Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Really? A snarling pack of hounds? Charming.
Maybe he misspelled "snarking"? Anyway, if the shoe fits...

I kid, I kid. It's clearly a figure of speech. I think it well captures the fierce doggedness with which some pursue this game.

And while this thread does occasionally yield something interesting, I would say that what goes on here is quite charmless.
 
hugh farey: ISTR that you have indicated that apart from the C14 dating, you think that shroud is most likely authentic. I wonder if you could perhaps provide us with some evidence in favor of authenticity? All we've seen from Jabba, and lately David Mo and yourself, is attempts to call into question the evidence against authenticity. The problem is, even if you threw out the D'arcis memo, threw out the C14 dating, etc, there doesn't appear to be any evidence that actually points to a first century date, let alone tying it to a specific guy whose existence is somewhat in question. So why should anyone even consider the possibility of it being authentic?
 
An observation: David and Hugh have both been active on shroudstory.com which, on a cursory glance, looked to be a good-natured place where people who have an interest in the Filthy Dishrag got together to discuss it at length. As someone says in response to Dan Porter's farewell

If anyone knows of a website where it’s possible to read and post comments about the shroud on a daily basis, please provide the link.

This place isn't like that. Here, the CIQ is just another mundane item that some people thought was supernatural in origin, but has been thoroughly (spectacularly) debunked. The chances of it being c. 2000 years old are so vanishingly small, what's the point of splitting hairs over what a pope said about it.

Here the question is "show us the evidence?" The answer to this isn't, "your debating techniques are ineffective." This response will draw a lot of impolite comments.
 

See what I mean? Charmless.

And it's not even a good joke, is it? A thing--this thread for example--can lack both charm and harm. It's not a "fix" to swap one for the other.

Anyway, why is it important to you to point out that this thread is harmless? Was there some implication that the thread might be harmful somehow?
 
There is not any scientific theory about the shroud that has been able to produce an exact replica of the Shroud with medieval resources.

Very well, science cannot yet explain how the image was made, if by forgery as thought. But the claimants for authenticity cannot yet explain how the image was made, if by supernatural or any other speculative means.

This situation goes on from a century and after more than ten failed attempts of replying it. Therefore, the Shroud is unavailable to science.

Nonsense. Science can tell us the image is anatomically and gravitationally incorrect. This indicates artifice. Demanding that science pull out of some orifice the exact process used many hundreds of years ago sets a very high bar. Interpreting failure to replicate the image as evidence that the image was not forged requires exhaustive knowledge of the ways in which it may have been forged. Sadly, as in all such science, validating the rediscovery of lost arts is necessarily incremental.

In the meantime it's far more parsimonious to believe in an as-yet undiscovered forgery method than in the claims made by Shroud enthusiasts.

Obviously this doesn’t refute directly the 1988 dating, but introduces the mystery and opens the way to alternative knowledge.

Speculating on what hitherto unknown biological process or what inscrutable supernatural effect produced the image isn't any kind of knowledge. The only knowledge we have is a conclusive dating of the fabric.
 
Nonsense. Science can tell us the image is anatomically and gravitationally incorrect. This indicates artifice. Demanding that science pull out of some orifice the exact process used many hundreds of years ago sets a very high bar.

...especially since we don't know what it actually looked like when it was made. So to replicate the shroud, you have to wait 700 years to see if it comes out right.


Interpreting failure to replicate the image as evidence that the image was not forged requires exhaustive knowledge of the ways in which it may have been forged.

...and what it looked like when it was first made.

On the other hand, we know that, regardless of what it looked like originally, wrapping a body in a sheet will NOT give the image that is on the shroud, not immediately, and not in 2000 years.


Sadly, as in all such science, validating the rediscovery of lost arts is necessarily incremental.

In the meantime it's far more parsimonious to believe in an as-yet undiscovered forgery method than in the claims made by Shroud enthusiasts.

Yeah. "We don't (actually, we _can't_) know for sure how it was forged" isn't a a great thing to say, but it's a lot better than "We know it's NOT the result of wrapping a sheet around a dead body 2000 years ago, much less that of Jesus as described in the bible."

It's true, we may not know exactly how it was done, but we can say unequivocally how it was NOT done.



Speculating on what hitherto unknown biological process or what inscrutable supernatural effect produced the image isn't any kind of knowledge. The only knowledge we have is a conclusive dating of the fabric.

It's very clear to me now that the "authenticists" ultimately are just trying to show that it is a miracle, and therefore must be Jesus. That's why they don't bother with evidence for authenticity, and spend their time complaining about how no "artist" has ever been able to reproduce the shroud, while completely ignoring the fact that no "authenticist" has ever been able to even reproduce the picture, much less the shroud itself. It doesn't matter, because if it can't be reproduced, it's because it was a miracle.
 
See what I mean? Charmless.

And it's not even a good joke, is it? A thing--this thread for example--can lack both charm and harm. It's not a "fix" to swap one for the other.

Anyway, why is it important to you to point out that this thread is harmless? Was there some implication that the thread might be harmful somehow?

One wonders: if you, personally, are not "charmed", and are not enjoying yourself, why are you here?

Might I ask which of the threads here on ISF you, personally, find "charming"?
 
One wonders: if you, personally, are not "charmed", and are not enjoying yourself, why are you here?
Like I said, it's occasionally a source of interesting information. And there are other forms of enjoyment.

Might I ask which of the threads here on ISF you, personally, find "charming"?
Now that you mention it, I'm having a hard time thinking of even one.
 
- I think I'm back.

- I'll try to present my evidence for the shroud being ~2000 yrs old.
- Again, I admit that I have little, or no, direct evidence for it being ~2000 yrs old. But, I do think that I have a lot of circumstantial evidence. I'll try to present that evidence.

- The trick here is that I simply cannot attend to nearly all of everyone's objections and questions (at least, not in any kind of timely manner)... Consequently, unless you guys can figure out a better way to determine what I should address next, I'll just have to decide for myself what seems the most important.
- For now, I think the blood sub-issue is especially important, and I'll address that first. For instance, if you guys could convince me that the stains are probably not blood, I would probably give up the ghost...

- Dinner time.
 
You've had all this time off where you should have got you evidence together, for once, and you immediately say, " I'll try to present that evidence." Yawn.
 
- I think I'm back.

- I'll try to present my evidence for the shroud being ~2000 yrs old.
- Again, I admit that I have little, or no, direct evidence for it being ~2000 yrs old. But, I do think that I have a lot of circumstantial evidence. I'll try to present that evidence.

- The trick here is that I simply cannot attend to nearly all of everyone's objections and questions (at least, not in any kind of timely manner)... Consequently, unless you guys can figure out a better way to determine what I should address next, I'll just have to decide for myself what seems the most important.
- For now, I think the blood sub-issue is especially important, and I'll address that first. For instance, if you guys could convince me that the stains are probably not blood, I would probably give up the ghost...

- Dinner time.
No evidence then.


Sent from my SM-A300FU using Tapatalk
 
- I think I'm back.

- I'll try to present my evidence for the shroud being ~2000 yrs old.
- Again, I admit that I have little, or no, direct evidence for it being ~2000 yrs old. But, I do think that I have a lot of circumstantial evidence. I'll try to present that evidence.

- The trick here is that I simply cannot attend to nearly all of everyone's objections and questions (at least, not in any kind of timely manner)... Consequently, unless you guys can figure out a better way to determine what I should address next, I'll just have to decide for myself what seems the most important.
- For now, I think the blood sub-issue is especially important, and I'll address that first. For instance, if you guys could convince me that the stains are probably not blood, I would probably give up the ghost...

- Dinner time.
We are all pretty much asking the same questions so I'm not sure why you're having a problem.
 
- I think I'm back.

- I'll try to present my evidence for the shroud being ~2000 yrs old.
- Again, I admit that I have little, or no, direct evidence for it being ~2000 yrs old. But, I do think that I have a lot of circumstantial evidence. I'll try to present that evidence.

- The trick here is that I simply cannot attend to nearly all of everyone's objections and questions (at least, not in any kind of timely manner)... Consequently, unless you guys can figure out a better way to determine what I should address next, I'll just have to decide for myself what seems the most important.
- For now, I think the blood sub-issue is especially important, and I'll address that first. For instance, if you guys could convince me that the stains are probably not blood, I would probably give up the ghost...

- Dinner time.

You don't attend to anyone's objections, even when they are repeated by multiple people. Same **** different year.
 
But, I do think that I have a lot of circumstantial evidence.

No.

This just resets the discussion back to a month or so ago when you tried to tell everyone that your rampant handwaving and speculation constituted some form of evidence and was probative by its sheer alleged volume. You presented nothing that qualified as any kind of evidence, and your presentation was all of two points, which you abandoned. You have neither anything qualifying as evidence (circumstantial or otherwise), nor an abundance of it.

The trick here is that I simply cannot attend to nearly all of everyone's objections and questions...

Nonsense. When you do attend to anything, it's to endlessly equivocating, evading, and stalling. You do nothing else. If you have time to actively stall, you have time to address all comers. Get on with it without further delay.

For instance, if you guys could convince me that the stains are probably not blood, I would probably give up the ghost...

Shifting the burden of proof. In order for the cloth to be authentic, you have to prove the alleged blood spots are blood, and even then that doesn't rule out forgery. Blood is a valid artistic medium. You don't get to assume the spots are identifiable as that specific thing (among the panoply of available substances) and task your critics with coming up with some conclusive identification to the contrary. That's tantamount to a begged question.

And before we let you change horses yet again to another of your well-worn subjects, let's be clear on the disposition of Marino and Prior so that we don't have to endure a likely return to it after you think your critics have forgotten your inability to understand or defend it. Since you rejected both documents (the chronology and the addendum) and gave no reason for suddenly returning to them before now abandoning them both again in favor of blood, will you agree not to attempt presenting Marino and Prior again?
 
Last edited:
- I think I'm back.

- I'll try to present my evidence for the shroud being ~2000 yrs old.
- Again, I admit that I have little, or no, direct evidence for it being ~2000 yrs old. But, I do think that I have a lot of circumstantial evidence. I'll try to present that evidence.

- The trick here is that I simply cannot attend to nearly all of everyone's objections and questions (at least, not in any kind of timely manner)... Consequently, unless you guys can figure out a better way to determine what I should address next, I'll just have to decide for myself what seems the most important.
- For now, I think the blood sub-issue is especially important, and I'll address that first. For instance, if you guys could convince me that the stains are probably not blood, I would probably give up the ghost...

- Dinner time.
We all did the blood crackpottery several times already. Are you somehow suggesting that it is everyone else's fault that you didn't pay attention? Is that what you are trying to do? Yet another fringe reset? With no actual evidence pertaining, just a baseless claim that you have"some" evidence which you decline to share yet again? Do you really think that will fly?

Guess again, Jabba.
 
- I'll try to present my evidence for the shroud being ~2000 yrs old.


Go on then, nobody can stop you. Apart from yourself, of course.

- The trick here is that I simply cannot attend to nearly all of everyone's objections and questions (at least, not in any kind of timely manner)...


Well, don't worry about doing that, then: just present your evidence.
 
- For now, I think the blood sub-issue is especially important, and I'll address that first. For instance, if you guys could convince me that the stains are probably not blood, I would probably give up the ghost...

Actually, I do you one even better.

Let's say, for the sake of argument, they ARE blood.

And? Explain how that is evidence for a 2000 year old burial cloth.

Do you not think that there was blood available in the middle ages?

ETA: BTW, before you pull the "it tips the scales" nonsense: NO, it doesn't. There is nothing about blood on the shroud that would suggest a preference for authenticity. It adds just as much weight to the non-authentic side as it does to the authentic side, so it does NOT tip the scales in either direction.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom