[Merged]Scott Forbes powerdown revisited

Do you have proof he was lying?
have i said he was lying? i can think of a few scenarios in which his story is wring without him knowingly spreading false information

but rather than asking me to prove a negative do you have any evidence at all (not even going so far as "proof") that he isnt mistaken?
 
Last edited:
Do you have proof he was lying?


We don’t need to “prove” that he was lying. We only need to show that it’s more rational to believe that he was reflecting the matter inaccurately (whether intentionally or not) than to believe that he was reflecting the matter accurately.
 
LC, I'd love to hear your theory as to why Forbes' powerdown isn't corroborated by anyone else.
 
Oh, two thousand. I didn't notice. There should have been a firework or something. I'd have been off my tits on happiness.
 
whats extraordinary to everyone else is one fo the busiest buildings on the planet being powered down for 36 hours and only 1 man noticing

In my correspondence with him;

1. He never saw the building at night with the floors blacked out.

2. He was not in the building at all during that time.

3. He gave me two email addresses for a co-worker of his who supposedly is still in NYC and who can verify his story, and neither address was answered. I had marked the messages for return receipt and never got the return (yes I know that does not always work.)

4. He could provide NOTHING whatsoever to corroborate his story.

Charitably, I think he might believe what he is saying, but is mistaken for one reason or another.
 
OK, here is the deal, I will give the name and email of this supposed corroborating contact privately to anybody in NYC (anybody I decide I trust) who wants to run down that lead further than email. The emails went to http://www.fiduciarytrust.com/ and to http://www.franklintempleton.com/ - On neither site can I find a employee directory, not surprising in that industry. The name is fairly common, 13 in NYC phone book alone and who knows if he lives in Jersey or Rochelle or Long Island?

I don't have time to run this down further, I have a radio network to keep running now, but I'd be happy to see it run down.

-Ben
 
We don’t need to “prove” that he was lying. We only need to show that it’s more rational to believe that he was reflecting the matter inaccurately (whether intentionally or not) than to believe that he was reflecting the matter accurately.

More rational does not mean true. And it's not a debunking of anything.
 
have i said he was lying? i can think of a few scenarios in which his story is wring without him knowingly spreading false information

but rather than asking me to prove a negative do you have any evidence at all (not even going so far as "proof") that he isnt mistaken?

So you don't know if he is wrong, lying, or telling the truth. You can only guess and pretend your guess is better then the next.
 
So you don't know if he is wrong, lying, or telling the truth. You can only guess and pretend your guess is better then the next.
yeah thats pretty much what ockham's razor does

any lucking finding anyone else? or was forbes the only one in the building that weekend?
 
More rational does not mean true.


It’s more rational to believe that the Earth orbits the Sun than to believe the opposite. More rational doesn’t mean true. But it would be strange to adopt a belief that is less rational that its alternative.
 
More rational does not mean true. And it's not a debunking of anything.


Well, essentially that’s exactly what debunking is – showing that the non-conspiratorial explanation is more rational than the conspiratorial one.
 
I thought it was debunkers who claimed the towers fell from structural damage and building content fire to a few floors near the top.

Not that they couldn't if they wanted to I sourced how they could do it in a couple days or had years if needed, but why would they need to wire the whole entire building given your version of how the towers collapsed? Couldn't they have just done some floors near the top?

You can't place any explosives near the site of an airliner exploding and expect them to survive the blast.

It is impossible for explosives to have initiated the collapse of the World Trade Center. They simply wouldn't have survived the impact and ensuing fireball.

Watch videos of the collapse up close if you don't believe me. The collapse began right on the impact zone, and you can see the walls get pulled inwards (see the NIST report for more).
 
Do you have proof he was lying?

He made the claim, he provides the evidence.

There are mountains of facts that indicate that there was no power down, as I have shown you in this thread. Given these facts working against him, I think it's highly irrational to believe Forbes until he presents some evidence or corroborating witnesses to support his case.
 
More rational does not mean true. And it's not a debunking of anything.

Looks like it's heads-you-win, tails-we-lose. What stupidity. Stop embarrassing yourself.

So you don't know if he is wrong, lying, or telling the truth. You can only guess and pretend your guess is better then the next.

No, I can apply my relevant knowledge and experience, and not argue from a point of complete and utter ignorance like a petulant child. To wit, the power-down alleged by Forbes has been corroborated by no one, yet thousands would have been aware if it had taken place. Many companies in NYC essentially operate 24-7. Not all, but enough so that building managers MUST notify all tenants and their employees regarding any planned interruption in building services. No exceptions. Period. If half a WTC tower was shut down for a day+, it would be easy to get corroboration. Forbes can't, since Forbes is a liar.

Some consider he might just be "mistaken". In a sense I think this is true - there was probably some sort of upgrade at his firm that required temporarliy shutting down their systems or some such. Unfortunately, that can't possibly be used as cover to justify the obviously false claims in his initial letter, as well as his claim that (paraphrasing) "as soon as I saw 9/11 unfold, I knew it was related to the weekend work".

He didn't make a mistake, honestly misinterpreting events. He had an agenda, and was willing to prove himself a lying pinhead to support it.

That's dedication.
 
Did anyone else notice that after LC failed to get anywhere with his contention that there was an electrical safety issue in the pulling fiber optic cable in the building he dropped that issue and started on a new tack that is also going nowhere fast?
 
So you don't know if he is wrong, lying, or telling the truth. You can only guess and pretend your guess is better then the next.

He is completely wrong about the powerdown for the top 50 floors as claimed.

He goes to truthers meetings in the UK and repeats those claims therefore he is lying.

We already had this discussion where you claimed to have been to the top of the towers but could not remember what electrical apparatus was needed in the sky lobby. If there was no power above floor 50 then the lobby was not open. If the lobby was not open then my friends were hallucinating it when they were up there during the supposed power down. The ticket supplied on this site for the same timing was proof the lobby was open therefore must have had power.

If the power down was in effect it still would not have affected the cameras or security locks, that Scott insinuated, at the ground lobby level. If there were cameras and security locks below floor 50 then how the the "strange boiler suited guys" get up to his floor past security.

It is Scott who claims that the powerdown was something to do with the events of the day, not debunkers, so the claims need to be verified and so far he has failed spectacularly. Much like you LC

He is a liar
 
So what have we learned? I for one have learned that just because something is more rational doesn't mean it is true. Interesting.

Well, I have no problem with that, but I think I'll keep the 'rational' explanation of events as my number one position until I have some pretty compelling evidence to believe the 'irrational' explanation is the one that's true.

I suspect, however, that LCs brilliant stance on rationality vs irrationally is simply a circuit breaker to allow him to deal with the fact that his position is irrational. I don't blame him; my 8 year old does the same thing.
 
I filed a FOIA with the PANYNJ, incl links to this thread:

I've come across a claim made by an employee of Fiduciary
Trust, a tenant of WTC2, Scott Forbes, where he states that the top half
of WTC2 had a complete electrical "power down" the weekend prior to
9/11 2001.

This power down, mr Forbes claims, was ordered by the Port Authority and
thus I would like to request under the FOIA any information pertaining
this alleged power down, in an effort to validate mr Forbes claim.

I recieved this reply:

PANYNJ said:
Re: Freedom of Information Reference No. ****

Dear Mr. ***************

This is a response to your April 22, 2008 request, which has been processed under the Port Authority’s policy on Freedom of Information, (the “Policy,” copy enclosed) for records generally related to a scheduled power down at Two World Trade Center the weekend prior to September 11, 2001.

Please be advised that there are no documents in Port Authority files responsive to your request.

Sincerely,



Kathleen P. Bincoletto
FOI Administrator

I would imagine that had PA ordered a power down as mr Forbes claim, there would have been a paper-trail.
 
I filed a FOIA with the PANYNJ, incl links to this thread:



I recieved this reply:



I would imagine that had PA ordered a power down as mr Forbes claim, there would have been a paper-trail.
Maybe you should rephrase that to all written and e-mailed communication with Fiduciary Trust from 9/01/2001 - 9/10/2001. There may not be any documents that specifically state "power down."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom