Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are suggesting I'm off-topic or being inappropriate to the MA or something, that's what the /!\ icon on the lower left is for. There is no need to lose your composure because I said your position wasn't always easy to understand.

This is my final word on the matter.

Sorry, I was suggesting that your advise was not pertinent because I know well the subject and the opinions of Jabba and other participants in this forum also. Nothing more.
 
You are assuming as true what you have to prove.

You are wrong. D'Arcis doesn't say that the artisan was still alive. He says that Henri de Poitiers discovered this artisan (in 1356 c.). It is a very different thing.

Even if your position were correct, you still have to deal with the statements that the artist was identified contemporaneously with the first historical records of the CIQ.

This has all been done (and re-done, and re-re-done) in this thread and its progenitors. Welcome (if fashionably late) to the party...
 
Sorry, I was suggesting that your advise was not pertinent because I know well the subject and the opinions of Jabba and other participants in this forum also. Nothing more.

MMm OK. Perhaps you came in a bit sideways.

I suggest you restate your opinion on how we should discuss the shroud, and why. I recommend you do it as briefly and concisely as possible.

Hans
 
You are assuming as true what you have to prove.

You are wrong. D'Arcis doesn't say that the artisan was still alive. He says that Henri de Poitiers discovered this artisan (in 1356 c.). It is a very different thing and not easy to prove.

These testimonies must be taken with the reservations that are appropriate for all testimony of such age. Nevertheless they are there, and they do trump not having any. Sindonists do not have any historical evidence at all for a greater age.

Hans
 
But why do the sentances have to be non-vague or conclusive, or non-debated?

Remember, your challenge was for "NON-SCIENTIFIC" evidence. Given your request, you can't complain that the evidence doesn't stand up to scientific scrutiny.

In fact, when you made your request for "non-scientific evidence", the first thing I thought of was the letter from the middle ages that said it was a forgery and they knew who the forger was.

As evidence goes, despite being non-scientific, it is far, far better than anything the burial cloth of Jesus side has (for Pete's sake, Jabba has claimed the "undocumented history" as evidence for authenticity!)

The criticisms of the attempts to replicate the shroud because they don't account for every single detail are similarly pretty weak considering that the explanation for the image by authenticists, knowing that you can't get the image by wrapping a cloth around a body, is quantum radiation. AKA, a miracle occurred.

At that point, vague and non-conclusive sentences are a major upgrade.

Maybe “non-scientific” was not an accurate word for what I was intending to explain. I try again.

The 14C dating is the stronger scientific evidence against the authenticity of the Shroud. The basic rules of radiocarbon dating are easily understandable with no much scientific knowledge, but there are other particular (and important) aspects that are not known by most. I assume that people that usually discuss about this matter are not expert in radiocarbon dating. I am not, of course. Therefore, in this kind of forums it is easy to find someone that claims that the very last essay of XXXX shows how the 1988 dating was flawed. These “very last” investigations are usually debunked in a period of time more or less large (Kouznetsov, Garza-Valdés, etc.). Other (Rogers) are more resistant. But there are others that avoid the attention of the experts. Do you know Alconchel-Pecino? These kind of academic works don’t deserve the attention of the experts, they are not criticised and they allow some obstinate sindonists to cling on to them indefinitely. So, the debate becomes impossible.
I maintain that is more useful focussing the discussion in other points. These points don’t need a profound scientific knowledge, but common sense and critical spirit only. Of course, sometimes some scientific knowledge is implied, but not a specialized one. That is why I have called them “non-scientific”.
The advantage is that you can ask some basic questions to sindonists that don’t imply sophisticated devices or theories. My experience is that the sindonists are not able to answer by appealing strange scientists that work in some Lithuanian lab. This is what I call a “conclusive” argument. The inability to answer is evident to everybody.
You have quoted one of them: the position of the sheet. I have mentioned others:
-The position of the hair.
-The absence of squashing in the back of the body in the image.
- The blood trickles on the hair in the back of the head.
-The direction of the blood trickles.
-…and some other.

Discuss Mr. Alconchel-Pecino seems to me really boring and useless. It is more interesting to see how the sindonists react to the simple questions I have proposed.
And therefore is important to separate what is a conclusive evidence from what is only an indication.
See my argumentation about d’Arcis memorandum, please.
 
[...]

Discuss Mr. Alconchel-Pecino seems to me really boring and useless. It is more interesting to see how the sindonists react to the simple questions I have proposed.
And therefore is important to separate what is a conclusive evidence from what is only an indication.
See my argumentation about d’Arcis memorandum, please.

There is only one person here who defends the authenticity of the shroud. If you ask him anything like what you are proposing, he will ignore it and reply that the 14C dating is invalid because of magical patches, that McCrone was difficult to work with, that Mme F-L was incompetent, and "Undocumented History". Therefore, the shroud is "probably" authentic

No one to date has found a way to have a meaningful discussion with him, but be my guest. It would be refreshing to see someone actually get him to engage honestly.
 
Last edited:
Maybe “non-scientific” was not an accurate word for what I was intending to explain. I try again.

*snipped for brevity*
And therefore is important to separate what is a conclusive evidence from what is only an indication.
See my argumentation about d’Arcis memorandum, please.

Fair enough, but 'conclusive' is the wrong term. The C14 dating is conclusive evidence.

Perhaps you could say "immidiately convincing". However, I think the main failing is the idea that anything will convince folks like Jabba.

What we do here is batting back any and all of his arguments, lest he confuse any spectators.

Hans
 
The 14C dating is the stronger scientific evidence against the authenticity of the Shroud. The basic rules of radiocarbon dating are easily understandable with no much scientific knowledge, but there are other particular (and important) aspects that are not known by most. I assume that people that usually discuss about this matter are not expert in radiocarbon dating. I am not, of course. Therefore, in this kind of forums it is easy to find someone that claims that the very last essay of XXXX shows how the 1988 dating was flawed.


Yes, but the same people will come up with all sorts of arguments against whatever other evidence you propose using instead. Worse, in Jabba's case he will then introduce another Gish gallop of debunked and/or irrelevant information that he says belongs in his "pro-authenticity pan", and claim that since the carbon dating is now out the "preponderance of evidence" must favour authenticity.
 
Maybe “non-scientific” was not an accurate word for what I was intending to explain. I try again.
OK.

The 14C dating is the stronger scientific evidence against the authenticity of the Shroud. The basic rules of radiocarbon dating are easily understandable with no much scientific knowledge, but there are other particular (and important) aspects that are not known by most.
While generally true, I can think of at least one exception to this.

I assume that people that usually discuss about this matter are not expert in radiocarbon dating. I am not, of course.
Your assumption is incorrect.

Therefore, in this kind of forums it is easy to find someone that claims that the very last essay of XXXX shows how the 1988 dating was flawed. These “very last” investigations are usually debunked in a period of time more or less large (Kouznetsov, Garza-Valdés, etc.). Other (Rogers) are more resistant. But there are others that avoid the attention of the experts. Do you know Alconchel-Pecino? These kind of academic works don’t deserve the attention of the experts, they are not criticised and they allow some obstinate sindonists to cling on to them indefinitely. So, the debate becomes impossible.
Which assumes that the protagonist actually wants an honest discussion of the facts. This is not the case in this thread.

I maintain that is more useful focussing the discussion in other points. These points don’t need a profound scientific knowledge, but common sense and critical spirit only. Of course, sometimes some scientific knowledge is implied, but not a specialized one. That is why I have called them “non-scientific”.
Again, you assume that the goal is to resolve the matter. It isn't. The goal is and always has been to prolong the "debate" in the hope of being able to declare a Pyrrhic victory over science. Introducing these other issues is simply grist to the sindonist mill and will be used as a blunt instrument with which to attack science, history and sheer common sense to artificially create a sense that there is any controversy at all.

The advantage is that you can ask some basic questions to sindonists that don’t imply sophisticated devices or theories. My experience is that the sindonists are not able to answer by appealing strange scientists that work in some Lithuanian lab. This is what I call a “conclusive” argument. The inability to answer is evident to everybody.
The disadvantage is the sindonists simply don't care.

You have quoted one of them: the position of the sheet. I have mentioned others:
-The position of the hair.
-The absence of squashing in the back of the body in the image.
- The blood trickles on the hair in the back of the head.
-The direction of the blood trickles.
-…and some other.
Been there and done that again and again and again. Everyone who has been here since the start of this nonsense is heartily sick to death of all of the evasions, dodges, fringe resets, Gish gallops, in fact everything from the woo playbook over and over and over.

Seems to me that your real problem is that all of us who have been here from the start look at your posts and groan because it will mean yet another turn of the hamster wheel of doom that is this thread and issues long thought to be firmly put to bed will (haha) be resurrected once again. That may seem a little harsh, but after four years and multiple threads tolerance levels are just a bit on the low side. This is not your fault. I am simply trying to convey to you why there is so much cynicism in this thread.

Discuss Mr. Alconchel-Pecino seems to me really boring and useless. It is more interesting to see how the sindonists react to the simple questions I have proposed.
And therefore is important to separate what is a conclusive evidence from what is only an indication.
See my argumentation about d’Arcis memorandum, please.

Alconchel-Pecino published an article, not a peer reviewed paper. And he sets out his stall right from the title, which is...
A possible hypothesis for correcting the radiocarbon
age of the Shroud of Turin
Yeah, you read that right. He wants to set the C14 dating to the "correct" age which he already knows is 2000 years before he even puts pen to paper.

Here is the full article.

Enjoy.
 
There is only one person here who defends the authenticity of the shroud.
Which assumes that the protagonist actually wants an honest discussion of the facts. This is not the case in this thread.
(…)
Been there and done that again and again and again. Everyone who has been here since the start of this nonsense is heartily sick to death of all of the evasions, dodges, fringe resets, Gish gallops, in fact everything from the woo playbook over and over and over.
When I speak of the sindonists I am not thinking in Jabba… only.
I don’t know whether he is honest or dishonest. I suppose he is honest by principle.The method “I-come-back-again-and-again” is popular between the low levels of sindonism but I know many other species. There are more coriaceous and more sophisticated kinds of sindonism. There are even indecisive sindonsits. I don’t pretend to persuade anyone. I intend to make evident some of their contradictions with no way out. Everybody can draw his own conclusions.

Alconchel-Pecino published an article, not a peer reviewed paper. And he sets out his stall right from the title, which is...
I am not a believer of the peer review religion. Many of the best articles about the Shroud by Nicolotti, Rinaldi or Garlaschelli were publied in a non peer reviewed journal.
I know many flawed cases of the peer review system. Once again the peer review is an advisable requisite, but not definitive.
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
Those who have very much enjoyed the intellectual cut-and-thrust of shroudstory.com have been upset by its recent closure, although with competent searching it remains an essential repository of primary sources and intelligent opinions. There was a time when I found internationalskeptics worthwhile, and indeed, followed chiefly mathematical arguments from an authenticist to a non-authenticist viewpoint. Since then, I have scrupulously examined every authenticist argument for discrediting the radiocarbon date, and found nearly all of them spurious, although there are still one or two grey areas. Many of the other evidences for a medieval date have also been scrutinised, in detail, with a view to determining their level of support. The d'Arcis memorandum is one of these.

Over the years the weakness of the authenticist position on this site has resulted in some very slack counter-arguments from non-authenticists, with the result that, although Jabba is frequently blamed for the pointless continuation of this thread, which must surely for heading for the Guinness Book of World Records, it has really been maintained by his opponents. In more or less the same three words ("I'll be back"), posted every month or so, Jabba has managed to keep a pack of hounds snarling at his heels, without achieving the slightest progress in denting his belief in the Shroud's authenticity. Mostly, the site has become an increasingly inaccurate re-iteration of supposed non-authenticist arguments, to the edification of nobody.

There may be an unrecognised worthwhile reason for the maintenance of this thread, which is to demonstrate the weakness of authenticist arguments, or the strength of non-authenticist ones, to readers who follow it, but never comment. For several years they have been largely disappointed, I fear.

Neither the Pope, nor Bishop d'Arcis, nor Bishop Henri, nor anybody else, has left any record that they knew the painter responsible for the image of the Shroud. All we have is an unsigned, undated draft of a letter addressed to the Pope from d'Arcis, claiming that the Shroud being exhibited in Lirey in 1389 was not a true relic of Christ, but a deceitful fraud, and that the whole thing had been investigated by Henri of Poitiers, "the truth being attested by the artist who painted it," after which it had been hidden for 34 years or so, a date so precise that it suggests some knowledge (or assumed knowledge) that the first time the Shroud was exhibited was in 1355 or so. ("Or so" perhaps being crucial, as we shall see. The Latin is "vel circa")

This is important. We do not have Bishop Henri's report. What we do have is his signed, dated, effusive commendation of Geoffroi de Charny written on 28 May 1356, with no mention of a fraudulent Shroud. It seems unlikely that Bishop Henry would have been so kind if he had just condemned a fraudulent relic.

Geoffroi de Charny died at the battle of Poitiers on 19 September 1356.

Suppose, for a moment, that d'Arcis' information, whether or not he actually sent his letter, was correct. An interpretation of the evidence could be that the Shroud began to be exhibited after de Charny's death ('vel circa' being the operative words here), and Bishop Henri, having commended de Charney only the previous Spring, was shocked to discover that by the Autumn the canons at Lirey had exceeded their remit. This seems possible, and to me the most likely.

It is sometimes claimed that since there is no proof that d'Arcis' letter was sent, that no credence should be given to it. However, even if this particular complaint was not received by the Pope, he nevertheless commanded in 1389 that the Shroud could only be shown as a representation, and without all the ceremonial trappings of sanctity that might attend the display of the real thing, suggesting that at least somebody had complained. It is not obvious whether he personally thought the Shroud was genuine or not, but he certainly acted as if it wasn't.

On the other hand, if we decide that the "vel circa" is not adequate to reconcile the conflicting evidence from 1356, we could claim that Bishop Henri knew all about the Shroud and commended Geoffroi de Charney for building a chapel for its veneration. His commendation specifically states: "after scrupulous examination [...] of the said knight's sentiments of devotion, which he has hitherto manifested for the divine cult, and which he manifests ever more daily. And ourselves wishing to develop as much as possible a cult of this nature, we praise, ratify and approve the said letters in all their parts - a cult which is declared and reported to have been canonically and ritually prescribed, as we have been informed by legitimate documents." What could this "cult" have been, if not that of the Holy Shroud? Well, the fact that the church is dedicated to St Mary may be related to that.

It may be worth considering how we know about the two conflicting documents in this case. The d'Arcis memorandum has been researched twice, by the Catholic Historian Ulysse Chevalier, at the turn of the 19th/20th century, and by Hilda Leynen in the 90s. The document by Bishop Henri was discovered by Bruno Bonnet-Eymard, who is a fairly extreme fundamentalist Catholic and Shroud authenticist, who thinks that the radiocarbon date was falsified by Dr Tite and Cardinal Ballestrero in the sacristy of the Royal Chapel in Turin in 1988. Although his discovery of the Bishop Henri document was presented to the St Louis Shroud Symposium in 1991, it was not referred to at all by Luigi Fossati in his two articles for Shroud Spectrum International in 1992, or in Jack Markwardt's 'The Conspiracy Against the Shroud' in 2001.

Finally, Luigi Fossati draws our attention to an interesting change of phrase in successive communications from Pope Clement to Troyes, at around that time, beginning with "figura seu representatio" (July 1389) amending it to "pictura seu tabula" (January 1390), but reverting to "figura seu representatio" in May 1390.

References:
D'Arcis memorandum: https://archive.org/details/tudecritiquesur00chevgoog
Bishop Henri commendation: "The Shroud of Turin: A Case for Authenticity" (google.books)
Markwardt Discussion: http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/n55part3.pdf
Fossati Discussions: http://shroud.com/pdfs/ssi41part3.pdf and http://shroud.com/pdfs/ssi42part14.pdf
Bruno Bonnet-Eymard: http://crc-internet.org/our-doctrine/catholic-counter-reformation/holy-shroud-turin/
 
[...]

Over the years the weakness of the authenticist position on this site has resulted in some very slack counter-arguments from non-authenticists, with the result that, although Jabba is frequently blamed for the pointless continuation of this thread, which must surely for heading for the Guinness Book of World Records, it has really been maintained by his opponents. In more or less the same three words ("I'll be back"), posted every month or so, Jabba has managed to keep a pack of hounds snarling at his heels,[...]]

Really? A snarling pack of hounds? Charming.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom