Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
- According to Jay, observation "trumps" inference.
- I would point out that this word doesn't really apply -- and confuses the issue -- when we're considering "preponderance of evidence."
- Do I need to explain?

Don't waste your time. You don't have any preponderence of evidence. You have a preponderance of wishful thinking and faulty logic. No one here is confused except perhaps yourself.
 
and confuses the issue -- when we're considering "preponderance of evidence."

As others have stated, you're the one trying to confuse the issue by insisting that we consider speculation on par with actual evidence. They are qualitatively dissimilar and, in terms of probative value, as dissimilar as night and day. This is one of two reasons why your scale pan metaphor is dishonest. You visualize it as placing one thing in the "pro" pan and another thing in the "con" pan and seeing where the scale balances. It's dishonest because only one of those things is a thing. You have nothing to put in the other pan. Conjecture only describes what could be put in the pan. It doesn't actually put anything there. In terms of evidence that is, versus evidence that could be if you would only produce it, the scale thunks quite solidly and loudly down on the side that has actual evidence.

The other reason your metaphor is dishonest is that in you hands it's not an objective tool. You simply say you won't believe what's in the other pan. That's tantamount to holding your hand under it to keep its ponderance from having its true effect. You dismiss what's in one pan based on nothing more substantial than your dislike of its weight. You are not dispassionately and objectively weighing evidence. Your bias glares quite brightly.
 
Suppose you explain, in your own words, what is there, and what you think it means.

He's resigning from blogging to pursue other interests, but gives as his parting shot the belief that the preponderance of evidence still favors authenticity.

In other words, safe and sound in the illusion that he has submitted his beliefs to the judgment of a skeptical audience and emerged victorious.
 
He's resigning from blogging to pursue other interests, but gives as his parting shot the belief that the preponderance of evidence still favors authenticity.

In other words, safe and sound in the illusion that he has submitted his beliefs to the judgment of a skeptical audience and emerged victorious.

How very...odd. Does he give any indication whether he intends to continue here?
 
- According to Jay, observation "trumps" inference.
- I would point out that this word doesn't really apply -- and confuses the issue -- when we're considering "preponderance of evidence."
- Do I need to explain?

It does. But you may say that observation out-preponders inference, if that works better for you.

Also, it is not inference, it is conjecture, which does not preponder at all.

Hans
 
Last edited:
Congratulations, Tomboy, on your selection as Jabba's current Least Skeptical Poster. It is not a permanent position, but it is an important one. I wish you luck over the next few days and hope you can help move this thread forward. Remember, with great power comes great responsibility. Godspeed.
Hoo boy. If the regular participants in this discussion haven’t been able to move the thread forward over the years, then the likelihood of me being able to do so is about equal to the likelihood that the Shroud of Turin is actually 2000 years old. :p (Note to Jabba: That’s not an admission that I believe the SoT is 2000 years old. All evidence indicates that it’s a medieval artifact.)

Tomboy,
- So far, I don't agree with why others don't count Entry#2 as evidence. Is your explanation the same as theirs?
- Whatever, I'll go back and rethink their explanations.

Please do. In the meantime, can you explain to me, in your own words, what part of Entry 2 you find compelling and why? Because I’m having trouble wrapping my brain around Benford and Marino’s reasoning. Help convince me.

Here’s my take. Entry #2 starts with, “Textile expert Gilbert Raes of Belgium, who extracted a sample in 1973 for analysis, wrote in his report that he found cotton.” McCrone found occasional cotton fibers in his samples, and he had samples from multiple areas of the shroud (source: “Judgment Day for the Shroud of Turin”, Walter McCrone, Prometheus Books, 1999.), so it doesn’t surprise me that a bit of cotton was found in the Raes sample, too. The source of that cotton could be almost anything, from cotton fibers that got mixed in with the flax during the original manufacture, to contamination from cloth gloves worn by the people who handle the shroud.

Then Benford and Marino somehow take that one statement about cotton and turn it into a cotton-containing patch. Note that this source sites Raes as actually saying, “in some of the preparations from the warp as well as from the weft of Piece 1, traces of cotton fibers were observed.” (Footnote lists source as Gilbert Raes: “The textile study of 1973-1974”. Shroud Spectrum International. 1991. N°38/39.) That’s a pretty big leap to go from “traces of cotton fibers” to “cotton-containing patch”. Without knowing anything else about them, Benford and Marino lose credibility with me right there.

Let’s play What If. What if there really was a cotton-containing patch in the Raes sample? First, the Raes sample wasn’t carbon dated. It was next to the area that was carbon dated, so any patch on the Raes sample couldn’t have affected the carbon dated sample. That’s where we’re going with this, right? Because the only way a patch can in any way help your argument towards a non-medieval origin is if it somehow skewed the carbon 14 dating, and did so drastically.

Second, just like the dirt/contamination issue, a patch containing enough cotton to skew the carbon dating results would have to be more cotton than original shroud material. In other words, it would be highly visible. Not invisible, or nearly invisible. It would be an entirely different type of fiber from an entirely different time period made by entirely different methods of manufacturing. It would be blatantly obvious to even a lay person much less a textile expert, and yet none of the textile experts who very meticulously examined the area to be carbon dated noted any type of patch or aberration.

There is no evidence of any patch of any kind on the area selected for carbon dating.

All of which is a very long and wordy way of saying that, yes, I agree with those who don’t count entry #2 as evidence.
 
My Dear Mr. Savage:

Suppose you explain, in your own words, what is there, and what you think it means.

I remain,

Appreciatively yours, &ct.
Slowvehicle,
- As I've always claimed: though I want the shroud to be authentic, I'm here trying to weigh the evidence, and Dan Porter's opinion has been a significant weight on the pro side of my scales. I hadn't realized how strong his doubts were before this news...
- I'm not sure when he revised the opening comment on his blog to just say that the shroud may be authentic instead of the old, it's probably authentic. Whatever, I must admit that I'm discouraged -- and to be honest, might need to revise my own opinion somewhat...

- At any rate, I still think that the M&P papers constitute evidence, and for now, I'll keep trying to show why.
 
Slowvehicle,
- As I've always claimed: though I want the shroud to be authentic, I'm here trying to weigh the evidence, and Dan Porter's opinion has been a significant weight on the pro side of my scales. I hadn't realized how strong his doubts were before this news...
- I'm not sure when he revised the opening comment on his blog to just say that the shroud may be authentic instead of the old, it's probably authentic. Whatever, I must admit that I'm discouraged -- and to be honest, might need to revise my own opinion somewhat...

- At any rate, I still think that the M&P papers constitute evidence, and for now, I'll keep trying to show why.

My Dear Mr. Savage:

It is clear why you think that the contradictory conjectures in the M&P papers are evidence--you want the CIQ to be the "True Shroud", so you have adopted the confirmed sidonist position that anything that can be claimed to support the conjecture that the CIQ might, possibly, be "authentic" must be uncritically accepted as "evidence"; wheras anything that demonstrates that the anatomically absurd, historically ridiculous, scripturally heretical, posturally impossible, byzantine-styled representational figure (complete with anti-gravity "hair" and "blood") rendered on the sized and gessoed surface of the manifestly medieval linen dates from the mid-thirteenth Century, B.C.E. must be rejected in the name of bolstering your faith.

Still not a sniff of actual evidence.

Through it all, I remain,

Patiently yours, &ct.
 
[T]hough I want the shroud to be authentic, I'm here trying to weigh the evidence...

These are incompatible objectives. You can't be trusted to weigh the evidence if you want that outcome to be a certain thing. And you have presented no evidence to weigh. Via handwaving, conjecture, and pharisaical word games you're trying to say the weight of evidence against your desired belief really isn't weight. That's not a weighing of evidence. That's an excusory tactic for hiding your lack of evidence to weigh.

At any rate, I still think that the M&P papers constitute evidence...

No. Sometimes you do and sometimes you don't. You admitted these authors misrepresented Delorenzi. You've realized, but not yet admitted, that they misrepresented Ehrlich. It's been shown that they misrepresented Raes et al. You yourself planned to abandoned the chronology. You speculated the authors believed it may have been too debunked to stand as evidence, therefore the need for the addendum. Then one step into the addendum, you abandoned it in favor of a stealth rehabilitation of the chronology.

Your critics have noted this shell game and asked you to explain yourself. Will you finally do that? Or will you continue the ham-fisted motte-and-bailey tactic?

I'll keep trying to show why.

But you don't know why. You aren't an expert in any of the relevant sciences, and you clearly haven't vetted your authors' treatment of their primary sources. You haven't done enough homework to know whether it is the evidence you say it is, and your critics keep demonstrating this to you.

The addendum clearly fails, for the reasons stated. It cannot be considered consilient when its small number of sources nevertheless manage to reach vastly different and incompatible conclusions.

The chronology ought to fail, since you abandoned it. Even if we charitably let you retract that abandonment, you're still stuck with all its blatant misrepresentations. You cling to it by simply ignoring the evidence it can't explain and pretending that act of ignorance is some careful, dispassionate deliberation on your part. This is you letting your desired outcome drive the interpretation of the results. That is anti-consilience.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom