Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
- At this point, I don't think that I can honestly apply "probably" -- but, I do still give the shroud a 50/50 chance of being authentic...

Totally absurd, considering that you have admitted you have no direct evidene.

- Obviously, I still want it to be authentic. Whatever, I still want to know the truth about it. And also, I still think that we humans need to develop an effective method of public debate -- that I have at least the beginnings of such a method -- and, that the shroud controversy makes for a perfect subject for analyzing the ins and outs of debate.

What makes you think the method of debate can change the FACT of whether the shroud is authentic or not? The fact is a fact, no matter how it is discussed, or even if it isn't discussed at all.

- And, as you already know, I believe that my method hasn't worked so far because you guys won't let me apply it fully. But then, I also think that I may be learning how to skirt your obstacles... We'll see.

Jabba, what makes you think you get to decide how a debate is undertaken here? Is this your forum? Are you in a position of majority here? Are you in a position of authority here?

Obviously the answer to all three is NO. You have to take what you can get, or get out.

Hans
 
Oh dear.

[...]

Moreover, the use of the word "controversy" is somewhat amusing in the context of this thread. A cynic might conclude that the purpose of your bluff and bluster is to create the appearance of controversy when none exists, so that you can point at it and proclaim the issue unresolved. Such a tactic is well within the behavioral parameters you've already demonstrated in this thread.

Bingo.
 
<snip to remove content that was, apparently, moderated while I was composing>

My Dear Mr. Savage:

I am sorry to say that this last post of yours contains many things to which a reasonable person will, even must, object.

First, I remind you that you do not have "multiple opponents"; you have only one: reality.

Second, I beleive that you are misusing the term, "colleagues". There are as many reasons to point out the errors in your apporach and your reasoning as there are people doing so. You may, in fact, feel as if a vast group of posters are allied against you; in fact, there is no such alliance.

Third, you have yet to provide a single bit of evidence that positively indicates that the CIQ is ~2000 years old. You have made a habit of continued equivocation, ignoring the demonstrable fact that casting unsupported aspersions on the 14C date, or calumniating Mme F-L and Dr. McCrone, do nothing to indicate a 1st Century C.E. date for the CIQ; nor do they undermine a mid-13th Century C.E. date. The 14C dating is a consistent part of a bigger pattern: the cloth itself, the style of the representative (and, I remind you, undistorted) image, the hisotrical record, the papal declaration of fraud; all of these and more point to a medieval date. You have yet to provide any evidence that says otherwise. Please do be aware that conjectures about "...patching..." or the Whangers' fanciful pareidolia are not evidence of a 1st Century C.E. date. (NB: even if the "coins" [for instance] that the Whangers claim to be able to identify were, in fact, images of 1st Century C.E. coins, that only provides a limit on how old the CIQ could be. I could be buried tomorrow with a 1st Centiry C.E. coin in my pocket...)

Fourth, and very telling, you do not listen when it is explained to you why your sources (sources, it pains me to add, that you often have not even read) do not constitute evidence. As mentioned above, merely speculating about supposed weaknesses of the 14C date does nothing to indicate that the CIQ is ~2000 years old. Smearing Dr. McCrone and Mme F-L does nothing to indicate that teh CIQ is ~2000 years old. You really, really ought to consider presenting what positive evidence you have.

Fifth, your "branch about your "Effective Debate" technique would, in fact, be unsupportably off-topic for this thread. I, for one, will report any attempt at such a derail, and will agitate to have it removed form the thread. You had the opportunity to demonstrate your "Effective Debate" technique, in an unprecedented, protected, and moderated thread; a thread you, personally, abandoned. I wonder why it is that you have not admitted to, and attempted to explain, your actions there. If you must do so, please conduct that "branch" in a separate thread. Before you begin, do consider your experiences in your "immortality" thread(s), and in your "Effective Debate" threads; and ponder whether you have the resources to assay two discussions at once.

In my humble opinion, what you really ought to do is find, and present, positive evidence (empirical, objective, testable, practical evidence, attested to by neutral scholars) that the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old. Without that, all the rest is vanities (saith the ex-preacher).

I continue to remain,

Patiently yours &ct.
 
Last edited:
Third, you have yet to provide a single bit of evidence that positively indicates that the CIQ is ~2000 years old. You have made a habit of continued equivocation, ignoring the demonstrable fact that casting unsupported aspersions on the 14C date, or calumniating Mme F-L and Dr. McCrone, do nothing to indicate a 1st Century C.E. date for the CIQ; nor do they undermine a mid-13th Century C.E. date.
The confusing system of Jabba's reasoning doesn't clarify the main stream of current sindonism: 90% of sindonists efforts are dedicated to disqualify the 14C dating. Sophisticated theories, such as the bio-plastic layer (Garza-Valdés), vanillin dating (Rogers), mechanical dating (Fanti) or invisible mending (Marino and Bedford) are developed with this aim. We have a new theory every month. There are two "curious" circumstances: they are mutually incompatible and there is not a sindonist consensus after more of 30 years of attempts. This is a serious objection against the critics of the radiocarbon dating 1988.

The sindonists usually reply that the sceptics have a similar problem: they cannot explain how the image of the shroud was made. They are unable to do a satisfactory reply with medieval resources. There is not a sceptical consensus about this question.

I think this is the strongest position of sindonism. Is it really strong?
 
The confusing system of Jabba's reasoning doesn't clarify the main stream of current sindonism: 90% of sindonists efforts are dedicated to disqualify the 14C dating. Sophisticated theories, such as the bio-plastic layer (Garza-Valdés), vanillin dating (Rogers), mechanical dating (Fanti) or invisible mending (Marino and Bedford) are developed with this aim. We have a new theory every month. There are two "curious" circumstances: they are mutually incompatible and there is not a sindonist consensus after more of 30 years of attempts. This is a serious objection against the critics of the radiocarbon dating 1988.

The sindonists usually reply that the sceptics have a similar problem: they cannot explain how the image of the shroud was made. They are unable to do a satisfactory reply with medieval resources. There is not a sceptical consensus about this question.

I think this is the strongest position of sindonism. Is it really strong?


If it is the strongest position of sindonism then it shows just how pathetically weak the sindonist position is!
 
The confusing system of Jabba's reasoning doesn't clarify the main stream of current sindonism: 90% of sindonists efforts are dedicated to disqualify the 14C dating. Sophisticated theories, such as the bio-plastic layer (Garza-Valdés), vanillin dating (Rogers), mechanical dating (Fanti) or invisible mending (Marino and Bedford) are developed with this aim. We have a new theory every month. There are two "curious" circumstances: they are mutually incompatible and there is not a sindonist consensus after more of 30 years of attempts. This is a serious objection against the critics of the radiocarbon dating 1988.

The sindonists usually reply that the sceptics have a similar problem: they cannot explain how the image of the shroud was made. They are unable to do a satisfactory reply with medieval resources. There is not a sceptical consensus about this question.

I think this is the strongest position of sindonism. Is it really strong?

No, it is not a strong position, at all. The committed sidonist acts as if casting enough ungrounded aspersion upon the 14C date demonstrates support for "authenticity"; when, in reality, if the 14C dating had never been done there is still no indication, none, that the CIQ is ~2000 years old.

And, as has been pointed out to Mr. Savage, even if the CIQ were conclusively demonstrated to be ~2000 years old, that does nothing to address all of the other deficiencies of the image.
 
Oh dear.

You still seem to be operating under the delusion that debate is the correct method to use, and that your variant of debating is the best way to go about it.

Once again: debate is a method that uses rhetoric to sway an opinion, not a method for weighing evidence to arrive at a conclusion.

Moreover, the use of the word "controversy" is somewhat amusing in the context of this thread. A cynic might conclude that the purpose of your bluff and bluster is to create the appearance of controversy when none exists, so that you can point at it and proclaim the issue unresolved. Such a tactic is well within the behavioral parameters you've already demonstrated in this thread.

I am that cynic.
 
Oh dear.

You still seem to be operating under the delusion that debate is the correct method to use, and that your variant of debating is the best way to go about it.

Once again: debate is a method that uses rhetoric to sway an opinion, not a method for weighing evidence to arrive at a conclusion.

Moreover, the use of the word "controversy" is somewhat amusing in the context of this thread. A cynic might conclude that the purpose of your bluff and bluster is to create the appearance of controversy when none exists, so that you can point at it and proclaim the issue unresolved. Such a tactic is well within the behavioral parameters you've already demonstrated in this thread.

Once again Jabba, Airline pilots don't consider what the Flat Earth Society thinks when they plan their route from Frankfurt to Seattle. Having an objection and it being meaningful aren't the same thing.
 
I have mixed feelings that he got suspended for a response to one of my posts.

I doubt it- it was just the same old same old. Don't feel bad (assuming that this describes one of your mixed feelings, rather than a mix of elation and pride, for example). If "body of work" applies to any one, it certainly applies to the aggregate of Jabba's posts.
 
I doubt it- it was just the same old same old. Don't feel bad (assuming that this describes one of your mixed feelings, rather than a mix of elation and pride, for example). If "body of work" applies to any one, it certainly applies to the aggregate of Jabba's posts.

My mixed feelings are between "ha ha" and being bummed about seven days of not poking the bear. You see, deep down, I'm very shallow.
 
If it is the strongest position of sindonism then it shows just how pathetically weak the sindonist position is!
No, it is not a strong position, at all.
Well, you can say "the less weak".
The committed sidonist acts as if casting enough ungrounded aspersion upon the 14C date demonstrates support for "authenticity"; when, in reality, if the 14C dating had never been done there is still no indication, none, that the CIQ is ~2000 years old.

And, as has been pointed out to Mr. Savage, even if the CIQ were conclusively demonstrated to be ~2000 years old, that does nothing to address all of the other deficiencies of the image.
I am afraid I have not explained it correctly. The argument arises in the context of a pragmatic conception of scientific truth.

A scientific theory is verified when produces accurate predictions and affords manipulate (control) the things. There is not any scientific theory about the shroud that has been able to produce an exact replica of the Shroud with medieval resources. This situation goes on from a century and after more than ten failed attempts of replying it. Therefore, the Shroud is unavailable to science.

Obviously this doesn’t refute directly the 1988 dating, but introduces the mystery and opens the way to alternative knowledge.

This line of reasoning seems to me harder than the efforts to invalidate the 1988 dating.
 
There is not any scientific theory about the shroud that has been able to produce an exact replica of the Shroud with medieval resources.
The best that could be done, even with full knowledge of how the original was created, would be to produce an exact replica of the Shroud as it looked when it was originally created 800 years ago. You would then need to wait 800 years, during which you would need to subject your replica to the identical environments and treatments the original underwent, before you could reasonably expect it to be an exact replica.

We cannot produce an exact replica of any centuries old art work as it looks now. We cannot deduce anything about such art works from that fact.
 

Not very long ago, I mentioned that we might be approaching a melt-down. Seems Jabba is aiming for a suicide by moderator. During the last several weeks, Jabba has made no attempt at all at any kind of argument. Instead, he has made diversions, attacked the form, and lamented that he is overwhelmed by enemies.

Once he achieves a banning, he can enjoy martyrdom with his friends, claiming that he was ganged up upon and silenced because skeptics did not want to have an effective debate[tm] .

Sad.

Hans
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom