the 19th century (and in the d'Arcis memorandum) were that as the bible was the precise word of God, then the word othonia precluded the possibility of a large sheet being the Shroud. I applaud your apparent belief in angels.

Seriously, though, the bible can be useful, but, as I said, one should avoid too much reliance on it, and one certainly shouldn't cherry pick one word from one of the four accounts of the burial of Jesus in order to discredit the Shroud. Only John, which is generally considered to have been the last assembled gospel and from a different tradition, uses the word othonia, and although, as I say, very little is known about the appropriate 'burial custom', Jewish scholars are unanimous that nobody at that time would have been wrapped in strips. The other gospels use sindonion, as I'm sure you know, which certainly does not refer to bandages. Some people consider that John knew of the rather peculiar long thin nature of the shroud, and described it as othonia precisely to distinguish it from a more sheetlike sindonion. Interestingly John is also the only evangelist to describe the raising of Lazarus, whose grave-clothes he also describes as othonia. (Disclaimer: I personally think that the cloth was made long and thin for convenient display purposes above or in front of an altar. However, there are others who disagree, and their views are not contemptible.)

As for "Levitical injunctions about treating dead bodies", there aren't any. Try "Death & Bereavement in Judaism: Ancient Burial Practices" at https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/Judaism/ancientburial.html for a review of biblical instruction.
 
I think the red car blue car analogy only mudies the water with regard to the strength of conclusions to be drawn for the carbon dating tests but also this much spoken preponderance of evidence for the other side. Lets ditch the analogy and lay out this other claim.
 
Hugh Farey (Yesterday 2:08):

“It is true that there is a large body of miraculist belief in the authenticity of the Shroud. The foundations for such a belief are outside the realm of Science, and cannot be discussed form a Scientific point of view. Occasionally Scientists are told that it is unscientific to reject the possibility that wholly supernatural events can occur, which is true. Science is based on the premise that the universe is rational, and there are those who do not accept that premise. However, the correct scientific response is not that the universe cannot be irrational, but that if it is, science cannot investigate it, and so leave it at that. I am not an 'irrationalist', and nor, I think, is the current Pope, who has made it quite clear that for him, God is not a magician who waves a magic wand (I mention this only because I am known as a Catholic, and often accused of recusancy in my relentless rationality, but I'm not going to discuss theology here).”

Science can say when a particular “miracle” can be explained with a scientific method, doing so the miraculous “explanation” (it is not) irrelevant. The more general question about the existence of miracles it is not a scientific issue. It is a philosophical subject. This matter is very wide and difficult to summarize here. But a general rule can be established: “Exceptional claims need exceptional evidence”. I have tried to show how some particular sindonsits’ theories that are essential to them and inevitably leads to proclamation of miraculous.
A classic example is the blood trickles on the back of the head in the Man of Turin. See here: https://shroudofturinwithoutalltheh...-dorsal-blood-on-hair-cropped.png?w=768&h=411 I claim some obvious facts;

-The blood doesn’t flow in form of sinous “rivulets” on the hair.
-The blood doesn’t flows from right to left in a corpse lying on a flat surface ( nor standing up!).
-The blood doesn’t flow making "rivulets" in a head that is resting on a cloth.

My (obvious) claims are very easy to refute: show it! Garlaschelli and Borrini’s experiment was an easy way to show that the trickles of blood of the Shroud are unnatural. I have challenged many times the sindonists to show something similar with the stains of blood in the back of the head. Without answer. No complex theories, no sophisticated mathematics nor expensive devices are needed. Just a bit of realism.

Here my question, Hugh. Do you know any plausible answer to my request?
 
Last edited:
It does not seem to me that you are using terms, the meanings of which you understand.
Nothing strange. My wifi connexion doesn't work well and I was writing with the help of my student dictionary.

The Codex Pray afair is not pareidolia. It is a direct manipulation of language.


The worth of the D'arcis memo and the Clement declaration is not that a Bishop, or a Pope, settled the issue by declaring that the CIQ was not "authentic". The worth of the D'arcis memo and the Clement declaration is that, shortly after the very first reliably recorded appearance of the CIQ, it was the subject of consideration; and there is no earlier reliable record of the CIQ's existence. (The "Pray Codex" identification is a bit of pareidolia on par with the Whangers' "coins".)
I agree on that. The silence about the shroud and the claims contrary to the autenticity by d'Arcis, the pope and the Liège's comission are strong indicators of some kind of fake. But not definitive. And they are independent of the reliability of d'Arcis testimony.
 
Last edited:
theprestige:

Thanks for your comments, and indeed advice. There is a new article on academia.edu by a scientist whose early peer-reviewed work on X-rays and lasers quite independent of his Shroud studies surely entitles him to be called so, but who nevertheless believes in the authenticity of the Shroud. I think I shall use that as the basis for more considered Shroud discussion on a new thread, if I'm allowed.

I am anxiously waiting for it!
 
<snip for focus>

My Dear Mr. Farey:

This apporach dseems to embody the ethical obverse of "just asking questions".

If one is to indulge in the supposition that the anatomically impossible presentation of the representational image on the CIQ is due to the fact that the "body" was supposedly laid on a supposed bed of spices (as opposed to being "bound up" in the spices with "strips" of cloth), but that the image of the arms was produced by a "rubbing", one has supposed oneself out of the possibility that one is still referring to the "actual shroud" used to bury the body of an HJ.

"This is John Henry's typewriter" comes to mind.

Further, if one rejects, or allows contradiction with, the 'god'spiel accounts of the crucifiction (in the Koiné), one supposes oneself out of any possibility that one is defending the "actual shroud" used to "wrap" the body of the MJ.

And one must still deal with the results of the 14 dating, which is primarily considered "wrong" by those who already assume that the CIQ must be "authentic" (and therefore must be ~2000 years old).

One may "hope" that the CIQ is "authentic"; one may "suppose" one's way around the evidence, and make ad hoc rationalizations (and indulge in special pleading) to shore up one's assumed consequent, to one's heart's content. Such an act of devotion does not change the facts.

Ah, well.

BTW, I do apologize for slipping back into the seminarian's habit of using "levitical" (with a small "l") as a shorthand way to refer to all of the "law". I will, in the future, be more precise.

Through it all,

I remain faithfully yours &ct.
 
Last edited:
theprestige:
The radiocarbon dating is a real thorn in the authenticist side, but it is not, to them, fatal, and I think I am being fair to them if I say that they deal with it in terms of a preponderance of evidence. If nine friends tell you a car is blue...

The comparison is not fair. If a reputed doctor tells you have got a pneumonia and nine medicine men say that some bad spirit has thrown to you evil eye it will be advisable to accept the doctor's diagnostic. I am afraid you include in the opposite opinions to the 14C dating some sorcerer's apprentices and no true doctor.

This is a common problem of the aprioristical "neither-nor".
 
Last edited:
. The more general question about the existence of miracles it is not a scientific issue. It is a philosophical subject.

I disagree. If sceince (physics, chemistry, medicine) can't provide an answer to the "miracle," then psychology almost certainly will. I have been to the Cappella della Sacra Sindone in Turin, I have witnessed believers weeping as they knelt in prayer in front of the empty display cabinet that used to contain the dirty tea towel. Not the tea towel itself, but an empty space. All of the miracles suggested for the various anomalies of the tea towel are borne of that pitiful desperation for the CIQ to be real.
 
I disagree. If sceince (physics, chemistry, medicine) can't provide an answer to the "miracle," then psychology almost certainly will. I have been to the Cappella della Sacra Sindone in Turin, I have witnessed believers weeping as they knelt in prayer in front of the empty display cabinet that used to contain the dirty tea towel. Not the tea towel itself, but an empty space. All of the miracles suggested for the various anomalies of the tea towel are borne of that pitiful desperation for the CIQ to be real.

Certo, fra Filippo. Science can explain some believers' behaviours, physical processes, historical antecedents, etc. of particular cases of alleged miracles. But problems such as definition, identification or possibility of miracles in general terms are not scientific. The very category of "miracle" is not scientific but theological or philosophical.
 
Last edited:
theprestige:
The radiocarbon dating is a real thorn in the authenticist side, but it is not, to them, fatal, and I think I am being fair to them if I say that they deal with it in terms of a preponderance of evidence. If nine friends tell you a car is blue, and one says it is red, it is probably fair to say that he may be mistaken.

Two problems here:

1) The analogy is false. It is not about people's testimonies. There is objective evidence for one side.

2) The alleged preponderance of evidence is imaginary. In fact, the authenticy side has no evidence at all.

"The image on the cloth doesn't look the way one would expect a dead body lying on its back to look." Really? One the contrary, it looks exactly as one would expect a crucified body to look, if it had been carried in a state of rigor mortis from cross to tomb and its arms pulled into position for burial.

Does rigor mortis make the arms unnaturally long?

Hans
 
Blood/What difference does it make?

Good morning, Jabba. Welcome back.

Would you please give us a brief explanation of how blood relates to determining age? I don't understand how the shroud can be dated based on the presence or lack of blood. I thank you in advance. :)
Monza,
- Good.
- Somewhere back in time, I started trying to present that explanation. I don't think I got very far. Hopefully, I won't have to track that down.
- For one thing, showing that the stains really were blood would pretty much discredit McCrone -- who has been a major witness for the inauthentic side.
- One step at a time. Would you agree?
 
Monza,
- Good.
- Somewhere back in time, I started trying to present that explanation. I don't think I got very far. Hopefully, I won't have to track that down.
- For one thing, showing that the stains really were blood would pretty much discredit McCrone -- who has been a major witness for the inauthentic side.
- One step at a time. Would you agree?

No, No, NO!!! You still don't understand how the burden of proof works. It doesn't matter a whit what McCrone said. The default position is not "authentic until proven otherwise". The default position is "there is no reason to consider authenticity until some evidence shows up indicating authenticity." When you assert that blood is evidence of authenticity, you need to show how it is POSITIVE evidence of authenticity.
 
Monza,
- Good.
- Somewhere back in time, I started trying to present that explanation. I don't think I got very far. Hopefully, I won't have to track that down.
- For one thing, showing that the stains really were blood would pretty much discredit McCrone -- who has been a major witness for the inauthentic side.
- One step at a time. Would you agree?

All that would show is that McCrone was wrong about there being blood on the cloth. That would do nothing to show that the cloth was the burial shroud of Jesus of Nazareth, or was the right age to be the burial cloth of Jesus of Nazareth.
 
Blood

- Though Hugh Farey disagrees with my ultimate conclusion, he does a much better job of presenting my case than do I. He gives a lot of my answers that I have simply been too slow to give. Hopefully, my one-step-at-a-time will eventually pay off.

Hugh,
- I've asked you about the blood claim before, but can't remember your objections. Could you tell me again?
 
Certo, fra Filippo. Science can explain some believers' behaviours, physical processes, historical antecedents, etc. of particular cases of alleged miracles. But problems such as definition, identification or possibility of miracles in general terms are not scientific. The very category of "miracle" is not scientific but theological or philosophical.

I see "theological" as a synonym for "fantastical"
 
Last edited:
- Though Hugh Farey disagrees with my ultimate conclusion, he does a much better job of presenting my case than do I. He gives a lot of my answers that I have simply been too slow to give. Hopefully, my one-step-at-a-time will eventually pay off.

Hugh,
- I've asked you about the blood claim before, but can't remember your objections. Could you tell me again?

Two days ago you claimed to have "lots of evidence," where is it?
 
Monza,
- Good.
- Somewhere back in time, I started trying to present that explanation. I don't think I got very far. Hopefully, I won't have to track that down.
- For one thing, showing that the stains really were blood would pretty much discredit McCrone -- who has been a major witness for the inauthentic side.
- One step at a time. Would you agree?

My Dear Mr. Savage:

Good Morning!

I must remind you, again, that Dr. McCrone's work with the surface chemicals of the CIQ is independent of the 14C testing; that is, even if you were able to prove that Dr. McCrone was wrong, and that the "blood" on the CIQ was actual human blood (pace the wrong color, the anti-physics behavior, and the lack of [for instance] potassium), you would still have "blood" on a piece of linen that has been dated by three independent laboratories to the mid-thirteenth century C.E.

Let me say that again: Even if the "blood" on the CIQ were conclusively demonstrated to be human blood, that has no bearing at all on the 14C date. As has been pointed out to you, multiple times by multiple posters, human blood is available wherever (and whenever) there are humans.

...and don't presume to continue to ignore my post abut the H&A paper...

Through it all, I remain

Patiently yours &ct.

ETA: FYI, and to forestall search engine complaints:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=10675254#post10675254

You are, of course, most welcome.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom