Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Carbon Dating/Doubts/Repair?/M&P/Entry #2

Slowvehicle,
- If I understand what you're saying, my answer is that "preponderance of evidence" is not limited to a "trial" situation. It's like the basic concept in probability, and applies to any question of likelihood -- such as, "How likely is it that the shroud is authentic?"
- The word "trump" normally refers to a bi-variate situation, where "degree" is not taken into account. That is not the case when we're considering the probability of an event -- which is what we're considering here.

Reality is not decided by "preponderance of evidence"...
- Reality isn't, but probability is.
My Dear Mr. Savage:
You will be providing support for this statement?
...that would be refreshing...
Slowvehicle,
- Again, I suspect that I'm not understanding your question. It seems obvious to me that the probability of something being true is determined by compiling the relevant information (evidence) available -- i.e., by determining the preponderance of available evidence. Do you find that statement meaningless, or doubtful?
 
Slowvehicle,
- Again, I suspect that I'm not understanding your question. It seems obvious to me that the probability of something being true is determined by compiling the relevant information (evidence) available -- i.e., by determining the preponderance of available evidence. Do you find that statement meaningless, or doubtful?

Stop being obtuse.
 
Again, I suspect that I'm not understanding your question.

You aren't, but it's already been answered at least twice by me and innumerable times by others. Asking it repeatedly while ignoring those answers is rude and disrespectful. Your critics question whether your obtuseness is deliberate. This sort of evasion helps them decide.

It seems obvious to me that the probability of something being true is determined by compiling the relevant information (evidence) available -- i.e., by determining the preponderance of available evidence.

Asked and answered.

The probability of something being true is irrelevant when you can observe directly whether it's true or not. Any exercise aimed at estimating or computing the probability of a different outcome is moot and unprobative. And more than a little ridiculous.

Additionally your proposed estimation exercise is flawed because you propose to decide the preponderance not between evidence and evidence, but between evidence and conjecture. That is a qualitatively invalid comparison.

Do you find that statement meaningless, or doubtful?

It's meaningless in the context of your argument, for the reasons patiently elaborated and assiduously ignored by you.
 
Slowvehicle,
- Again, I suspect that I'm not understanding your question. It seems obvious to me that the probability of something being true is determined by compiling the relevant information (evidence) available -- i.e., by determining the preponderance of available evidence. Do you find that statement meaningless, or doubtful?

My Dear Mr. Savage:

I see.

Brief derail:

You choose not to support your statement, but simply reiterate it, as if the problem were a deficiency in my understanding, instead of a deficiency in your unsupportable assertion.

I had actually hoped you might provide a citation or something to buttress your position.

Follow:

I do not find your statement "meaningless"; I find it incorrect.

I do not find your statement "doubtful"; I find it incorrect.

What, in your mind, is the "probability" of something that is impossible?



Instead of pursuing yet another attempt to avoid the question, why not simply marshal, and present, any evidence at all that the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old?

I remain,

Determinedly yours &ct.
 
It seems obvious to me that the probability of something being true is determined by compiling the relevant information (evidence) available -- i.e., by determining the preponderance of available evidence. Do you find that statement meaningless, or doubtful?


Jabba,
- What is the probability of something being true if it is impossible?
 
Slowvehicle,
- Again, I suspect that I'm not understanding your question. It seems obvious to me that the probability of something being true is determined by compiling the relevant information (evidence) available -- i.e., by determining the preponderance of available evidence. Do you find that statement meaningless, or doubtful?

So what is the evidence that the shroud is the burial cloth of Jesus? In order to have a preponderance of evidence in the balance, you actually have to have something in the pan. All you ever talk about is taking evidence out of the other side, but without anything on the authentic side, it is meaningless.

For example, in what respect does the Raes claims provide evidence to put in the authentic pan? Hint: it doesn't . Even if it were patched in 1500, that does not mean it was the burial shroud of Jesus. See how that works?
 
[...]Jabba, for the record, please do not quote me or refer to anything I’ve said on your website. Thanks kindly in advance.

* Other than you seem to have this mistaken idea that if you can convince enough people to agree with you, your belief in the Shroud as the burial cloth of Jesus will be proven correct despite all of the facts and evidence to the contrary, but science doesn’t work that way.

Jabba has already quoted you.
 
Slowvehicle,
- Again, I suspect that I'm not understanding your question. It seems obvious to me that the probability of something being true is determined by compiling the relevant information (evidence) available -- i.e., by determining the preponderance of available evidence. Do you find that statement meaningless, or doubtful?

Jabba, important info:

Probability cannot be used to evauate the truth of a statement. It can only be used to try to predict an outcome.

If you want to try to calculate the probability that the shroud is found authentic, an important factor is the probability that Jesus existed, that he was crucified, and that he was resurrected. This alone is a virtually impossible to do, but here comes the real catch: As the probability of Jesus is an important factor in the probability of the authentic shroud, you cannot afterwards use the shroud to argue for the authenticy of Jesus, because that would be a circular argument.

Hans
 
With the OP again burying failed attempts at evidence with hand wringing over probability, I can't help but think the introduction of Baysian methods could drag things out to great effect.
 
Jabba has already quoted you.

*sigh* This shouldn't surprise me. At least the individual posts seem to have been copy/pasted verbatim, but the fact that they’re not shown chronologically means it’s not an accurate representation of the conversation.

Jabba, if you’re going to reproduce the discussion that’s taking place here on your website, at least do so in a way that maintains the integrity of the content.
 
Tell me about it! I threw up a little in my mouth after reading the comments after Jabba's guest post. Here are a few notable "comments":

"Richard, seeing as these athiests seem to attack you on all fronts, never really giving you a chance to direct yourself to one area (A typical strategy by the way). Here’s a tip; Attack them directly at their strongest points for inauthenticity and don’t waver from this strategy.They don’t have many points; C14, d’ Arcis, McCrone. But be specific and thorough. With the c14 you may want to explain to them first, it’s fallibility and it’s propensity to errors, from it’s basic assumptions, up to written documents showing very good ‘reviews’ of the supposed peer-reviewed Nature paper. Little unknown facts such as all labs using samples of too small or of too low weight to be properly sampled, for example." - Ron

"Yes, I agree. They change topics constantly. They aren’t willing to actually DISCUSS anything. This shows their blatant dishonesty, in my opinion." - AnnieCee

"One thing they can’t handle is anything supernatural. And yet the evidence collected so far about the Shroud indicates that something supernatural most likely DID happen in order to imprint the image on the cloth.
Maybe you can’t exactly prove it, but they can’t disprove it either."
- AnnieCee

"Ron and Annie,
– I don’t have time to address your points tonight, but I’ll be back tomorrow. So, don’t go away."
- Guess who?

"They have read absolutely nothing on the science of radiocarbon dating or vanillan loss as stated by R Rogers, most of them are talking out of their ‘other’ ends…It also seems they get all their answers from a couple of athiest sites and non scholarly writings." - Ron

"“Also what do you mean by the supposed peer-review?” Exactly what it says. If the RCD article released by Nature was peer-reviewed, it was a very shoddy job. Almost bad enough to the point that one wonders was it actually properly reviewed or just scanned over quickly." - Ron, implying that the peer review process on the Nature article was shoddy

"Also — when confronting Randian Looney Tunes, it is important to hold them to their own standards. They are ready to dismiss any work supportive of the Shroud if it is not peer-reviewed, or they can find some *ad hominem* against the author; but they dismiss out of hand even the possibility of anything against atheists attacking the Shroud, usually by demanding proof *ad infinitum*. See post #69 on the Randian thread for examples." - grey

"These athiests are completely biased, blinded, unintelligent and more precisely talking thru their rear orifices. Notice their references to Joe Nickels for most of their evidence…that very telling of thier intelligence….they actually would accept the words of Nickels against the peer-reviewed words of a world reknowned chemist as R. Rogers….idiots." - Ron

"I learned that they tend to get crazy if you talk about Noah’s Ark... There’s plenty of evidence of the Flood, lots and lots of it. The flood is probably what throws off Carbon dating because they don’t factor that in. That’s my opinion on it anyway because I think their dates are screwy. It jumps from 10,000 years to millions and billions – with hardly anything in between. In other words, carbon dating gets really weird if they try to go back before the flood happened and so I think they left the flood out of their algorithms." - AnnieCee

"They refuse to talk about angels. Even though there’s an endless supply of stories from people who have met and talked with angels or had angels save their life. They won’t go there. An angel saved MY life one time, maybe more than that. I’ve seen a few genuine for-real documented miracles. But of course they mock all of it. Even the PROOF is not good enough for them, the idiots." - AnnieCee

"Running in circles is probably my biggest problem, and I think that I know how to prevent such foolishness — it’s just hard to resist the temptation to try to answer all my opponents questions and objections as quickly as possible…" - Jabba, admitting that he purposefully slows the entire process down for the purpose of messing with everybody on the forum
 
Carbon Dating/Doubts/Repair?/M&P/Entry #2

So what is the evidence that the shroud is the burial cloth of Jesus? In order to have a preponderance of evidence in the balance, you actually have to have something in the pan. All you ever talk about is taking evidence out of the other side, but without anything on the authentic side, it is meaningless.

For example, in what respect does the Raes claims provide evidence to put in the authentic pan? Hint: it doesn't . Even if it were patched in 1500, that does not mean it was the burial shroud of Jesus. See how that works?
Pgwenthold,
- Do you accept that if I had stuff in the authentic pan, showing weakness in the carbon dating would be meaningful?
 
Do you accept that if I had stuff in the authentic pan, showing weakness in the carbon dating would be meaningful?

"Showing weakness in the carbon dating" is not something you can put in the "authentic pan." You don't seem to understand, at a fundamental level, what evidence actually is.
 
Pgwenthold,
- Do you accept that if I had stuff in the authentic pan, showing weakness in the carbon dating would be meaningful?

- That would be great if you could stop diddling around and present some evidence for the authentic pan.
- Will you be back with that?
- Haven't you given showing weakness in the carbon dating your best shot by tossing around shroudie web links and talking points but repeatedly failed?
- Are you bored of probability talk and about to rehash past points as if they were not abject failures every other time you have raised them, ignoring past criticisms?
- Are these questions obviously rhetorical given your years of dishonest behaviour in your threads?
 
Last edited:
That would do nothing to establish the date.

...or location or style or composition or culture or ownership or provenance or any of the other things we discussed would have to come out affirmatively favorable for a rational person to even consider the possibility that it was the actual burial cloth of Jesus.

Affirmatively favorable. No amount of chipping away at the undesired findings creates that affirmative statement. No amount, Jabba. They are qualitatively dissimilar things.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom