Miracle of the Shroud / Blood on the shroud

Status
Not open for further replies.

We're getting close to the "burst of resurrection energy" time.

Scientists are building the case that the image of a crucified man on the Shroud of Turin was created by radiation that emanated from the body itself, a theory remarkably supportive of the traditional resurrection account that is central to Christian theology.


http://www.wnd.com/2010/09/199013/
 
What next?

- Slowvehicle has recommended that I now present my perceived evidence for Shroud authenticity. That's what I'll do unless I get another (serious) suggestion or two.
--- Jabba
 
- Slowvehicle has recommended that I now present my perceived evidence for Shroud authenticity. That's what I'll do unless I get another (serious) suggestion or two.
--- Jabba

*sigh*

Don't play to the crowd.

As I said before, don't explain how you're going to show it; don't talk about sets of "rules" and interlocking sub-threads; whatever you think you have, now is the time to just lay it on the table.

It's "go" time--if you have it, show it.

Dance like you don't need the money...
 
Now? As far as I know Jabba has been participating since page 1 of this thread. That ship has already sailed, Slowvehicle.
 
- Slowvehicle has recommended that I now present my perceived evidence for Shroud authenticity. That's what I'll do unless I get another (serious) suggestion or two.
--- Jabba

:rolleyes:

We've asked innumerable serious questions and given you even more suggestions. I'm sorry if you object to it, but suggesting you go back and learn the basics of the fields you're discussing IS a serious suggestion. You demonstrably don't know multiple fields you're arguing with people over, and it would behoove you to actually get a grasp of the basics. Radiometric dating isn't linear, for example, and French Reweaving uses threads from the same cloth--both of which you not only didn't know, but flagrantly ignored.

-The result of the carbon dating is only one piece in a whole pile of evidence -- a piece that, in my opinion, is greatly outweighed by the evidence for a much earlier date. I've presented very little of what I perceive as evidence for a much earlier date because the carbon dating (the best evidence against Shroud authenticity) has been the preferred subject in our debate so far.
--- Jabba
Bovine byproduct. First, until you can present an argument for why the C14 dating is wrong NOTHING ELSE MATTERS. If the C14 dating isn't wrong, the shroud is a 14th century artifact. This is as binary as it gets in science. Second, if you had such evidence you could EASILY have listed it. Third, we've given you ample opportunity to do so--and we've shown EVERY SINGLE PIECE of your "evidence" to be wrong, fraudulant, or fabrications on your part.
 
- Slowvehicle has recommended that I now present my perceived evidence for Shroud authenticity. That's what I'll do unless I get another (serious) suggestion or two. ...

Great, Jabba.
Why not post them up one at a time, so we can discuss each one of them thoroughly?
Don't forget to include links to your direct sources.
Please don't route us via other websites, but link to the actual source of information.

We're getting close to the "burst of resurrection energy" time.

http://www.wnd.com/2010/09/199013/
Strange. I read all those 'proofs' and it adds up to some sort of 'photographic' or camera oscura experiment, touched up with paint and/or blood.


It's my favorite. Here it is: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oRmCaindCpg at about 1:10.

Ward

Whew.
So they're suggesting the image was 'formed from the 'underside of the fabric, the which was covered by the holland cloth backing?
That would imply the force that created the image permeated the cloth to form the image on the visible side, right?
In that case the colouring would be seen throught the entire thickness of the cloth.

I thought the coloured parts of the image were only a few microns deep?
So the 'radiated from the wrapped body' idea must be false, correct me if I'm wrong.
 
At the risk of appearing stupid, I need to ask a question. I searched through this thread and read a lot of previous posts but I cannot find any cites referring to a refutation of Ray Rogers' 2005 claim that part of the carbon-dated sample was dyed cotton. I was under the impression this was verified by a lab (maybe in Los Alamos?)

Be easy on me -- I have not studied this very much or even very recently.
 
Hi, Ampulla of Vater!
This thread is so long and complex that it's no wonder you may have missed that.
Try using cotton as your search word.
 
The issue is that there are two ways to attach a cotton patch: first, you can do it via reweaving (which is obvious upon examination of the patched cloth), and second, you can attach the threads themselves together (which doesn't work with plant fibers, as they lack the necessary oils). So the only plausible way to do it would be instantly seen.
 
It was scientifically stupid to take all the samples from the same area. It appears this was a deviation from the originally agreed-upon protocol. It is too bad they won't allow it to be redone, with samples from different areas. At this point, it is merely a piece of art so why not allow more sampling to take place to put the issue at rest once and for all?

I suppose it is in their best interest to keep alive whatever debate remains.
 
It was scientifically stupid to take all the samples from the same area.
The RCC insisted, and in any event it matters not where the samples were taken.

It appears this was a deviation from the originally agreed-upon protocol.
At the behest of the bishops. Did they have a vested interest? Surely not?

It is too bad they won't allow it to be redone, with samples from different areas.
And redone, and redone and redone, until there is no shroud left, just the same old samples in the lab, yielding the same results of a medieval forgery.

At this point, it is merely a piece of art so why not allow more sampling to take place to put the issue at rest once and for all?
Because the bleevers will repeat their claims until there is no shroud left, and once that happens, it becomes a fairy shroud, of which there is nothing left to test. Evanescant, it will live on as a ghost of what once was a valuable artifact of the past, ready and willing to trap the gullible.

I suppose it is in their best interest to keep alive whatever debate remains.
Ah, whose interest would that be?
 
ETA: Never mind, I am an idiot.

Not sure what you deleted. I apologize if my post came off as abrupt--I intended it as more of a summary, is all.

It was scientifically stupid to take all the samples from the same area. It appears this was a deviation from the originally agreed-upon protocol.
So what?

Here's the thing: sampling protocols are ALWAYS fluid. I've had drillers flat-out refuse to take samples in the agreed-upon spot (justifiably, as there was a gas line running WAY too close to the site). I've also hit refusal too soon (ie, the drill won't go any further) and we've had to move the sample location. Moving the sample site is something that happens universally in anything that samples anything.

As far as C14 samples go? This is the single best-chosen and best-document C14 sample EVER TAKEN. Period. Bar none. I've taken C14 samples before, and our criteria was "any charcoal" or "somewhere in that lower unit". Those were verbatum my instructions. Documentation was my field notes. That may not be the perception of how science works, but that's what we on the ground do.

Unless someone can present a scientific reason for this particular place being an inapropriate site, where it was sampled doesn't matter. That's the way sampling is done--and I'm saying this as someone who's put his time in doing sampling.

It is too bad they won't allow it to be redone, with samples from different areas.
It's largely irrelevant. If they sampled the whole cloth people like Jabba would refuse to beleive the results. The issue isn't the validity of the sample site; it's that the results don't agree with what Jabba has decided the right result should be.

At this point, it is merely a piece of art so why not allow more sampling to take place to put the issue at rest once and for all?
Again, it won't do any good. The shroud was determined to be a fake within years of coming to light--nearly 600 years ago. NOTHING will put this issue to rest. The believers don't want it to be a fraud, and are trying everything they can to evade the knowledge that it is.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom