[Merged]Scott Forbes powerdown revisited

It depends on what your claim is. If as debunker one wants to claim they needed years to set-up the building I proved years of access was available. If you claimed they couldn't have done it in a few days I also proved that wrong and sourced it.

Go back and read. I got you covered.

What you have not proven is that your scenario would be valid without having the people who worked in and maintained the building for a living being "In on it."

please do so.

Do you have any idea how many people are involved in a renaovation project like the ones you describe?

Do you have any idea just how many people are involved in the maintance and management of a building like just one of the towers?

Any whatsoever?

Do you have any idea what sort of access restricitons and controlls that the various financial institutions that occupied the buildings had built into their leases?

Grow up and get a real job.
 
Last edited:
One more time.

LEARN TO READ DEBUNKER AND READ EVERYTHING BEFORE YOU OPEN YOUR MOUTH

http://findarticles.com/p/articles/m...18/ai_75610255

NEW YORK--(BUSINESS WIRE)—June 18, 2001

"Once the cable installation is complete later this summer, we will be able to deliver network and communications services within days - an amazing capability through the use of this air-blown fiber process."
perhaps you should try reading, that quote clearly refers to communication cable, not power, and as several have pointed out to you there would be no need to cut power to do that (as someone who has installed fiber, cat3, cat5 and cat6 i can confirm that they wouldnt cut power to install it)
 
Because they didn't plant the explosives on the raceways, they ripped open the column enclosures to plant the explosives directly on the columns.

Then of course the patched it all back up, repainted, and replaced the walpaper, ceiling tiles, etc. without anyone noticing. You didn't notice when the NWO wired the pru building in Boston, did you? ah, oops, Ah, just forget I said that. . . ;)

Too young for the Pru.... but I was the electrician at one of the hotels that was involved during 911. I did notice some thermite harnesses on several columns in the upper floors that made them burn at angles. Big stickers on them .... "ACME THERMITE DETONATOR"
 
I'm curious... when these companies came in to upgrade facilities in the buildings, but instead laid explosive charges and det cord, why is it that none of the high powered tenants in the WTC complained that the upgrades didn't improve their services at all, but that the guys doing the upgrade had laid cables all over the show, around the core and perimeter of the floors, disrupting their business and leaving these odd bulges on the columns?

I mean, c'mon. The June upgrade was for network and communication services. Do you really think the tenants in the WTC didn't notice that their network performance didn't improve at all?
 
Back and forth back and forth with nothing but nonsense.

Let me know what time the debunking starts will ya?

I can't believe so many of you spend so much time coming up with absolutely nothing.

What a waste. I mean this Forbes guy has been around with this claim for years and this is the best you can come up with?

Don't make me laugh. You debunk nothing.
 
LC you prove nothing. This is a forum with pretty smart people. Your infantile claim of victory in a situation that warrants NO such confidence is simply funny. Nothing more.
 
Last edited:
What a waste. I mean this Forbes guy has been around with this claim for years and this is the best you can come up with?
youd think in all that time the truthers would be able to find at least one other person who can confirm a building of 10,000 employees was powered down, i mean you dont even have a mike the emt to back up forbes's story
 
Why in God's name is this thread still alive? It seems as though the argument has descended below the trees in arguing the nature of the forest. Regardless of whether the conspiracy fantasy posits a multihour window during a powerdown, or a multiyear one during an ongoing project, the fact remains that no evidence of either explosives or incendiaries in the post-collapse rubble exists, nor is there any evidence showing that any suspicious activity occured during the decade-plus project. So it's pushing an irrelevancy to claim the explosives/incendiaries emplacement window was on the order of years rather than hours. And it's seriously descending beyond irrelevancy to quibble over whether power or networking cables are involved, or whether powerdowns occur in given situations in general. No matter what the results of such minute arguments are, the basic facts still stand.

Can this thread please die? I say this with profuse apologies to Panoply Prefect, who was merely trying to discuss FOIAs to determine the nature of the power-down discussion. The thread got infected and lost its way.
 
Not that they needed it and I proved it but 10 years is a small window?

You are severely misunderstanding what I am saying to you. YOUR SIDE OF THE DEBATE uses this point. The reason they do so is to convince people that a power down in the WTC before the attacks was the time that explosives were placed. According to conspiracists no power = no surveillance and no workers.

The conspiracist argument is:
1. Scott Forbes Claims Power down.
2. Therefore no power.
3. Therefore no workers.
4. Therefore no security.
5. Therefore explosives could be placed in secrecy.

The ten years that you speak of is irrelevant. Sure, 10 years is plenty of time to wire a building for demolition. However, demolition doesn't just involve putting some cable in a wall and attaching it to explosives.

The walls of the building need to be pulled down. Charges need to be fork lifted into the offices and placed on exposed columns. Det cord (not fiber optic cables) is then attached to the explosives. You can't just pack det cord in a wall and expect it to last 10 years.

And your side was the first to dismiss it as nothing by presenting absolutely nothing.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=3089122
http://screwloosechange.blogspot.com/2007/10/power-down-debunked.html
http://www.911mysteriesguide.com/19.php
http://www.911myths.com/html/wtc_power_down.html

I'd call that far more than "absolutely nothing". So instead of claiming that no counter-points have been made, how about addressing them?

You are posting from the position no one had time or access to the building to do whatever the hell they wanted. That would be wrong.

No, I'm not saying that at all, captain Straw Man. I'm saying that the tasks that need to be completed to prepare a controlled demolition are much more extensive, laborious, and noticeable than those that involve installing some fiber optic cables.

I'm of the position that a controlled demolition being prepared in a busy office building is something that cannot be completed in a building that is 99.7% occupied (Real Estate figures in 2001) around the clock.

det cord? lol Is this your debunking? Ok I'll pretend like that means something...

http://www.newsday.com/news/nationworld/nation/ny-nyaler122362178sep12,0,1255660.story

Heightened Security Alert Had Just Been Lifted
September 12, 2001
Daria Coard, 37, a guard at Tower One, said the security detail had been working 12-hour shifts for the past two weeks because of numerous phone threats. But on Thursday, bomb-sniffing dogs were abruptly removed.

Typical of a conspiracy theorist. Repeat an argument that has been debunked on several occasions in the past six years. Try reading some of the counter-points that you claim don't exist and you may learn something.

There were bomb sniffing dogs in the WTC up until, and during the events of 9/11. Of of them was named Sirius. Google him.

And this…

http://findarticles.com/p/articles/m...18/ai_75610255

NEW YORK--(BUSINESS WIRE)--June 18, 2001
"Once the cable installation is complete later this summer, we will be able to deliver network and communications services within days - an amazing capability through the use of this air-blown fiber process."


Wow you can’t even knock down a strawman. How pathetic.

Let me guess. Your vision of a controlled demolition involves a Navy SEAL team going into the building under darkness through air conditioning shafts and placing a few sticky-explosive packs on the walls and parachuting off the room to safety?

I fail to see why you have put that text in bold? What is significant about it? Are you trying to say that because communications can be delivered in days, a controlled demolition can be prepared in the same time frame? How about instead of random quotes, you explain their significance to your argument for once.

You really do have nothing. Why do you bother?

Ignore the whole post, extract one random comment, claim it as my argument. Nice method, although it won't hold up to third party scrutiny of this conversation.

If that’s even what they had to do they could have. This is not a debunking of anything.

"Nuh-uh!" has never been a valid counter argument, LastChild.

Try the post before the one you reported genius. You know who I am? OH NO! Are they coming to get me? Lol

At moderator request, I'm going to let this go. You should read the forum management forum if you wish to talk more about this.
 
It depends on what your claim is. If as debunker one wants to claim they needed years to set-up the building I proved years of access was available.

Ok, which years, between 1973 and 2001, were the offices of World Trade Center 1,2 and 7 free of occupants, bomb detection systems, security, police etc? Sure, you may be able to do them floor by floor, but at the end of the day the det cord is still going to be lying around and going from floor to floor until it's destroyed.

I'm tempted to say any time after 1993, seeing as that bomb blast presumably would have yielded a complete search of the buildings involving bomb sniffer dogs. Seeing as I have no proof of that though, you can find me a block of years before then.

Years of access to lay down fiber optic cables may have been there, but I suggest you read some literature on controlled demolition if you think the preparation is the same.

You're also making the assumption that cable workers aren't inspected along with their equipment by security before they start work. What happens when they go to use their new fiber optics system and discover that it doesn't work because all the tubing was replaced with detonation equipment?
 
Doc,

For Lost Child to be correct, about 30,000 people would have to have been "in" on this thing, including many who died that day.

I think we can see that this is something only a fool would consider for even a moment.

-Ben
 
Doc,

For Lost Child to be correct, about 30,000 people would have to have been "in" on this thing, including many who died that day.

I think we can see that this is something only a fool would consider for even a moment.

-Ben

I thought it was debunkers who claimed the towers fell from structural damage and building content fire to a few floors near the top.

Not that they couldn't if they wanted to I sourced how they could do it in a couple days or had years if needed, but why would they need to wire the whole entire building given your version of how the towers collapsed? Couldn't they have just done some floors near the top?
 
I thought it was debunkers who claimed the towers fell from structural damage and building content fire to a few floors near the top.

Not that they couldn't if they wanted to I sourced how they could do it in a couple days or had years if needed, but why would they need to wire the whole entire building given your version of how the towers collapsed? Couldn't they have just done some floors near the top?

Because the nonsense argument made by twoofers is that the speed of the collapse was too fast. This would mean that every other floor had to have explosives at least in order to move the building out of the way in time. According to CTer logic. Thus the entire building would indeed have to be wired up.

And are you telling me that your evidence is that half of an entire building was powered down and only 1 person noticed? Wow....
 
Because the nonsense argument made by twoofers is that the speed of the collapse was too fast. This would mean that every other floor had to have explosives at least in order to move the building out of the way in time. According to CTer logic. Thus the entire building would indeed have to be wired up.

I'm not asking you to answer someone else's question I'm asking you to answer mine. Can you? Could the towers have collapsed from explosives damaging the same amount of floors as the plane?

What about any amount of explosives at all in addition to the planes? Would that have helped the collapse or slowed it down?

And are you telling me that your evidence is that half of an entire building was powered down and only 1 person noticed? Wow....

Are you telling me you have proof he's lying? Well post it debunker. What's taking you so long?
 
Could the towers have collapsed from explosives damaging the same amount of floors as the plane?

Perhaps....if you can think of some explosive devices that can survive having a 757 slammed into them.

This suggestion of yours is pretty desperate, LC.

We know that a plane slammed into the WTC...we know that there was heavy damage and severe fires....we know that the collapse started on the exact floors where the plane impacted...

And you contend that this could mean that CD charges were planted on those same floors, that a plane slammed into them, triggering a massive inferno, all of which the charges withstood...and then the charges were set off after an hour to take the building down?
 
What's extraordinary to me is calling Forbes a liar based on absolutely nothing.


Well, if you believe that his story is so compelling and our responses have been so inadequate, then publicise both sides of the discussion and have your new investigation. I don’t think it’ll work, personally. I think that practically any rational person who you showed it to would agree with us. But you obviously think differently.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom