[Merged]Scott Forbes powerdown revisited

I filed a FOIA with the PANYNJ, incl links to this thread:



I recieved this reply:



I would imagine that had PA ordered a power down as mr Forbes claim, there would have been a paper-trail.

Well, we can state with moderate certainty that there was no building-wide powerdown, since PANYNY has no such record. But then again, we haven't been considering building-wide powerdowns for some time now anyway, so it's sort of a moot point. This leaves us with (gack!) speculation.

It could be that individual floors or businesses within the tower powered down internally for some reason, and that's what Forbes discovered. At the university I work at, buildings or sections of buildings have powerdowns for various maintenance or installation activities, and when the affected area is local, many of us who are part of "central" support organizations are almost never told about such activities. Or if we are, it's as a "courtesy", or a "heads up, in case someone bugs you about it instead of us". Now of course, that is complete speculation, but I'm trying to reconcile Panoply's FOIA result with Forbes's statement. I'm not ready to out-and-out say he's a "liar", because to me, his claim sounds like it's simply being "misinterpreted" by conspiracy peddlers:

SF: I can't absolutely verify that there was no power on lower floors ... all I can validate is that we were informed of the power down condition, that we had to take down all systems and then the following day had to bring back up all systems ...
http://www.911myths.com/html/wtc_power_down.html

To me, all this does is add to the ledger saying that there's nothing suspicious to be found in running down the "powerdown" at the WTC. Which, given that it was merely one of many big reach claims by the "Truth" movement back in the day, is really not that surprising.
 
I'm not asking you to answer someone else's question I'm asking you to answer mine. Can you? Could the towers have collapsed from explosives damaging the same amount of floors as the plane?

What about any amount of explosives at all in addition to the planes? Would that have helped the collapse or slowed it down?



Are you telling me you have proof he's lying? Well post it debunker. What's taking you so long?

Oh so now you want to change the subject? So then what you are saying is that you now have NO evidence of a controlled demolition. And I agree with you that there is no proof of a controlled demolition. Because after all, what is your reason for thinking it was a controlled demolition? The speed of the collapse. So if explosives were used just where the plane was, which is impossible since they would be destroyed by the planes, then the collapse would have been too slow based on the reason for claiming its a demolition in the first place.

So you see kid, I am not avoiding your question, i am showing you WHY it's wrong.

And as for Scott, are you telling me that everyone who was there that day and saw the lights on and all the people who were up in the towers during that time are all liars? Because what I am saying is that scott is proven to be wrong. For what reasons I don't know or care. All that matters are the facts kid. You should try them sometime.
 
Since we know Scott Forbes in indeed wrong about his claims, maybe our little LC can tell us why he is wrong? You tell us, is he lying or was he just mistaken? Since you are the one interested in speculation, then you tell us.
 
I would imagine that had PA ordered a power down as mr Forbes claim, there would have been a paper-trail.

Most definitely.

I'm sure there would have been dozens of complaints from the tenants that would all have been on paper if there was a power-down.
 
What paper? What security footage? What's your point?

You seem to have a very difficult time ever understanding the point. Please read the posts multiple times until you understand them before you post irrelevant posts or requests for people to make it easier for you to understand.

I'm saying that a power-down of multiple floors of any of the World Trade Center buildings surely would have drawn some complaints to the Port Authority by the tenants.

The tenants of the floors that Forbes claims were affected by the alleged power-down include the First Commercial Bank (Floor 78), Fuji Bank (Floors 78 – 92), Fiduciary Trust and the Atlantic Bank of New York.

I don't know about you, but if I was a bank, and I found out my power (and therefore security) was going to be shut off for 24-36 hours (as Forbes claimed), I'd be contacting people to complain and make plans to keep my assets secured. This would leave a paper trail.

As the FOIA request has shown, there isn't any record of any power-down, or anyone contacting the Port Authority regarding a power-down. Based on this, and mountains of other evidence that I posed links to earlier in this thread, taking Scott Forbes word for it is simply illogical and irrational.
 
Last edited:
The tenants of the floors that Forbes claims were affected by the alleged power-down include the First Commercial Bank (Floor 78), Fuji Bank (Floors 78 – 92), Fiduciary Trust and the Atlantic Bank of New York.

I don't know about you, but if I was a bank, and I found out my power (and therefore security) was going to be shut off for 24-36 hours (as Forbes claimed), I'd be contacting people to complain and make plans to keep my assets secured. This would leave a paper trail.

More than likely, such a powerdown would have been expressly prohibited by the lease agreement unless pre-approved by the affected tenants.
 
Wow that's some debunking thus far. So a powerdown would have been unusual huh?

Let me ask all you scary debunkers something.

Isn't that the same thing Forbes is claiming?
 
Wow that's some debunking thus far. So a powerdown would have been unusual huh?


Yes. Such a power down going unrecorded and practically unnoticed is far less likely that the possibility that Forbes is reflecting the matter inaccurately. I’m glad to see that you’re following this.
 
Last edited:
Wow that's some debunking thus far. So a powerdown would have been unusual huh?

Let me ask all you scary debunkers something.

Isn't that the same thing Forbes is claiming?

Let me try to put it this way:
How would possibly a 24-36 hrs powerdown in approxemately half of WTC2 go unnoticed by thousands of people, save one?

Unless every other person in WTC2 but Scott Forbes and the occasional passer by on Manhattan, on a weekend, was blind as a mice or had the short term memory of the common mosquito of course. I cannot grasp how this event would go totally unnoticed.
I sincerely and honestly ask you for some sort of theory on this subject.
 
Last edited:
Wow that's some debunking thus far. So a powerdown would have been unusual huh?

Let me ask all you scary debunkers something.

Isn't that the same thing Forbes is claiming?

You seem to be living up to your screen name here.

If the top of one of the towers was dark all weekend, don't you think someone would have taken a picture of it? Wouldn't that picture have come out by now?
 
What's extraordinary to me is calling Forbes a liar based on absolutely nothing.

It's based on the fact that there is NOTHING that backs up his claims. No paper trail, no other workers who remember a severe power-down, etc.

The burden of proof is on Mr. Forbes if he wants us to believe what he's saying.
 
You seem to be living up to your screen name here.

If the top of one of the towers was dark all weekend, don't you think someone would have taken a picture of it? Wouldn't that picture have come out by now?


SF: All systems were shutdown on Saturday morning and the power down condition was in effect from approximately 12 noon on Saturday September 8, 2001.

GW: When did it end?

SF: Approximately 2PM on Sunday 9/9.


Saturday night isn't all weekend and he just claimed it's what he was told...

GW: How do you know that there was no electricity from floor 50 up, if Fiduciary Trust was on much higher floors -- starting at the 90th floor?

SF: I can't absolutely verify that there was no power on lower floors ... all I can validate is that we were informed of the power down condition, that we had to take down all systems and then the following day had to bring back up all systems ...


Now one more time debunkers. Scott Forbes thought this was significant because a power-down never happened before so he thought it was unusual.

So let me get this straight. Your debunking of Scott Forbes claiming a power-down at the WTC was unusual is that a power-down at the WTC would have been unusual?

BRAVO
 
Scott Forbes thought this was significant because a power-down never happened before so he thought it was unusual.


Such a power-down going unrecorded and practically unnoticed would have been so unusual that it is far less likely than the possibility that Forbes is reflecting the matter inaccurately.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom