[Merged]Scott Forbes powerdown revisited

Yup, out of 50,000 WTC workers ONE guy says there was a powerdown.

That's all the proof LC needs.

Lest anyone wonder what that "new investigation" would be like.
 
Last edited:
What is this debunking NIST style? I should maybe check back next week? Next year?


I don’t have any intention of debunking NIST, let alone their style. Further, you’ve threatened to leave me before. You don’t have the grapes.
 
Well, if there is some proof he's lying then look you have had five pages now to show it.

What's taking so long debunker? What is this debunking NIST style? I should maybe check back next week? Next year?

Let me know will ya?

I want his proof that he was notified.

Where is the email(s) that surely he must have received about this?

Why did the person that he (Scott Frobes) said could back up his claim, not get back to the poster here (sorry, forgot who it was) that tried to contact him/her?
 
What LastChild is expecting is something along the lines of a letter from the Port Authority in written form saying "Attention employees, there will not be a power-down this weekend". He fails to even grasp the most basic concepts of the burden of proof.

There is absolutely no evidence to back up what Forbes is claiming. The only evidence that exists for a power-down in the WTC on the weekend before 9/11 is his statement. There is a mountain of evidence that indicates that a power-down was highly unlikely, and it has essentially even been proven that one did not occur. Even if that mountain of counter-evidence didn't exist, it's still highly irrational to believe Forbes until he presents some evidence to back up his claims. Given that he's had nearly 7 years to do this, and has thus far failed, I can only say that the man's a liar.

If he ever comes out with some evidence that corroborates his claims, I will happily apologize to him and withdraw my comment.
 
Last edited:
What LastChild is expecting is something along the lines of a letter from the Port Authority in written form saying "Attention employees, there will not be a power-down this weekend". He fails to even grasp the most basic concepts of the burden of proof.

There is absolutely no evidence to back up what Forbes is claiming. The only evidence that exists for a power-down in the WTC on the weekend before 9/11 is his statement. There is a mountain of evidence that indicates that a power-down was highly unlikely, and it has essentially even been proven that one did not occur. Even if that mountain of counter-evidence didn't exist, it's still highly irrational to believe Forbes until he presents some evidence to back up his claims. Given that he's had nearly 7 years to do this, and has thus far failed, I can only say that the man's a liar.

If he ever comes out with some evidence that corroborates his claims, I will happily apologize to him and withdraw my comment.

LC is obviously a youngster, going through that intolerable stage where (some) unhappy kids seem to live to piss other people off. It's sad, really.

Nothing he says makes a lick of sense, so I'm not sure why anyone responds to his drivel anymore. A lesson I obviously just learned myself, btw.:D
 
Well, if there is some proof he's lying then look you have had five pages now to show it.

In fairness, he may not be lying, he could just be completely wrong.

At any rate, it's his claim, he's the one who needs to provide proof.

Example:
I was in the tower during the time he reported this "power down" and there wasn't one...prove I'm lying. (See how that works?)
 
Well, if there is some proof he's lying then look you have had five pages now to show it.
I would say the link to the thread that contains this post pretty much did that very thing.

What's taking so long, LC, to show your evidence that the powerdown did occur? What is this exposing da twoof Loose Change style? We should maybe check back next week? Next year? In do-over #47?

Let us know will ya?
 
I saw Scott Forbes giving his alleged account of a power down at a UK troof group meeting in London last year. At that time, he was on the fence about woo. He was asked outright if he was MIHOP, and stated that such ideas "are just too much to deal with" or something to that effect. I don't know anything more than that, though.
 
In fairness, he may not be lying, he could just be completely wrong.

My assessment of Forbes might be more charitable were it not for his initial letter bringing up the power-down. He began to back off his his claims later on, but that first letter was unequivocal. About obvious lies. Told by a liar.
 
So again, only 1 person noticed a power outage that supposedly effected half of one of the WTC towers which housed many many majority companies? Despite other people remembering the power was on and having hard physical evidence to prove it? 1 person?
 
I saw Scott Forbes giving his alleged account of a power down at a UK troof group meeting in London last year. At that time, he was on the fence about woo. He was asked outright if he was MIHOP, and stated that such ideas "are just too much to deal with" or something to that effect. I don't know anything more than that, though.

Edmuind

A UK truther on here claims that Scott said he was being prevented from speaking out because his employers had "pressurised" him. This truther pretty much insinuated that Scott was adamant the power down had something to do with the attacks. Does this ring true from what you saw and heard?
 
Edmuind

A UK truther on here claims that Scott said he was being prevented from speaking out because his employers had "pressurised" him. This truther pretty much insinuated that Scott was adamant the power down had something to do with the attacks. Does this ring true from what you saw and heard?

I wish I could remember. It was a very boring talk and I only recall parts of it. I remember him talking about being 'debriefed' by the FBI or CIA, so maybe he thinks they put pressure on him. I do remember he was fairly vague and a very unengaging speaker. I'm also sure that he was very noncommittal about what conclusions he actually drew from what he claims to have witnessed. He came across as a 'just asking questions' type, although that could be a smokescreen and he may actually be a troofer.
 
You seem to be living up to your screen name here.

If the top of one of the towers was dark all weekend, don't you think someone would have taken a picture of it? Wouldn't that picture have come out by now?

23663481273301737c.jpg
 
your right, i have it on good authority that manhattan is pretty deserted on saturday nights


whats unusual is such an unusual event happening and only 1 PERSON taking notice


does that not seem the slightest bit odd to you?

A friend of mine has been in contact with Scott Forbes. He is actually working with a group of over 30 fellow WTC employees who witnessed the power downs, to have this evidence officially acknowledged.
 
A friend of mine has been in contact with Scott Forbes. He is actually working with a group of over 30 fellow WTC employees who witnessed the power downs, to have this evidence officially acknowledged.

Yeah, sure. We believe you. really, we do.:boggled:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom