Miracle of the Shroud / Blood on the shroud

Status
Not open for further replies.
Effective Debate

- Continuing: I also think that there is much more to the Jesus concept/story than is first seen by the rational eye... That's what I try to show in that website.
--- Jabba
 
Carbon Dating/Re-weave/Getting Past the Experts/threads from grtr cloth

^
This.

Thanks for actually calling, Jabba.
You realise you've just done more research than Marino and Benford?
Pakeha,
- Thanks.
--- Jabba
 
- Rats!

- Mr Ehrlich said that the really "invisible" re-weaving, the French Re-weaving, would use only threads from the main cloth...
- "Inweaving," which would not be "invisible," could use new material.

- He was in a hurry, and I didn't specifically ask Pakeha's question, but sure sounds like Ehrlich would say that experts would have recognized the patch if it had used new material.
- He was happy to have me quote him, and I told him that it would be on the Randi forum, but didn't get a chance to give him the Internet address.

- I reserve the right to come back and add new, "exculpatory," evidence if I should find some, but for now at least, I concede this round to you guys, and will drop my invisible re-weave explanation possibility.
- I will, however, tell Joe Marino, and the guys on Dan Porter's blog what Ehrlich said, and see if anyone has an effective comeback.

- Raspberries!!!

--- Jabba

Jabba:

Please do not take this as a personal attack, but the hilited area demonstrates a fundamental problem of which you should make yourself aware. You have spoken of "bias" before, claiming that you are no more biased that the rest of us--but consider your statement. Mmme. F-L adamantly states that there is no "patch"; that she would not have missed one if one were there. The recent restoration did not see, find, or detect a patch. Mr. Erlich pointed out to you that a patch would not be "invisible"...

...and yet, instead of accepting the fact that all available data support the idea that the cloth is a medieval artifact, you are "reserving the right" to come up with "exculpatory evidence"...which is not how science is done.

You start with a conclusion: The 14C dates must be wrong. Every piece of information you encounter is filtered through that presupposition. Never mind that the 14C dates are reliable, and consistent; never mind that no researcher who has examined the cloth in person has found the slightest evidence of a "patch" (not to mention a patch that would conveniently alter the apparent date to precisely the same degree in three independent labs), never mind that experts have told you that "invisible" reweaving is actually perfectly visible to the naked eye. Despite all evidence, you are committed to your conclusion.

What you should do is start with the evidence. There is a cloth. The cloth has been carbon-dated by three independent labs. The carbon dating indicates that the cloth is a medieval artifact. No textile expert who has examined the actual cloth has provided the least hint that there is reason to distrust the 14C dates. With that in hand, you can then reach a conclusion: the cloth is a medieval artifact.

Do you see, and understand, the difference? Instead of trying to prove that the experts are incompetent, or in cahoots, spend your energy determining what it means that the cloth, in fact, dates from the late-13th to mid-14th centuries.

Work with what is there, not with what you wish were there.

(BTW, good job on following through on Erlich--now apply what you have learned.)
 
Carbon Dating/Explanations?/Irradiation

In all honesty, Jabba just did something skeptical. He didn't accept what some people (that is, us) said about what other people (that is, experts) had to say on a topic. He went to the source. Unfortunately for Jabba, in this case said source confirmed what others in the forum have been saying for months.

It looks like Jabba is going to have to come up with another reason as to why the carbon-14 dating is "incorrect". So far we're ruled out contamination and invisible re-weaving. I don't know if there are any other alternatives.
Blue,

- For the moment, at least, invisible re-weave and contamination seem to be ruled out... (I hardly ever give up entirely. But then, what's important here (to me) is the effect that our confrontation is having upon a theoretical neutral audience -- not on whether or not one of us concedes.)

- Unless you guys have another preference as to the next sub-etc-issue for discussion, I'll next look into the alternative of some sort of irradiation or scorch causing the 14th century dating.
- Again, this is what I mean by "tedious" -- but, in my opinion, it is also the only way to actually get somewhere in serious debate.
- If you guys think you have a better smoking gun against Shroud authenticity than "there appears to be no way to explain a 1300 year discrepancy in the carbon dating," I should probably take on your "better" nominee first.

--- Jabba
 
Last edited:
Blue,

- For the moment, at least, invisible re-weave and contamination seem to be ruled out... (I hardly ever give up entirely. But then, what's important here (to me) is the effect that our confrontation is having upon a theoretical neutral audience -- not on whether or not one of us concedes.)


What an abject failure is your presentation here.

Not only does your case fail abysmally in terms of the facts of the matter, it also fails even more dramatically in that it displays itself to have never had any intention of succeeding on the basis of evidence.

I probably should add a third measure of failure - your total inability to present a cogent and rational argument regardless of what the evidence might say.


- Unless you guys have another preference as to the next sub-etc-issue for discussion, I'll next look into the alternative of some sort of irradiation or scorch causing the 14th century dating.


Why not just cut to the chase and say "Goddidit!"? It's just as (un)likely, but at least it has the advantage of displaying a little bit of (albeit misguided) integrity.


- Again, this is what I mean by "tedious" -- but, in my opinion, it is also the only way to actually get somewhere in serious debate.


It's not tedious; it's assinine.

And the only place your 'debate' is going is down, as in 'gurgler'.


- If you guys think you have a better smoking gun against Shroud authenticity than "there appears to be no way to explain a 1300 year discrepancy in the carbon dating," I should probably take on your "better" nominee first.

--- Jabba



You should probably take on the slugs attacking your raspberry canes, but of course you won't.

Slugs: 1

Jabba: nil​

NAGL
 
Effective Debate

Jabba:

...What you should do is start with the evidence. There is a cloth. The cloth has been carbon-dated by three independent labs. The carbon dating indicates that the cloth is a medieval artifact. No textile expert who has examined the actual cloth has provided the least hint that there is reason to distrust the 14C dates. With that in hand, you can then reach a conclusion: the cloth is a medieval artifact...
Slowmover (not meant as an insult, just think it's a "cooler" name, but I'll stick with the "Slowvehicle" if you prefer.),
-The result of the carbon dating is only one piece in a whole pile of evidence -- a piece that, in my opinion, is greatly outweighed by the evidence for a much earlier date. I've presented very little of what I perceive as evidence for a much earlier date because the carbon dating (the best evidence against Shroud authenticity) has been the preferred subject in our debate so far.
--- Jabba
 
Coming Soon!!! Bluuuuurd!

Slowmover (not meant as an insult, just think it's a "cooler" name, but I'll stick with the "Slowvehicle" if you prefer.),


I wish it was my place to say "How dare you?"


-The result of the carbon dating is only one piece in a whole pile of evidence -- a piece that, in my opinion, is greatly outweighed by the evidence for a much earlier date.


Fortunately for us all, the opinions of those who reject evidence out-of-hand in favour of superstitious wishful thinking are as easily discarded as childood beliefs in Tooth Bunnies and Easter Fairies.


I've presented very little of what I perceive as evidence for a much earlier date because the carbon dating (the best evidence against Shroud authenticity) has been the preferred subject in our debate so far.
--- Jabba


Again, fortunately, what you perceive as evidence isn't anything of the sort.

It is, however, comedy gold. Moreover, it's the best way of winning converts to atheism short of forcing people to read a DOC thread.

Keep up the good work!
 
Slowmover (not meant as an insult, just think it's a "cooler" name, but I'll stick with the "Slowvehicle" if you prefer.),
-The result of the carbon dating is only one piece in a whole pile of evidence -- a piece that, in my opinion, is greatly outweighed by the evidence for a much earlier date. I've presented very little of what I perceive as evidence for a much earlier date because the carbon dating (the best evidence against Shroud authenticity) has been the preferred subject in our debate so far.
--- Jabba
I have one sone who, like me, is atheist, and another who is quite Christian. Neither of them can stomach the intentional deception you continue to display here. There are ways to believe while maintaining your honesty and your morals. You have chosen to believe another way, a way that requires the twisting of facts, the denial of reality, and the pretense of rationality.

As my Christian son would say: "If you want to believe, then believe, but if your belief requires misrepresentation, then you believe in a lying God."

I am proud of both sons and may invite both of them to read this thread, though I doubt either could stomach much of it.
 
As my Christian son would say: "If you want to believe, then believe, but if your belief requires misrepresentation, then you believe in a lying God."

I am proud of both sons and may invite both of them to read this thread, though I doubt either could stomach much of it.


Props to you and yours.

One of my bestest friends here at JREF is an honest Christian and I respect him and his ilk, both in the interworld and IRL, at least as much as my heathen friends. Often quite a bit more.

Those who choose wilful ignorance and outright lying in defence of their weak faith I despise.
 
<snip>
-The result of the carbon dating is only one piece in a whole pile of evidence -- a piece that, in my opinion, is greatly outweighed by the evidence for a much earlier date. I've presented very little of what I perceive as evidence for a much earlier date because the carbon dating (the best evidence against Shroud authenticity) has been the preferred subject in our debate so far.
--- Jabba
And yet again you continue posting this rubbish.
The radiocarbon dating is one element of the evidence that the shroud is a medieval fake. The sum of the individual elements is greater than anyone of them individually and leads only to one reasonable conclusion; the shroud is a medieval fake.
To summarise:
The shroud is a medieval fake. This has been well established by scientific testing (chemical, microscopic, spectroscopic and radiocarbon), expert examination (textile, weave and artistic style) and historical research (comparison to others, culture and documentation) and is supported by other evidence:

  • Historical: the lack of evidence for the shroud's existence prior to the mid fourteenth century; further it's emergence during the 'holy relic' craze (along with about forty other such burial shrouds); lack of mention of a miraculously imaged Shroud in any early Christian writings; the distinct changes in the shroud, fading of colour, since its first exposure
  • Physiological: the lack of resemblance of the shroud image to an actual human body; likewise the position of the body with hands folded across the genitals isn't possible for a body lying flay (the arms aren't long enough)
  • Textile: the weave patten of the shroud does not match anything known from first century Mid East but matches medieval Europe well; no example of the complex herringbone twill weave has even been shown to come from the first century Mid East
  • Testimony: the d'Arcis Memo indicates the shroud was created around 1354 and was a known fake
  • Artistic: the face of the image resembles medieval Byzantine style, with Gothic elements; the unnaturally elongated body shape and extremities are typical of the elongated style the Late Medieval/High Gothic period
  • Reproducibility: contrary to the claims of shroudies the image can and has been reproduced using medieval methods
  • Analytic: examination, microscopic (including electron microscopy) and chemical testing show the shroud image is made from common artistic pigments of the period of its origin
  • Cultural: the shroud does not match with what is known of first century Jewish burial practices or the only extant sample of such burial cloths; nor does the shroud match the biblical accounts; nor are there any demonstrated artifacts of the putative Jesus extant today; nor does the supposed historical background indicate that such a cloth would have been preserved, certainly without much publicity prior to ~1355
  • Serological: a minor point (as blood probably wouldn't survive this long anyway) but despite the best attempts of (and much lying and pseudoscience by) shroudies there is no evidence for blood residue

Like your fellow believers you have failed to contradict any one of these points, let alone their sum.
 
Summary of the evidence against the shroud's authenticity.

1. Historical:
a) the lack of evidence for the shroud's existence prior to the mid fourteenth century
b) it's emergence during the 'holy relic' craze (along with about forty other such burial shrouds)
c) lack of mention of a miraculously imaged Shroud in any early Christian writings
d) the distinct changes in the shroud, fading of colour, since its first exposure

2. Physiological:
e) the lack of resemblance of the shroud image to an actual human body;
f) likewise the position of the body with hands folded across the genitals which simply isn't possible for a body lying flay (the arms aren't long enough)

3. Textile:
g) the weave pattern of the shroud does not match anything known from first century Mid East
h) the weave pattern matches medieval Europe well;
i) no example of the complex herringbone twill weave has even been shown to come from the first century Mid East

4. Testimony:
j) the d'Arcis Memo indicates the shroud was created around 1354 and was a known fake

5. Artistic:
k) the face of the image resembles medieval Byzantine style, with Gothic elements;
l) the unnaturally elongated body shape and extremities are typical of the elongated style the Late Medieval/High Gothic period

6. Reproducibility:

m) contrary to the claims of shroudies the image can and has been reproduced using medieval methods

7. Analytic:

n) microscopic examination, (including non-visible, polarised light and electron microscopy) shows the shroud is composed of common artistic pigments of the period of its origin
o) chemical testing shows the same
p) radiocarbon testing, carried out under highly controlled conditions by three laboratories. showed the cloth to originate between 1260 and 1390AD (>95 per cent confidence) and between 1000 and 1500AD (>99.9 per cent confidence)

8. Cultural:
q) the shroud does not match with what is documented and known of first century Jewish burial practices
r) nor does the shroud match the only extant sample of such burial cloths;
s) neither does the shroud match the biblical accounts of the burial cloths;
t) there any no demonstrated artefacts of the putative Jesus extant today
u) the supposed historical background does not suggest that such a cloth would have been preserved, certainly without publicity prior, to ~1355

9. Serological:
v) a minor point (as blood probably wouldn't survive this long anyway) but despite the best attempts of (and much lying and pseudoscience by) shroudies, there is no evidence for blood residue
 
Jabba, if there's no patch and there's no problem with the 14C dating then all other evidence is moot.

If the material of the shroud was made in the 14th century then it cannot possibly be the burial shroud of a man who died in the 1st century.

If you think otherwise then you are a lost cause so far as logic and reason go.
 
Slowmover (not meant as an insult, just think it's a "cooler" name, but I'll stick with the "Slowvehicle" if you prefer.),
-The result of the carbon dating is only one piece in a whole pile of evidence -- a piece that, in my opinion, is greatly outweighed by the evidence for a much earlier date. I've presented very little of what I perceive as evidence for a much earlier date because the carbon dating (the best evidence against Shroud authenticity) has been the preferred subject in our debate so far.
--- Jabba

Rich:

You have been tap-dancing around the "patch" solution to the 14C dates. You have made dark suggestions of "other evidence" that "greatly outweighs" the 14C dates. Well, now is the time to present your "other evidence". Not the time to tell me that you have other evidence. Not the time to explain how you are going to set up "rules" about how you are going to present other evidence. Not the time to explain that your "evidence" is the fact that you need the cloth to be real. Not the time to negotiate about which points you will "concede".

Now is the time to present your best argument. If you are going to claim a vast, lengthy, international and ecumenical conspiracy, now is the time. If you are going to claim a miracle, now is the time.

The cloth has been correctly dated. Three independent labs confirm the date. Any "new evidence" you present will have to overcome that hurdle, first. No sense talking about any other evidence, any other theories, any other remote possibilities. Since the cloth is a medieval artifact, it cannot be the Authentic Shroud™.

Now, if what you are going to say is that you believe in the cloth despite all evidence, just say so and have done with it.

I don't mean to seem unkind, or unfriendly--but I taught high school too many years to care if you like me because I will not coddle you.

Please consider cutting right to the chase, and presenting your best evidence, right up front.

ETA: PS: you have a PM.
 
Last edited:
I wish it was my place to say "How dare you?"





Fortunately for us all, the opinions of those who reject evidence out-of-hand in favour of superstitious wishful thinking are as easily discarded as childood beliefs in Tooth Bunnies and Easter Fairies.





Again, fortunately, what you perceive as evidence isn't anything of the sort.

It is, however, comedy gold. Moreover, it's the best way of winning converts to atheism short of forcing people to read a DOC thread.
Keep up the good work!

There are international agreements against that sort of thing.
 
I have one sone who, like me, is atheist, and another who is quite Christian. Neither of them can stomach the intentional deception you continue to display here. There are ways to believe while maintaining your honesty and your morals. You have chosen to believe another way, a way that requires the twisting of facts, the denial of reality, and the pretense of rationality.

As my Christian son would say: "If you want to believe, then believe, but if your belief requires misrepresentation, then you believe in a lying God."

I am proud of both sons and may invite both of them to read this thread, though I doubt either could stomach much of it.

GoodONya, Dad!
 
...
- Unless you guys have another preference as to the next sub-etc-issue for discussion, I'll next look into the alternative of some sort of irradiation or scorch causing the 14th century dating. ...

What?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom