How very...odd. You dispute that there is "a lot of evidence" that the CIQ is a representational image; and yet, when presented with a précis of the evidences that the CIQ cannot physically be the "shroud" in which a body (
any body) was "wrapped" after supposedly being crucified, you complain about being presented with "too much" evidence.
For a more exhaustive list of the evidence, look
here.
I will overlook the fact that each one of your objections has, in fact, been addressed by multiple posters in this tortuous, 4-part thread, and simply respond to your objections. With facts.
You include dubious facts (2, 6 )...
(2)There is nothing "dubious" about the historical fact that Bishop D'Arcis reported to Pope Clement VII that the CIQ was a cleverly-wrought fake produced by an artist. Pope Clement's response was to allow the continued exhibition of the CIQ, but not as a relic; and to instruct the clergy that it should not be presented as the "actual shroud of Christ", but as an image of it.
(6)There is nothing "dubious" about he fact that, had the body supposedly "wrapped" in the CIQ been prepared "...following the Jewish burial custom..." (John 19:40, NJB), it would have been washed, and wrapped in strips of linen, with spices. The "body" represented on the CIQ is represented as bleeding copiously enough for blood to flow down its neck; this could not happen (ignoring for a moment the navïete of the representation of the "blood flows") if the body had been washed after its heart had stopped beating.
The CIQ is a sheet of linen that shows no hint of draping distortion; the image is flat. The gospels call for "strips" of linen (
ὀθόνιον, literally the diminutive of
ὀθόνη) that were "wrapped" (
δέω) around the body. The CIQ does not conform with what is known about 1st. Century C.E. funerary practices, nor with what is presented in the 'god'spiel.
(3)The linen of the CIQ is of a size and fineness typical of medieval looms. The 3:1 weave is not represented in any piece of cloth known to date from the 1st Century C.E. This is not an "exaggeration" but a statement of fact. You are welcome to provide evidence of any authentically-dated 1st Century C.E. middle eastern cloth that demonstrated the 3:1 twill, but until you do, your characterization is demonstrably incorrect.
...vague sentences (5)...
(5)The 'god'spiel attributed to "John" states that the body was "wrapped" (
δέω) in "strips" (
ὀθόνιον) of linen. The CIQ is a "sheet" (
ὀθόνη) of linen; the representational image on it shows no trace of wrapping distortions.
...non-conclusive sentences (7, 8, 11)...
I confess that I am not sure what you mean by "non-conclusive sentences". However:
(7)The Byzantine style of representational image is a style recognizable by anyone with even a layman's exposure to religious iconography. It is characterized by distinctly european facial feature, with characteristic elongations, simplifications, and iconic traditions. The representational image on the CIQ follows recognizable Byzantine traditions.
(8)The arms of the figure represented on the CIQ are not the same length; the posture of the CIQ cannot be assumed by an actual body on a flat surface; the features of the "face" on the CIQ are european ("gentile white guy, meek and mild..."), and not representational of middle eastern peoples of the 1st Century C.E.
(11)The wild-eyed prophet with untrimmed locks and beard is a medieval construct; the "hippie Jesus" in white robe and sandals is a 19th century construct; a Jewish man of the 1st Century CE (or, for that matter, any 1st Century C.E. asiatic Hebrew) would have been unlikely to have sported the long, flowing locks depicted on the CIQ (Xref. Cor. 11:14).
(14)I suggest you read
Bright Earth, by Phillip Ball. The substances on the CIQ are representative of common medieval art supplies. The ubiquitous CaCO
3 indicates that the linen was sized and gessoed, which is not something that would be done to any cloth intended to absorb fluids leaking from a corpse (size and gesso are used to
prevent fluids from absorbing into the treated cloth).
All these evidences have been questioned by sindonists long time ago.
Of course sidonists disagree with the evidence; they do so, however, without the support of demonstrable fact. They do so in support of their assumed consequent, with incessant special pleading, instead of allowing the evidence to lead to a conclusion.
I think a most suitable strategy should be focused on strong points. In your scheme the strong points are 4, 10, 12, 13.
Point 4, 10 forces the sindonist to claim miraculous events if correctly developed. The “blood rivulets” (12 and 13) lead to a factual impossibility. (Very interesting -and obvious: Garlaschelli and Borrini:
https://youtu.be/SNzVc1MqJ2s
; Garlaschelli, Luigi & Borrini, Matteo: “A BPA Approach to the Shroud of Turin:A Preliminary Examination of the Left Forearm to Reconstruct the Crucifixion Practice”,
Proceedings of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences, 66th Annual Scientific Meeting, Seattle, February 17-22, 2014;
http://www.aafs.org/sites/default/files/AAFS2014Proceedings.pdf ).
I think this line of attack makes irrelevant all the never ending debates with sindonists about the nature of the stains of blood, the invisible mending, the coins in the eyes and other sindonist topics. Yes, the sindonist can take refuge in miracle claims. (Cf. Gilbert Lavoie or John Jackson), but this upsets the bulk of the “sindonologs” because their alleged science became irrelevant. The “sindonology” is a myth of the twentieth century because its acritical devotion of techno-science. It is a myth built with slot machines. The sindonists need a “scientific” confirmation of the existence of God. Without this, they become simple believers and remain in front of the philosophical/epistemological problems of their belief. They don’t like this. Too heavy.
Therefore, if you want to put an end to a discussion with a sindonist, you should bring on the table simple questions as the floating hair, the blood trails on the nape or the absence of marks of crush in the buttocks due to the corporal weight.
Every time that I have brought those questions up to the sindonists they tried to change of subject. Significative.
You are, of course, welcome to whatever approach comforts you. I will continue as I have done, pointing out that there is not a single bit of evidence that actually supports "authenticity"; instead, every bit of evidence points to the fact that the CIQ is not a 1st Century C.E. cloth in which a 1st Century C.E. body was wrapped.
I would, however, encourage you to be more careful about misrepresenting facts that are presented you.