Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

If you haven't read "the demon-haunted world", you should. It's a fun read and contains the answer to your question.

I don't have a problem with Carl Sagan's criticism of superstitions and other irrational beliefs. But to attack them with skepticism and at the same time believe in aliens, flying saucers and ETI is a contradiction.
There are several instances in his biography that demonstrates how seriously he took aliens and UFOs. He even wrote to the Sectary of State wanting to know if the US was prepared for an alien attack. He did turn skeptical of UFOs later on. But that did not stop him from dedicating his whole life to search for alien life after he denounced them.
I am sure there are many scientist also keen on looking for aliens, UFOs. But how does a rational person like Carl Sagan dismiss people looking for aliens, UFOs HERE as wacky but still believe in a project looking for them in outer space (for 50 years).
 
I think Carl Sagan did more than insist alien life exists. He went looking for them!!! for over 50 years. That is an obsession, conviction and wishful thinking all rolled in one. :jaw-dropp

Seeking evidence is not "obsession", nor did Sagan limit his activities in those 50 years to efforts to collect that evidence.

But let's grant that he was obsessed, just for the sake of discussion. Carl Sagan was obsessed with finding evidence for ETI.

And...? So...? How would that disqualify him from being a skeptic?
 
I think Carl Sagan did more than insist alien life exists. He went looking for them!!! for over 50 years. That is an obsession, conviction and wishful thinking all rolled in one. :jaw-dropp

No. You clearly have not read Sagan. He clearly stated that it was entirely possible that no signals would be detected, even after an exhaustive search. While this would not necessarily rule out the possibility of extraterrestrial civilizations, it would certainly give us empirical data that would allow us to narrow our speculations. Sagan specifically stated that hearing nothing but the cosmic noise of nature in our little part of the universe could suggest something of the rarity and preciousness of life.

The histrionic application of words like "obsession" and the use of emoticons do nothing but reveal your lack of an argument and your biases. Sagan did a great many things during his career, including working on projects that explored the other worlds in our solar system up close for the first time. SETI was certainly of interest to him, but it was, at best, a side project for him. I see no justification for your characterization of "obsession".
 
I don't have a problem with Carl Sagan's criticism of superstitions and other irrational beliefs. But to attack them with skepticism and at the same time believe in aliens, flying saucers and ETI is a contradiction.
There are several instances in his biography that demonstrates how seriously he took aliens and UFOs. He even wrote to the Sectary of State wanting to know if the US was prepared for an alien attack. He did turn skeptical of UFOs later on. But that did not stop him from dedicating his whole life to search for alien life after he denounced them.
I am sure there are many scientist also keen on looking for aliens, UFOs. But how does a rational person like Carl Sagan dismiss people looking for aliens, UFOs HERE as wacky but still believe in a project looking for them in outer space (for 50 years).


You seem to be suggesting that a "rational person", or "skeptic", should reject the idea of alien life without bothering trying to find out if there is any evidence for it. Since "closed-mindedness" is a frequent criticism (unfairly) aimed at skeptics, it looks rather as if you're trying to erect a strawman argument.
 
Was it reasonable to send ships into the ocean looking for new land? Or should people not bother because someone drew a waterfall edge and "There be dragons here" on a map?

Land, distant lands separated by wide expanses of water (ocean) are tangible just as rocks and dirt are on other planets. But aliens? Superior advanced intelligent aliens.
 
You seem to be suggesting that a "rational person", or "skeptic", should reject the idea of alien life without bothering trying to find out if there is any evidence for it. Since "closed-mindedness" is a frequent criticism (unfairly) aimed at skeptics, it looks rather as if you're trying to erect a strawman argument.

I am not erecting a strawman. I am relating what Carl Sagan actually did.
 
Nope. While he said that it was likely that they exist, he didn't "insist alien life exists"; he tried to find evidence for it.

More importantly, from a scientific perspective, he made clear that any answer is the right answer. There is no "failure" if no signals are detected. The goal of the project is to investigate the true nature of the universe. If nothing is detected, then we know something about the nature of the universe (or at least our little part of it) that we did not know before. It doesn't tell us that we are alone as a civilization, but it does tell us that no one is sending signals using radiation. This could be because most civilizations quickly discover far better technologies than radio. Or it could be because civilizations don't last long enough to be around to communicate with others. Or it could be that we are an incredibly rare phenomenon in the galaxy, or even the universe. These are all questions worth seeking the answers to. But in order to seek those answers we have to start looking.
 
I came across this intriguing double play.
Skeptics are reactive not proactive. They are not seekers of knowledge nor keepers of knowledge they are critiques of knowledge. And because knowledge is never present in an absolute way skeptics can get caught up in endless disagreements. For example "A man is innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt." As abstract as the law may be it is circumspect in the application of the word "reasonable". But what is a reasonable doubt or reasonable argument is less definable or guaranteed to satisfy the skeptic because the threshold also vary from skeptic to skeptic.
Most skeptics are not in a positioned to make an informed decision or arrive at a reasonable conclusion because the process designed to extract the facts are often steeped in ignorant dogma and the failure to admit to ones own biases.
Skeptics often put the burden of proof on the one who makes the claim. It is not a cooperative exchange but an adversarial challenge. More often than not the skeptic is not an expert in the field under discussion which leads to endless missed turns, so complex issues are best avoided when confronting a skeptic. Which begs the question, why deal with skeptics if even the obvious are subject to



So the question can go beyond "Why you might not be a skeptic" and can be truthfully answered with "why you might very well be a very insecure individual."


:dl::wackycry::wackycry::wackycry::wackycry:


somebody has had the smackdown put on them before I see
 
Land, distant lands separated by wide expanses of water (ocean) are tangible just as rocks and dirt are on other planets. But aliens? Superior advanced intelligent aliens.

What is it about life, intelligent or otherwise, that informs you that it cannot exist on other worlds? Life evolved here, why not elsewhere? Is the question, "how common is life in the universe?" not worth investigating?
 
Seeking evidence is not "obsession", nor did Sagan limit his activities in those 50 years to efforts to collect that evidence.

But let's grant that he was obsessed, just for the sake of discussion. Carl Sagan was obsessed with finding evidence for ETI.

And...? So...? How would that disqualify him from being a skeptic?

His obsession clouded his judgement. He lost scientific objectivity. Sometimes gut feelings turn out successful. Very rarely do obsession bear fruit. Carl Sagan rolled obsession, conviction and wishful thinking together to stack the odds in his favor.
 
I don't have a problem with Carl Sagan's criticism of superstitions and other irrational beliefs. But to attack them with skepticism and at the same time believe in aliens, flying saucers and ETI is a contradiction.

There are several factual problems with your claim here, as there have been every other time you have made it. I encourage you to provide evidence for the claims you make, as, after all, pursuing, and evaluating, evidence is one of the driving forces of skeptical inquiry.

1. Please provide evidence that Dr. Sagan "belkeived in" "aliens" (As opposed to, say, "searching for evidence of extraterrestrial intelligences").

2. Please provide evidence that Dr. Sagan "beleived in" "UFOs", particularly given his work in debunking credulous claims of "UFO sightings" and "alien abductions".

3. Please provide evidence that Dr. Sagan "believed in" extra-terrestrial intelligences (as opposed to searching for evidence of extra-terrestrial intelligences).

4. Please explain how, on the one hand, explaining the superstitious nature of "UFO sightings" and "alien abduction" stories, based primarily upon the grounds that there is no evidence that UFOs have ever been sighted, or that anyone has ever been abducted by an "alien"; but looking for evidence of the existence of extra-terrestrial intelligences (instead of simply existing that they do, in fact, exist) is a "contradiction".

There are several instances in his biography that demonstrates how seriously he took aliens and UFOs. He even wrote to the Sectary of State wanting to know if the US was prepared for an alien attack. He did turn skeptical of UFOs later on. But that did not stop him from dedicating his whole life to search for alien life after he denounced them.

As has been explained to you before, the letter you like to mention was written by a young man. In the letter, he did not say, "Since aliens exist, we must prepare", but instead, asked the Secretary of State (Dean Acheson, at the time) how the United States would respond if "UFOs" actually did turn out to be of extraterrestrial origin. You might want to consider re=reading the letter before claiming that it demonstrates that the young Sagan "believed in" "UFOs and aliens".

I am sure there are many scientist also keen on looking for aliens, UFOs. But how does a rational person like Carl Sagan dismiss people looking for aliens, UFOs HERE as wacky but still believe in a project looking for them in outer space (for 50 years).

As has been explained to you, the difference between. on the one hand, credulous claims of "UFOs" and "alien abductions" with no evidence (ever wonder why UFOs and aliens seem to bollix cameras and vidcorders at will?); and, on the other hand, searches for evidence of intelligent signals from outer space, or evidence of how "aliens" could abduct humans and leave no traces, or evidence of the existence of (and the physics that would allow) "flying saucers" is the difference between superstition and science; between knowing and believing.
 
Sagan used the odds. He knew that there were ,as he's so often quoted, billions and billions of stars, if only a tiny amount supported planets, and of these planets only a tiny amount had liquid water, well by golly there "could' be life there. and if only one other watery world had evolved intelligent life, well it's our duty as another intelligent species to seek them out!!

Trying to besmirch the character of Sagan due to some hidden agenda on your part is cute. But it isn't gonna work. Not that way anyway, I would refer you to the kiddy pool, but apparently you got banned from there. This is the grownups area, and yer gonna have to do better than that.
 
I keep hearing that Skepticism is a process of applying critical thinking and demanding credible evidence to determine validity. Now they are nice catch words. But the roots of Skepticism are closer to a psychological state of mind than a philosophical approach.

Definition of Skepticism: . A doubting or questioning attitude or state of mind; dubiety synonyms with uncertainty.

As you have been told before, you could do worse that starting here, a post you yourself once provided:
http://skeptoid.com/skeptic.php
 
More importantly, from a scientific perspective, he made clear that any answer is the right answer. There is no "failure" if no signals are detected. The goal of the project is to investigate the true nature of the universe. If nothing is detected, then we know something about the nature of the universe (or at least our little part of it) that we did not know before. It doesn't tell us that we are alone as a civilization, but it does tell us that no one is sending signals using radiation. This could be because most civilizations quickly discover far better technologies than radio. Or it could be because civilizations don't last long enough to be around to communicate with others. Or it could be that we are an incredibly rare phenomenon in the galaxy, or even the universe. These are all questions worth seeking the answers to. But in order to seek those answers we have to start looking.
How is it rational that Carl Sagan though it was important to seek answers to alien life but dismissed all other searches as irrational, superstitions. Was he the final authority on what were conclusively without evidence?
 
How is it rational that Carl Sagan though it was important to seek answers to alien life but dismissed all other searches as irrational, superstitions. Was he the final authority on what were conclusively without evidence?

Could you perhaps offer a concrete example of just what you're on about?

Links, that sort of thing?
 
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, particularly in claims that are far fetched or that violate physical laws.

Carl Sagan did not need extraordinary evidence to spend his adult life searching for ETI (aliens).

The extraordinary evidence is what he was looking for.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom