Filippo Lippi
Philosopher
- Joined
- Nov 28, 2002
- Messages
- 5,568
Oh, he's gone
You go off on these waffling and pointless tangents about what kind of framework would support authnticity. Only to come back and throw out the same debunked claims.
This is not a debate because you will not engage with any counter argument.
- According to Jay, observation "trumps" inference.
- I would point out that this word doesn't really apply -- and confuses the issue -- when we're considering "preponderance of evidence."
- Do I need to explain?
My Dear Mr. Savage:
You do not need to "explain" your hope that you can avoid facing reality by pretending that this is a "trial", and that the proper standard is "preponderance of the evidence" (neither of which, as has been pointed out to you repeatedly) is correct.
Slowvehicle,
- If I understand what you're saying, my answer is that "preponderance of evidence" is not limited to a "trial" situation. It's like the basic concept in probability, and applies to any question of likelihood -- such as, "How likely is it that the shroud is authentic?"
- The word "trump" normally refers to a bi-variate situation, where "degree" is not taken into account. That is not the case when we're considering the probability of an event -- which is what we're considering here.
...
Reality is not decided by "preponderance of evidence"...
- Reality isn't, but probability is.
My Dear Mr. Savage:
You will be providing support for this statement?
...that would be refreshing.
I remain,
Hopefully yours, &ct.
Slowvehicle,
- Again, I suspect that I'm not understanding your question. It seems obvious to me that the probability of something being true is determined by compiling the relevant information (evidence) available -- i.e., by determining the preponderance of available evidence. Do you find that statement meaningless, or doubtful?
My Dear Mr. Savage:
I see.
Brief derail:
...You choose not to support your statement, but simply reiterate it, as if the problem were a deficiency in my understanding, instead of a deficiency in your unsupportable assertion.
I had actually hoped you might provide a citation or something to buttress your position.
Follow:
I do not find your statement "meaningless"; I find it incorrect.
I do not find your statement "doubtful"; I find it incorrect.
What, in your mind, is the "probability" of something that is impossible?
So what is the evidence that the shroud is the burial cloth of Jesus? In order to have a preponderance of evidence in the balance, you actually have to have something in the pan. All you ever talk about is taking evidence out of the other side, but without anything on the authentic side, it is meaningless.
For example, in what respect does the Raes claims provide evidence to put in the authentic pan? Hint: it doesn't . Even if it were patched in 1500, that does not mean it was the burial shroud of Jesus. See how that works?
Pgwenthold,
- Do you accept that if I had stuff in the authentic pan, showing weakness in the carbon dating would be meaningful?
Do you accept that if I had wings, I could fly.
If there were evidence for authenticity, we could compare that to the evidence for a forgery...
- In other words, "Yes. If I had stuff in the authentic pan, showing weakness in the carbon dating would be meaningful."
- A while back, I was told by your colleagues that the carbon dating amounted to a smoking gun, trumped any other evidence and that I needed to disprove its results before bothering with anything else.
- I claimed that I didn't need to disprove the results; I just needed to cast some doubt upon it. That's what I'm currently trying to do.
It doesn't matter how much you "take out" of the forgery pan, if there is nothing in the authentic pan, it doesn't matter, you can never tip the scales in its favor...
pgwenthold,
- I claim that making a disagreement in a debate as specific as possible is especially useful, and that hypothetical questions do just that. Do you disagree?
pgwenthold,Baseless hypotheticals do nothing to advance debate.
Unless you actually have some evidence for authenticity, it does not matter what hypotheticals you create.
That seems to imply that it does matter if I actually have some evidence of authenticity. Is that correct?
And here, I'm just trying to follow the directions encouraged by your colleagues...
...so before I go back to what I think is evidence of authenticity, I need to show that the carbon dating is not a slam dunk.
pgwenthold,
- That seems to imply that it does matter if I actually have some evidence of authenticity. Is that correct?
- And here, I'm just trying to follow the directions encouraged by your colleagues -- so before I go back to what I think is evidence of authenticity, I need to show that the carbon dating is not a slam dunk.
pgwenthold,
- That seems to imply that it does matter if I actually have some evidence of authenticity. Is that correct?
- And here, I'm just trying to follow the directions encouraged by your colleagues -- so before I go back to what I think is evidence of authenticity, I need to show that the carbon dating is not a slam dunk.
- That seems to imply that it does matter if I actually have some evidence of authenticity.
pgwenthold,
- That seems to imply that it does matter if I actually have some evidence of authenticity. Is that correct?
- And here, I'm just trying to follow the directions encouraged by your colleagues -- so before I go back to what I think is evidence of authenticity, I need to show that the carbon dating is not a slam dunk.
How about you stop wasting everyone's time with your nonsensical attempts at evasion and present the evidence you've been claiming you have? Or alternatively accept the reality that the shroud is a medieval fake.pgwenthold,
- That seems to imply that it does matter if I actually have some evidence of authenticity. Is that correct?
- And here, I'm just trying to follow the directions encouraged by your colleagues -- so before I go back to what I think is evidence of authenticity, I need to show that the carbon dating is not a slam dunk.
How about you stop wasting everyone's time with your nonsensical attempts at evasion and present the evidence you've been claiming you have? Or alternatively accept the reality that the shroud is a medieval fake.
Apparently someone told him that he's not allowed to do this until he's managed to cast sufficient doubt on the "slam dunk" carbon dating evidence. He'd make substantial progress on this if only people would engage in effective debateTM and follow each tiny thread's attempt to pick a hole in the carbon dating evidence to the very end without stopping it in its tracks with facts![]()
pgwenthold,
- That seems to imply that it does matter if I actually have some evidence of authenticity. Is that correct?
- And here, I'm just trying to follow the directions encouraged by your colleagues -- so before I go back to what I think is evidence of authenticity, I need to show that the carbon dating is not a slam dunk.
pgwenthold,
- I claim that making a disagreement in a debate as specific as possible is especially useful, and that hypothetical questions do just that. Do you disagree?
- I should have posed one claim at a time (and phrased the one slightly differently). Do you accept that in a debate it is very useful to make the specific disagreements as explicit as possible?Baseless hypotheticals do nothing to advance debate.
Unless you actually have some evidence for authenticity, it does not matter what hypotheticals you create.
- I should have posed one claim at a time (and phrased the one slightly differently). Do you accept that in a debate it is very useful to make the specific disagreements as explicit as possible?
- I should have posed one claim at a time (and phrased the one slightly differently). Do you accept that in a debate it is very useful to make the specific disagreements as explicit as possible?
- I should have posed one claim at a time (and phrased the one slightly differently). Do you accept that in a debate it is very useful to make the specific disagreements as explicit as possible?
- I should have posed one claim at a time (and phrased the one slightly differently). Do you accept that in a debate it is very useful to make the specific disagreements as explicit as possible?