Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
This is not ananswer. This is a flight of fancy.

It does not seem to me that you are using terms, the meanings of which you understand.

However, at the risk of being identified as a "snarling dog", or an abuser of the helpless:

The worth of the D'arcis memo and the Clement declaration is not that a Bishop, or a Pope, settled the issue by declaring that the CIQ was not "authentic". The worth of the D'arcis memo and the Clement declaration is that, shortly after the very first reliably recorded appearance of the CIQ, it was the subject of consideration; and there is no earlier reliable record of the CIQ's existence. (The "Pray Codex" identification is a bit of pareidolia on par with the Whangers' "coins".)
 
An observation: David and Hugh have both been active on shroudstory.com which, on a cursory glance, looked to be a good-natured place where people who have an interest in the Filthy Dishrag got together to discuss it at length. As someone says in response to Dan Porter's farewell


This place isn't like that. Here, the CIQ is just another mundane item that some people thought was supernatural in origin, but has been thoroughly (spectacularly) debunked. The chances of it being c. 2000 years old are so vanishingly small, what's the point of splitting hairs over what a pope said about it.

Here the question is "show us the evidence?" The answer to this isn't, "your debating techniques are ineffective." This response will draw a lot of impolite comments.

I have occasionally participated in Porter's blog. I tryed to defend my anti-authenticity position and I received insults and anathemas and some polite answers by exceptional sidonists such as Porter and Farey (a very particular sindonist, by the way). The rational discussion was an exception and became particulary impossible when I raised some of the contradictions of sindonism that I am suggesting here.
I am amazed because the global disqualifications and the refusing to discuss the same particular subjects is being replicated here.
It is easy to say "you are a X" or "that has already been discussed". It is easy to dispatch the opponent accusing him of "dishonestity" or be "obtuse". It is easy to jabbatise the opponent. It is not easy to respect the rules of a rational discussion, be patient and pay attention to the true position of our antagonists.
The absence of opponents (Jabba is not) is a problem of a forum because it encourage the formation of automatisms and slogans. This is the problem here.
 
Fair enough, Jond (#2325), but YSTR the case from some time ago. I would love the Shroud to be authentic, same as I would love the Loch Ness Monster to be authentic (Why not? What fun weird and unlikely things are!),

Well, there are lots of things I would love to be true, but which are not. :rolleyes:

and like Houdini's search for authentic communication with the dead, I have searched the existing evidence (particularly that which had persuaded me of the authenticity of the shroud before I changed my mind), and carried out some research myself, to try to persuade myself that it is.

Self persuation is not a good basis for objective research.

Sadly, I have not, so far, succeeded, although I think there are a few historical grey areas which are so far inaccessible.

Hope of the gaps?

However, those "historical grey areas" which do not convince me are compelling to many others, and, coupled to a few other bits of geological and biological evidence, and the easy dismissal of many of the less precise arguments put forward in favour of a medieval provenance, constitute a large body of pro-authenticity support.

Yeah, so we have noticed. That is the result of researching for self-persuation.

The Shroud is, I think, an artefact of much wider general interest than almost any other historical object.

Really? Can't say I agree.

What's more, it cannot be said that there is any overwhelming consensus either in favour, or against, authenticity.

Really? Then you might venture where Jabba never fared and point oit some pro authenticy evidence? .... Just a little bit?

As such, it is a fair topic for debate, and anyone from either side could fairly call themselves 'skeptical' of the opinions of the others. There is a lot to be said for allowing this state of affairs to continue, but it is in the nature of Scientists not only to want to pin down the truth of the matter, but also to achieve at least a majority, if not universal consensus.

Facts are not a matter of consensus. They are a matter of evidence.

Those who think the earth is spherical vastly outnumber those who think it flat, and perhaps there is little value in trying to persuade them otherwise, but opinions about the Shroud are far less polarised, which is why discussion about it is as plentiful now as it ever was.

This is silly. Earth is not round from consensus. Even if every human being in the world was thoroughly convinced it is flat, it would still be round.

Filippo Lippi (#2326), are you sure you aren't deceiving yourself? If "thoroughly debunked" implies some kind of general acceptance, then nothing could be further from the truth.

Thoroughly debunked means defeated by evidence.

I do not think that the aim of internationalskeptics is simply to establish dogma, indeed, as a teacher myself, I think its aim is to educate people in rational exploration and 'critical thinking' (a phrase which occurs 4 times in the JREF mission statement page).

Which is exactly the reason why evidence counts, not opinions.

Slowvehicle's last list of "arguments against authenticity" (#2270), which I know have been reiterated many times, and so have perhaps become less than precise more by neglect than intent, are all arguable, and, as we have seen, in some cases simply wrong.

Please list your evidence.

For instance, JayUtah claims that "Science can tell us the image is anatomically and gravitationally incorrect." Can it? Can JayUtah point to any comparative measurements that would substantiate his anatomical claim? I have myself attempted comparative measurements, but it is extremely difficult to define specific anatomical points on the Shroud from which to derive measurements to compare to standard, or even non-standard, human dimensions.

Now, I'm afraid, you are speaking against better knowledge. However, I can design a simple experiment for you, which while very easy to perform is still sound, empirical science:

1) Lie flat on the floor (or other firm surface). Cross your hands over your genitals (as depicted on the shroud).

2) Note the position of your elbows: Unless you are a chimpanzee, they will be lifted from the floor.

3) Now relax, as dead persons tend to do (and as the shroud depicts the person to do), and let your elbows rest on the floor beside your chest.

4) Note the position of your hands: They now no longer cover your genitals.

Here you are: Empirical proof of one of the anatomical impossibilities of the shroud.

... You're welcome!

Hans
 
I have occasionally participated in Porter's blog. I tryed to defend my anti-authenticity position and I received insults and anathemas and some polite answers by exceptional sidonists such as Porter and Farey (a very particular sindonist, by the way). The rational discussion was an exception and became particulary impossible when I raised some of the contradictions of sindonism that I am suggesting here.
I am amazed because the global disqualifications and the refusing to discuss the same particular subjects is being replicated here.
It is easy to say "you are a X" or "that has already been discussed". It is easy to dispatch the opponent accusing him of "dishonestity" or be "obtuse". It is easy to jabbatise the opponent. It is not easy to respect the rules of a rational discussion, be patient and pay attention to the true position of our antagonists.
The absence of opponents (Jabba is not) is a problem of a forum because it encourage the formation of automatisms and slogans. This is the problem here.

Praps you might deign to provide actual examples?
 
Fair enough, Jond (#2325), but YSTR the case from some time ago. I would love the Shroud to be authentic, same as I would love the Loch Ness Monster to be authentic (Why not? What fun weird and unlikely things are!), and like Houdini's search for authentic communication with the dead, I have searched the existing evidence (particularly that which had persuaded me of the authenticity of the shroud before I changed my mind), and carried out some research myself, to try to persuade myself that it is. Sadly, I have not, so far, succeeded, although I think there are a few historical grey areas which are so far inaccessible.

However, those "historical grey areas" which do not convince me are compelling to many others, and, coupled to a few other bits of geological and biological evidence, and the easy dismissal of many of the less precise arguments put forward in favour of a medieval provenance, constitute a large body of pro-authenticity support.

The Shroud is, I think, an artefact of much wider general interest than almost any other historical object. It never ceases to surprise me, as I review recent publications for the BSTS newsletter, that fictional adventures involving the Shroud as a major part of the plot are published at the rate of about one a month. I do not know if the same can be said of the Mona Lisa, the Pyramids or any other religious artefact, but the Shroud is certainly up there with the best of them. What's more, it cannot be said that there is any overwhelming consensus either in favour, or against, authenticity. As such, it is a fair topic for debate, and anyone from either side could fairly call themselves 'skeptical' of the opinions of the others. There is a lot to be said for allowing this state of affairs to continue, but it is in the nature of Scientists not only to want to pin down the truth of the matter, but also to achieve at least a majority, if not universal consensus. Those who think the earth is spherical vastly outnumber those who think it flat, and perhaps there is little value in trying to persuade them otherwise, but opinions about the Shroud are far less polarised, which is why discussion about it is as plentiful now as it ever was.

Filippo Lippi (#2326), are you sure you aren't deceiving yourself? If "thoroughly debunked" implies some kind of general acceptance, then nothing could be further from the truth. I do not think that the aim of internationalskeptics is simply to establish dogma, indeed, as a teacher myself, I think its aim is to educate people in rational exploration and 'critical thinking' (a phrase which occurs 4 times in the JREF mission statement page). This cannot be done by mere dismissal of the eccentric, and nor can it be done by less than critical thinking on the part of the critical thinkers themselves. Slowvehicle's last list of "arguments against authenticity" (#2270), which I know have been reiterated many times, and so have perhaps become less than precise more by neglect than intent, are all arguable, and, as we have seen, in some cases simply wrong. They are adequate for preaching to the already converted, and more than adequate against the pro-authenticist quarry this thread has been pursuing for so long, but wholly unlikely to educate more informed authenticists, who may begin to visit this site, into critical re-evaluation. Instead of the "I'm right you're wrong" approach of your comment, this thread would benefit from a "Why I'm right and why you're wrong" attitude.

For instance, JayUtah claims that "Science can tell us the image is anatomically and gravitationally incorrect." Can it? Can JayUtah point to any comparative measurements that would substantiate his anatomical claim? I have myself attempted comparative measurements, but it is extremely difficult to define specific anatomical points on the Shroud from which to derive measurements to compare to standard, or even non-standard, human dimensions. Various forensic pathologists have attempted to assess the height of the man imaged in the Shroud, but the range of these (over 20cm) attests to the difficulty of the task. I should be very interested in JayUtah's evidence. By 'gravitational' I suppose JayUtah to be considering the image of the hair (although there are other gravitational considerations), which appears to look more like hair hanging vertically from a standing man than hair falling away from the face on a lying man. However this assumes that the image of the hair is a contact print. If the image were able to form at a distance, then the problem is negated. There seems to be a consensus among internationalskeptics commenters that authenticists are all stupid, and blind to the most obvious objections to their view. This is naive. Many of them, like myself, have spent years considering all the possible factors involved, and differ only in that, unlike myself, they consider that the preponderance of evidence points to authenticity rather than non-authenticity.

I will take this as a long way of saying, "no, there is no evidence in favor of authenticity." Thanks.
 
-- For now, I think the blood sub-issue is especially important, and I'll address that first. For instance, if you guys could convince me that the stains are probably not blood, I would probably give up the ghost..

Besides the fact that back at the start of the baseball season, Slowvehicle struck you out on the blood claim, there's a question I've asked before and you ignored before. If you were going to try to make a convincing "shroud", would you use blood on it? If not, why not? If so, do you understand why the presence of blood tells us nothing about when it was made and who's blood it is?
 
-[...]
- For now, I think the blood sub-issue is especially important, and I'll address that first. For instance, if you guys could convince me that the stains are probably not blood, I would probably give up the ghost...

Such temerity!

The presence of blood is not proof of authenticity. It's a simple-minded argument to pretend otherwise.
 
Some time ago I attempted a new thread on the cultural context of the Shroud, in the Arts forum, but it did not attract much interest. However if I were allowed to start a more investigative thread here, it might attract commenters who wanted to discuss the developments in Shroud research. I hope that over the weekend I might have time to think about it properly.

Responses to my last post here, however, have been disappointing. I have always wondered about the anatomical accuracy of the Shroud, but cannot find good evidence either way. JayUtah's vague comments that the 'arms have always looked wrong' or 'the head has always looked too big' are all very well, but others 'have always' completely disagreed, including various forensic pathologists of some renown. MRC Hans's 'lie-on-the-floor' experiment is irrefutable as it stands, but does depend on the image making 'body' lying flat on a surface. There have been numerous explanations of why that need not have been so. There are a few very detailed comparative analyses, all of them by authenticists, and all of them showing that neither the arms nor the head are wrong - no surprise there. But if one is to claim that these analyses are incorrect, one must produce evidence to the contrary, and I, for one, have found that very difficult, mostly because of the difficulty in making any measurements from the Shroud image itself. It can be argued that the analyses that have been done are unreliable for exactly the same reason, but that does not establish the contrary proposition.

In that statement I agree with JayUtah that dismissal of one set of evidence is not in itself evidence in favour of anything else, but I was careful not to claim that it was. Popular support for one proposition or another is not wholly evidence based, however, and lack of opposition can constitute a powerful reinforcement of belief. In my last few posts I have clearly said that I think the Shroud is medieval, but my opinions, and those of every other non-authenticist, are balanced by at least a similar number of people who think the opposite, and a discussion forum should be able to explore not just what people think, but why people think it. Abaddon is quite wrong to think I am a 'sindonist' (if that means one who believes in authenticity), but it is not failure of intellect if someone on one side of an argument wants to understand the reasoning behind those on the other.

It is true that there is a large body of miraculist belief in the authenticity of the Shroud. The foundations for such a belief are outside the realm of Science, and cannot be discussed form a Scientific point of view. Occasionally Scientists are told that it is unscientific to reject the possibility that wholly supernatural events can occur, which is true. Science is based on the premise that the universe is rational, and there are those who do not accept that premise. However, the correct scientific response is not that the universe cannot be irrational, but that if it is, science cannot investigate it, and so leave it at that. I am not an 'irrationalist', and nor, I think, is the current Pope, who has made it quite clear that for him, God is not a magician who waves a magic wand (I mention this only because I am known as a Catholic, and often accused of recusancy in my relentless rationality, but I'm not going to discuss theology here).

However there are plenty of authenticists who do not think the image on the Shroud breaks any laws of physics, and have been researching possible ways of producing an image from a dead body, in unusual circumstances. These are not all 'contact' hypotheses, and include various forms of action at at distance, such as the chemical action of vapours or various forms of radiation. I don't find any of them convincing, but there are plenty of others who do, and it is relevant to a discussion forum to try to understand why.

Some of Slowvehicle's arguments about the alleged bloodstains are well established, and as they stand it might seem astonishing that anybody could deny them. However they are denied, and have been investigated, in hideous detail. No potassium in the blood? - traumatic haemolysis. First century Jewish burial rites? - Nobody knows what they were, let alone whether they were always adhered to. Iron oxide and 'serum'? - Ah! Be careful! just because iron oxide and a medium are also found in paint is not, of course, evidence that the bloodstains are not blood. Trickles and flows - various forms of transfer, from subcutaneous oozes to pre-mortem dried blood subsequently moistened to post-mortem flows from major punctures. Do I think any of these counter-arguments convincing? No, I don't, but my point all along is that there are plenty of people who do, some of them well experienced in the forensic study of blood residues. All scientists working on any project must continually ask themselves; could my evidence be interpreted differently? And if there is a body of people who think they are wrong, be prepared to engage in discussion towards a resolution. MRC Hans missed the point about my flat-earth analogy, which was not that truth is established by consensus, but that where opinion is fairly divided between two views of something, then it is worthwhile to find out why. This may not be worthwhile if dissent is from an extreme minority, but in the case of the Shroud, where there is substantial opinion on both sides, I think it is.
 
-
- I'll try to present my evidence for the shroud being ~2000 yrs old.
...
- For now, I think the blood sub-issue is especially important, and I'll address that first.

Do you not get whiplash changing direction so quickly?
 
Some time ago I attempted a new thread on the cultural context of the Shroud, in the Arts forum, but it did not attract much interest. However if I were allowed to start a more investigative thread here, it might attract commenters who wanted to discuss the developments in Shroud research. I hope that over the weekend I might have time to think about it properly.

Responses to my last post here, however, have been disappointing. I have always wondered about the anatomical accuracy of the Shroud, but cannot find good evidence either way. JayUtah's vague comments that the 'arms have always looked wrong' or 'the head has always looked too big' are all very well, but others 'have always' completely disagreed, including various forensic pathologists of some renown. MRC Hans's 'lie-on-the-floor' experiment is irrefutable as it stands, but does depend on the image making 'body' lying flat on a surface. There have been numerous explanations of why that need not have been so. There are a few very detailed comparative analyses, all of them by authenticists, and all of them showing that neither the arms nor the head are wrong - no surprise there. But if one is to claim that these analyses are incorrect, one must produce evidence to the contrary, and I, for one, have found that very difficult, mostly because of the difficulty in making any measurements from the Shroud image itself. It can be argued that the analyses that have been done are unreliable for exactly the same reason, but that does not establish the contrary proposition.

In that statement I agree with JayUtah that dismissal of one set of evidence is not in itself evidence in favour of anything else, but I was careful not to claim that it was. Popular support for one proposition or another is not wholly evidence based, however, and lack of opposition can constitute a powerful reinforcement of belief. In my last few posts I have clearly said that I think the Shroud is medieval, but my opinions, and those of every other non-authenticist, are balanced by at least a similar number of people who think the opposite, and a discussion forum should be able to explore not just what people think, but why people think it. Abaddon is quite wrong to think I am a 'sindonist' (if that means one who believes in authenticity), but it is not failure of intellect if someone on one side of an argument wants to understand the reasoning behind those on the other.

It is true that there is a large body of miraculist belief in the authenticity of the Shroud. The foundations for such a belief are outside the realm of Science, and cannot be discussed form a Scientific point of view. Occasionally Scientists are told that it is unscientific to reject the possibility that wholly supernatural events can occur, which is true. Science is based on the premise that the universe is rational, and there are those who do not accept that premise. However, the correct scientific response is not that the universe cannot be irrational, but that if it is, science cannot investigate it, and so leave it at that. I am not an 'irrationalist', and nor, I think, is the current Pope, who has made it quite clear that for him, God is not a magician who waves a magic wand (I mention this only because I am known as a Catholic, and often accused of recusancy in my relentless rationality, but I'm not going to discuss theology here).

However there are plenty of authenticists who do not think the image on the Shroud breaks any laws of physics, and have been researching possible ways of producing an image from a dead body, in unusual circumstances. These are not all 'contact' hypotheses, and include various forms of action at at distance, such as the chemical action of vapours or various forms of radiation. I don't find any of them convincing, but there are plenty of others who do, and it is relevant to a discussion forum to try to understand why.

Some of Slowvehicle's arguments about the alleged bloodstains are well established, and as they stand it might seem astonishing that anybody could deny them. However they are denied, and have been investigated, in hideous detail. No potassium in the blood? - traumatic haemolysis. First century Jewish burial rites? - Nobody knows what they were, let alone whether they were always adhered to. Iron oxide and 'serum'? - Ah! Be careful! just because iron oxide and a medium are also found in paint is not, of course, evidence that the bloodstains are not blood. Trickles and flows - various forms of transfer, from subcutaneous oozes to pre-mortem dried blood subsequently moistened to post-mortem flows from major punctures. Do I think any of these counter-arguments convincing? No, I don't, but my point all along is that there are plenty of people who do, some of them well experienced in the forensic study of blood residues. All scientists working on any project must continually ask themselves; could my evidence be interpreted differently? And if there is a body of people who think they are wrong, be prepared to engage in discussion towards a resolution. MRC Hans missed the point about my flat-earth analogy, which was not that truth is established by consensus, but that where opinion is fairly divided between two views of something, then it is worthwhile to find out why. This may not be worthwhile if dissent is from an extreme minority, but in the case of the Shroud, where there is substantial opinion on both sides, I think it is.

You would profit from careful consideration of the nature of "special pleading"...
 
[...]
Some of Slowvehicle's arguments about the alleged bloodstains are well established, and as they stand it might seem astonishing that anybody could deny them. However they are denied, and have been investigated, in hideous detail. No potassium in the blood? - traumatic haemolysis. First century Jewish burial rites? - Nobody knows what they were, let alone whether they were always adhered to. Iron oxide and 'serum'? - Ah! Be careful! just because iron oxide and a medium are also found in paint is not, of course, evidence that the bloodstains are not blood. Trickles and flows - various forms of transfer, from subcutaneous oozes to pre-mortem dried blood subsequently moistened to post-mortem flows from major punctures. .

So what? If there is blood on it, that doesn't help establish authenticity.
 
It really does beggar belief that Jabba would declare an intention to present the evidence for the shroud being 2000 years old, and then promptly raise an issue which has no bearing whatsoever on the shroud's age.


Why? It isn't as if we haven't already seen him repeatedly do exactly that.
 
You, sir, at least do read the replies to your posts. A nice change compared to some.

*snip* MRC Hans's 'lie-on-the-floor' experiment is irrefutable as it stands, but does depend on the image making 'body' lying flat on a surface. There have been numerous explanations of why that need not have been so.

How else could a dead body lie, other than flat?

There are a few very detailed comparative analyses, all of them by authenticists, and all of them showing that neither the arms nor the head are wrong - no surprise there. But if one is to claim that these analyses are incorrect, one must produce evidence to the contrary, and I, for one, have found that very difficult, mostly because of the difficulty in making any measurements from the Shroud image itself. It can be argued that the analyses that have been done are unreliable for exactly the same reason, but that does not establish the contrary proposition.

I have not worked with this. Can you, briefly, explain why it is difficult to measure the image?

*snip*
However there are plenty of authenticists who do not think the image on the Shroud breaks any laws of physics, and have been researching possible ways of producing an image from a dead body, in unusual circumstances. These are not all 'contact' hypotheses, and include various forms of action at at distance, such as the chemical action of vapours or various forms of radiation. I don't find any of them convincing, but there are plenty of others who do, and it is relevant to a discussion forum to try to understand why.

It is not relevant to undestand why they find it convincing, only if there is some evidence supporting them.

*snip*
- Ah! Be careful! just because iron oxide and a medium are also found in paint is not, of course, evidence that the bloodstains are not blood.

Blood is a minor matter. There is not probative value in blood, as it can just as easily be found on a fake.

MRC Hans missed the point about my flat-earth analogy, which was not that truth is established by consensus, but that where opinion is fairly divided between two views of something, then it is worthwhile to find out why.

It may be worhtwhile from a philosophical or religious POV, but from a scientific POV, in search of facts about a given object, it is entirely irrelevant.


This may not be worthwhile if dissent is from an extreme minority, but in the case of the Shroud, where there is substantial opinion on both sides, I think it is.

And you don't think the pro-authenticy side is an extreme minority?

Hans
 
What is blue, with orange stripes; hangs on the wall; smells like roses; and whistles?

I don't know. What is blue, with orange stripes; hangs on the wall; smells like roses; and whistles?

A trout.

...A trout is not blue, with orange stripes!

It would be, if I painted it.

...A trout does not hang on the wall!

It would, if I nailed it there.

...A trout does not smell like roses!

It would, if I sprayed it with air freshener; at least it attar...

...A trout does not whistle!

I believe it might...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom