Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Segway

- Anyway,

- I probably shouldn't use the word "probably" anymore when referring to my opinion about the shroud. Dan Porter's opinion was a big part of mine,
and his recent announcement took me by surprise.
- At this point, I don't think that I can honestly apply "probably" -- but, I do still give the shroud a 50/50 chance of being authentic...

- Obviously, I still want it to be authentic. Whatever, I still want to know the truth about it. And also, I still think that we humans need to develop an effective method of public debate -- that I have at least the beginnings of such a method -- and, that the shroud controversy makes for a perfect subject for analyzing the ins and outs of debate.
- And, as you already know, I believe that my method hasn't worked so far because you guys won't let me apply it fully. But then, I also think that I may be learning how to skirt your obstacles... We'll see.
 
...snip...

Edited by jsfisher: 
Edited to comply with the Membership Agreement, specifically Rules 0 and 12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
And also, I still think that we humans need to develop an effective method of public debate -- that I have at least the beginnings of such a method


Why? What evidence do you have that your method is effective, or ever could be?
 
- Anyway,

- I probably shouldn't use the word "probably" anymore when referring to my opinion about the shroud. Dan Porter's opinion was a big part of mine,
and his recent announcement took me by surprise.
- At this point, I don't think that I can honestly apply "probably" -- but, I do still give the shroud a 50/50 chance of being authentic...

- Obviously, I still want it to be authentic. Whatever, I still want to know the truth about it. And also, I still think that we humans need to develop an effective method of public debate -- that I have at least the beginnings of such a method -- and, that the shroud controversy makes for a perfect subject for analyzing the ins and outs of debate.
- And, as you already know, I believe that my method hasn't worked so far because you guys won't let me apply it fully. But then, I also think that I may be learning how to skirt your obstacles... We'll see.

My Dear Mr. Savage:

I hope you and yours had a delightful Advent Season, and are enjoying Christmas. I am seriously snowed in here on the Manzano Range in High Desert New Mexico, but have plenty of supplies and a week off, so all is well.

What evidence have you to offer that the "truth" about the CIQ is that it is ~2000 years old?

Keep in mind that that is only the first hurdle, but it is a big one. If the CIQ is not, in fact, ~2000 years old, none of the other objections matter--it cannot be a piece of cloth that was used to wrap anyone in the 1st Century C.E. if it does not, itself date from the 1st Century C.E.

Also keep in mind that even if the CIQ could be demonstrated to be ~2000 years old (which is not the same as casting aspersions on the 14C dating) you need to provide positive evidence of an age of ~2000 years); you would still have to overcome the historical record, the anatomical absurdities, the postural impossibilities, the "anti-gravity "hair" and "blood", the scriptural contradictions, and the fact that the byzantine-styled representational image is rendered (without distortion) on the sized and gessoed surface of a piece (not "strips") of linen.

In the spirit of your holy days, I beseech you to abandon your hope of "...some patching..." and provide positive evidence of a 1st Century C.E. date.

I hope your season brings you your own Epihany.

Through it all, I remain,

Patiently yours, &ct.
 
Last edited:
- But, I don't know what you don't agree with.

How abour, your claim that there is any evidence that the shroud is the burial cloth of Jesus (much less that the preponderance of evidence is si, or that it is even 50/50).

So perhaps you could start by providing that evidence? Again, not stuff that could maybe lighten the pan of the non-burial cloth side, but actual evidence that it is Jesus's burial cloth, meaning it is at least 2000 years old.
 
- At this point, I don't think that I can honestly apply "probably" -- but, I do still give the shroud a 50/50 chance of being authentic...

Jabba:

Is this a

"The shroud is either authentic, or it is not. So there is default chance of 0.50 that it is authentic."

argument?
 
- And, as you already know, I believe that my method hasn't worked so far because you guys won't let me apply it fully.

What if your method doesn't seem to be working because you have not provided any evidence that the cloth is the burial shroud of Jesus?
 
- But, I don't know what you don't agree with.

My Dear Mr. Savage:

Do consider simply marshaling, and presenting, what evidence you have that the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old (and do remember that "Mme F-L was incompetent" is not evidence of a 1st Century C.E. date).

I remain,

Faithfully yours &ct.
 
- But, I don't know what you don't agree with.


Have you tried reading people's responses in this thread, many of which explain what they don't agree with?

In case you can't manage that, how about:

Your claim that there is evidence that the shroud is authentic.

Your claim that evidence that casts doubt on the carbon dating, should you actually produce any, would be evidence of authenticity.

Your claim that the "preponderance of evidence" shows that the shroud is authentic.

Your claim that, in the face of clear evidence that it is impossible that the shroud is authentic, the idea of the "preponderance of evidence" is even relevant.
 
- Anyway,

- I probably shouldn't use the word "probably" anymore when referring to my opinion about the shroud. Dan Porter's opinion was a big part of mine,
and his recent announcement took me by surprise.
- At this point, I don't think that I can honestly apply "probably" -- but, I do still give the shroud a 50/50 chance of being authentic...

- Obviously, I still want it to be authentic. Whatever, I still want to know the truth about it. And also, I still think that we humans need to develop an effective method of public debate -- that I have at least the beginnings of such a method -- and, that the shroud controversy makes for a perfect subject for analyzing the ins and outs of debate.
- And, as you already know, I believe that my method hasn't worked so far because you guys won't let me apply it fully. But then, I also think that I may be learning how to skirt your obstacles... We'll see.

Prevaricator. What you are skirting are facts.
 
- Anyway,

- I probably shouldn't use the word "probably" anymore when referring to my opinion about the shroud. Dan Porter's opinion was a big part of mine,
and his recent announcement took me by surprise.
- At this point, I don't think that I can honestly apply "probably" -- but, I do still give the shroud a 50/50 chance of being authentic...

- Obviously, I still want it to be authentic. Whatever, I still want to know the truth about it. And also, I still think that we humans need to develop an effective method of public debate -- that I have at least the beginnings of such a method -- and, that the shroud controversy makes for a perfect subject for analyzing the ins and outs of debate.
- And, as you already know, I believe that my method hasn't worked so far because you guys won't let me apply it fully. But then, I also think that I may be learning how to skirt your obstacles... We'll see.

We already have an effective method, it's called the Scientific Method. Everyone here is using it but you.
 
- Anyway,

- I probably shouldn't use the word "probably" anymore when referring to my opinion about the shroud. Dan Porter's opinion was a big part of mine,
and his recent announcement took me by surprise.
- At this point, I don't think that I can honestly apply "probably" -- but, I do still give the shroud a 50/50 chance of being authentic...

- Obviously, I still want it to be authentic. Whatever, I still want to know the truth about it. And also, I still think that we humans need to develop an effective method of public debate -- that I have at least the beginnings of such a method -- and, that the shroud controversy makes for a perfect subject for analyzing the ins and outs of debate.
- And, as you already know, I believe that my method hasn't worked so far because you guys won't let me apply it fully. But then, I also think that I may be learning how to skirt your obstacles... We'll see.

Oh dear.

You still seem to be operating under the delusion that debate is the correct method to use, and that your variant of debating is the best way to go about it.

Once again: debate is a method that uses rhetoric to sway an opinion, not a method for weighing evidence to arrive at a conclusion.

Moreover, the use of the word "controversy" is somewhat amusing in the context of this thread. A cynic might conclude that the purpose of your bluff and bluster is to create the appearance of controversy when none exists, so that you can point at it and proclaim the issue unresolved. Such a tactic is well within the behavioral parameters you've already demonstrated in this thread.
 
Jabba, please present you evidence that makes you think there is a 50/50 chance the CUQ covered the body of the person you think of as Jesus. What is it that makes you think this?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom