Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
...

Your critics have noted this shell game and asked you to explain yourself. Will you finally do that? Or will you continue the ham-fisted motte-and-bailey tactic?

...

That's a new one. I've looked it up, but I keep running into (1) medieval fortifications or (2) hard to follow philosophical definitions.

However, I think I get the gist.
 
Slowvehicle,
- As I've always claimed: though I want the shroud to be authentic, I'm here trying to weigh the evidence, and Dan Porter's opinion has been a significant weight on the pro side of my scales. I hadn't realized how strong his doubts were before this news...

Fair enough, Jabba, but if you want to weigh evidence, you must do it accordingly to commonly accepted scales. You can't invent your own weighing method.

Of course, there is always to possibility to, like Dan Porter seems to have done, simply admit that you were mistaken.

Just because we don't have his shroud, you can still believe in Jesus. After all, we also don't have his shoes, or his walking stick.

Hans
 
He's resigning from blogging to pursue other interests, but gives as his parting shot the belief that the preponderance of evidence still favors authenticity.

In other words, safe and sound in the illusion that he has submitted his beliefs to the judgment of a skeptical audience and emerged victorious.
Exactly. There is just too much evidence that the shroud is a medieval fake so he's abandoning any pretense of actual investigation in favour of declaring victory.

Distraction.
Yep.

- As I've always claimed: though I want the shroud to be authentic, I'm here trying to weigh the evidence, and Dan Porter's opinion has been a significant weight on the pro side of my scales.
Why? He had provided no evidence to support his opinion.

- At any rate, I still think that the M&P papers constitute evidence, and for now, I'll keep trying to show why.
Rubbish.
 
That's a new one. I've looked it up, but I keep running into (1) medieval fortifications or (2) hard to follow philosophical definitions.

However, I think I get the gist.

It's a form of equivocation; depending on which suits at the time, you take either a strict or loose definition of a word or phrase.
 
It's a form of equivocation; depending on which suits at the time, you take either a strict or loose definition of a word or phrase.

Yes, or of an entire argument. You use the weak form as an illusion of conciliation to draw an opponent out into a tentative position, then redeploy the argument in its stronger form. Jabba's arguments include tactical withdrawals that are meant to elicit a commensurate softening in his critics followed by an alignment of purpose -- "we're all just students and truth-seekers here," etc. Sadly it's being employed too ineptly to work.
 
Yes, or of an entire argument. You use the weak form as an illusion of conciliation to draw an opponent out into a tentative position, then redeploy the argument in its stronger form. Jabba's arguments include tactical withdrawals that are meant to elicit a commensurate softening in his critics followed by an alignment of purpose -- "we're all just students and truth-seekers here," etc. Sadly it's being employed too ineptly to work.

Yes or in the form:

Asking after some discourse where the weak for has been used: Do you agree that [weak form]?

Then, if the answer is positive, Jabba assumes the strong form.

He has done/attempted that several times. Last time recently.


Hans
 
Yes or in the form:

Asking after some discourse where the weak for has been used: Do you agree that [weak form]?

Then, if the answer is positive, Jabba assumes the strong form.

He has done/attempted that several times. Last time recently.


Hans

It is almost as if he is more aware of strategy and use of deliberate debating tricks than for which he has been willing to give himself credit. I had been concerned for Jabba in the past when he has cited memory problems, that he couldn't keep up with more than one debater or question, that he misplaced his notes, or when he asked for the assistance of his "opponents" in finding support for his own positions, but I've come to believe that he is much more capable and on-top than he had feared.
 
Carbon Dating/Doubts/Repair?/M&P/Entry #2

...
All of which is a very long and wordy way of saying that, yes, I agree with those who don’t count entry #2 as evidence.
Tomboy,
- Would you consider what was found in the Raes samples as a little bit of evidence of repair in the Raes sample?
 
Tomboy,
- Would you consider what was found in the Raes samples as a little bit of evidence of repair in the Raes sample?

Don't fall for it Tomboy, If you answer in the slightest bit affirmative, he'll misquoted you as supporting him. He's been caught doing that again and again. He's been caught misquoting peeps on his web site too.
 
Last edited:
Evidence

- According to Jay, observation "trumps" inference.
- I would point out that this word doesn't really apply -- and confuses the issue -- when we're considering "preponderance of evidence."
- Do I need to explain?

My Dear Mr. Savage:

You do not need to "explain" your hope that you can avoid facing reality by pretending that this is a "trial", and that the proper standard is "preponderance of the evidence" (neither of which, as has been pointed out to you repeatedly) is correct...
Slowvehicle,
- If I understand what you're saying, my answer is that "preponderance of evidence" is not limited to a "trial" situation. It's like the basic concept in probability, and applies to any question of likelihood -- such as, "How likely is it that the shroud is authentic?"
- The word "trump" normally refers to a bi-variate situation, where "degree" is not taken into account. That is not the case when we're considering the probability of an event -- which is what we're considering here.
 
It's like the basic concept in probability, and applies to any question of likelihood -- such as, "How likely is it that the shroud is authentic?"

Since you present no evidence that it is, the answer is "not at all." Since others present considerable countermanding evidence for a different origin, the answer is "not at all." Since you can't even answer the countermanding evidence, much less present any of your own to weigh, the analogy to a probabilistic comparison is simply irrelevant.

The word "trump" normally refers to a bi-variate situation, where "degree" is not taken into account. That is not the case when we're considering the probability of an event -- which is what we're considering here.

No, we are not. Do not rewrite or reinterpret my statements. Observation trumps inference because it is qualitatively conclusive whereas inference is not. We are not weighing probabilities. Observation removes probability from the consideration.
 
Slowvehicle,
- If I understand what you're saying, my answer is that "preponderance of evidence" is not limited to a "trial" situation. It's like the basic concept in probability, and applies to any question of likelihood -- such as, "How likely is it that the shroud is authentic?"
- The word "trump" normally refers to a bi-variate situation, where "degree" is not taken into account. That is not the case when we're considering the probability of an event -- which is what we're considering here.

It's not authentic. It's a fake. You lost.
 
Slowvehicle,
- If I understand what you're saying, my answer is that "preponderance of evidence" is not limited to a "trial" situation. It's like the basic concept in probability, and applies to any question of likelihood -- such as, "How likely is it that the shroud is authentic?"
- The word "trump" normally refers to a bi-variate situation, where "degree" is not taken into account. That is not the case when we're considering the probability of an event -- which is what we're considering here.

My Dear Mr. Savage:

You have demonstrated your infelicity with probabilities in your "immortality" thread.

Reality is not decided by "preponderance of evidence"; but instead, by the presence or absence of actual evidence.

Your continues wish that there were some sort of adulteration in the samples bit of the manifestly medieval linen of the CIQ has led you to try to equate conjecture with evidence. The sidonists' inveterate (and self-contradictory) claims that there must be "...some patching" is not evidence that there is "...patching"

It is, in fact evidence of their desperate adherence to groundless assertion, in service of their assumed consequent, but it is not in any way evidence about the CIQ itself.

I suggest you present any evidence of which you are aware that indicates that the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom