Miracle of the Shroud / Blood on the shroud

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm quite curious about this as well.

It seems to me that even if the shroud was dated to the first century, the cloth was identified as a product of Jerusalem, it was shown to have been soaked in bluuurd and it had a little tag in one corner saying "Property of Jesus" we'd still be no closer to demonstrating that anything in the Bible was true.

In fact, given that the shroud of Turin differs significantly from the gospel accounts of Jesus' burial accoutrements, evidence of its authenticity would tend to show that the Bible got the story wrong.

Hmmm

I intended to post a speculative bit, but was unable to come up with a plausible narrative. No matter how you slice it, wild leaps of faith are required.

So, agreed. Even if one were to establish the date of the shroud being 1st century, then what? I simply cannot invent a scenario where this means anything at all.

Well, maybe just one.

If you start with the assumption that the shroud is genuine, then it may be possible to work backwards, and retro-fit everything into your preconceived conclusion. Maybe. If you are prepared to accept levitating jebus corpse plus levitating shroud plus radioactive imprinting of an image plus nobody else wrapped a corpse in this fashion plus da bluuurrrrrd plus the unlikely anatomy plus the simple fact that I would pay good money for a front row seat if one could put jabba, doc, edge, mikeyx, epix and peacecrusader in the ring together. Why is it that they never debate each other?
 
- Slowvehicle has recommended that I now present my perceived evidence for Shroud authenticity. That's what I'll do unless I get another (serious) suggestion or two.
--- Jabba

You could reply to the serious suggestion made in post #3594.
Could I make a suggestion? Rather than trying to diagram the discussion, could you please just give us a very simple statement about why you think the C14 data is wrong.

Preferably in the format of "I think the C14 data is wrong because of blah, blah and blah. Here is the data thta led me to this conclusion......."

Thanks

Apologies for referencing one of my own posts.
 
Game Plan

- OK.
- Now I have two nominations as to what sub-etc-issue to address next: 1) my perceived evidence for Shroud authenticity, and 2) my perceived evidence against the carbon dating. Any more votes for one of these? Or, any votes for something else?
--- Jabba
 
Pain Glam

- OK.
- Now I have two nominations as to what sub-etc-issue to address next: 1) my perceived evidence for Shroud authenticity, and 2) my perceived evidence against the carbon dating. Any more votes for one of these? Or, any votes for something else?
--- Jabba


These two ssues are one and the same thing and they've been waiting for you to address them for months.

You don't really think anyone believes you're going to do so now, do you?
 
- OK.
- Now I have two nominations as to what sub-etc-issue to address next: 1) my perceived evidence for Shroud authenticity, and 2) my perceived evidence against the carbon dating. Any more votes for one of these? Or, any votes for something else?
--- Jabba

OK.

Calm down. OK.

You do not want to know, at this point, what I really want to say. It would violate the MA, and be deeply offensive to you. So I shall internalise that, not because I care if you are offended, but because this forum is more important to me than you are.

I have lost count of how many times I have said "Really? I didn't know that" and, I hope, I have thrown my own knowledge into the ring helping others understand the world around them.

I have posted the phrase "I stand corrected" often, and I do stand corrected. And I have no issue with being corrected.

That said, why why why? Still with the lame claim that you might present some evidence? Sometime? Maybe? Or will you persist with the claim that you have the evidence, you are just going to present it......soon.

Votes? Reality is not a democracy. Reality does not care what you believe. You cannot vote that there is no gravity.
 
- Now I have two nominations as to what sub-etc-issue to address next: 1) my perceived evidence for Shroud authenticity, and 2) my perceived evidence against the carbon dating. Any more votes for one of these? Or, any votes for something else? ...

I'll go for the second option.
Remember to link your sources of information, please!
 
- OK.
- Now I have two nominations as to what sub-etc-issue to address next: 1) my perceived evidence for Shroud authenticity, and 2) my perceived evidence against the carbon dating. Any more votes for one of these? Or, any votes for something else?
--- Jabba

Do you have anything in 2) other than "Mme. F-L must have made a mistake"; there's an invisible, undetectable, perfectly-matched patch of exactly the tight age to make a first-century artifact read medieval; or some claim of contamination/irradiation/bioplastic? In other words, do you have evidence that disproves, or even casts an actual shadow of doubt upon, the 14C dating that has not already been dealt with ad infinitum?

Because, if so, I'd love to hear it, although I might ask why you waited until now to show your cards.

If not, that is, if you cannot disprove the 14C dating, 1) is just fantasy.

As we have been saying, all along: if the 14C dating is correct, the cloth is a medieval artifact. If the cloth is a medieval artifact, is cannot be the Real Shroud ™.

Time, and past time, to show us what you have.
 
Excuses

Jabba,
I suspect I am like you in that I do wish it really was Jesus’ burial cloth, just because it would be some corroboration of the bible. I am, however, willing to accept that it is not. The thing is, provable science trumps unverifiable beliefs, no matter how much one wishes it didn’t. The only thing I can say is it would have been a more robust scientific experiment had they abided by the original design of taking the samples from different areas of the cloth. According to IanS, the scientists believed it would be statistically safer to take multiple samples from different areas of the cloth. I agree with this. Just because it was the religious officials who did not allow this does not nullify the fact that it would have been less refutable had they done it that way. But even with all that said, you can't ignore the C14 results.
Ampulla,

- I basically agree with you.

- I accept that there is significant evidence and arguments against Shroud authenticity (especially with the carbon dating), and I wouldn't be too surprised to ultimately conclude that the Shroud is not authentic. In fact, my opinion has been swayed somewhat -- against the Shroud -- by my time on this thread...
- I also accept that I am biased in favor of the Shroud -- I want it to be authentic -- and consequently, can't fully trust my own opinion.
- In addition, I accept that I haven't done a very good job of presenting my case for authenticity.
- However, so far, I do still believe that the overall scientific and historical evidence does support Shroud authenticity -- it's just that the situations in my life, and in this thread, have prevented me from achieving any sort of timeliness in presenting my case.

- And then, I can't understand why no one here appreciates the complexity of such a debate and the natural extreme difficulty in trying to respond to so many questions and comments from about 60 opponents -- even if I do, ultimately, have good answers...
- I'll try to find previous posts of my excuses. But, one basic problem is that for each response I give, I tend to get back several rebuttals (of one sort or another) -- mathematically speaking, this is a no-win situation. Obviously, there is a lot of redundancy in these rebuttals, but there is also a lot of different rebuttals, and there's no way that I can respond to a reasonable percentage of them in a timely manner. Exponential armies are assaulting my bulwarks on every front (not to be overly dramatic :D).
- And Then, I 1) am pretty old (70) -- with typical complaints about my memory, 2) tended to be slow anyway, 3) haven't kept a good catalog of appropriate links and 4) started my efforts with a small team of real authenticity experts who, unfortunately, have found more pressing matters that required their attention.
- One other "excuse" for now: I have two horses in this race. If my pro-authenticity horse loses to the con-authenticity horse, my effective-debate horse "places." Consequently, I'm actually not as intent on winning as I would be in a typical debate...

- Enough for now. I need to get on with my next sub-etc-issue.

--- Jabba
 
Ampulla,

- I basically agree with you.

- I accept that there is significant evidence and arguments against Shroud authenticity (especially with the carbon dating), and I wouldn't be too surprised to ultimately conclude that the Shroud is not authentic. In fact, my opinion has been swayed somewhat -- against the Shroud -- by my time on this thread...
- I also accept that I am biased in favor of the Shroud -- I want it to be authentic -- and consequently, can't fully trust my own opinion.
- In addition, I accept that I haven't done a very good job of presenting my case for authenticity.
- However, so far, I do still believe that the overall scientific and historical evidence does support Shroud authenticity -- it's just that the situations in my life, and in this thread, have prevented me from achieving any sort of timeliness in presenting my case.

- And then, I can't understand why no one here appreciates the complexity of such a debate and the natural extreme difficulty in trying to respond to so many questions and comments from about 60 opponents -- even if I do, ultimately, have good answers...
- I'll try to find previous posts of my excuses. But, one basic problem is that for each response I give, I tend to get back several rebuttals (of one sort or another) -- mathematically speaking, this is a no-win situation. Obviously, there is a lot of redundancy in these rebuttals, but there is also a lot of different rebuttals, and there's no way that I can respond to a reasonable percentage of them in a timely manner. Exponential armies are assaulting my bulwarks on every front (not to be overly dramatic :D).
- And Then, I 1) am pretty old (70) -- with typical complaints about my memory, 2) tended to be slow anyway, 3) haven't kept a good catalog of appropriate links and 4) started my efforts with a small team of real authenticity experts who, unfortunately, have found more pressing matters that required their attention.
- One other "excuse" for now: I have two horses in this race. If my pro-authenticity horse loses to the con-authenticity horse, my effective-debate horse "places." Consequently, I'm actually not as intent on winning as I would be in a typical debate...

- Enough for now. I need to get on with my next sub-etc-issue.

--- Jabba

Why spend time making excuses, and looking for your old excuses?

Why not just present your evidence?
 
Vexcuses

<snip>

- Enough for now. I need to get on with my next sub-etc-issue.

--- Jabba


There is one issue.

The C14 dating has shown the shroud to be an artefact of the Middle Ages.

Either you have evidence which will cast doubt on that analysis or you don't.

It's no more complicated than that.
 
Jabba, I have been harsh lately in my posts. For this one, however, I will assume you are legitimately seeking the truth, even if blinded with bias. From that assumption I feel compelled to make two points:

1. You are out of your depth. You have engaged in an argument requiring a level of knowledge you do not possess and have shown no inclination to obtain. Even if your position were correct you could not demonstrate it.

2. Your pro-authenticity experts have failed to support you because they are incapable of it. Were they truly experts with legitimate responses to what has been said here they would have it easily at hand. They do not, and they know it. They simply do not want to admit it either to us or to you.

You cannot win, Jabba, primarily because the evidence is overwhelmingly against you (as your experts know) but also because you are not up to the task of presenting it let alone discussing it.
 
Last edited:
Jabba, I have been harsh lately in my posts. For this one, however, I will assume you are legitimately seeking the truth, even if blinded with bias. From that assumption I feel compelled to make two points:

1. You are out of your depth. You have engaged in an argument requiring a level of knowledge you do not possess and have shown no inclination to obtain. Even if your position were correct you could not demonstrate it.

I second this. There are probably at least a half dozen posters participating in this thread that could make a better case for authenticity than Jabba has, because they actually understand the problem so much more and know a lot more about the science that is behind it all.
 
....
- However, so far, I do still believe that the overall scientific and historical evidence does support Shroud authenticity -- it's just that the situations in my life, and in this thread, have prevented me from achieving any sort of timeliness in presenting my case. ...

When have you ever simply presented this scientific and historical evidence?
With proper links, of course.
 
I want it to be authentic

And so we discover the heart of darkness.

WHY?

Why do you want it to be true?

It has been pointed out to you that the 1st century authenticity or not of the shroud means nothing with regard to any religious belief of any flavour, so why?

Why exactly is it important?

Why would it matter at all if it were proven to be from the end of a toilet roll in a remote McDonalds from last week, or a levitating sheet used to wrap a levitating corpse from 2000 years ago, or a miraculously preserved part of a comic written 65 million years ago by a T-Rex?

Why would this affect anyones faith?
 
Jabba said:
- However, so far, I do still believe that the overall scientific and historical evidence does support Shroud authenticity -- it's just that the situations in my life, and in this thread, have prevented me from achieving any sort of timeliness in presenting my case.
You keep saying this, but EVERY SINGLE POINT YOU HAVE RAISED has been completely disproven. Not just shown to be kind of wrong, but in several cases it's been shown that you have NO CLUE what you're talking about--in one case you've demonstrated less than a high school graduate level of understanding of what you're talking about.

So you don't understand the arguments against authenticity, and you haven't presented any valid reasons to oppose it. There's NOTHING to convince us that you are right. Even if we agreed with you, logic would demand we oppose you.

- And then, I can't understand why no one here appreciates the complexity of such a debate
~sigh~

Jabba, I'm a scientist. I've been in these debates. I've been in more complex debates, too--debates where there is actual data supporting both sides. Others have, as well, but I can only speak for my own experiences. We have explained to you so many times that it's become rediculous: This is a SCIENTIFIC debate, and your "complexity" amounts to nothing more than evading that simple fact. This is really a simple debate: we examine the data, and reach a conclusion. It's only complex because you've inverted that order.

and the natural extreme difficulty in trying to respond to so many questions and comments from about 60 opponents -- even if I do, ultimately, have good answers...
Since you've yet to provide ANY good answers (meaning answers backed up by data), that last line is irrelevant. As for the first, we DO grasp that it's difficult to respond to a few dozen opponents. We simply don't care, because it's an irrelevant excuse. Every single one of your opponents would be satisfied if you would focus on the data rather than attempting to force us to comply with an argument style YOU ADMITTED WAS DESIGNED TO BIAS THE DISCUSSION IN YOUR FAVOR. Do that, and we'll be content.

But, one basic problem is that for each response I give, I tend to get back several rebuttals (of one sort or another) -- mathematically speaking, this is a no-win situation.
Oh boo freaking hoo. If you'd bother to address any of the points raised I might consider this a valid criticism (for about half a second--welcome to the real world, kid; this type of debate is food and drink to a scientist), but since you have yet to do so in this debate, it's irrelevant. Furthermore, you're focused on the number, not the content. Most of us have been saying over and over "Present the data". You ignore that, over and over and over.

And Then, I 1) am pretty old (70) -- with typical complaints about my memory,
I once met a 90 year old Quaternary mammal paleontologist. She'd had her driver's license taken away, and walked to the university every day. She had her office next door to a 75 year old gentleman who spent his time analyzing microfossils. My advisor was 70. So yeah, this isn't much of an excuse to me.

2) tended to be slow anyway,
It's been well over 30 pages since you've actually presented an argument that hadn't been discussed to death in this thread. The only way to go slower would be to actually travel back in time.

3) haven't kept a good catalog of appropriate links
So you're a sloppy researcher. This is a SERIOUS blow to your credibility.

4) started my efforts with a small team of real authenticity experts who, unfortunately, have found more pressing matters that required their attention.
Here you yet again illustrate the inherent dishonesty of your position: you have experts in arguing that the shroud is authentic. We, on the other hand, are examining the data honestly and following where it leads.

- One other "excuse" for now: I have two horses in this race. If my pro-authenticity horse loses to the con-authenticity horse, my effective-debate horse "places." Consequently, I'm actually not as intent on winning as I would be in a typical debate...
Since you've admitted to defining "effective debate" as a debate which favores your side, this is a flat-out lie.

pgwenthold said:
I second this. There are probably at least a half dozen posters participating in this thread that could make a better case for authenticity than Jabba has,
I'VE presented a better argument than Jabba did. At least disproving my pro-authenticity argument (that threads may be able to be twisted together) taught someone something (me, that you can't do that with plant fibers, at least not effectively). Again, for 30 pages or so Jabba's arguments haven't even done that.
 
And so we discover the heart of darkness.

WHY?

Why do you want it to be true?

It has been pointed out to you that the 1st century authenticity or not of the shroud means nothing with regard to any religious belief of any flavour, so why?

Why exactly is it important? ...

Why would this affect anyones faith?
Yes, Jabba, please answer that. The Church withdrew its recognition of the Holy Foreskin of Jesus contained in a church in Calcata, Lazio. That didn't shatter anyone's faith. If anything it strengthened the faith of any sane adherent. Why should a repudiation of the Shroud have a different effect? You "want" the Shroud to be authentic. Do you "want" the miraculous liquefying blood of San Gennaro to be authentic? If so, why?
 
Last edited:
^
Ah, yes, the liquifying blood miracle.
In Madrid there's a monastery a stone's throw from the Senate that's cashed in for years and years on a vial of the 'blood' of St Pantaleon.
This last July,
Two large television screens were set up outside the monastery to give the thousands of Catholics gathered a close-up view of the miraculous liquefaction.
http://ewtnnews.com/catholic-news/World.php?id=3683

ETA
A second source of information:
In addition to housing sculptures of notoriety, such as the Bound Christ figure and the Prostrate Christ by Gregorio Fernandez, or La Dolorosa de José de Mora, the Encarnacion monastery is worth visiting for its astonishing reliquary. Made up of a collection of more than 700 pieces, all of the walls inside are lined with the glass cases protecting them. Inside are stone and precious metal coffers, as well as small chests made of coral, ivory, wood, gold, silver, marble...all of which contain the bones and blood of the most worshipped and praiseworthy saints.

Standing out among these is the glass holding the blood of San Pantaleon, a medical doctor who died in martyrdom in 405 ac. Every 27th of July, the monastery opens its doors to the public so that they may be witness to the awaited miracle.

While its is said to be in a solid state all year round, the blood of the saint liquefies "miraculously" and with no human intercession on the day of his martyrdom. The nuns who take care of this reliquary say that it is a "gift from God" and that the year that such liquefaction doesn't happen as due, it will be the sign of a looming tragedy, as happened previous to both world wars. To preserve the precious object, the nuns had cameras installed which watch over the glass and magnify it ten times.

http://www.esmadrid.com/en/portal.do?TR=C&IDR=474
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom