Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
- I should have posed one claim at a time (and phrased the one slightly differently). Do you accept that in a debate it is very useful to make the specific disagreements as explicit as possible?

Do you agree that honest debate is not possible if one party ignores counter arguments and continually rehashes debunked bald assertions?
 
- I should have posed one claim at a time (and phrased the one slightly differently). Do you accept that in a debate it is very useful to make the specific disagreements as explicit as possible?

This thread is not about your stupid debating technique
 
Do you accept that in a debate it is very useful to make the specific disagreements as explicit as possible?


Do you accept that if one side of a debate fails to produce any evidence supporting its position, that side loses?
 
Last edited:
I just don't understand. Why the futile effort to keep this losing case alive?
Choose a different relic, or 'miracle' or 'open your heart to Jesus and let him speak to you' or whatever else, build a faith on that, and get on with it.
 
I just don't understand. Why the futile effort to keep this losing case alive?
Choose a different relic, or 'miracle' or 'open your heart to Jesus and let him speak to you' or whatever else, build a faith on that, and get on with it.

At one time, Jabba said he was trying to convert an invisible jury of lurkers. At another time, he said he was trying to convince himself.

I guess both require appeals to pseudoscience and logical fallacies.
 
At one time, Jabba said he was trying to convert an invisible jury of lurkers. At another time, he said he was trying to convince himself.

I guess both require appeals to pseudoscience and logical fallacies.
And yet it would be so easy to convert me. Just have god come down and regrow an amputee's limb. That would go a lot longer way than some vague cloth.
 
And yet it would be so easy to convert me. Just have god come down and regrow an amputee's limb. That would go a lot longer way than some vague cloth.

I volunteer to be the test subject!

God would convert me at the same time. A two-for-one,and all it takes is one teensy little miracle. Pretty small potatoes, really, compared to the stunts he used to pull - stopping the sun & moon in the sky, pillars of fire, toppling city walls.
 
I come back to this waste of a life called The Shroud Threads to see how it will all end.

I am sure there will never be any worthwhile evidence, nor any logical arguments supporting Jabba's position that the CIQ is authentic, even if these threads continue another 4 years.

Happy Boxing Day to you all!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom