(Merged Thread) Facts and fictions in acupuncture

I am modesty aside a super skeptic: where everyone is in the bandwagon, like taking up Buddhism or bashing acupuncture, then I will take the opposite tack.
This is not a sign that you are any sort of sceptic. The idea that "sceptics" blindly oppose everything is a strawman. A sceptic is someone who bases their opinion on a subject on the available evidence.

Opposing ideas because they appear to be the majority view is not a sign that you are a sceptic: it is a sign that you are a troll.
 
yrreg:
Your repeated (and tedious) insistence on this `yes or no' principle demonstrates clearly how very little you understand about medicine, science, and indeed what knowledge really is. There are no absolutes in science, only diminishing uncertainty as knowledge increases. Your voluminous posts do not as you think show definitively that acupuncture cured anything, but every new post you make adds to the uncertainty. You are not going to convince anyone here by selecting sound bites that appear to support your simplistic ideas, while ignoring all the data which support a more equivocal interpretation.

Tell me, what scientific training have you had? What science books have you read? I mean books by proper scientists - eg Feynmann, Dawkins, Ridley, Medawar, Alvarez, Sagan, Margulis etc. If you haven't, do so and expand your mind.
 
Again, my answer is Yes, and why... 1st installment

I was asking people here to answer to the question, on the authority of Cochrane:

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​

Here is my answer again, though already given but not very explicitly:

I answer YES to the question:

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​

What I want to do now is to show people here why the answer should be Yes. I will reproduce the lines mentioning acupuncture and pain, in Cochrane's abstract of its review on the studies of:

Acupuncture and dry-needling for low back pain (Cochrane Review)http://www.cochrane.org/cochrane/revabstr/AB001351.htm​

Yrreg said:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1500182&postcount=159

List of mentions of pain and acupuncture in Cochrane's report:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1. Acupuncture and dry-needling for low-back pain (Cochrane Review) Furlan AD, van Tulder MW, Cherkin DC, Tsukayama H, Lao L, Koes BW, Berman BM ABSTRACT...

2. Background: Although low-back pain is usually a self-limiting and benign disease that tends to improve spontaneously over time, a large variety of therapeutic interventions are available for its treatment.

3. Objectives: To assess the effects of acupuncture for the treatment of non-specific low-back pain and dry-needling for myofascial pain syndrome in the low-back region. Search strategy...

4. Selection criteria: Randomized trials of acupuncture (that involves needling) for adults with non-specific (sub)acute or chronic low-back pain, or dry-needling for myofascial pain syndrome in the low-back region.

5. There were only three trials of acupuncture for acute low-back pain.

6. For chronic low-back pain there is evidence of pain relief and functional improvement for acupuncture, compared to no treatment or sham therapy.

7. There is evidence that acupuncture, added to other conventional therapies, relieves pain and improves function better than the conventional therapies alone.

8. Dry-needling appears to be a useful adjunct to other therapies for chronic low-back pain. No clear recommendations could be made about the most effective acupuncture technique.

9. Authors' conclusions: The data do not allow firm conclusions about the effectiveness of acupuncture for acute low-back pain.

10. For chronic low-back pain, acupuncture is more effective for pain relief and functional improvement than no treatment or sham treatment immediately after treatment and in the short-term only.

11. The data suggest that acupuncture and dry-needling may be useful adjuncts to other therapies for chronic low-back pain.

12. AD, van Tulder MW, Cherkin DC, Tsukayama H, Lao L, Koes BW, Berman BM. Acupuncture and dry-needling for low-back pain. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2005, Issue 1. Art. No.: CD001351.pub2.

Right away, we must know that Cochrane works first in establishing the facts, then drawing the conclusions; for intelligent readers of Cochrane's reviews the facts alone are enough for themselves to draw the conclusions.


See next post for the facts and the conclusions from Cochrane.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif
 
Again, my answer is Yes, and why... 2nd and last installment


Acupuncture and dry-needling for low back pain (Cochrane Review)
http://www.cochrane.org/cochrane/revabstr/AB001351.htm​


What are the facts established by Cochrane on acupuncture and pain? Here, in question and answer form:

Question I: Is there evidence for the fact of pain relief from acupuncture for chronic low-back pain?

Answer: 6. For chronic low-back pain there is evidence of pain relief and functional improvement for acupuncture, compared to no treatment or sham therapy.


Question II: Is there evidence of better pain relief from acupuncture than from conventional therapies alone?

Answer: 7. There is evidence that acupuncture, added to other conventional therapies, relieves pain and improves function better than the conventional therapies alone.


Question III: Is there evidence for dry-needling as an adjunct treatment to chronic low-back pain?

Answer: 8. Dry-needling appears to be a useful adjunct to other therapies for chronic low-back pain.


What are the conclusions of Cochrane from the facts established by them on evidence, in question and answer form?

Question IV: What is the conclusion for acute low-back pain?

Answer: 9. Authors' conclusions: The data do not allow firm conclusions about the effectiveness of acupuncture for acute low-back pain.


Question V: What about for chronic low-back pain?

Answer: 10. For chronic low-back pain, acupuncture is more effective for pain relief and functional improvement than no treatment or sham treatment immediately after treatment and in the short-term only.


Question VI: What is the general conclusion for chronic low-back pain?

Answer: 11. The data suggest that acupuncture and dry-needling may be useful adjuncts to other therapies for chronic low-back pain.

------------------

To the question then:

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​

I answer YES; as can be seen in the careful reading and examination of Cochrane's review on:



Acupuncture and dry-needling for low back pain (Cochrane Review)
http://www.cochrane.org/cochrane/revabstr/AB001351.htm​



Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif
 
Oolon (and indirectly Yrreg),

First, I am very happy for you for your recovery from a debilitating condition.

The treatment you described was (electrical over-)stimulation of a nerve. This technique is sometimes used in pain management. The stimulation can be via a needle through the skin, but can be from a conductur implanted under the skin. Some patients use such devices to help manage their own pain levels. Even simple physical stimulation can desensitize an area.

Did "accupuncture cure your problem?" That may depend upon your definition of accupuncture. In your case, a needle was involved, but that was not necessarily required. Had it been direct stimulation without a needle through the skin, would you (or Yrreg) still consider that accupunture? Meridians (as yrreg consistantly ignores) do not correspond directly with nerve pathways and needle placement does not seem to matter for some of the pain/nausea reduction techniques to which her refers elsewhere. Your treatment was directly to the nerve, not to a meridian, unless one were to claim the docor was lucky enough to hit one. Is this still accupuncture?

So I think the limb with more support for a position would be about electronic stimulation of nerves, not accupuncture.

My $.02.

CT
 
What are the facts established by Cochrane on acupuncture and pain?
Let's look at their conclusions:
The data do not allow firm conclusions about the effectiveness of acupuncture for acute low-back pain.
So we can't answer "yes" to your question in respect to acute low-back pain.

For chronic low-back pain, acupuncture is more effective for pain relief and functional improvement than no treatment or sham treatment immediately after treatment and in the short-term only.
Since your question is "Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint", this does not allow us to answer "yes" in respect to chronic low-back pain, as it only appears to provide temporary relief, and does not cure the complaint.

The data suggest that acupuncture and dry-needling may be useful adjuncts to other therapies for chronic low-back pain.
The words "may be" in that sentence mean that they were unable to draw a firm conclusion.

Because most of the studies were of lower methodological quality, there certainly is a further need for higher quality trials in this area.
In other words, they have concluded that the evidence from the available studies is not good enough to draw a firm conclusion.

To the question then:

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.
I answer YES; as can be seen in the careful reading and examination of Cochrane's review on:

Acupuncture and dry-needling for low back pain (Cochrane Review)

You have answered "yes" to your question on the basis of a review in which the authors clearly concluded that the evidence is not conclusive, and that the relief provided by acupuncture for chronic low-back pain appears to be only short-term. Why do you think the authors were wrong in their conclusions?
 
Last edited:
Oolon (and indirectly Yrreg),

First, I am very happy for you for your recovery from a debilitating condition.

The treatment you described was (electrical over-)stimulation of a nerve. This technique is sometimes used in pain management. The stimulation can be via a needle through the skin, but can be from a conductur implanted under the skin. Some patients use such devices to help manage their own pain levels. Even simple physical stimulation can desensitize an area.

Did "accupuncture cure your problem?" That may depend upon your definition of accupuncture. In your case, a needle was involved, but that was not necessarily required. Had it been direct stimulation without a needle through the skin, would you (or Yrreg) still consider that accupunture? Meridians (as yrreg consistantly ignores) do not correspond directly with nerve pathways and needle placement does not seem to matter for some of the pain/nausea reduction techniques to which her refers elsewhere. Your treatment was directly to the nerve, not to a meridian, unless one were to claim the docor was lucky enough to hit one. Is this still accupuncture?

So I think the limb with more support for a position would be about electronic stimulation of nerves, not accupuncture.

My $.02.

CT

It was, without a doubt, acupuncture. There were multiple needles inserted at a time during each session, and one session in which the needles were stuck in and around my (left, IIRC) ear only. There were numerous mannequins around the office with all the meridians and points clearly marked on them. The doctor knew what he was doing. During one of (perhaps the) first sessions, he hit the sciatic nerve dead on, and as you can well imagine, this made me tense up and squirm quite a bit. He admonished me for this, saying that if he lost the nerve (mine, not his!) he would have to search around for it again. His intention was to stimulate the sciatic nerve, and this, he did. Now, you might have missed my last post on the subject or just missed the relevant part, in any case, here it is again:

...even if acupuncture does work in certain cases, it should not be automatically assumed that it does so via the stated mechanisms, ie meridians and chi etc.

I should add, and I perhaps should have mentioned it before, that the doctor wanted to continue the treatment for several more sessions. He explained that my condition wasn't 'stabilised'. Whereupon I explained to him that my bank account had stabilised...at $0.00! I couldn't afford to keep seeing him, and as far as I was concerned at that point, I was 'cured'. So far, so good! Oh, one more thing, there were some powdered chinese herbs that I was supposed to eat. But I only ate one of the half dozen or so packets, as they tasted quite foul. If they were intended to be an essential part of the treatment, then one could effectively argue that I proved that they were not.
 
Just curious. Is acupuncture paranormal enough to be viable for the million?
 
Yes, accoding to Randi. However, since nobody is disputing that when you stick needles in it, the body notices, I'm not sure exactly what he'd expect you to demonstrate. Simply saying, if I stick a needle here, x will happen, surely isn't going to cut it, if x could be perfectly physiological.

Rolfe.
 
Yes, accoding to Randi. However, since nobody is disputing that when you stick needles in it, the body notices, I'm not sure exactly what he'd expect you to demonstrate. Simply saying, if I stick a needle here, x will happen, surely isn't going to cut it, if x could be perfectly physiological.

Rolfe.
Oh wow, Can I enter this study and win?

Sham Acupuncture Versus Placebo Pill

Swelling, redness, pain caused by not sticking a needle in, surely that's as paranormal as it gets! ;)
 
It was, without a doubt, acupuncture. There were multiple needles inserted at a time during each session, and one session in which the needles were stuck in and around my (left, IIRC) ear only. There were numerous mannequins around the office with all the meridians and points clearly marked on them.
[snip]
During one of (perhaps the) first sessions, he hit the sciatic nerve dead on, and as you can well imagine, this made me tense up and squirm quite a bit
I am sorry I was not clearer. I guess that is the distinction I am attempting to draw. Yes, the doctor was attempting to perform ACUPUNCTURE (thanks, Rolfe :) ). But were all needles required? We multiple treatments required? Were the herbs you mentioned required? When the needle directly touched the sciatic nerve, he now moved into an area slightly better studied in pain management, whether or not he intended to do so.

So was acupuncture (the treatment methodology) the relief, or was direct stimulation of the nerve? At the moment we cannot know for your case. That is why more studies are needed. First, see if the effects can be replicated. Second and third, isolate the possible cause/mechanism and find the best treatment option(s). If antibiotics and a good bedside manner will cure my infection, great. But I want to be sure I get the well-studied antibiotics first. Any placebo actions are a bonus.

And on behalf of empathetic wimps everywhere, may I sincerely say... OUCH! , and once again congratulations.

CT
 
Yes, accoding to Randi. However, since nobody is disputing that when you stick needles in it, the body notices, I'm not sure exactly what he'd expect you to demonstrate. Simply saying, if I stick a needle here, x will happen, surely isn't going to cut it, if x could be perfectly physiological.
Perhaps you'd have to demonstrate the existence of the "meridians" and "qi".
 
No, acupuncture is not a paranormal phenomenon.

Just curious. Is acupuncture paranormal enough to be viable for the million?

In my own thinking, acupuncture is not a paranormal phenomenon.

You see -- and I may be wrong here, so correct me -- a paranormal phenomenon is an event in the universe which is not normal, namely, not subject to a norm, namely again, not regular; to be brief: it cannot occur again.

What about so-called chance events? Chance events are chance to human observations, but in themselves they can and have occurred again and again I am sure in the vast recesses of the universe and time beyond human observations.

It is not possible for us to predict a so-called paranormal event or phenomenon because we don't know all the laws of life and the universe; but they can and have happened again and again in the as I said vast or even almost infinite in human conception reaches of the universe and time.

That is why I think very seriously that Randi is laughing all the time in offering a million to anyone who can perform or can point to a paranormal phenomenon or event; because he knows that there are no paranormal events except in our limited human observations -- and he can always fall back on what I have just written above, namely, no phenomenon or event in the universe is unique that cannot ever in the vast recesses of the universe and time happen again, it can and will and certainly has happened again and again -- and therefore it is not paranormal but normal, which is to say: when the factors responsible for the phenomenon meet again together the phenomenon will occur again.


Now, acupuncture is not a paranormal phenomenon, not a man-made paranormal event; it is normal only we still do not know and much less command the laws and all other components for its successful operation, unlike we know how to produce fire.


My point all along with the question:
Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No. ​
is precisely to explain that acupuncture is not a paranormal phenomenon or event or occurrence; I mean that in all the millennia of man's quest for healing, acupuncture has been at least once successful in effecting a healing even for a period; at least for periodical reliefs from medical complaints, just like people take anti-hypertensives for bringing down blood pressure to within normal range, and then take them again tomorrow and repeatedly everyday; and we cannot say that anti-hypertensives do not effect a cure to the medical complaint of hypertension or high-blood pressure because their effect of lowering blood-pressure is temporary.


I never studied acupuncture as much as I have done today, by reading and thinking; but I have met people whom I knew to be plagued by medical complaints and they have benefited from acupuncture: for pain, for allergies, for wounds, and other ills, which refuse to heal, or for which no relief was found in conventional scientific medicine. And I have talked with their acupuncturist; and I know that acupuncturists are doing successful practice everywhere.


When the Wright brothers were flying their primitive airplanes there were still people who refused to witness their experiments, but continuously wrote about the impossibility of objects heavier than air floating and moving in the air from its own operation in the air without any support linked to the ground.

If those people would only observe the phenomenon being demonstrated by the Wright brothers, just one instance; then they could have the certainty that humans can be certain with, that locomotion in air is possible and actual; and they could and should undertake researches into the how and the why on scientific premises.


In our case if they would at least see one successful cure of acupuncture to a medical complaint, then they should or might think of doing very serious and extensive researches into the why and how of acupuncture, with all the methods and instrumentations available today for scientific research.


By the way, some people here are resistant to the idea that the question I am asking, namely:

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​

doubting the validity and legitimacy of such a line of questioning.

In which case, what about this question:

Has surgery effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif
 
By the way, some people here are resistant to the idea that the question I am asking, namely:

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​

doubting the validity and legitimacy of such a line of questioning.

In which case, what about this question:

Has surgery effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​
Or how about:
Are parachutes effective in preventing major trauma related to gravitational challenge? ​
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom