(Merged Thread) Facts and fictions in acupuncture

Demanding standards for friends

Originally Posted by yrreg :
Suppose you read the Cochrane excerpts again, and remember that you are allowed to answer only Yes or No, what do you think is or should be your answer in order to pass the reading comprehension test in this question:

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.

It appears that you are the person who is having trouble with reading comprehension, if you are expecting people to answer yes or no to your question on the basis of a review that found the evidence inconclusive, and said that "there certainly is a further need for higher quality trials in this area."

I have the impression here that there are people -- it could be all in my mind of course -- who insist that acupuncture has not effected even just one cure to any one medical complaint.

And, once again, you have cited a review that is focusing on the use of acupuncture to alleviate symptoms (i.e. back pain, in this case) rather than actually curing a complaint.

So, I wish to attain a consensus from people here that acupuncture actually has effected at least one cure to a medical complaint.

I suggest that you go and get some good evidence for this, then.

To the people in the Alberta Heritage Foundation for Medical Research, if they possess reading comprehension, the answer is Yes.

http://www.ahfmr.ab.ca/hta/hta-publi...cupuncture.pdf

See my post #142 http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php...&postcount=142, above.

let's see what they actually said: "Clearly, more research of higher methodological quality is called for. Issues of blinding, the use of a credible control, varying diagnosis amonsgst differing philosophical approaches, and the diversity of treatment points chosen and techniques used challenge this particular area of complementary medicine." That looks more like a "maybe", even for the alleviation of symptoms they were looking at.

Amazing, isn't it, that while "alternative" medicine claims to be "holistic" and to treat the underlying condition, so much of what it actually appears to do focuses solely on subjective symptoms.

Do you think honestly that I will not succeed in arriving at a consensus from people here on the fact of at least one cure effected from acupuncture to one medical complaint?

You will only achieve this if you can provide evidence that acupuncture can in fact do this. So far all the evidence you have cited appears to be in the form of rather inconclusive studies of the ability of acupuncture to alleviate symptoms, rather than to cure a condition.
__________________
"You got to use your brain." - McKinley Morganfield

"We've been attacked by the intelligent, educated segment of the culture." - Pastor Ray Mummert

Not sure, and proud of it!

And, once again, you have cited a review that is focusing on the use of acupuncture to alleviate symptoms (i.e. back pain, in this case) rather than actually curing a complaint. -- Mojo

Amazing, isn't it, that while "alternative" medicine claims to be "holistic" and to treat the underlying condition, so much of what it actually appears to do focuses solely on subjective symptoms. -- Mojo

So far all the evidence you have cited appears to be in the form of rather inconclusive studies of the ability of acupuncture to alleviate symptoms, rather than to cure a condition. -- Mojo
​

Let us leave aside the accusation that acupuncture only deals with the symptoms but not the cure of a medical complaint.

I want to dwell on symptomatic treatment to medical complaints in conventional scientific medicine.

I had a discussion once with the house doctor of the place where I work, about symptomatic treatment of medical complaints.

He told me that as a matter of fact as far as he knows a very big part of medical practice for himself (more than 80%) and doctors he knows who are into primary care, symptomatic treatment is what they do when anyone comes to them with a medical complaint, for example shortness of breath or difficulty with breathing.

And he says that symptomatic treatment is absolutely medicine proper and very critically crucially important in any medical practice that is worth its salt.

In many many cases if you don't deal with the symptoms right away, the patient will die or get worse and worse until he becomes irremediably incapacitated for life or finally loses his life.

He tells me ancient physicians like Hippocrates and modern ones always attend right away to the four symptoms when a patient presents himself to them, namely:

dolor -- pain
calor -- heat, i.e., fever
tumor -- swelling
rubor -- redness
​

And I told him, "You forget one very important symptom." "What is that," he asked me. "Issue of blood," I reminded him, for example, nose-bleeding, esophageal bleeding, anal bleeding, vaginal bleeding.

-----------------

I still consider you a friend, Mojo, although to my impression and as per your words you have demanding standards for friends; for me a friend is someone who can use some good turn in any manner, and I want to do good turns to people here in the way of motivating them to be genuine skeptics -- even to people who otherwise to my impression harbor an unkind heart and mind toward persons who disagree with them.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif
 
Genuine skeptics don't give up so quickly and easily.

Jeff Corey said:
yrreg said:
In a reading comprehension test for promotion to the chief-editor's post in a newspaper, among other screening measures subjects are given the text of the report from Cochrane:

Acupuncture and dry-needling for low back pain (Cochrane Review)​

The link doesn't work, so we can't tell if they are from reliable journals. Good luck next time, o corpulent one.

------------------

Here, try again; don't go away too quickly and so nonchalantly.

http://www.cochrane.org/cochrane/revabstr/AB001351.htm

If it doesn't work, tell me and I will help you get the text by PM's.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif
 
Here's a maths exam question. Answer or fail the exam...
What is 2+3: Yes or No?

You're a TV fashion tipster. Answer or lose ratings...
What's next season's colour: Yes or No?

You're being interrogated. Answer or die...
Who is you commanding officer: Yes or No.

No matter how many times you ask your idiotic fantasy question, you're not going to goad them into giving you and idiotic answer. How stupid are you? I know nothing about this subject, or medicine or anything much, but even I can see that the conclusions in your study quite clearly say "we don't know". Not YES, not NO, but WE DON'T KNOW!

How painfully desperate are you to cling to that tiny ray of hope. "For chronic low-back pain, acupuncture is more effective for pain relief and functional improvement than no treatment or sham treatment immediately after treatment and in the short-term only." So what? Hitting them over the head with a frying pan would work immediately after treatment and in the short term only. Or pulling on gun on them... or throwing a bucket of water over them... Where's the cure? Where's the real benefit? It's agonisingly sad. I know people with chronic back pain and they've done all the rounds with the quacks but in the end, they've got most benefit out of a simple hot water bottle. They work great in the short term. Maybe that's because they're full of special kettle-chi that flows through the... oh god I can't even be bothered...

Sorry, it's probably a drive-by, but I just had to say it.
 
How painfully desperate are you to cling to that tiny ray of hope. "For chronic low-back pain, acupuncture is more effective for pain relief and functional improvement than no treatment or sham treatment immediately after treatment and in the short-term only." So what? Hitting them over the head with a frying pan would work immediately after treatment and in the short term only. Or pulling on gun on them... or throwing a bucket of water over them... Where's the cure? Where's the real benefit? It's agonisingly sad. I know people with chronic back pain and they've done all the rounds with the quacks but in the end, they've got most benefit out of a simple hot water bottle.

Shrinker, I’m sure your sentiments are shared by many. In fact, Bob Park wrote in a similar vein about acupuncture for arthritis of the knee back in December 2004:

A Maryland study of 570 elderly patients who suffer from arthritis of the knee, found that 6 months of acupuncture modestly reduced pain and improved agility. Six months? Why not take an aspirin? Scientists suggest the needles stimulate release of endorphins. Jalapeno peppers do the same thing. So it wouldn't matter where you stick the needles would it? Then who needs an acupuncturist?

Acupuncture: Researcher finds the haystack is full of needles
http://bobpark.physics.umd.edu/WN04/wn122304.html
 
Shrinker, I’m sure your sentiments are shared by many. In fact, Bob Park wrote in a similar vein about acupuncture for arthritis of the knee back in December 2004:



Acupuncture: Researcher finds the haystack is full of needles
http://bobpark.physics.umd.edu/WN04/wn122304.html

Hehe, that's great thanks. Jalapeno peppers eh? This supports my own Fearsome Hot Curry Healing Regime which works great on minor ailments and for my general 'wellness'. Perhaps I can start up a 3 year degree course in it.
 
Another reading comprehension test: Cochrane on meditation

For people who care to pass tests in reading comprehension made up of questions like the following:

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​

And you are asked to read a text for example from the gold standard of medical reviews, the Cochrane Collaboration,* about acupuncture and low-back pain:

Acupuncture and dry-needling for low-back pain (Cochrane Review)
http://www.cochrane.org/cochrane/revabstr/AB001351.htm
​

Here are some tips for people who care to be genuine skeptics:**

1. Read very carefully what the question is all about (that is also and already a challenge to your reading comprehension).

2. Encircle with your pen every mention of acupuncture and of pain in the given text.

3. Locate categorical statements in the text which convey in no uncertain terms that acupuncture effects or does not effect relief of low-back pain.

4. On the basis of these categorical affirmative and negative statements, choose your answer Yes or No.

For an illustration on the use of these tips, see my post #159 of the present thread, page 2, above, http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1500182&postcount=159


Should you happen to be in an open competitive examination for any reward, like admission to a limited enrollment in a prestigious graduate studies center, and the admission committee disagrees with you about your answer to that question, you can then challenge them all to the highest court of the land; and you will win.


Please read next post for another reading comprehension test: Cochrane on meditation.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif

*WHAT ARE COCHRANE REVIEWS?
http://www.cochrane.org/docs/newcomersguide.htm#reviews

Cochrane Reviews are systematic assessments of evidence of the effects of healthcare interventions, intended to help people to make informed decisions about health care, their own or someone else's. Cochrane Reviews are needed to help ensure that healthcare decisions throughout the world can be informed by high quality, timely research evidence. This is described in 'Systematic reviews and The Cochrane Collaboration'. Cochrane Reviews are published in full in The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, one of several databases in The Cochrane Library.

THEIR IMPACT AROUND THE WORLD
The main output of The Cochrane Collaboration, the Cochrane Reviews, has had a real and significant impact on practice, policy decisions and research around the world. Many examples are given in 'The Impact of Cochrane evidence'.


**Genuine skeptics are people who always maintain very strictly, no not a made-up-mind, but one that for a default keeps the door ajar on every issue which even the masters of skepticism have already closed to the door to believing that they know already everything correctly of life and the universe -- including themselves.
​


(Courtesy of Pes Oir Amsus)
 
Genuine skeptics are people who always maintain very strictly, no not a made-up-mind, but one that for a default keeps the door ajar on every issue which even the masters of skepticism have already closed to the door to believing that they know already everything correctly of life and the universe -- including themselves.


(Courtesy of Pes Oir Amsus)

Will you answer a question yourself, dear Yrreg?

Is it possible that acupuncture is fake medicine? Answer yes or no.

I also take it that this means you admit that you are Pes Oir Amsus?
 
...reading comprehension: Cochrane on meditation

Here is a group of applicants to a prestigious graduate studies center, and among other measures they are being tested on reading comprehension, and they come across this question to be answered with Yes or No, or to be left unanswered (meaning applicant does not know how to answer at all):

Has meditation effected a relief to anxiety? Yes or No.​

And they are given this text from the Cochrane Collaboration:

Meditation therapy for anxiety disorders
http://www.cochrane.org/reviews/en/ab004998.html​

So, our enterprising applicants will encircle with his pen all mentions of meditation and anxiety, thus:

1. Meditation therapy for anxiety disorders Krisanaprakornkit T, Krisanaprakornkit W, Piyavhatkul N, Laopaiboon M Plain language summary...

2. Although meditation therapy is widely used in many anxiety-related conditions there is still a lack of studies in anxiety disorder patients.

3. The small number of studies included in this review do not permit any conclusions to be drawn on the effectiveness of meditation therapy for anxiety disorders.

4. Transcendental meditation is comparable with other kinds of relaxation therapies in reducing anxiety, and Kundalini Yoga did not show significant effectiveness in treating obsessive-compulsive disorders compared with Relaxation/Meditation.

5. Drop out rates appear to to be high, and adverse effects of meditation have not been reported.

6. Anxiety disorders are characterised by long term worry, tension, nervousness, fidgeting and symptoms of autonomic system hyperactivity.

7. Meditation is an age-old self regulatory strategy which is gaining more interest in mental health and psychiatry.

8. Meditation can reduce arousal state and may ameliorate anxiety symptoms in various anxiety conditions.

9. Objectives: To investigate the effectiveness of meditation therapy in treating anxiety disorders...

10. Types of participants: patients with a diagnosis of anxiety disorders, with or without another comorbid psychiatric condition.

11. Types of interventions: concentrative meditation or mindfulness meditation.

12. ...psychological treatment 3) other methods of meditation 4) no intervention or waiting list.

13. Types of outcome: 1) improvement in clinical anxiety scale 2) improvement in anxiety level specified by triallists, or global improvement 3) acceptability of treatment, adverse effects 4) dropout.

14. Both studies were of moderate quality and used active control comparisons (another type of meditation, relaxation, biofeedback).

15. Anti-anxiety drugs were used as standard treatment.

16. In one study transcendental meditation showed a reduction in anxiety symptoms and electromyography score comparable with electromyography-biofeedback and relaxation therapy.

17. Another study compared Kundalini Yoga (KY), with Relaxation/Mindfulness Meditation.

18. The small number of studies included in this review do not permit any conclusions to be drawn on the effectiveness of meditation therapy for anxiety disorders.

19. Transcendental meditation is comparable with other kinds of relaxation therapies in reducing anxiety, and Kundalini Yoga did not show significant effectiveness in treating obsessive-compulsive disorders compared with Relaxation/Meditation.

20. Drop out rates appear to be high, and adverse effects of meditation have not been reported.

How do the skeptics in this website page answer the question:

Has meditation effected a relief to anxiety? Yes or No.​



Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif
 
How do the skeptics in this website page answer the question:

Has meditation effected a relief to anxiety? Yes or No.​

Excuse me, why did you suddenly change the subject? Bored of typing in the same thing over and over again?

Why are you asking us to answer questions when you refuse to answer any yourself?

Maybe there's something wrong with your reading comprehension?

Anyway, from that text of yours, it's impossible to answer yes or no to the question, for the same reason that your previous question couldn't be answered yes or no.

Why? This quote here, from your previous post :

18. The small number of studies included in this review do not permit any conclusions to be drawn on the effectiveness of meditation therapy for anxiety disorders.
 
No coercion here, please.

I am not forcing anyone to answer the question; and I can't force anyone.

It is just an invitation which anyone can decline or accept, all in the spirit of exchange of views, to the advancement of knowledge for the benefit of mankind -- my humble ambition.



Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif
 
I am not forcing anyone to answer the question; and I can't force anyone.

It is just an invitation which anyone can decline or accept, all in the spirit of exchange of views, to the advancement of knowledge for the benefit of mankind -- my humble ambition.

How can there be an exchange of views when you're not answering questions?

Why should we answer your questions when you don't answer ours?
 
I am not forcing anyone to answer the question; and I can't force anyone.

It is just an invitation which anyone can decline or accept, all in the spirit of exchange of views, to the advancement of knowledge for the benefit of mankind -- my humble ambition.
No, you cannot force anyone to participate. What you are attempting to do is called framing the debate. How many times can we say it?

  • You are not asking questions that have meaningful answers as you frame them.
  • You patently ignore statements in your "evidence" about inconclusiveness and need for more study to be able to draw conclusions.

This is not an exchange of ideas. It appears to be a test of patience.

CT
 
I have absolutely no intention of wading through 5 pages of this, so I'll just jump right in at the end and say that I had acupuncture for a hip condition in the early 90's and I haven't been bothered with it since.

It all began in 1980, when I slipped during an indoor footb...er...soccer game and landed squarely on my left hip. From that day forward, I was plagued by periodic bouts of what I self-diagnosed as sciatica. My doctor, on the other hand, begged to differ. He ordered x-rays of course, and blood analysis. He prescribed Indocid (anti-inflamatory), two capsules three times per day, but it did nothing. A few weeks later he called and asked me to come to his office. He was grinning like a cheshire cat. The reason he was so pleased, he said, was that I was his first ever case of Ankylosing Spondylitis, a form of rheumatoid arthritis if I remember correctly. I would have shared his enthusiasm but for the fact that he then informed me that it is incurable, and that eventually the bones in the small of my back would fuse together. Lovely! However, just to verify his diagnosis, he made an appointment for me with an osteopath, and he made arrangements for me to visit with a physiotherapist. Now, I should point out that, by that time, the pain was intermittent. Much of the time it was merely a nuisance, but at others it would flare up and be nothing less than debilitating. At those times, it felt as though the lining of my hip joint was completely gone, and the act of walking made it feel like bone grating on bone in the joint. Every movement was accompanied by excrutiating agony. As time went by, the really bad attacks became less frequent, but never more than six months apart. From time to time, it would flare up again and be almost more than I could bear, so I would go and see my doctor. He eventually admitted that his A-S diagnosis had proved to be inaccurate, a fact he had known for some time but had just never gotten around to telling me. He was at a loss. After years of listening to me complain, his best advice was "Try to remember what you were doing before the attack, then don't do it anymore". Brilliant. Absolutely brilliant! Let's see, I got up, had a shower, dried myself, got dressed, got in my car, drove to work.......I know what he was getting at, and it would have been helpful if there were any activities that were out of the ordinary in which I had engaged before the pain began, but there weren't any. Now, I'm quite certain that, once the pain began, I altered my gait and it is highly probable that doing so served to aggravate the condition. It would usually last for weeks. Sometimes months. I don't know what took me so long, but I did seek an alternative to traditional western medicine. I was desperate. And so I went to see an acupuncturist. Now, this man was a doctor of 'traditional' medicine as well, and was a consultant at a large teaching hospital, so it wasn't simply a matter of letting some guy jam long, sharp electrified needles in my butt. Long story short (oops! too late!), I received 8 treatments after which time I was able to run, jump, tie my own shoes, drive my stick shift car without everyone thinking I was pasted! It was utterly phenomenal, the difference acupuncture made to my quality of life. I should not gloss over just how painful the procedures were. Afterall, he pushed those needles directly into the largest nerve in the human body (if memory serves) and then wiggled them around for good measure. Once they were in place, he then attached them to a mild current, and I had to lay there on my face with an a$$ full of electric needles for half an hour and pay for the privelege! The point is, for whatever reason, acupuncture worked for me. I haven't had an attack in over 12 years! Call it the placebo effect, or aversion therapy, what-have-you, I just don't care. Well...I am a bit curious, and the best explanation I could come up with is, I probably had pinched a nerve in my hip when I fell, and his needling managed to unpinch it. Would I try acupuncture again? That would depend on what the problem was. I wouldn't trust it to, for instance, stop me smoking. Do I think there's a metaphysical component involved? No.

I had to laugh one day, though. I was looking at the mannequins he had with all the meridians and little black dots where the needles go, and I noticed there was quite a concentration of dots in the middle of the face. I was going to ask him what needs to be wrong with you before you get needles in the face. Then I pictured him making stabbing motions with a needle and yelling "Ha! You no pay you bill!" Laughter truly is the best medicine. Hey, maybe that's what cured me!? :D
 
Oolon, I am so happy for you!

Yesterday, 12:44 PM #174
Oolon Colluphid
Critical Thinker

Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Trapped inside an osteal carapace.
Posts: 395

I have absolutely no intention of wading through 5 pages of this, so I'll just jump right in at the end and say that I had acupuncture for a hip condition in the early 90's and I haven't been bothered with

Good friend, Oolon, may I ask of you to answer the following question with an Yes or No, or just say you prefer not to answer it for whatever reasons you also prefer not to tell us about.

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​

I am so happy for you that today it is March 14, 2006, and since early 90's after your acupuncture treatment, you have not been bothered anymore with your hip condition, for which your conventional scientific doctor had given up on you.

If you had come to me much earlier I could have told you my recommendations, see next post.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif
 
Any value in acupuncture? Recommendations from Yrreg.

Dear good friend Oolan, I gave this list of recommendations on that thread, "Any value in acupuncture by Paineroo," and I have been explaining myself from since then, and even defending myself in the midst of the most hostile fires from some people here frequently employing very unkind language.

I am really so glad that you have come along, and gave us your own personal testimony of one acupuncture treatment that has effected a cure to a medical complaint.



[Kindly give careful attention to phrases in bold.]

----------------

1. Acupuncture is an acceptable option for dealing with medical complaints, if you don't have enough money for treatment and medication in conventional scientific medicine, or if conventional scientific medicine has given up on you.

-----------------

2. I might be wrong with this suspicion, but if you make a survey of medical complaints treated by acupuncture and treated by conventional scientific medicine, you might just find that the number of successful cases and lasting duration of the successful treatments are quantitatively the same.

3. This rough study means you get people who are treated with acupuncture and people treated with conventional scientific medicine, on the same diseases or medical complaints.
Is this a valid approach for a study? Never tried that; as I said, it is just my almost arbitrary suspicion.

4. Actually I have seen Chinese doctors using their Chinese medical procedures, with herbs or concoctions made directly from herbs, heal patients in cases where conventional scientific medicine has given up.

5. And they cost in most instances less than 20% or even less of what scientific medical practitioners will cost you, with all kinds of drugs, procedures, and equipment expenses and hospitalization. (Addendum: the sky is the limit in professional fees, unless you enjoy socialized medicine.)

6. I said that if you don't have enough money for conventional scientific medicine or this kind of medicine has given up on you, you can and might profitably try acupuncture, and I will add also Chinese medical practitioners working with herbs and drugs directly sourced from herbs, including natural components from organic and mineral origins.

7. I will also add that if you want to experiment because you are not in an urgent medical situation, try the Chinese medical practitioners, you might just save a bundle of money and get the successful lasting treatment for your medical problem.

8. I would like to ask people here whether there are scientific studies of successful treatments done by Chinese doctors in patients given up by conventional scientific medicine.

9. I think that is a good approach for a study: round up people who had been treated successfully by Chinese doctors, who had been earlier given up by medical practitioners of conventional scientific medicine, and find out why the Chinese doctors succeeded where conventional scientific doctors had given up. In this manner conventional scientific medicine stands to gain new knowledge in medicine.

10. Allow me to point out that Chinese medicine is not to be equated with what people might think to consist in gestures and in orations executed by religious medicine men, maybe called tribal healers, who would treat sick people by appeals to invisible agents called spirits.

------------------

For my part I am searching the net for reliable accounts of people given up by doctors of conventional scientific medicine, but healed and still alive and healthy today, by Chinese medical practitioners using their traditional methods, and with herbs or concoctions made from materials of organic and mineral origins.


[Please remain calm and keep to rational mood with your reactions.]


Yrreg

Again, I am so glad for you and for the advancement of knowledge in mankind, and the banishment of fanaticism and bigotry.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif
 
Good friend, Oolon, may I ask of you to answer the following question with an Yes or No, or just say you prefer not to answer it for whatever reasons you also prefer not to tell us about.

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​
I am so happy for you that today it is March 14, 2006, and since early 90's after your acupuncture treatment, you have not been bothered anymore with your hip condition, for which your conventional scientific doctor had given up on you.

Although it is not outside the realm of possibility that there was some other explanation for the change in my medical condition, I'm going to go out on a limb and say 'Yes, acupuncture effected a cure for my medical complaint'. However, as I pointed out, even if acupuncture does work in certain cases, it should not be automatically assumed that it does so via the stated mechanisms, ie meridians and chi etc.
 
Apologia pro vita mea.

I consider myself a genuine and even super skeptic compared to some others here; and I insist on being academically non-emotive in the disquisition of an issue, always maintaining the door in my mind a bit ajar, instead of insisting that science as known today has the final definitive and immutable explanations for everything we know of life and the universe.

Allow me to reproduce here one early post in this thread where I had to answer a poster here who in effect told me to go away and join a pro alternative medicine board, forgetting that this board is exactly ordained by its author toward education, i.e., of everyone, including you and me and all who do care to be educated in the most exalted sense of humanistic aspiration for knowledge wherever it leads mankind. And what is the title of this website? Answer: James Randi Educational Foundation Forum; and I am absolutely certain that the author here is against all forms of fanaticism and bigotry.

[http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1453440&postcount=14]

There is emotion and emotion.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Originally Posted by Yuri Nalyssus (http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=1456766#post1452470):

I think you'll find that constitutes an emotional response.

I am still waiting for an answer to my question to Yrreg - What is it about emotional responses that worry him, what does he feel is wrong with robust debate?

People on this list presumably feel strongly about alternative medicine, why cannot Y.reg debate on this level. If confrontation makes Y.reg so unhappy all he needs to do is go to a more pro-acupuncture list. If Y.reg really cares about the points on debate he should start answering some questions. I would rather listen to mild sarcasm and the occasional passionate outburst than to veiled insults.

Yuri

Emotional responses of the kind in which people are called stupid and to be engaged in stupidity, are inhibitive to productive discussion, because they cloud the creative faculty of the mind to arrive at solutions to questions which solutions could be workable even though not in accordance with scientific doctrines of today -- in which case we have to broaden into new directions our concept and practice of science.

Consider war, it is not a rational answer to the conflict among men, but an emotional one. That's why we have to avoid emotionalism in our discourse here, if we want to be productively useful to each other instead of slaughtering each other.

However, there is emotion and emotion. The emotion that drives people to find the programming that exists or might exist or should exist in everything, that is one emotion that should always dwell in the hearts of men, who are given to the quest for knowledge wherever the quest leads them.

People on this list presumably feel strony about alternative medicine, why cannot Y.reg debate on this level. If confrontation makes Y.reg so unhappy all he needs to do is go to a more pro-acupuncture list. If Y.reg really cares about the points on debate he should start answering some questions. I would rather listen to mild sarcasm and the occasional passionate outburst than to veiled insults. -- Yuri (http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=1456766#post1452470):

That is where and why people here are wrong, and I am right to be here, because I am a super skeptic with a demanding scientific critical attitude, i.e., open to all directions except fanaticism and bigotry.

Here is a saying from my favorite student of human behavior, Pes Oir Amsus:

Be not like unto frogs which chant in unison.​
This is a rhetorical question: Has anything radically new ever been found by dwelling on the present doctrines of science and confining one's mind to them as to exclude all other avenues of thought imaginable and unimaginable?


Originally Posted by Yrreg:
(http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=1448085#post1448085
CE 16th February 2006, 05:14 AM post 55)

I am modesty aside a super skeptic: where everyone is in the bandwagon, like taking up Buddhism or bashing acupuncture, then I will take the opposite tack.

About answering questions, I am always in a hurry, so I have to choose what questions to answer in order to benefit all parties here, of whatever persuasion or sympathy, specially visitors who seek to read something of help to themselves, and not be bored with endless nitpicking that totally forgets the big picture which can be set forth in the short statement.

Good friend Oolan, you know as well as myself that explanations can always be thought up by man to satisfy his own understanding of phenomena which otherwise would be inexplicable to his mind -- that human mind which better exposed and experienced searchers know to be indeed limited in regard to its acquaintance with life and the universe.

First, before anything else, we want to verify the existence of a phenomenon, in the present context that acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.

Then we will try to analyze it according to our latest command of explanation or science at present; the ancients also had their own command of explanation, which in the light of our present command of explanation, which we call today's science, is inadequate.

Now, if it should happen that today's science cannot explain sufficiently to our understanding (i.e. again, of science today); then we have to look in new directions for explanations that will render the phenomenon in question comprehensible to our mind that is always in search for a better view of life and the universe.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif
 
I consider myself a genuine and even super skeptic compared to some others here; and I insist on being academically non-emotive in the disquisition of an issue, always maintaining the door in my mind a bit ajar, instead of insisting that science as known today has the final definitive and immutable explanations for everything we know of life and the universe.

Allow me to reproduce here one early post in this thread where I had to answer a poster here who in effect told me to go away and join a pro alternative medicine board, forgetting that this board is exactly ordained by its author toward education, i.e., of everyone, including you and me and all who do care to be educated in the most exalted sense of humanistic aspiration for knowledge wherever it leads mankind. And what is the title of this website? Answer: James Randi Educational Foundation Forum; and I am absolutely certain that the author here is against all forms of fanaticism and bigotry.



Good friend Oolan, you know as well as myself that explanations can always be thought up by man to satisfy his own understanding of phenomena which otherwise would be inexplicable to his mind -- that human mind which better exposed and experienced searchers know to be indeed limited in regard to its acquaintance with life and the universe.

First, before anything else, we want to verify the existence of a phenomenon, in the present context that acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.

Then we will try to analyze it according to our latest command of explanation or science at present; the ancients also had their own command of explanation, which in the light of our present command of explanation, which we call today's science, is inadequate.

Now, if it should happen that today's science cannot explain sufficiently to our understanding (i.e. again, of science today); then we have to look in new directions for explanations that will render the phenomenon in question comprehensible to our mind that is always in search for a better view of life and the universe.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif
:words:
 
Sorry to rain on your parade, yrreg, but Oolon's reply isn't the sort of unequivocal "yes or no" answer that you are looking for. Note that he said, "it is not outside the realm of possibility that there was some other explanation for the change in my medical condition". This, as has already been pointed out to you several times, will always be an issue in anecdotal accounts. If acupuncture really is an effective treatment for this condition, it should be possible to run a controlled trial to eliminate other factors. I suggest that you look for a report of such a trial.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom