[Merged]Scott Forbes powerdown revisited

SF: All systems were shutdown on Saturday morning and the power down condition was in effect from approximately 12 noon on Saturday September 8, 2001.

GW: When did it end?

SF: Approximately 2PM on Sunday 9/9.

Saturday night isn't all weekend and he just claimed it's what he was told...
your right, i have it on good authority that manhattan is pretty deserted on saturday nights

GW: How do you know that there was no electricity from floor 50 up, if Fiduciary Trust was on much higher floors -- starting at the 90th floor?

SF: I can't absolutely verify that there was no power on lower floors ... all I can validate is that we were informed of the power down condition, that we had to take down all systems and then the following day had to bring back up all systems ...

Now one more time debunkers. Scott Forbes thought this was significant because a power-down never happened before so he thought it was unusual.

So let me get this straight. Your debunking of Scott Forbes claiming a power-down at the WTC was unusual is that a power-down at the WTC would have been unusual?

BRAVO
whats unusual is such an unusual event happening and only 1 PERSON taking notice


does that not seem the slightest bit odd to you?
 
your right, i have it on good authority that manhattan is pretty deserted on saturday nights


whats unusual is such an unusual event happening and only 1 PERSON taking notice


does that not seem the slightest bit odd to you?

I think the whole thing is odd and obviously so did Scott Forbes and that's why he wrote the 9/11 commission to bring it to their attention.

So? Your debunking of Forbes is that you agree with him?
 
Another odd thing is that within the same interview, Forbes goes from 36hrs blackout to 26:

SF: Because of a "power down" notified by the Port Authority. Power was being switched off for a 36hr period in the top half of tower

Off on Saturday afternoon - around 12 noon I think - and back on at about 2 pm on the Sunday

Or do I misunderstand something here?
 
I think the whole thing is odd and obviously so did Scott Forbes and that's why he wrote the 9/11 commission to bring it to their attention.

So? Your debunking of Forbes is that you agree with him?

You mean that Forbes went to the 9/11 Commission saying "Hey, the odd thing about this power down is that I'm the only one ever to notice it"?
 
LC,

what's your theory on why only Scott Forbes noticed this powerdown?

Was the rest of New York just too stupid to notice that only half the WTC was lit up?
 
I think the whole thing is odd and obviously so did Scott Forbes and that's why he wrote the 9/11 commission to bring it to their attention.

So? Your debunking of Forbes is that you agree with him?
so you honestly think the powerdown was unusual, but its perfectly reasonable only 1 person noticed?
 
LC,

what's your theory on why only Scott Forbes noticed this powerdown?

Was the rest of New York just too stupid to notice that only half the WTC was lit up?

How do you know they didn't notice? Should they have taken out an ad somewhere? Or maybe they should have called you personally?

Are you debunking yet? Cause I might have missed it. Let me know when it starts.
 
LC,

what's your theory on why only Scott Forbes noticed this powerdown?

Was the rest of New York just too stupid to notice that only half the WTC was lit up?

That I don't know he was the only one who noticed?
 
I think the whole thing is odd and obviously so did Scott Forbes and that's why he wrote the 9/11 commission to bring it to their attention. So? Your debunking of Forbes is that you agree with him?


Such a power-down going unrecorded and practically unnoticed would have been so unusual that it is far less likely than the possibility that Forbes is reflecting the matter inaccurately.
 
He said he was notified.
He said he was not there.

How does he know it actually happened?

He can't be sure of the amount of floors affected, or if it was just his company.

Maybe it was not a power down, might it have been an IT related system thing only related to his company?

Just Asking Questions here.

There are too many problems with his story.
It just does not add up.
Why the change in the time frame?

We need an investigation into his official story.
(/truthy mode)
 
Are you debunking yet? Cause I might have missed it. Let me know when it starts.

Not really anything here to debunk. This guy claims there was a power down despite the fact that there is no evidence of such an event occurring.
 
your right, i have it on good authority that manhattan is pretty deserted on saturday nights


whats unusual is such an unusual event happening and only 1 PERSON taking notice


does that not seem the slightest bit odd to you?

That is the first logical and effective use of oversize letters I have seen in this forum. You used them to make an actual point, unlike 99% of the users who do it just because they think it is "cool".
 


I’d advise you not to get upset. The last time you did so, you became so frustrated that you started telling lies and got yourself suspended in the process. We don’t want a repeat of that performance.
 
Well, if there are more witnesses, then by all means cite them.

Well, if there is some proof he's lying then look you have had five pages now to show it.

What's taking so long debunker? What is this debunking NIST style? I should maybe check back next week? Next year?

Let me know will ya?
 
Yup. As usual, despite absolutely NO corroborating evidence, a single dissenting voice is held up as the ultimate truth, that is as long as the voice supports ones position of course.

Truthers ROCK!
 
Well, if there is some proof he's lying...


We don’t need to “prove” that he was lying. We only need to show that it’s more rational to believe that he was reflecting the matter inaccurately (whether intentionally or not) than to believe that he was reflecting the matter accurately.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom