Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Tomboy,
- Would you consider what was found in the Raes samples as a little bit of evidence of repair in the Raes sample?

See? He does it again. Tries to elicit some little concession, which will then translate to something like "repairs were done in the same area as the C14 sample".:mad:

There is no other reason to ask that question, because logically it is totally irrelevant what is or is not in the Raes sample.

Hans
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle,
- If I understand what you're saying, my answer is that "preponderance of evidence" is not limited to a "trial" situation. It's like the basic concept in probability, and applies to any question of likelihood -- such as, "How likely is it that the shroud is authentic?"
- The word "trump" normally refers to a bi-variate situation, where "degree" is not taken into account. That is not the case when we're considering the probability of an event -- which is what we're considering here.


Jabba,
- you are standing on a sidewalk at noon, enjoying the sunshine. The sidewalk is dry, there isn't a cloud in the sky, and no trace of moisture in the air.
- someone phones you from 50 miles away and tells you that they think they hear thunder.
- someone else tells you that if someone is holding a large and invisible (or nearly invisible) umbrella over you then it could be raining.
- someone says that it has rained there in the past.
- several people say that it might be raining somewhere else.
- on the preponderance of the evidence, how likely is it that it is raining right now where you are?
 
Last edited:
Tomboy,
- Would you consider what was found in the Raes samples as a little bit of evidence of repair in the Raes sample?

How about you make that argument and explain why what was done and what was found should constitute evidence of repair. For bonus points in honesty, do so while addressing critique of the Raes samples as evidence made by your ever patient interlocutors in this thread.
 
Last edited:
And ain't it dandy you are currently focused on what "the preponderance of evidence" means. A neat red herring to pick at, forget for a bit, returning to the stinky carcase when embarrassed by the stark reality that you have no evidence at all.
 
Slowvehicle,
- I'm not sure what you mean by "infelicity" here.

My Dear mr. Savage:

An "infelicity" is a remark, phrase, or usage that is inappropriate, inept, and/or unapt.

See, for example, your deeply-held belief that you may define both A and ~A in a condition.

Through it all, I remain,

Lexicographically yours, &ct.
 
Last edited:
..

- At any rate, I still think that the M&P papers constitute evidence, and for now, I'll keep trying to show why.

Look at that. You allowed yourself to be distracted, what was the probability of that happening?




(hint - it's vanishingly close to 1 as you have been backed into a corner)
 
Reality isn't, but probability is.

This is not a probabilistic comparison, for the reasons already belabored by myself and others, and assiduously ignored by you. If one is able to observe the reality of something, then no amount of probabilistic conjuration or preponderant hand-waving to the contrary changes it.
 
Evidence of preponderance

You know how when you repeat a word or phrase over and over again, it loses all meaning? That's what happened to me when "preponderance of evidence" came up for the eleventy-billionth time. I had to look it up to get some perspective, and this is what I found at dictionary.law.com (I only copied the relevant bits and highlighted the parts the grabbed my attention):

This preponderance is based on the more convincing evidence and its probable truth or accuracy, and not on the amount of evidence. Thus, one clearly knowledgeable witness may provide a preponderance of evidence over a dozen witnesses with hazy testimony...


If we're going with the Matlock scenario, the shroudies have contributed only feathers and hot air to their side of the scale.

Meanwhile, back in reality...

- Reality isn't, but probability is.


Wow. Deep. Pass the dutchie.
 
What a merry dance. Ive almost forgotten your last failed attempt to provide evidence for authenticity.
 
Tomboy,
- Would you consider what was found in the Raes samples as a little bit of evidence of repair in the Raes sample?

Hi Jabba.

I'm not at all sure why you're asking me for my opinion about any of this*. I'm not a scientist or an expert in any relevant field of study, and plenty of the other participants in this discussion whom you regularly dismiss and ignore have done far more research into the matter than I and are more knowledgeable. Whether I agree with you or not isn't going to change the evidence.

But no, a few stray cotton fibers are in no way evidence of a repair or patch of any kind.

Can you explain to me why you think a few stray cotton fibers are evidence of repair and why that would be relevant to the issue of the date of origin of the Shroud? The Raes sample wasn't the piece that was carbon dated, and the piece that was carbon dated was meticulously inspected by textile (and other) experts who were specifically looking for any sort of aberration that would make it inappropriate for testing.

Don't fall for it Tomboy, If you answer in the slightest bit affirmative, he'll misquoted you as supporting him. He's been caught doing that again and again. He's been caught misquoting peeps on his web site too.

No worries. I don’t speak up much but I’ve been following along through all of these threads. I’m trying to choose my words carefully so I don’t inadvertently leave any wiggle room that could be misinterpreted.

Jabba, for the record, please do not quote me or refer to anything I’ve said on your website. Thanks kindly in advance.

* Other than you seem to have this mistaken idea that if you can convince enough people to agree with you, your belief in the Shroud as the burial cloth of Jesus will be proven correct despite all of the facts and evidence to the contrary, but science doesn’t work that way.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom