whats extraordinary to everyone else is one fo the busiest buildings on the planet being powered down for 36 hours and only 1 man noticing
Do you have proof he was lying?
whats extraordinary to everyone else is one fo the busiest buildings on the planet being powered down for 36 hours and only 1 man noticing
have i said he was lying? i can think of a few scenarios in which his story is wring without him knowingly spreading false informationDo you have proof he was lying?
Do you have proof he was lying?
whats extraordinary to everyone else is one fo the busiest buildings on the planet being powered down for 36 hours and only 1 man noticing
We don’t need to “prove” that he was lying. We only need to show that it’s more rational to believe that he was reflecting the matter inaccurately (whether intentionally or not) than to believe that he was reflecting the matter accurately.
have i said he was lying? i can think of a few scenarios in which his story is wring without him knowingly spreading false information
but rather than asking me to prove a negative do you have any evidence at all (not even going so far as "proof") that he isnt mistaken?
yeah thats pretty much what ockham's razor doesSo you don't know if he is wrong, lying, or telling the truth. You can only guess and pretend your guess is better then the next.
More rational does not mean true.
More rational does not mean true. And it's not a debunking of anything.
I thought it was debunkers who claimed the towers fell from structural damage and building content fire to a few floors near the top.
Not that they couldn't if they wanted to I sourced how they could do it in a couple days or had years if needed, but why would they need to wire the whole entire building given your version of how the towers collapsed? Couldn't they have just done some floors near the top?
Do you have proof he was lying?
More rational does not mean true. And it's not a debunking of anything.
So you don't know if he is wrong, lying, or telling the truth. You can only guess and pretend your guess is better then the next.
So you don't know if he is wrong, lying, or telling the truth. You can only guess and pretend your guess is better then the next.
I've come across a claim made by an employee of Fiduciary
Trust, a tenant of WTC2, Scott Forbes, where he states that the top half
of WTC2 had a complete electrical "power down" the weekend prior to
9/11 2001.
This power down, mr Forbes claims, was ordered by the Port Authority and
thus I would like to request under the FOIA any information pertaining
this alleged power down, in an effort to validate mr Forbes claim.
PANYNJ said:Re: Freedom of Information Reference No. ****
Dear Mr. ***************
This is a response to your April 22, 2008 request, which has been processed under the Port Authority’s policy on Freedom of Information, (the “Policy,” copy enclosed) for records generally related to a scheduled power down at Two World Trade Center the weekend prior to September 11, 2001.
Please be advised that there are no documents in Port Authority files responsive to your request.
Sincerely,
Kathleen P. Bincoletto
FOI Administrator
Maybe you should rephrase that to all written and e-mailed communication with Fiduciary Trust from 9/01/2001 - 9/10/2001. There may not be any documents that specifically state "power down."I filed a FOIA with the PANYNJ, incl links to this thread:
I recieved this reply:
I would imagine that had PA ordered a power down as mr Forbes claim, there would have been a paper-trail.