Miracle of the Shroud / Blood on the shroud

Status
Not open for further replies.
There is no basis for thinking that there is any problem with taking the samples all from one area. Why shouldn't they?

Remember, the whole "patch" thing is a complete red-herring. There is absolutely no reason to think there is a patch in that area in any way, shape, or form, invisible or otherwise. No one ever ever contemplated the possibility of a patch there until the results came back affirming it was a forgery, and for good reason: there is nothing to suggest a patch was ever put there. But the results come back against authenticity, then everyone is complaining about the selection of the material? That's not how it works.

So, aside from the possibility that there was an invisible _and secret_ (remember, not only did they patch it, but they didn't tell anyone that they patched this insignificant corner of the shroud, which is remarkable since they put patches all over the bloody thing without trying to hide it at all) patch, why does it matter whether they took all the samples from the same spot or not?
 
Last edited:
Thank you! Wow, I never realized STRP was baised. Thank you for finding the above links for me. I have been much enlightened.

This thread is a gold mine of information about the shroud.
Just be creative with your search words and you'll end up finding quotations from and links to just about everything on the subject.

... At this point, it is merely a piece of art so why not allow more sampling to take place to put the issue at rest once and for all?

I suppose it is in their best interest to keep alive whatever debate remains.

As Dinwar ably pointed out, it's important to keep in mind the shroud was known to be a 'mere' work of art at the time it first appeared as a money-spinner in the 14th century.

The Vatican paid for not one but three C14 dating procedures on the TS.
The results are in, yet pro-authenticity advocates still hang in there.
They can't give up.

...Here's the thing: sampling protocols are ALWAYS fluid. I've had drillers flat-out refuse to take samples in the agreed-upon spot (justifiably, as there was a gas line running WAY too close to the site). I've also hit refusal too soon (ie, the drill won't go any further) and we've had to move the sample location. Moving the sample site is something that happens universally in anything that samples anything.

As far as C14 samples go? This is the single best-chosen and best-document C14 sample EVER TAKEN. Period. Bar none. I've taken C14 samples before, and our criteria was "any charcoal" or "somewhere in that lower unit". Those were verbatum my instructions. Documentation was my field notes. That may not be the perception of how science works, but that's what we on the ground do.

Unless someone can present a scientific reason for this particular place being an inapropriate site, where it was sampled doesn't matter. That's the way sampling is done--and I'm saying this as someone who's put his time in doing sampling. ...

Dinwar, your post reminded me that we're lucky enough to have the opinions of someone who works with C14 dating and sample taking.

So.
Are we officially entering the Twilight Zone of shroud authenticity ideas, then?
 
This thread is a gold mine of information about the shroud.
Just be creative with your search words and you'll end up finding quotations from and links to just about everything on the subject.



As Dinwar ably pointed out, it's important to keep in mind the shroud was known to be a 'mere' work of art at the time it first appeared as a money-spinner in the 14th century.

The Vatican paid for not one but three C14 dating procedures on the TS.
The results are in, yet pro-authenticity advocates still hang in there.
They can't give up.



Dinwar, your post reminded me that we're lucky enough to have the opinions of someone who works with C14 dating and sample taking.

So.
Are we officially entering the Twilight Zone of shroud authenticity ideas, then?

You should start a poll...
 
Not sure what you deleted. I apologize if my post came off as abrupt--I intended it as more of a summary, is all.

No, it wasn't your post at all. I asked a question but the answer was right in front of me. I realized it right at the time I hit 'submit' and wanted to delete the post. Next time I will just edit and write <delete>

As far as C14 samples go? This is the single best-chosen and best-document C14 sample EVER TAKEN. Period. Bar none.

This is quite an assertion. Why is it the "single best-chosen sample EVER TAKEN?" Obviously I disagree because I believe they should have stuck to the originally agreed-upon plan of 3 different areas. If it was necessary to scale back, then at least they should have done 2.

I've taken C14 samples before, and our criteria was "any charcoal" or "somewhere in that lower unit". Those were verbatum my instructions. Documentation was my field notes. That may not be the perception of how science works, but that's what we on the ground do.

My point is the criteria in this case was not "any" or "somewhere" but rather areas specifically discussed and agreed-upon ahead of time. It changed at the time of sampling, which I agree can be due to unforeseen circumstances, but the decision to reduce it to one area was unfortunate.

Unless someone can present a scientific reason for this particular place being an inapropriate site, where it was sampled doesn't matter. That's the way sampling is done--and I'm saying this as someone who's put his time in doing sampling.

Then why do you suppose they originally chose 3 different areas? Surely there must have been some reason separate areas were thought to be important.

It's largely irrelevant. If they sampled the whole cloth people like Jabba would refuse to beleive the results. The issue isn't the validity of the sample site; it's that the results don't agree with what Jabba has decided the right result should be.

It is because of odds. Had the samples been taken from separate sites, people like Jabba, and Marino-Benford wouldn't get any traction with their assertions.
 
It is because of odds. Had the samples been taken from separate sites, people like Jabba, and Marino-Benford wouldn't get any traction with their assertions.

OTOH, "people like Jabba" have been shown to be completely ignorant regarding anything to do with 14C dating, or even science (read the thread, he spends 90% of the time talking about how we need to organize the discussion to talk about data). Why in the blazes should anyone worry about doing things to accommodate the ignorant? As Dinwar points out, it doesn't matter, because folks like that are so embedded to authenticity that they will just invent some other loopy idea.

The only reason they resort to the "invisible patch" nonsense is because that is all they have. It's baseless, and no one who is serious about it takes it seriously.
 
You should start a poll...

Nah. I've yet to set up a poll and I'm saving myself for the thread I love.

...It is because of odds. Had the samples been taken from separate sites, people like Jabba, and Marino-Benford wouldn't get any traction with their assertions.

I beg to differ, Ampulla because I'm convinced the pro-authenticity proponents would have seized on some other objection.

Have you ever read the Pray Manuscript arguments in favour of the TS's authenticity?
 
….


Originally Posted by Dinwar
Not sure what you deleted. I apologize if my post came off as abrupt--I intended it as more of a summary, is all.
No, it wasn't your post at all. I asked a question but the answer was right in front of me. I realized it right at the time I hit 'submit' and wanted to delete the post. Next time I will just edit and write <delete>


Originally Posted by Dinwar
As far as C14 samples go? This is the single best-chosen and best-document C14 sample EVER TAKEN. Period. Bar none.
This is quite an assertion. Why is it the "single best-chosen sample EVER TAKEN?" Obviously I disagree because I believe they should have stuck to the originally agreed-upon plan of 3 different areas. If it was necessary to scale back, then at least they should have done 2.


Originally Posted by Dinwar
I've taken C14 samples before, and our criteria was "any charcoal" or "somewhere in that lower unit". Those were verbatum my instructions. Documentation was my field notes. That may not be the perception of how science works, but that's what we on the ground do.
My point is the criteria in this case was not "any" or "somewhere" but rather areas specifically discussed and agreed-upon ahead of time. It changed at the time of sampling, which I agree can be due to unforeseen circumstances, but the decision to reduce it to one area was unfortunate.


Originally Posted by Dinwar
Unless someone can present a scientific reason for this particular place being an inapropriate site, where it was sampled doesn't matter. That's the way sampling is done--and I'm saying this as someone who's put his time in doing sampling.
Then why do you suppose they originally chose 3 different areas? Surely there must have been some reason separate areas were thought to be important.


Originally Posted by Dinwar
It's largely irrelevant. If they sampled the whole cloth people like Jabba would refuse to beleive the results. The issue isn't the validity of the sample site; it's that the results don't agree with what Jabba has decided the right result should be.
It is because of odds. Had the samples been taken from separate sites, people like Jabba, and Marino-Benford wouldn't get any traction with their assertions.

....



The agreement to run the C14 tests at all, took ten years of meetings. The reason it took so long is that the majority of participants at those meetings were the religious officials and members of STURP who continuously tried to persuade the C14 scientists to perform much simpler and less invasive tests than the scientists were ideally requesting.

It was the religious officials, and particularly the Vatican and the Cardinal of Turin, who eventually refused to allow more than one 7cm strip to be cut from the shroud, and who refused to allow more than three C14 labs which they themselves chose.

It was the C14 scientists who had long explained why 6 or 7 labs and several different shroud samples would be statistically safer in the sense of refuting any subsequent claims that there may be any doubt about the resulting dates.

However, the religious officials did not want that level of statistical certainty in the final dates.

As it turned out, the three C14 labs did not need more than that single 7cm strip of shroud, because the agreement between them turned out to be so close that they were able to satisfy the required statistical standards without any further testing.

But, however the tests were done, and no matter how many different samples were taken, you could never stop religious fanatics like STURP and Luigi Gonella from raising any number of fraudulent objections … such as claiming that an invisible patch might have been present, or that the C14 content of the shroud could have been divinely altered by some sub-atomic reaction resulting from Jesus levitating away from planet Earth!

However, back in the real world, the fact of the matter is that in over 20 years, no independent scientists have ever published any criticism of the C14 paper.

As far as criticism of the Rogers paper is concerned – there is no need for any C14 or other relevant scientists to waste their time publishing any criticism of that paper. Because (a)it is in an extremely obscure journal where few serious scientists would ever bother to take any notice of it, (b)it has not been supported by any independent scientists in any more well-known journals, (c)it does not address the C14 tests in any way at all, (d)it only offers speculation about what Rogers thought might be the reason for what he thought he could see as colour changes in a few microscopically small threads, (e)there was no corroboration that the threads ever came from any part of the C14 samples anyway.

IOW – the Rogers paper is so weak, and with no support from any independent scientists, and so irrelevant to the C14 dates, that it would be giving it far more credit than it was ever due if the C14 scientists got dragged into a publishing battle with known religious shroud fanatics like Ray Rogers.
 
Appreciation

- Ampulla,
- I assume that your educated guess is that the Shroud is a forgery, but I wanted to let you know that I do appreciate your efforts to "get to the bottom" of this...
- I have some things to say on my behalf, but don't hold your breath -- I'm notoriously slow.
- But also, I'll be back.
--- Jabba
 
Why not say whatever you want to say in the post you just made? This is not twitter, you aren't character-limited.

It's really frustrating that you write a post telling us what you will do in the future instead of just doing it. The time you waste on telling people you are going to post something could be saved if you just posted whatever it was.

I don't suppose what you were going to say was any refutation of the carbon dating results, was it?
 
- Ampulla,
- I assume that your educated guess is that the Shroud is a forgery, but I wanted to let you know that I do appreciate your efforts to "get to the bottom" of this...
- I have some things to say on my behalf, but don't hold your breath -- I'm notoriously slow.
- But also, I'll be back.
--- Jabba

Promises, promises.

This has been said before, and I repeat it here very much in the spirit of encouragement--you say you have been studying the cloth for 20 years or more, if I recall correctly. Why do you not have these arguments marshaled?

If I may make a suggestion, go back through this thread and collect all of your arguments: the good, the bad, the wishful thinking...and make a file of them Keep them in order, with references, so that next time the issue comes up, in whatever venue, you have everything at your fingertips.

When you do present your next argument, please remember that you have not explained away the 14C dates. Whatever other argument you plan to advance, if it does not address the fact that the cloth is a medieval artifact, the argument is moot from the start.
-If you want to claim that a first-century image was somehow miraculously transferred onto a medieval cloth, go for it--but please do not expect anyone to agree to concede that dating.
-If you want to claim that a medieval cloth was somehow miraculously present in the first century, feel free--but if you were going to argue "miracle" from the word "go", why bother smearing McCrone, and Mmme. F-L?

I am eager to see what you have to present.
 
- Ampulla,
- I assume that your educated guess is that the Shroud is a forgery, ---snip--- Jabba
Regardless if that is Ampulla's position, it is far more than an educated guess, and you know this. I am not surprised any longer by your blatant misrepresentation of the facts, either individually or in aggregate, but I also will not stop pointing it out.

The shroud is a medieval forgery. The facts are clear. Your position that it is authentic is not even a guess and is willfully uneducated; it is deliberately ignorant wishfulness.
 
- Ampulla,
- I assume that your educated guess is that the Shroud is a forgery, but I wanted to let you know that I do appreciate your efforts to "get to the bottom" of this...
- I have some things to say on my behalf, but don't hold your breath -- I'm notoriously slow.
- But also, I'll be back.
--- Jabba

Jabba,
I suspect I am like you in that I do wish it really was Jesus’ burial cloth, just because it would be some corroboration of the bible. I am, however, willing to accept that it is not. The thing is, provable science trumps unverifiable beliefs, no matter how much one wishes it didn’t. The only thing I can say is it would have been a more robust scientific experiment had they abided by the original design of taking the samples from different areas of the cloth. According to IanS, the scientists believed it would be statistically safer to take multiple samples from different areas of the cloth. I agree with this. Just because it was the religious officials who did not allow this does not nullify the fact that it would have been less refutable had they done it that way. But even with all that said, you can't ignore the C14 results.
 
Jabba,
I suspect I am like you in that I do wish it really was Jesus’ burial cloth, just because it would be some corroboration of the bible. I am, however, willing to accept that it is not. The thing is, provable science trumps unverifiable beliefs, no matter how much one wishes it didn’t. The only thing I can say is it would have been a more robust scientific experiment had they abided by the original design of taking the samples from different areas of the cloth. According to IanS, the scientists believed it would be statistically safer to take multiple samples from different areas of the cloth. I agree with this. Just because it was the religious officials who did not allow this does not nullify the fact that it would have been less refutable had they done it that way. But even with all that said, you can't ignore the C14 results.
My understanding of what Dinwar and IanS have said (and I gather they are not saying identical things, merely similar things) is that the procedure as done was more than sufficient for scientific surety regarding the data. Sampling from more multiple areas might have increased that surety but only in the final placement of the decimal point. Sort of like arguing over 1 in 1,000 odds v. 1 in 1,001.

So it really comes down to rhetorical certainty, and that is not the bailiwick of science. As has been pointed out, the scientific certainty is meaningless; regardless what science shows, the believers will find something specious upon which to latch. Jabba is excellent evidence of that.
 
Jabba,
I suspect I am like you in that I do wish it really was Jesus’ burial cloth, just because it would be some corroboration of the bible. ...

Ampulla, how could the TS, if dated to the first century, possibly be a corroboration of the bible?
What is your reasoning on that?
 
Last edited:
Ampulla, how could the TS, if dated to the first century, possibly be a corroboration of the bible?
What is your reasoning on that?


I'm quite curious about this as well.

It seems to me that even if the shroud was dated to the first century, the cloth was identified as a product of Jerusalem, it was shown to have been soaked in bluuurd and it had a little tag in one corner saying "Property of Jesus" we'd still be no closer to demonstrating that anything in the Bible was true.

In fact, given that the shroud of Turin differs significantly from the gospel accounts of Jesus' burial accoutrements, evidence of its authenticity would tend to show that the Bible got the story wrong.
 
This is quite an assertion. Why is it the "single best-chosen sample EVER TAKEN?" Obviously I disagree because I believe they should have stuck to the originally agreed-upon plan of 3 different areas. If it was necessary to scale back, then at least they should have done 2.
In comparison to most sampling processes for analysis the sample taken from the shroud was removed under extremely stringent conditions with multiple witnesses and video recording. Plus there were additional control samples and a reasonable attempt to blind the process.
Regarding changes in the procedure for radiocarbon dating, these were made by Cardinal Ballestrero and his science adviser Professor Gonella.
I am unable to find any reference to a plan to remove three samples from the shroud, either in the SEP1986 or OCT1987 discussions. Perhaps you're confusing this with the control samples?

My point is the criteria in this case was not "any" or "somewhere" but rather areas specifically discussed and agreed-upon ahead of time. It changed at the time of sampling, which I agree can be due to unforeseen circumstances, but the decision to reduce it to one area was unfortunate.
No. The changes to what is sometimes referred to as the "Turin Protocol" were made in October 1987, not at the time of sampling (21APR1988) and were criticised by scientists at the time as they might leave the process open to suspicions of unreliability. The changes appear to have been motivated by a desire to minimise the amount of material removed from the cloth, i.e. the reduction of the number of laboratories performing the tests and the abandonment of the proportional counter technique.
The process for blinding the shroud samples was also abandoned, this was the make the pretreatment (removal of contamination) easier.

Then why do you suppose they originally chose 3 different areas? Surely there must have been some reason separate areas were thought to be important.
Can you cite a source for this? The original protocol agreed at Trondheim does not mention three samples to be removed from the cloth. It does refer to two additional control samples.

It is because of odds. Had the samples been taken from separate sites, people like Jabba, and Marino-Benford wouldn't get any traction with their assertions.
I think you drastically over-estimate the rationality and reasonableness of believers. It wasn't long after the radiocarbon results were in that the believers were accusing the testing scientists of malfeasance and fraud.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom