Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Discussion Format

My Dear Mr. Savage:

As you have been told, repeatedly, even if it were possible for you to actually demonstrate a "weakness" in the 14C dating; that would, at best, indicate that the 14C dating did not conclusively date the CIQ to the mid-thirteenth Century, C.E. You would still have to deal with each and every one of the other indicators of medieval provenance...
- Right. That's the idea. One step at a time. Tedious, but logical.
 
- Right. That's the idea. One step at a time.


That's one more than we generally seem to see. You have yet to post anything that undermines the carbon dating, for example.

And the direction is also important. If you keep going around in circles the debate won't actually go anywhere.

Why not take a real step forward, and post whatever evidence you have that the cloth is around 2000 years old?
 
Last edited:
That's the idea. One step at a time. Tedious, but logical.

You aren't taking one step at a time. You're replaying the well-repeated steps over and over again, hoping to get a more favorable answer each time from newcomers you think don't know your tactics. The tedium can't be denied, but you create it by tediously retreading old ground and tediously equivocating until your critics are convinced you have little other purpose.

And there is nothing logical in your approach. The flaws in your logic have been explained to you several times by several people and you display absolutely no interest in correcting it or even acknowledging the contribution to the discussion.
 
Pgwenthold,
- Do you accept that if I had stuff in the authentic pan, showing weakness in the carbon dating would be meaningful?

Do you accept that if I had wings, I could fly.

If there were evidence for authenticity, we could compare that to the evidence for a forgery.

Now, what is the evidence that it is the burial cloth of Jesus?
 
How interesting that you avoid the entire issue in his post.

That's how Effective Debate™ works. He wasn't really specific regarding what it's effective at doing. The lengthy history of this thread and its progenitors suggests it's intended to effect a prolongation of the debate by means of a pattern of pseudo-participation.
 
I serves a purpose and you gave everyone a clue. It's a wilfully dishonest attempt to create the thin end of the wedge.

In addition it sets up a false dichotomy. Jango attempted just such a thing in one of the 9/11 threads. He posted a poll whose question whose wording was deliberately ambiguous. He slipped up later and admitted he had intended to entrap reasonable dissent into the "wrong" side of the poll. But the effect was to elicit a modicum of reasonable doubt and then rewrite it as support for the other side.

Yes, that creates the point of the wedge. But in the context of debates like this, it polarizes the respondents. "Do you believe the cloth is Jesus' burial shroud?" gets asked. Then a weaker form: "Do you think it's even remotely possible the cloth is Jesus' burial shroud?" Having been asked the stronger question first, the astute respondent sees what's being attempted. While it's abstractly possible, in the most trivial way, that the cloth could be authentic, the respondent rightly sense a trap.

If the respondent nods to the theoretical but impractically remote chance of success and says "Well, yes, but..." then it gets equivocated to the stronger form. If he remains faithful to the context of the ongoing discussion and says, "No, it's not," then that's what fuels the blogs that decry skeptics as intractable ideologues. The question gets taken out of that all-important context (which frankly is just ham-fisted rhetorical wrangling) and paraded as proof of how "unreasonable" skeptics are.

Motte and bailey, for those who want the Game of Thrones style nomenclature.
 
Carbon Dating/Doubts/Repair?/M&P/Entry #2

Pgwenthold,
- Do you accept that if I had stuff in the authentic pan, showing weakness in the carbon dating would be meaningful?

Do you accept that if I had wings, I could fly.

If there were evidence for authenticity, we could compare that to the evidence for a forgery.

Now, what is the evidence that it is the burial cloth of Jesus?
- In other words, "Yes. If I had stuff in the authentic pan, showing weakness in the carbon dating would be meaningful."
- A while back, I was told by your colleagues that the carbon dating amounted to a smoking gun, trumped any other evidence and that I needed to disprove its results before bothering with anything else.
- I claimed that I didn't need to disprove the results; I just needed to cast some doubt upon it. That's what I'm currently trying to do.
 
As you surely know, I have a theory (much disparaged by your colleagues) re what makes for effective debate, and a significant aspect of my theory requires tracing one 'branch' at a time to its end. So far, I haven't been able to do that in this setting, but currently think that I'm learning how to do it... We'll see.

It is worthy of much disparagement:

First, because you do not trace each branch to its end. Instead, you change horses at the last moment, to avoid acknowledging that the end of each branch goes against your preferred conclusion. You do this every single time. You betray your method always.

Second, because your method is irrelevant to the discovery of truth. For hundreds of years, now, humanity has discovered truth of all kinds, without having recourse to your method of effective debate. Scientists and scholars the world over, generation after generation, have been able to meet together and fruitfully discuss their ideas, without having recourse to your method.

  • The workings of gravity: Successfully investigated without your 'truly effective debate'.
  • The integral and differential calculus: Derived (more than once!) without your 'truly effective debate'.
  • The principles of aerodynamic flight: Established without your 'truly effective debate'.
  • The engineering of tall buildings: Developed without your 'truly effective debate'.
  • All of modern medicine: Practiced without your 'truly effective debate'.
  • All of history and archaeology: Studied without your 'truly effective debate'.
  • The mechanisms of electronic digital computation, that enable this discussion and many other rich discussions besides, implemented without your 'truly effective debate'.
  • The methods of weaving used in the manufacture of the Pope's ceremonial garments, invented and employed without your 'truly effective debate'.

In fact, there is no field of human endeavor, where truth has been discovered or results have been achieved, that has depended on your 'truly effective debate' for its success.

In fact, you have invented a method of debate whose sole purpose is to support your conclusion regarding the Shroud of Turin. And, in a twist that is both tragic and comic, your method fails even in this one purpose: You must abandon it at the moment of truth, every time.
 
- In other words, "Yes. If I had stuff in the authentic pan, showing weakness in the carbon dating would be meaningful."


But you don't. So it wouldn't.

ETA: And, as we have seen so often before, you're putting words in someone else's mouth.

- A while back, I was told by your colleagues that the carbon dating amounted to a smoking gun, trumped any other evidence and that I needed to disprove its results before bothering with anything else.
- I claimed that I didn't need to disprove the results; I just needed to cast some doubt upon it. That's what I'm currently trying to do.


That's what you're currently failing to do (among other things).
 
Last edited:
In other words...

Don't restate his post. In his words, your question is meaningless. It's an abstract conditional, and you're trying to "convert" it (in logical analysis terms). You have nothing in the Authenticity pan, so speculating on how the debate might go differently if you did is pointless.

A while back, I was told by your colleagues that the carbon dating amounted to a smoking gun, trumped any other evidence and that I needed to disprove its results before bothering with anything else.

I addressed this at some length in the preceding pages, and you're representing only half of what I said. It is necessary for you to address evidence contrary to your belief. However, addressing it is not sufficient to prove your belief in any way. Proving your belief requires both direct, affirmative evidence and credible rebuttals for counter evidence. Now that you've emphasized you're trying to argue a preponderance of evidence, merely rebutting your critics is not probative in that way.

I claimed that I didn't need to disprove the results; I just needed to cast some doubt upon it.

You can propose that, but you can't demand your critics (or the world) accept that as a reasonable standard of proof. This is just the standard meta-debate tactic fringe claimants use to arbitrarily dictate the onus and the standard of proof.

As I and others have repeatedly said, you can't weigh a preponderance between something and nothing. The something always wins by default, no matter how lightweight it is made to appear. And casting doubt on contrary evidence is an activity proper only to a fully populated argument. With nothing in the Authenticity pan, lightening the Forgery pan, conjuring up "doubt" by chipping little bits off of it, doesn't swing the scale in the least.

The doubt also has to be reasonable and substantial. Conjecture doesn't cut it. You and your authors are confusing doubt with denial. Denying the strength of counter evidence by imagining what might undermine it, without showing any that does, is not casting doubt. You want there to be a medieval patch where the 14C sample was taken. There simply isn't one. Your doubt is unreasonable.

So no, your approach is not valid. You don't understand the argument your critics have made regarding standards and methods of proof, and you're misrepresenting it.
 
Last edited:
- In other words, "Yes. If I had stuff in the authentic pan, showing weakness in the carbon dating would be meaningful."
- A while back, I was told by your colleagues that the carbon dating amounted to a smoking gun, trumped any other evidence and that I needed to disprove its results before bothering with anything else.
- I claimed that I didn't need to disprove the results; I just needed to cast some doubt upon it. That's what I'm currently trying to do.

You've been asked, time and again, to provide pro-authenticity evidence. You have steadfastly refused to do so - why ?

What evidence do you have which supports the authenticity ?
 
- In other words, "Yes. If I had stuff in the authentic pan, showing weakness in the carbon dating would be meaningful."
- A while back, I was told by your colleagues that the carbon dating amounted to a smoking gun, trumped any other evidence and that I needed to disprove its results before bothering with anything else.
- I claimed that I didn't need to disprove the results; I just needed to cast some doubt upon it. That's what I'm currently trying to do.

It doesn't matter how much you "take out" of the forgery pan, if there is nothing in the authentic pan, it doesn't matter, you can never tip the scales in its favor.

Then again, the "there might be a patch" assertions don't actually weaken the 14c dating because even if there "might" there is no reason to think there is, and lots of reasons to think there isn't. For example, there is no way a medieval cotton patch made from non-shroud fibers could lead to an un-interrupted banding pattern.

But again, this is all irrelevant if there is nothing in the authentic pan.
 
- Right. That's the idea. One step at a time. Tedious, but logical.

So which step are you on now? It's awfully hard for me to tell because at one time, I seem to remember that your discussion with someone who makes so-called invisible repairs for a living told you that they're not truly invisible, and you seemingly accepted this person's explanation and were going to concede the point. Now invisible repairs are back in play, despite the actual, factual, practical imposibility of repair in the sample area, as verified by textile experts who examined the cloth and found no indication of repairs in the area, and radiographs of the cloth which show uninterrupted banding through the same area.

So which step are you on now? Is it a step forward or backward?
 
- In other words, "Yes. If I had stuff in the authentic pan, showing weakness in the carbon dating would be meaningful."
.

Whose words were these? I think you are lying.

- A while back, I was told by your colleagues that the carbon dating amounted to a smoking gun, trumped any other evidence and that I needed to disprove its results before bothering with anything else.

OK


- I claimed that I didn't need to disprove the results; I just needed to cast some doubt upon it. That's what I'm currently trying to do.

You claim a lot of things all the time. You have spent 4 years trying to cast doubt on the 14C date, and you have failed in every attempt.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom