Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
2. The CIQ was declared a clever work of art by a pope, who claimed to know the identity of the painter.

I beg your pardon!

(2)There is nothing "dubious" about the historical fact that Bishop D'Arcis reported to Pope Clement VII that the CIQ was a cleverly-wrought fake produced by an artist. Pope Clement's response was to allow the continued exhibition of the CIQ, but not as a relic; and to instruct the clergy that it should not be presented as the "actual shroud of Christ", but as an image of it.

It is correct now. But the fact that bishop d'Arcis said a thing doesn't mean that we have the evidence of this. D'Arcis' document is a draft that doesn’t present any evidence of his claims. It is possible that d’Arcis’ charges were invented in the course of a power battle with the Lirey canons. Pope’s opinion is obviously political. We have no idea whether it was well founded or not.
Therefore, we have d'Arcis' opinion and pope's opinion. They are meaningful, but not conclusive.

To be continued.
 
Last edited:
Nope. That weave is unknown until medieval times. If you have evidence that such a weave was present in the Levant 2,000 years ago, please, share. Nobody else has ever seen such.
You are a believer? You want to direct the counter argument to where you think you can argue rather than the issues you know you cannot?
You are advocating pandering to sindonists, ignoring evidence that shoots them in the foot and only debating that which they think they can argue when the eveidence is right in front of them. Do you think that's valid? Ignore the actual evidence so that one may focus on the arguable? Really?

So you feel one should ignore all the objective evidence and concentrate on something vague. ..... You should get along fine with Jabba.

How very...odd. You dispute that there is "a lot of evidence" that the CIQ is a representational image; and yet, when presented with a précis of the evidences that the CIQ cannot physically be the "shroud" in which a body (any body) was "wrapped" after supposedly being crucified, you complain about being presented with "too much" evidence.

Be calm , gentlemen. Don't be excited and read what I have written. Was I defending the authenticity of the Shroud?

According to his website, David believes the dirty tea towel to be a medieval fake.
Thank you. I think this was evident from my claims here that I am not a sindonist. I think the Shroud is a medieval fake. And I think I have some evidence about this.
But some people seem scandalized because my arguments are different to theirs.

The evidence is the evidence.

Bravo! Nicely tautological!
But I think you are confusing indications with evidences. Evidence is conclusive, indications are not.
The first example, in my previous comment about d’Arcis’ document.
 
Was I defending the authenticity of the Shroud?


You seem to be advocating ignoring the strong evidence that the shroud is not authentic in favour of weaker and more debatable evidence, thus enabling the discussion to continue as if authenticity is actually arguable, which is almost precisely Jabba's approach.
 
It takes the OP having an enforced absence for some kind of actual argument to break out.
 
Last edited:
I beg your pardon!



It is correct now. But the fact that bishop d'Arcis said a thing doesn't mean that we have the evidence of this. D'Arcis' document is a draft that doesn’t present any evidence of his claims. It is possible that d’Arcis’ charges were invented in the course of a power battle with the Lirey canons. Pope’s opinion is obviously political. We have no idea whether it was well founded or not.
Therefore, we have d'Arcis' opinion and pope's opinion. They are meaningful, but not conclusive.

To be continued.

Oh, my. You may, in fact, choose to reject Celement's opinion. You may, in fact, accuse Clement of the kind of duplicity of which Mme. F-L and Dr. McCrone have been accused, and which sidonists practice as a high art form. You may, in fact, indulge yourself in special pleading and conjecture about Clement's motivations.

None of which changes the fact that among the earliest historical references to the actual CIQ (not misidentifications like the Pray Codex; or red herrings, like the "Sudarium") is the D'Arcis Report and Clement's proscriptions as to the proper display of the CIQ, due to it not being the
True Shroud".

...it's been continued for more than four years. Have you, perhaps, read the rest of this thread? Most of this has been hashed to death already.
 
It's not easy to tell from post to post.

Indeed, I was going to post a similar sentiment. One must wonder why it is that anyone would demand that the best evidence be thrown under the bus in favour of quibbling about other issues. Have we not seen four years of this behaviour already?
 
Indeed, I was going to post a similar sentiment. One must wonder why it is that anyone would demand that the best evidence be thrown under the bus in favour of quibbling about other issues. Have we not seen four years of this behaviour already?

That's the whole game. Teach the controversy.
 
Too much.
You include dubious facts (2, 6 ), exaggerations (3), vague sentences (5), non-conclusive sentences (7, 8, 11), debated facts (14)...

But why do the sentances have to be non-vague or conclusive, or non-debated?

Remember, your challenge was for "NON-SCIENTIFIC" evidence. Given your request, you can't complain that the evidence doesn't stand up to scientific scrutiny.

In fact, when you made your request for "non-scientific evidence", the first thing I thought of was the letter from the middle ages that said it was a forgery and they knew who the forger was.

As evidence goes, despite being non-scientific, it is far, far better than anything the burial cloth of Jesus side has (for Pete's sake, Jabba has claimed the "undocumented history" as evidence for authenticity!)

The criticisms of the attempts to replicate the shroud because they don't account for every single detail are similarly pretty weak considering that the explanation for the image by authenticists, knowing that you can't get the image by wrapping a cloth around a body, is quantum radiation. AKA, a miracle occurred.

At that point, vague and non-conclusive sentences are a major upgrade.
 
But why do the sentances have to be non-vague or conclusive, or non-debated?

Remember, your challenge was for "NON-SCIENTIFIC" evidence. Given your request, you can't complain that the evidence doesn't stand up to scientific scrutiny.

In fact, when you made your request for "non-scientific evidence", the first thing I thought of was the letter from the middle ages that said it was a forgery and they knew who the forger was.

As evidence goes, despite being non-scientific, it is far, far better than anything the burial cloth of Jesus side has (for Pete's sake, Jabba has claimed the "undocumented history" as evidence for authenticity!)

And McCrone's being a grouch.
 
Was I defending the authenticity of the Shroud?
It's not easy to tell from post to post.
Ein?
The “sindonology” is a myth of the twentieth century because its acritical devotion of techno-science. It is a myth built with slot machines. The sindonists need a “scientific” confirmation of the existence of God. Without this, they become simple believers and remain in front of the philosophical/epistemological problems of their belief. They don’t like this.
Is this not clear enough? I think it is “very easy to tell”. ...snip...

Edited by jsfisher: 
Edited for compliance with Rule 12 of the Membership Agreement.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Oh, my. You may, in fact, choose to reject Celement's opinion. You may, in fact, accuse Clement of the kind of duplicity of which Mme. F-L and Dr. McCrone have been accused, and which sidonists practice as a high art form. You may, in fact, indulge yourself in special pleading and conjecture about Clement's motivations.

None of which changes the fact that among the earliest historical references to the actual CIQ (not misidentifications like the Pray Codex; or red herrings, like the "Sudarium") is the D'Arcis Report and Clement's proscriptions as to the proper display of the CIQ, due to it not being the True Shroud".

No, I don’t reject the opinion of pope Clement. I consider it just an opinion. I only say that we don’t know the rational or irrational basis of his opinion. Neither those of d’Arcis’ opinion. It is evident that Clement is playing a double game: He allows the public exhibition of the Shroud, he orders the canons to say that it is not “the true Shroud of our Lord” and then he orders to keep the mouth shut the unique person that was able to control the canons. This is exactly the same double game of the contemporary popes: they don’t affirm the Shroud is an authentic relic but permit the exhibitions as it were.
I don’t intend to deny what the Pope and d’Arcis said. They said the Shroud was not authentic. But we don’t know why, we don’t know the basis of evidence of their claims. Therefore, we only know two opinions. And you cannot base evidence on opinions.

NOTE: The episode of Liège (Zantfliet, 1449) seems to me a stronger blow against the authenticity because it comes from a third testimony. Neutral, in some way.
 
No, I don’t reject the opinion of pope Clement. I consider it just an opinion. I only say that we don’t know the rational or irrational basis of his opinion. Neither those of d’Arcis’ opinion. It is evident that Clement is playing a double game: He allows the public exhibition of the Shroud, he orders the canons to say that it is not “the true Shroud of our Lord” and then he orders to keep the mouth shut the unique person that was able to control the canons. This is exactly the same double game of the contemporary popes: they don’t affirm the Shroud is an authentic relic but permit the exhibitions as it were.
I don’t intend to deny what the Pope and d’Arcis said. They said the Shroud was not authentic. But we don’t know why, we don’t know the basis of evidence of their claims. Therefore, we only know two opinions. And you cannot base evidence on opinions.

NOTE: The episode of Liège (Zantfliet, 1449) seems to me a stronger blow against the authenticity because it comes from a third testimony. Neutral, in some way.

You are, of course, free to approach the CIQ in whatsoever way you choose. I still think you are missing the point of the D'Arcis/Clement bits. What is significant is not that a Pope (or an anti-Pope, depending upon your taste is sects' acts) declared that the CIQ was not to be considered the "true shroud"; the point is that the Pope and the Bishop (if there were a choir girl, it would be the set-up of a joke) danced their fandango in the closing days of the 12th Century, C.E., while the artist D'Arcis identified was still alive; and while the CIQ, from all contemporary renderings, was much different in appearance that it is today. Any claim of "authenticity" must deal with the fact that the CIQ has faded dramatically in the 700 years since its historical appearance.
 
"The “sindonology” is a myth of the twentieth century because its acritical devotion of techno-science. It is a myth built with slot machines. The sindonists need a “scientific” confirmation of the existence of God. Without this, they become simple believers and remain in front of the philosophical/epistemological problems of their belief. They don’t like this."

Is this not clear enough? I think it is “very easy to tell”. ...snip...

Edited by jsfisher: 
Edited for compliance with Rule 12 of the Membership Agreement.

OK. What is the problem with this?
 
Last edited:
I have been some years studying the subject and I have participated in other threads on the Shroud in these forums. I haven't see the subject I am posing now. Your suggestion is out of place.

If you are suggesting I'm off-topic or being inappropriate to the MA or something, that's what the /!\ icon on the lower left is for. There is no need to lose your composure because I said your position wasn't always easy to understand.

This is my final word on the matter.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom