JayUtah's vague comments that the 'arms have always looked wrong' or 'the head has always looked too big' are all very well, but others 'have always' completely disagreed, including various forensic pathologists...
But if one is to claim that these analyses are incorrect, one must produce evidence to the contrary...
I, for one, have found that very difficult, mostly because of the difficulty in making any measurements from the Shroud image itself.
It can be argued that the analyses that have been done are unreliable for exactly the same reason, but that does not establish the contrary proposition.
In that statement I agree with JayUtah that dismissal of one set of evidence is not in itself evidence in favour of anything else, but I was careful not to claim that it was.
Abaddon is quite wrong to think I am a 'sindonist' (if that means one who believes in authenticity)...
It is true that there is a large body of miraculist belief in the authenticity of the Shroud. The foundations for such a belief are outside the realm of Science, and cannot be discussed form a Scientific point of view.
Blood is a minor matter. There is not probative value in blood, as it can just as easily be found on a fake.
That is, if the shroud is authentic then the stains must be blood. But if the stains are blood, that doesn't mean the shroud must be authentic.
- I think I'm back.
- I'll try to present my evidence for the shroud being ~2000 yrs old.
- For now, I think the blood sub-issue is especially important, and I'll address that first.
Various ideas regarding anatomical irregularities.
Does it matter why our opponents are convinced of their beliefs? Well it might.
In a forum labelled "Religion and Philosophy", I think investigation into why there are such different interpretations of observations is entirely valid.
Carbon dating tells us nothing about anatomical precision.
Two papers will show how variable assessments of these measurements on the Shroud are.
Perhaps this was badly worded by me. In order to show that a reasoned hypothesis is incorrect, you have to produce evidence to the contrary. If you demonstrate that the reasoning is faulty or inadequate, you do not show that the hypothesis is incorrect, merely that it is invalid.
As it is, of course, no-one (except possibly myself) has demonstrated insufficiency.
That's a touch petty, if you'll forgive me. Did you need credentials in anthropometrics to to claim that the head looks big or the arms look too long?
"You said science can't touch the cloth." I don't understand this whole comment at all, but I certainly didn't say anything as meaningless as "science can't touch the cloth."
MRC Hans, and JayUtah, thank you. First MRC Hans.
1) Various ideas regarding anatomical irregularities.
a) If the body was in a rigor mortis position established while hanging from a cross, it could have a distorted shape when laid down (head slightly raised, legs bent).
b) If its shroud were laid over such a body, its upper side would follow the contours of the body, while its underside would be flat.
c) If the body were laid on some sort of mattress, such as a pile of straw, spices, a stone 'pillow' or whatever, it would adopt a more bent attitude.
There are various permutations of these, including combinations, all of which have been suggested, and all of which enable the wrists to be crossed over the genitals.
<snip for focus>
No evidence of such a "pillow" or "mattress" has been presented, nor is such recorded in the crucifiction accounts.
Raw special pleading, hoping for an unevidenced "pillow" or "mattress" The only reason a "pillow" or "mattress" is proposed is to explain away the inconvenience of the anatomical impossibility of the"shroud slouch".
All of which have been proposed as ad hoc solutions; driven, not by the discovery of evidence, but by creative conjecture as ways to explain away evidence in the face of an assumed consequent.
Business as usual...
Among the description we have of the burial is that it was carried out according to Jewish custom. Did those customs include a pillow or mattress? I'd be surprised...
Yeah, all those "Well it COULD be due to this or that" are baseless. Is there any reason to think there was a pillow or mattress, other than you need that in order to rationalize authenticity? If not? Then baseless.
Part and parcel with the "patching" conjectures.
I'm pretty sure that Hugh understands the weaknesses of the arguments he's presenting. I don't think he's presenting the arguments to persuade skeptics that they are valid.
That's good to know, and a good reason why I like your suggestion that he start a new thread.
How does your friend address the carbon dating?I don't know how often I have to say that I m not convinced by authenticist arguments before it sinks in. Wardenclyffe is entirely correct. My point is not that these arguments are valid, but that they do exist, and that they are convincing to a great many perfectly intelligent, rational people. I am honoured that I count among my friends Barrie Schwortz, a Jew by birth and a scientific photographer by trade, who has become convinced by the evidence that the Shroud is genuine, and flatter myself that he counts among his friends myself, a Catholic by birth and a Science teacher by trade, who has become convinced by exactly the same evidence that the Shroud is medieval. There are, no doubt, non-authenticists who think that Barrie is an idiot, and there are certainly authenticists who think that I am damned, but these are simplistic reductions of what could be a fruitful field of 'religion and philosophy' enquiry.
Slowvehicle raises the issue of "special pleading" which I think is worth addressing. The term suggests some kind of unjustified exemption from the norm, and in order to be adduced, there ought to be a norm from which some exemption can be claimed. The trouble with the Shroud is that it is unique. Whether it is ancient or medieval, it cannot be compared to anything similar. The nature of Second Temple Jewish burial seems almost invariably to have involved moving the remains of the deceased into an ossuary after a year or so, at which time the rotted shrouds, if any, seems to have been discarded. The nature of 1st century Roman crucifixion is attested by one single heelbone with a nail through it. If any crucified person, whether of any religious significance or not, has left us his shroud, then it could only be via an extraordinary, and, self evidently unique, accumulation of circumstances. The term "special pleading" can hardly apply in these circumstances.
Similarly, however, barely a single example of such fine linen survives from the middle ages, and no example at all of an image of two bodies lying in head to head, front and back juxtaposition. There is no evidence that Shroud is in anyway typical of any medieval tradition - but then, since no similar medieval cloths remain to compare it with, the concept of "special pleading" can hardly apply in these circumstances either.
Regarding rigor mortis, its onset, progress and duration are extremely variable, depending on the circumstances and environment of the death. Cadaveric spasm, which occasionally occurs in circumstances of violent death, and is superficially indistinguishable from rigor mortis, into which it develops, is almost instantaneous, and it can continue almost indefinitely. An interesting old article entitled "The phenomena of death in battle" by George L. Kilmer is highly recommended for its observations, although its medical conclusions, being over 100 years old, may have been superceded by more recent information. To suggest that a crucified body might be in a state of rigor mortis when it is entombed does not seem like special pleading in the light of these observations - quite the reverse, in fact. Some pathologists have suggested that Jesus was actually carried to the tomb with his arms outstretched, either as they were on the cross or still fastened to the crossbeam, which were then forcibly brought downwards, and possibly tied at the wrist, to facilitate burial.
Another thing non-authenticists ought to avoid is too much reliance on the King James Bible's account for an accurate description of the events surrounding the suffering, death and burial of Jesus Christ. If John 19:40 (about the burial customs) is an accurate account, then so, presumably is John 20:12 (in which two Angels appear to Mary Magdalene). Why not?
Furthermore, we really have little idea what the burial customs really were, or how they might have been amendable in the case of a) a convicted criminal or b) the imminence of the Sabbath. If they were completed on the evening of Jesus's death, then we must ask ourselves why the women went back two days later, for example. Archaeological evidence is extremely meagre, and written instructions either date from hundreds of years before, or tens of years after, the events of the crucifixion.
I don't know how often I have to say that I m not convinced by authenticist arguments before it sinks in. Wardenclyffe is entirely correct. My point is not that these arguments are valid, but that they do exist, and that they are convincing to a great many perfectly intelligent, rational people. I am honoured that I count among my friends Barrie Schwortz, a Jew by birth and a scientific photographer by trade, who has become convinced by the evidence that the Shroud is genuine, and flatter myself that he counts among his friends myself, a Catholic by birth and a Science teacher by trade, who has become convinced by exactly the same evidence that the Shroud is medieval. There are, no doubt, non-authenticists who think that Barrie is an idiot, and there are certainly authenticists who think that I am damned, but these are simplistic reductions of what could be a fruitful field of 'religion and philosophy' enquiry.
Slowvehicle raises the issue of "special pleading" which I think is worth addressing. The term suggests some kind of unjustified exemption from the norm, and in order to be adduced, there ought to be a norm from which some exemption can be claimed. The trouble with the Shroud is that it is unique. Whether it is ancient or medieval, it cannot be compared to anything similar. The nature of Second Temple Jewish burial seems almost invariably to have involved moving the remains of the deceased into an ossuary after a year or so, at which time the rotted shrouds, if any, seems to have been discarded. The nature of 1st century Roman crucifixion is attested by one single heelbone with a nail through it. If any crucified person, whether of any religious significance or not, has left us his shroud, then it could only be via an extraordinary, and, self evidently unique, accumulation of circumstances. The term "special pleading" can hardly apply in these circumstances.
Similarly, however, barely a single example of such fine linen survives from the middle ages, and no example at all of an image of two bodies lying in head to head, front and back juxtaposition. There is no evidence that Shroud is in anyway typical of any medieval tradition - but then, since no similar medieval cloths remain to compare it with, the concept of "special pleading" can hardly apply in these circumstances either.
Regarding rigor mortis, its onset, progress and duration are extremely variable, depending on the circumstances and environment of the death. Cadaveric spasm, which occasionally occurs in circumstances of violent death, and is superficially indistinguishable from rigor mortis, into which it develops, is almost instantaneous, and it can continue almost indefinitely. An interesting old article entitled "The phenomena of death in battle" by George L. Kilmer is highly recommended for its observations, although its medical conclusions, being over 100 years old, may have been superceded by more recent information. To suggest that a crucified body might be in a state of rigor mortis when it is entombed does not seem like special pleading in the light of these observations - quite the reverse, in fact. Some pathologists have suggested that Jesus was actually carried to the tomb with his arms outstretched, either as they were on the cross or still fastened to the crossbeam, which were then forcibly brought downwards, and possibly tied at the wrist, to facilitate burial.
Another thing non-authenticists ought to avoid is too much reliance on the King James Bible's account for an accurate description of the events surrounding the suffering, death and burial of Jesus Christ. If John 19:40 (about the burial customs) is an accurate account, then so, presumably is John 20:12 (in which two Angels appear to Mary Magdalene). Why not?
Furthermore, we really have little idea what the burial customs really were, or how they might have been amendable in the case of a) a convicted criminal or b) the imminence of the Sabbath. If they were completed on the evening of Jesus's death, then we must ask ourselves why the women went back two days later, for example. Archaeological evidence is extremely meagre, and written instructions either date from hundreds of years before, or tens of years after, the events of the crucifixion.
I don't know how often I have to say that I m not convinced by authenticist arguments before it sinks in.
[T]hese are simplistic reductions of what could be a fruitful field of 'religion and philosophy' enquiry.
The trouble with the Shroud is that it is unique.
I don't know how often I have to say that I m not convinced by authenticist arguments before it sinks in. Wardenclyffe is entirely correct. My point is not that these arguments are valid, but that they do exist, and that they are convincing to a great many perfectly intelligent, rational people. I am honoured that I count among my friends Barrie Schwortz, a Jew by birth and a scientific photographer by trade, who has become convinced by the evidence that the Shroud is genuine, and flatter myself that he counts among his friends myself, a Catholic by birth and a Science teacher by trade, who has become convinced by exactly the same evidence that the Shroud is medieval. There are, no doubt, non-authenticists who think that Barrie is an idiot, and there are certainly authenticists who think that I am damned, but these are simplistic reductions of what could be a fruitful field of 'religion and philosophy' enquiry.
Slowvehicle raises the issue of "special pleading" which I think is worth addressing. The term suggests some kind of unjustified exemption from the norm, and in order to be adduced, there ought to be a norm from which some exemption can be claimed. The trouble with the Shroud is that it is unique. Whether it is ancient or medieval, it cannot be compared to anything similar. The nature of Second Temple Jewish burial seems almost invariably to have involved moving the remains of the deceased into an ossuary after a year or so, at which time the rotted shrouds, if any, seems to have been discarded. The nature of 1st century Roman crucifixion is attested by one single heelbone with a nail through it. If any crucified person, whether of any religious significance or not, has left us his shroud, then it could only be via an extraordinary, and, self evidently unique, accumulation of circumstances. The term "special pleading" can hardly apply in these circumstances.
Similarly, however, barely a single example of such fine linen survives from the middle ages, and no example at all of an image of two bodies lying in head to head, front and back juxtaposition. There is no evidence that Shroud is in anyway typical of any medieval tradition - but then, since no similar medieval cloths remain to compare it with, the concept of "special pleading" can hardly apply in these circumstances either.
Regarding rigor mortis, its onset, progress and duration are extremely variable, depending on the circumstances and environment of the death. Cadaveric spasm, which occasionally occurs in circumstances of violent death, and is superficially indistinguishable from rigor mortis, into which it develops, is almost instantaneous, and it can continue almost indefinitely. An interesting old article entitled "The phenomena of death in battle" by George L. Kilmer is highly recommended for its observations, although its medical conclusions, being over 100 years old, may have been superceded by more recent information. To suggest that a crucified body might be in a state of rigor mortis when it is entombed does not seem like special pleading in the light of these observations - quite the reverse, in fact. Some pathologists have suggested that Jesus was actually carried to the tomb with his arms outstretched, either as they were on the cross or still fastened to the crossbeam, which were then forcibly brought downwards, and possibly tied at the wrist, to facilitate burial.
Another thing non-authenticists ought to avoid is too much reliance on the King James Bible's account for an accurate description of the events surrounding the suffering, death and burial of Jesus Christ. If John 19:40 (about the burial customs) is an accurate account, then so, presumably is John 20:12 (in which two Angels appear to Mary Magdalene). Why not?
Furthermore, we really have little idea what the burial customs really were, or how they might have been amendable in the case of a) a convicted criminal or b) the imminence of the Sabbath. If they were completed on the evening of Jesus's death, then we must ask ourselves why the women went back two days later, for example. Archaeological evidence is extremely meagre, and written instructions either date from hundreds of years before, or tens of years after, the events of the crucifixion.