Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Discussion Format

*sigh* This shouldn't surprise me. At least the individual posts seem to have been copy/pasted verbatim, but the fact that they’re not shown chronologically means it’s not an accurate representation of the conversation.

Jabba, if you’re going to reproduce the discussion that’s taking place here on your website, at least do so in a way that maintains the integrity of the content.
Tomboy,
- I hardly know what I'm doing on my blog, and, for some reason keep deleting stuff by accident... Putting stuff back, requires me to take extra time to properly sort it. This isn't as easy as it would seem cause I'm trying to sort by specific topic rather than (or, before) chronology.
- If you don't want to be included on my blog, I'll take you off -- but I'd like to be able to quote you, and fit your questions/comments into the discourse by their specific topics first, and then by chronology.

- As you surely know, I have a theory (much disparaged by your colleagues) re what makes for effective debate, and a significant aspect of my theory requires tracing one 'branch' at a time to its end. So far, I haven't been able to do that in this setting, but currently think that I'm learning how to do it... We'll see.
 
I hardly know what I'm doing on my blog...

Then don't do it. There is widespread objection to your selective copypasting on your blog. You clearly cannot summarize the discussion accurately to the satisfaction of those whose statements you're using. If you aren't pleased either with your attempts at editorship, then give it up. It's highly insulting for you to beg indulgence for your ineptitude from the people who don't agree you should be editing the discussion at all.

As you surely know, I have a theory [...] re what makes for effective debate...

Nothing you're doing here constitutes effective debate, in theory or in practice. In fact, your critics have identified several elements in your approach here that seem calculated to make it as ineffective and illusory as possible. Skimming over the top of the debate, as you do, picking and choosing only ephemera to respond to, is insulting to the critics who are attempting to engage you directly and honestly.
 
Tomboy,
- I hardly know what I'm doing on my blog, and, for some reason keep deleting stuff by accident... Putting stuff back, requires me to take extra time to properly sort it. This isn't as easy as it would seem cause I'm trying to sort by specific topic rather than (or, before) chronology.
- If you don't want to be included on my blog, I'll take you off -- but I'd like to be able to quote you, and fit your questions/comments into the discourse by their specific topics first, and then by chronology.

- As you surely know, I have a theory (much disparaged by your colleagues) re what makes for effective debate, and a significant aspect of my theory requires tracing one 'branch' at a time to its end. So far, I haven't been able to do that in this setting, but currently think that I'm learning how to do it... We'll see.

Your map is a bad joke and you cannot even adhere to your own waffling ideas about makes for effective debate.
 
Pgwenthold,
- Do you accept that if I had stuff in the authentic pan, showing weakness in the carbon dating would be meaningful?

My Dear Mr. Savage:

As you have been told, repeatedly, even if it were possible for you to actually demonstrate a "weakness" in the 14C dating; that would, at best, indicate that the 14C dating did not conclusively date the CIQ to the mid-thirteenth Century, C.E. You would still have to deal with each and every one of the other indicators of medieval provenance, or, even even better, provide the slightest indication (not the Whangers' "coins", but actual evidence) of the CIQ being ~2000 years old (something you have yet to even begin to do).

it is not a binary problem, no matter how blithely you choose to cling to your pretense that it is.

I also encourage you to be punctiliously accurate in your dealings with the sidonists.

Somewhat disappointedly, I remain,

Faithfully yours, &ct.
 
You would still have to deal with each and every one of the other indicators of medieval provenance...

And in his weighing analogy, that's not putting stuff in the Authentic pan. It's taking stuff out of the Medieval pan.

...or, even even better, provide the slightest indication (not the Whangers' "coins", but actual evidence) of the CIQ being ~2000 years old (something you have yet to even begin to do).

That's the only thing that puts weight in the Authentic pan. If there's nothing there, then taking stuff out of the Medieval pan never tips the balance toward authenticity -- even if the Medieval pan were completely empty.
 
After coffee and a big breakfast I'm about ready to deposit some evidence of kind we have become accustomed to in the authentic pan.
 
Jabba, the evidence in the "pro-forgery" pan is rather weighty: the 14C dating, the preserved letters among church officials, the medieval rendering of the image, the weave--and even the twist of the yarn.

All you're putting on to the "pro-authentic" pan is hot air and dust bunnies.
 
- That would be great if you could stop diddling around and present some evidence for the authentic pan.
- Will you be back with that?
- Haven't you given showing weakness in the carbon dating your best shot by tossing around shroudie web links and talking points but repeatedly failed?
- Are you bored of probability talk and about to rehash past points as if they were not abject failures every other time you have raised them, ignoring past criticisms?
- Are these questions obviously rhetorical given your years of dishonest behaviour in your threads?


Well spake.
 
Pgwenthold,
- Do you accept that if I had stuff in the authentic pan, showing weakness in the carbon dating would be meaningful?
Well then, considering that entry #1 in your most recent list of evidence has been thoroughly debunked, I take it that we can place that in the medieval forgery pan, and the scales have now significantly tilted away from authenticity. This is easy!
 
- As you surely know, I have a theory (much disparaged by your colleagues) re what makes for effective debate, and a significant aspect of my theory requires tracing one 'branch' at a time to its end. So far, I haven't been able to do that in this setting...


Largely because whenever one of your points is demolished, you change the subject, only to return to it later.
 
snip.

- As you surely know, I have a theory (much disparaged by your colleagues) re what makes for effective debate, and a significant aspect of my theory requires tracing one 'branch' at a time to its end. So far, I haven't been able to do that in this setting, but currently think that I'm learning how to do it... We'll see.

Yeah, your idea about debate isn't a very good one and you're the only one engaging in it and selectively at that. You should just produce evidence for your claim. All else is just hiding behind process in a now clearly failed attempt to obscure the fact that you cannot produce evidence for the CIQ being what you want it to be.
 
- As you surely know, I have a theory (much disparaged by your colleagues) re what makes for effective debate, and a significant aspect of my theory requires tracing one 'branch' at a time to its end. So far, I haven't been able to do that in this setting, but currently think that I'm learning how to do it... We'll see.

To do this, we must agree on when a branch is at its end. It won't work when one side (you) insists on wordsplitting endlessly over little details.

And, please stop trying to lure little consessions out of people all the time. It is dishonest, and it serves no purpose.

Hans
 
I serves a purpose and you gave everyone a clue. It's a wilfully dishonest attempt to create the thin end of the wedge.

"If you concede that this bit of nonsense is true, just for argument's sake, then this bit of nonsense might be true, which means this other bit of nonsense might be true...[repeat n times..], then this piece of 'evidence' belongs in the pro-pan"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom