David Mo
Philosopher
2. The CIQ was declared a clever work of art by a pope, who claimed to know the identity of the painter.
I beg your pardon!
(2)There is nothing "dubious" about the historical fact that Bishop D'Arcis reported to Pope Clement VII that the CIQ was a cleverly-wrought fake produced by an artist. Pope Clement's response was to allow the continued exhibition of the CIQ, but not as a relic; and to instruct the clergy that it should not be presented as the "actual shroud of Christ", but as an image of it.
It is correct now. But the fact that bishop d'Arcis said a thing doesn't mean that we have the evidence of this. D'Arcis' document is a draft that doesn’t present any evidence of his claims. It is possible that d’Arcis’ charges were invented in the course of a power battle with the Lirey canons. Pope’s opinion is obviously political. We have no idea whether it was well founded or not.
Therefore, we have d'Arcis' opinion and pope's opinion. They are meaningful, but not conclusive.
To be continued.
Last edited:
