- In other words, "Yes. If I had stuff in the authentic pan, showing weakness in the carbon dating would be meaningful."
- A while back, I was told by your colleagues that the carbon dating amounted to a smoking gun, trumped any other evidence and that I needed to disprove its results before bothering with anything else.
- I claimed that I didn't need to disprove the results; I just needed to cast some doubt upon it. That's what I'm currently trying to do.
My Dear Mr. Savage:
You should not make so free to paraphrase the words of others; especially when your "paraphrase" goes against the meaning of the original words. That is, simply, dishonest.
It has been pointed out to you, multiple times, that the
14C date is
only one of a multitude of indications that the CIQ is manifestly medieval. To say nothing of the fact that, even were you to prove that the
14C date (provided by the mostly scrutinized bit of carbon dating ever) was, in fact, demonstrable an Illuminati plot, you would sill have the anatomical absurdity, the postural impossibility, the scriptural disagreement, the historical inaccuracy, and the anti-gravity "hair" and "blood" of the representational byzantine-styled image on the
sized and
gessoed surface of a manifestly medieval bit of linen.
When do you intend to begin producing any evidence that the CIQ is ~2000 years old?
I remain,
disappointedly yours, &ct.