Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
I claimed that I didn't need to disprove the results; I just needed to cast some doubt upon it. That's what I'm currently trying to do.

You are wrong. Simple as that. The C14 test is a conclusive result. "Some doubt" gets you nowhere. You need strong, objective counter-evidence. All else is a waste of time.

Hans
 
- In other words, "Yes. If I had stuff in the authentic pan, showing weakness in the carbon dating would be meaningful."
- A while back, I was told by your colleagues that the carbon dating amounted to a smoking gun, trumped any other evidence and that I needed to disprove its results before bothering with anything else.
- I claimed that I didn't need to disprove the results; I just needed to cast some doubt upon it. That's what I'm currently trying to do.

If it's wrong then we just don't have a carbon date. That's all. If the carbon dating never happened you'd still have no evidence the Shroud covered the body of the person you want it to have.
 
- Right. That's the idea. One step at a time. Tedious, but logical.

My Dear Mr. Savage:

It is dishonest of you to continue to pretend, as you do, that hypothetical expressions ("even IF it were possible for you to demonstrate a weakness...") represent actual situations ("...since you agree that the 14C dating is infirm, there has to be '...some patching'").

When do you intend to demonstrate that the CIQ must be ~2000 years old?

I remain,

Accurately yours, &ct.
 
- In other words, "Yes. If I had stuff in the authentic pan, showing weakness in the carbon dating would be meaningful."
- A while back, I was told by your colleagues that the carbon dating amounted to a smoking gun, trumped any other evidence and that I needed to disprove its results before bothering with anything else.
- I claimed that I didn't need to disprove the results; I just needed to cast some doubt upon it. That's what I'm currently trying to do.

My Dear Mr. Savage:

You should not make so free to paraphrase the words of others; especially when your "paraphrase" goes against the meaning of the original words. That is, simply, dishonest.

It has been pointed out to you, multiple times, that the 14C date is only one of a multitude of indications that the CIQ is manifestly medieval. To say nothing of the fact that, even were you to prove that the 14C date (provided by the mostly scrutinized bit of carbon dating ever) was, in fact, demonstrable an Illuminati plot, you would sill have the anatomical absurdity, the postural impossibility, the scriptural disagreement, the historical inaccuracy, and the anti-gravity "hair" and "blood" of the representational byzantine-styled image on the sized and gessoed surface of a manifestly medieval bit of linen.

When do you intend to begin producing any evidence that the CIQ is ~2000 years old?

I remain,

disappointedly yours, &ct.
 
Discussion Format

- In other words, "Yes. If I had stuff in the authentic pan, showing weakness in the carbon dating would be meaningful."
- A while back, I was told by your colleagues that the carbon dating amounted to a smoking gun, trumped any other evidence and that I needed to disprove its results before bothering with anything else.
- I claimed that I didn't need to disprove the results; I just needed to cast some doubt upon it. That's what I'm currently trying to do.

It doesn't matter how much you "take out" of the forgery pan, if there is nothing in the authentic pan, it doesn't matter, you can never tip the scales in its favor.
pgwenthold,
- I claim that making a disagreement in a debate as specific as possible is especially useful, and that hypothetical questions do just that. Do you disagree?
 
pgwenthold,
- I claim that making a disagreement in a debate as specific as possible is especially useful, and that hypothetical questions do just that. Do you disagree?

Why do we need your effective debate when we have the Scientific Method? Make a claim and support it with evidence. Pretty straight forward.
 
pgwenthold,
- I claim that making a disagreement in a debate as specific as possible is especially useful, and that hypothetical questions do just that. Do you disagree?

Absolutely disagree. Hypothetical questions are rarely useful, and mostly serve to cloud the issue.

Hans
 
Absolutely disagree. Hypothetical questions are rarely useful, and mostly serve to cloud the issue.

Hans

Indeed. As has been pointed out many times before, Jabba needs his hypotheticals because he has no evidence and thus must rely entirely on his "what if" scenarios.
 
pgwenthold,
- I claim that making a disagreement in a debate as specific as possible is especially useful, and that hypothetical questions do just that. Do you disagree?

Baseless hypotheticals do nothing to advance debate.

Unless you actually have some evidence for authenticity, it does not matter what hypotheticals you create.
 
I claim that making a disagreement in a debate as specific as possible is especially useful

You can claim that, but your argument style explicitly tends toward the opposite. You take my carefully and clearly worded posts and manipulate them as best you can to try to make them say something else. Equivocation, the mainstay of your argument, is the enemy of specificity.

...and that hypothetical questions do just that. Do you disagree?

I can't possibly disagree more. Between your highly dishonest and errant "map" maintained elsewhere and your ham-fisted attempts to cram "hypotheticals" into your critics' mouths, you're simply trying to pretend there is some other debate happening other than what is unfolding before your eyes.

When may we expect you to deal with the actual arguments on the table, not the ones you fervently wish had been made instead?
 
Last edited:
pgwenthold,
- I claim that making a disagreement in a debate as specific as possible is especially useful, and that hypothetical questions do just that. [...]

Is this series of 4 grotesque threads spread-out over as many years supposed to be an example of that?

If so, the verdict is: Fail.
 
Last edited:
- You post assertions made by shroudies without examining the evidence and argument behind them.
- You do not engage with considered and detailed criticism of these. That's just plain rude.
- You go off on these waffling and pointless tangents about what kind of framework would support authnticity. Only to come back and throw out the same debunked claims.
- As far as any actual debate going on, this is easily the limpest defence of an idea I have ever seen on these forums. We have zero vigorous back and forth. This is not a debate because you will not engage with any counter argument.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom