[Merged]Scott Forbes powerdown revisited

Does that mean I have detention? Dude?
<snip>
Try the post before the one you reported genius. You know who I am? OH NO! Are they coming to get me? Lol

I want this to be the end of this line of discussion.
Issues of moderation should be discussed in Forum Mgt, not in threads.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: chillzero
 
So none of you scary debunkers can think of any reasons they might need to turn off some power when installing fiber-optic cables?

I can't imagine where there would be any need in any building built to National Electric Code standards, which is EVERY building in the US.

A special case may be where the installers have to drill into a floor or wall known to have conduit where the blueprints are unavailable. In this case, a breaker would be turned off for one part of one floor for the few minutes. This is more likely for ad-hoc installations, not for major projects.

I don't think I've ever seen anything but very rare, momentary power downs for ANY data wiring, be it fibre (optical) or copper, and I've seen lots wiring installed in 17 years and several construction and renovation projects in two bank datacenter buildings in Manhattan. The data cable installation people work a normal day shift unless there is a crash deadline.

Fibre and low-voltage copper cable are all the same for safety issues around high voltage cable. If you are installing LV/Fibre and find yourself working near exposed HV (even if it is OFF), you are doing something very wrong.

In my experience of managing 24x7 computer facilities in three big Manhattan buildings, I say that the power-down claim is bullsh*t and I'd love to ask Forbes a few questions about his claims.
 
From another article on the same web site:


City in the Sky states that the upgrades were all completed before Silverstein leased the property (p. 232), and several PANYNJ press releases, including the following, suggest that this is the case.

February 11, 2000
:

February 4, 1999:


This is all beside the point, however, because I was specifically responding to your attempt to suggest via handwaving that installing fiber-optic cable outside the buildings would have carried a significant risk of electrocution.

From the same article you originally quoted:


So please explain, if you would, LastChild, how workers installing fiber-optic cable outside the buildings would have been at any risk of being electrocuted.

Yet again,


No you fail miserably and that's why you post pictures instead of facts. It is claimed by debunkers fiber-optics have nothing to do with power so there was no need for a power-down. This isn't even true never mind a debunking of anything. I sourced were fiber-optic workers have been electrocuted when they as professionals thought it was safe. This is all besides the point in the fact that they weren't just upgrading fiber optics but doing a complete upgrade to power as well. Did they never power-down anything when they did the power upgrade? All the same company who also BTW upgraded and maintained the security cameras that is supposedly the issue. And these people were still there on Sept 11th 2001 doing just that.

So if you want to claim no one had access or time to do whatever the hell they wanted to the towers that would be wrong debunker. YOU FAIL

If you want to claim on the other hand that it would take years to wire the building you would also be wrong. YOU FAIL AGAIN DEBUNKER

And if it’s an issue to you and you want to claim they have security footage of everything that went on before and during 9/11 at the WTC then produce some.

Scott Forbes claimed they were working in the towers the weekend before. I sourced where a project was slated to be going on around that very time to do exactly what he claimed they were doing. You want to focus on the power-down why? Because you think that if you can insinuate that there was no power-down it debunks something. It does not. But if you are going to setup this straw man at least have the metal muscle to knock it down.
 
Last edited:
BigAl,

Indeed, I have worked in wiring spaces at particle accelerators with just some massive live conductors right over my shoulder and I was in no danger whatsoever from them.

If I had an axe and wanted to get into those, it would have taken me several minutes to get through the armor. The only places where there was danger was in junction boxes, and if you were in those, you had to kill the circuit, and lock the breaker with a lock you had the key to so as to prevent it being re-energized. (I never did this but saw contractors do it.) But the guys who pulled detector wiring never worried about killing the circuit; it was safe.

-Ben
 
BigAl,

Indeed, I have worked in wiring spaces at particle accelerators with just some massive live conductors right over my shoulder and I was in no danger whatsoever from them.

If I had an axe and wanted to get into those, it would have taken me several minutes to get through the armor. The only places where there was danger was in junction boxes, and if you were in those, you had to kill the circuit, and lock the breaker with a lock you had the key to so as to prevent it being re-energized. (I never did this but saw contractors do it.) But the guys who pulled detector wiring never worried about killing the circuit; it was safe.

-Ben

This is the point that is completely lost on LC. He as asked repeatedly is there any danger of being electrocuted while installing fibre optic cables, the answer is yes of course there is, if the cables go anywhere near life high voltage. Any engineer would know exactly where these danger areas are and simply avoid them; hence the risk is completely gone. There is absolutely no risk of getting a belt from the FO cable itself.

I have worked on multicore cables which have fibres in them along with HV conductors but again the risk is simply eliminated by making sure everything is simply isolated. It’s a simple concept really. The way to avoid getting a belt when installing a new FO cable is to avoid or isolate any HV stuff that is close to your working area.If the FO cable as to go through junction boxes,then they are isolated.

I guess in troofy land the best way to install any cable in any part of a building is to simply throw the main breaker to the entire building and plunge it into total darkness.
 
Last edited:
This is the point that is completely lost on LC. He as asked repeatedly is there any danger of being electrocuted while installing fibre optic cables, the answer is yes of course there is, if the cables go anywhere near life high voltage. Any engineer would know exactly where these danger areas are and simply avoid them; hence the risk is completely gone. There is absolutely no risk of getting a belt from the FO cable itself.

I have worked on multicore cables which have fibres in them along with HV conductors but again the risk is simply eliminated by making sure everything is simply isolated. It’s a simple concept really. The way to avoid getting a belt when installing a new FO cable is to avoid or isolate any HV stuff that is close to your working area.If the FO cable as to go through junction boxes,then they are isolated.

I guess in troofy land the best way to install any cable in any part of a building is to simply throw the main breaker to the entire building and plunge it into total darkness.

And I guess in duh duh duh bunka land fiber-optic techs never get electrocuted. Even though I sourced and rubbed the pretend debunker nose in this very reality happening multiple times. Still they attempt in vain to try and wander away from the main issue that there was plenty of time and access to the building to do whatever certain people may have wanted to do. In other words the debunker lives in fantasy land with his official 9/11 version fantasy. It's the only place it will fly.

You debunk nothing. You pretend.
 
And I guess in duh duh duh bunka land fiber-optic techs never get electrocuted.
so if they power down the buildings before installing fiber how are they getting electrocuted?

unless of course they install the fiber WITHOUT powering down the building...
 
And I guess in duh duh duh bunka land fiber-optic techs never get electrocuted. Even though I sourced and rubbed the pretend debunker nose in this very reality happening multiple times.

You debunk nothing. You pretend.

Edit , nevermind, why bother.
 
Last edited:
And I guess in duh duh duh bunka land fiber-optic techs never get electrocuted. Even though I sourced and rubbed the pretend debunker nose in this very reality happening multiple times. Still they attempt in vain to try and wander away from the main issue that there was plenty of time and access to the building to do whatever certain people may have wanted to do. In other words the debunker lives in fantasy land with his official 9/11 version fantasy. It's the only place it will fly.

You debunk nothing. You pretend.

So, if "they" had years given to them to silently accomplish the wiring and set-up of explosives. Why then start a short cut the week before one of historys more noticable events? Did "they" suddenly ran out of time?
 
Last edited:
No you fail miserably and that's why you post pictures instead of facts. It is claimed by debunkers fiber-optics have nothing to do with power so there was no need for a power-down. This isn't even true never mind a debunking of anything. I sourced were fiber-optic workers have been electrocuted when they as professionals thought it was safe.


Frankly, you appear to be acting deliberately obtuse. Please answer the following four questions:

1. Were all three of the electrocutions you cited as examples due to contact with overhead power lines?

2. Do you understand that overhead power lines are generally insulated only where they are connected to utility poles, and that other sorts of power lines must be insulated all along their entire lengths?

3. Were there any overhead power lines at the World Trade Center?

4. If there were no overhead power lines at the World Trade Center, then how are your examples applicable?

This is all besides the point in the fact that they weren't just upgrading fiber optics but doing a complete upgrade to power as well. Did they never power-down anything when they did the power upgrade? All the same company who also BTW upgraded and maintained the security cameras that is supposedly the issue. And these people were still there on Sept 11th 2001 doing just that.


Again, quite frankly, you seem to be acting deliberately obtuse. The power upgrade was finished 2 1/2 years before the attacks. Are you seriously suggesting that the towers were rigged with explosives 2 1/2 years ahead of time??

<snip of various straw-man arguments>

Scott Forbes claimed they were working in the towers the weekend before. I sourced where a project was slated to be going on around that very time to do exactly what he claimed they were doing.


Your source, an article written before the upgrade received final approval, gave a vague estimate of 10 years from 1993 for completion. I cited a source that gave details of the final approval by the PANYNJ, including a planned completion date of March 1999. I cited two primary sources that indicate the project was completed by, or even slightly before, then. So why do you continue to parrot the 10-year figure, which was clearly just a preliminary estimate (or perhaps even a misunderstanding by the writer)?

You want to focus on the power-down why? Because you think that if you can insinuate that there was no power-down it debunks something. It does not. But if you are going to setup this straw man at least have the metal muscle to knock it down.


In other words, you're saying that no matter what, we can't prove that there wasn't a US government conspiracy. This is true, but it's also irrelevant, because proving such is impossible. Therefore, we must assume that there is no US government conspiracy, and require proof that one exists. Being in support of a clearly extraordinary claim, such proof must itself be extraordinary. Vague suspicions, unsubstantiated rumors, and innuendo do not come anywhere close to meeting that standard.
 
Last edited:
Frankly, you appear to be acting deliberately obtuse. Please answer the following four questions:

1. Were all three of the electrocutions you cited as examples due to contact with overhead power lines?

2. Do you understand that overhead power lines are generally insulated only where they are connected to utility poles, and that other sorts of power lines must be insulated all along their entire lengths?

3. Were there any overhead power lines at the World Trade Center?

4. If there were no overhead power lines at the World Trade Center, then how are your examples applicable?

Oh brother this is a debunking or a JAQing off? Were they laying fiber-optics near power sources when they got electrocuted? Yes or no? Like you obviously assume things did they also assume things right before they were zapped dead?
Edited by Lisa Simpson: 
Edited to remove inappropriate remark.
And when you source how power was core in-cased or underground source the power upgrade not the system that they upgraded from that you claim was in place when they did the fiber-optic upgrade genius.

Do not threaten or imply in any way violence upon another forum member.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson


Again, quite frankly, you seem to be acting deliberately obtuse. The power upgrade was finished 2 1/2 years before the attacks. Are you seriously suggesting that the towers were rigged with explosives 2 1/2 years ahead of time??
Your source, an article written before the upgrade received final approval, gave a vague estimate of 10 years from 1993 for completion. I cited a source that gave details of the final approval by the PANYNJ, including a planned completion date of March 1999. I cited two primary sources that indicate the project was completed by, or even slightly before, then. So why do you continue to parrot the 10-year figure, which was clearly just a preliminary estimate (or perhaps even a misunderstanding by the writer)?

One more time.

LEARN TO READ DEBUNKER AND READ EVERYTHING BEFORE YOU OPEN YOUR MOUTH

http://findarticles.com/p/articles/m...18/ai_75610255

NEW YORK--(BUSINESS WIRE)—June 18, 2001

"Once the cable installation is complete later this summer, we will be able to deliver network and communications services within days - an amazing capability through the use of this air-blown fiber process."

In other words, you're saying that no matter what, we can't prove that there wasn't a US government conspiracy.

Don’t use other words use my words or use nothing.

This is true, but it's also irrelevant, because proving such is impossible.

We are talking about you and the other duh duh duh bunkas not being able to debunk Scott Forbes. Not some imaginary thing you claim I said in your attempt to move the goal posts.

Therefore, we must assume that there is no US government conspiracy, and require proof that one exists. Being in support of a clearly extraordinary claim, such proof must itself be extraordinary. Vague suspicions, unsubstantiated rumors, and innuendo do not come anywhere close to meeting that standard.

You do all the assuming you like to support your fantasy of a complete and adequate version of events regarding 9/11. After all what else do you have? Picking on Scott Forbes and one thing he claimed out of all the unanswered questions and convenient coincidences needed to hold together this lame official version of 9/11 is debunking nothing. You keep trying to micromanage all of these inconsistencies surrounding 9/11 and separate them from making a whole but still that doesn’t even work for you anymore.

You continue to fail.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So, if "they" had years given to them to silently accomplish the wiring and set-up of explosives. Why then start a short cut the week before one of historys more noticable events? Did "they" suddenly ran out of time?

It depends on what your claim is. If as debunker one wants to claim they needed years to set-up the building I proved years of access was available. If you claimed they couldn't have done it in a few days I also proved that wrong and sourced it.

Go back and read. I got you covered.
 
Correct me if I'm wrong.

You are claiming the perps had access to critical areas to plant explosives? Det chord? Thermite?

So, am I to understand that while the electricians are upgrading the electrical systems at the WTC, they are acting as CD experts? Please help me understand.
I am a licensed electrician in the state of Massachusetts and heck, I would know if someone planted come TNT on my raceway's. I would think that the electrical inspectors may notice it a bit odd.

Explain how this is done without anyone noticing.
 
Lost Childs Strawman debunked!!

And I guess in duh duh duh bunka land fiber-optic techs never get electrocuted. Even though I sourced and rubbed the pretend debunker nose in this very reality happening multiple times. Still they attempt in vain to try and wander away from the main issue that there was plenty of time and access to the building to do whatever certain people may have wanted to do. In other words the debunker lives in fantasy land with his official 9/11 version fantasy. It's the only place it will fly.

You debunk nothing. You pretend.
All your examples of electrocution were outdoors on uninsulated power lines. NONE were indoors where power transmission lines are insulated and isolated from contact within conduit.
 
So none of you scary debunkers can think of any reasons they might need to turn off some power when installing fiber-optic cables?

http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/localnews/2003717300_webwaterparkdeath22m.html
Worker killed by high-voltage line at Wild Waves
By Jennifer Sullivan
Seattle Times staff reporter
On Monday, Kessler, 28, of Marysville, was killed at Wild Waves water park in Federal Way. And Kessler's co-worker, Steve Uplinger, 19, of Snohomish, was seriously burned after they struck a 7,200-volt power line.
Kessler and Uplinger had been working at the water park the past three weeks, retrofitting fiber-optic lines before the park's June 9 opening. They were in a cherry-picker-type lift when it struck a live Puget Sound Energy line. Kessler died almost immediately.


http://www.cdc.gov/NIOSH/face/stateface/ne/98ne025.html
Three Fiber Optic Cable Installers Killed by Contact with Power Line
A 41-year-old journeyman lineman, a 38-year-old journeyman lineman and a 24-year-old, all working as cable installers in aerial line construction, were killed when a guy wire contacted an 8,000 volt above ground power line. The 41-year-old and the 38-year-old were electrocuted and the 24-year-old died the following day as a result of electrical burns. There were no witnesses to the incident, but it appears a guy wire was disconnected by the victims and it contacted an 8,000 volt overhead power line that grounded to earth.


http://www.herzogcrebs.com/CM/Articles/Articles7.asp
John Logan, an apprentice lineman, was fatally electrocuted while working for Irby Construction Company. Irby was under contract with Sho-Me Power Electric Cooperative to install 63 miles of fiber-optic cable near existing power lines and to perform structure reinforcement on existing energized lines owned by Sho-Me Power. At the time of his death, Logan was working near one of the energized lines.
[/I]


So, your evidence of a power-down to install fiber optics is three instances where there wasn't a power-down to install fiber optics?

The Child is self-debunking.
 
Correct me if I'm wrong.

You are claiming the perps had access to critical areas to plant explosives? Det chord? Thermite?

So, am I to understand that while the electricians are upgrading the electrical systems at the WTC, they are acting as CD experts? Please help me understand.
I am a licensed electrician in the state of Massachusetts and heck, I would know if someone planted come TNT on my raceway's. I would think that the electrical inspectors may notice it a bit odd.

Explain how this is done without anyone noticing.

There it is LC, the elephant in your basement that we have been trying to point out to you.

See it yet?
 
I am a licensed electrician in the state of Massachusetts and heck, I would know if someone planted come TNT on my raceway's. I would think that the electrical inspectors may notice it a bit odd.

Explain how this is done without anyone noticing.

Because they didn't plant the explosives on the raceways, they ripped open the column enclosures to plant the explosives directly on the columns.

Then of course the patched it all back up, repainted, and replaced the walpaper, ceiling tiles, etc. without anyone noticing. You didn't notice when the NWO wired the pru building in Boston, did you? ah, oops, Ah, just forget I said that. . . ;)
 
Last edited:
All your examples of electrocution were outdoors on uninsulated power lines. NONE were indoors where power transmission lines are insulated and isolated from contact within conduit.


Ha, and next I suppose you are going to claim that the NWO was not flying kites in the towers the week before as well!!!

How could they fly the kites near the WTC power chases without getting electrocuted?

Silly debunker

;)
 
It depends on what your claim is. If as debunker one wants to claim they needed years to set-up the building I proved years of access was available. If you claimed they couldn't have done it in a few days I also proved that wrong and sourced it.

Go back and read. I got you covered.

That must've been an answer to another question.
If " they" had several years of access to the towers to plant the explosives. Why a power down the weekend before 9/11? What took "them" several years to accomplish if they had to turn of the power just ahead of 9/11? Bad logistics?
There you go.
 
And I guess in duh duh duh bunka land fiber-optic techs never get electrocuted. Even though I sourced and rubbed the pretend debunker nose in this very reality happening multiple times.


You haven't rubbed anyone's nose in anything, except in your imagination. Just to reiterate, all three of those men were electrocuted due to contact with overhead power lines, of which there were none at the World Trade Center.

Still they attempt in vain to try and wander away from the main issue that there was plenty of time and access to the building to do whatever certain people may have wanted to do. In other words the debunker lives in fantasy land with his official 9/11 version fantasy. It's the only place it will fly.

You debunk nothing. You pretend.


Yet again, you're trying to shift the burden of proof. Further, you simply handwave away the issue of how the people planting explosives could have been certain that they and their work would have gone unnoticed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom