Miracle of the Shroud / Blood on the shroud

Status
Not open for further replies.
In comparison to most sampling processes for analysis the sample taken from the shroud was removed under extremely stringent conditions with multiple witnesses and video recording. Plus there were additional control samples and a reasonable attempt to blind the process.
Regarding changes in the procedure for radiocarbon dating, these were made by Cardinal Ballestrero and his science adviser Professor Gonella.
I am unable to find any reference to a plan to remove three samples from the shroud, either in the SEP1986 or OCT1987 discussions. Perhaps you're confusing this with the control samples?

According to wiki:

Among the most obvious differences between the final version of the protocol and the previous ones stands the decision to sample from a single location on the cloth.

Of course it will only take you a matter of time to find out the source of this quote and poo-poo it.

Never-the-less, it must have been what I had read. Or, as you state, it could be the control samples I was confused about.
 
Ampulla, how could the TS, if dated to the first century, possibly be a corroboration of the bible?
What is your reasoning on that?

I officially withdraw that statement.

FWIW, I originally had written it would corroborate the existence of Jesus. I thought that through and decided I could never back that up so I switched it to corroborate the bible. I didn't think that one through at all though.

You guys are very good. One cannot slip anything by you.
 
I officially withdraw that statement.

FWIW, I originally had written it would corroborate the existence of Jesus. I thought that through and decided I could never back that up so I switched it to corroborate the bible. I didn't think that one through at all though.

...

Rationality wins every time. :tsbounce:
 
<snip>
Jabba, I'm a scientist. I've been in these debates. I've been in more complex debates, too--debates where there is actual data supporting both sides. Others have, as well, but I can only speak for my own experiences. We have explained to you so many times that it's become rediculous: This is a SCIENTIFIC debate, and your "complexity" amounts to nothing more than evading that simple fact. This is really a simple debate: we examine the data, and reach a conclusion.
<snip>


I suspect THIS is why it takes so long for Jabba. IMO, the first hundred posts one makes on this forum is when you learn you cannot simply assert a claim you cannot back up. In the next hundred posts one learns your sources had better be reliable and able to withstand scrutiny.

This is easier accomplished by those of you who are scientists or otherwise possess expertise in the subject matter. For the rest of us (most likely those of us with just a few hundred posts) it is time-consuming and daunting. Personally, I can spend several days non-stop researching a subject before making a single post. Don't get me wrong though, I love doing it and I enjoy the learning process immensely. In fact, reading this JREF forum has significantly changed the way I think and speak about pretty much everything in my life. But participating in a thread sucks up a ton of time, which is often hard to come by.

Now, back to the shroud...

What do you think about the possibility of the C14 date being altered due to the water poured onto the cloth as a result of the fire? Does water have the capability of affecting a C14 date? Has anyone ever tested this hypothesis?
 
- OK. Back to the carbon dating.
--- Jabba

That's it?

That's your entire post?

"Back to the carbon dating" where we all await any meaningful statement, opinion, evidence, anything at all?

Agog at the thought of some C14 killer blow, we await that one liner demolition of the C14 case and that is what you post?

And for Ampulla. You have somewhat of a Hobson's choice.

You can either read the entire thread start to finish, in order to understand why exactly we are all browned off with such circularity that new mathematics is being invented to describe the extra dimensions such circularity requires, or you can accept that a little snippiness exists in this thread due to aforementioned circularity.

None of it is your doing. Seems to me that you are being perfectly reasonable, and reading the whole saga would likely have you attacking your monitor with an axe. Not something I would recommend.
 
I call that the ferous oxyde miracle.

here's what happened in Naples when the nature of the 'miracle' was explained:
http://www.religionnewsblog.com/12250/naples-blood-boils-at-miracles-debunking

I officially withdraw that statement.

FWIW, I originally had written it would corroborate the existence of Jesus. I thought that through and decided I could never back that up so I switched it to corroborate the bible. I didn't think that one through at all though.

You guys are very good. One cannot slip anything by you.

Very good?
I don't think so.
Just trying to follow what the available evidence actually says, not what one would want it to say. We're lucky to have a number of extremely knowledgeable posters here, so more than trying to dodge them or slip anything past them, why not learn from them?

...What do you think about the possibility of the C14 date being altered due to the water poured onto the cloth as a result of the fire? Does water have the capability of affecting a C14 date? Has anyone ever tested this hypothesis?

Let's turn this question around.
What do YOU think about that possibility?
Have you researched it even to the extent of a google search?
Let us know what you find!
 
I like this statement from the Naples link:

The trouble with scientists is that when they cannot find an explanation they invent one.
Besides the explanation not being "invented," it would be heartening to have the believers look at it the other way:

The problem with believers is that when they are given an explanation they ignore it.
 
Let's turn this question around.
What do YOU think about that possibility?
Have you researched it even to the extent of a google search?
Let us know what you find!
Best response possible. Wish I'd thought of it.
 
I'll be interested in seeing what Ampulla comes up with.

And yes, the liquefying blood 'miracle' is astonishing in its continued popularity even today.
Given the indisputable fact the Vatican tolerates this sort of chicanery, it's really quite surprising they agreed to shell out the money for not one, but three different labs to run the C14 testing on the shroud.
 
I'll be interested in seeing what Ampulla comes up with.

And yes, the liquefying blood 'miracle' is astonishing in its continued popularity even today.
Given the indisputable fact the Vatican tolerates this sort of chicanery, it's really quite surprising they agreed to shell out the money for not one, but three different labs to run the C14 testing on the shroud.

I got a feeling that it was partially due to the fact they already had rejected authenticity in the past, partially because they anyway see the relic as troublesome but are bound to accept it (because baseline cathos like them --- the hierarchy not so much) but saw an impartial way to shift the blame on non-authenticity on somebody else (hey the scientist said it was not authentic, don't look at us) and it was an iconic relic. I doubt that it was because they suddenly had science at heart, i am willing to bet my last shirt that it was more a question on how to torpedoe the "rival" without outing oneself.
 
Last edited:
I suspect THIS is why it takes so long for Jabba. IMO, the first hundred posts one makes on this forum is when you learn you cannot simply assert a claim you cannot back up. In the next hundred posts one learns your sources had better be reliable and able to withstand scrutiny.

This is easier accomplished by those of you who are scientists or otherwise possess expertise in the subject matter. For the rest of us (most likely those of us with just a few hundred posts) it is time-consuming and daunting. Personally, I can spend several days non-stop researching a subject before making a single post.
Normally a good point, but Jabba himself has stated he has put in over twenty years of research into the shroud of Turin. For all of his floundering in this thread, I am now thinking that by 'twenty years of research', Jabba means, 'I read an article twenty years ago and hang out with guys who think exactly like I do about the shroud.'
 
Sub-sub-subarines/Floating down the stream

- OK. Back to the carbon dating.
--- Jabba

That's it?

That's your entire post?

"Back to the carbon dating" where we all await any meaningful statement, opinion, evidence, anything at all?

Agog at the thought of some C14 killer blow, we await that one liner demolition of the C14 case and that is what you post?


I'm sure this sort of rubbish is part of the greater "effective debate" nonsense.

Jabba likes to pretend that we're reaching these points of consensus as though we were all working together happily in pursuit of the truth, the difficulty, of course, being that the need to either present data which casts doubt on the C14 dating or admit that no such data exists is the only point on which both "sides" have ever agreed.

Although to say Jabba agrees is probably being overly generous since he appears only to acknowledge the importance of the carbon dating issue but never actually addresses it.
 
Merrily, merrily, merrily, merrily/Where's the C14?

What do you think about the possibility of the C14 date being altered due to the water poured onto the cloth as a result of the fire?


Without water having been poured on the cloth to stop it from being on fire the C14 date would have been altered to "non-existant".


Does water have the capability of affecting a C14 date?


I'll bet this question appears on Jabba's list of sub-sub-sub-sub-sub-sub-sub-sub issues before we're done.


Has anyone ever tested this hypothesis?


You'd think someone would have. I'm looking forward, as are the others, to what you can discover about this.
 
Quite revealing. Two years have passed since then, and Jabba continues to attempt the same fallacious courtroom style debate, to demonstrate the same inability to reference basic sources, to fail to use simple paragraphs, to talk about what he will talk about without talking about it, and to show that he neither reads nor attempts to understand counter arguments.
 
Blue,

- For the moment, at least, invisible re-weave and contamination seem to be ruled out... (I hardly ever give up entirely. But then, what's important here (to me) is the effect that our confrontation is having upon a theoretical neutral audience -- not on whether or not one of us concedes.)

Assuming that you want to win over the neutrals, you are doing an exceedingly bad job. Any neutral will long ago have reached the conclusion that you don't have a clue.

- I know I have, and, perhaps to your surprise, I'm actually more or less neutral: I did not, a' priory, know or care much about the shoud. However, following these debates, and participating a bit, I have learned that it is, beyond any reasonable doubt, a fake.

- Unless you guys have another preference as to the next sub-etc-issue for discussion, I'll next look into the alternative of some sort of irradiation or scorch causing the 14th century dating.

I don't really think anybody cares much what your next hand-wave will be. You have thorughly lost the discussion, and all that remains is a mild curiosity as to how long you will trash around in the wreckage of your cause before you either admit defeat or run away.

Hans
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom