[Merged]Scott Forbes powerdown revisited

Hi!

A couple of years ago, I stumbled upon a page on Killtowns blog with an interview with Scott Forbes:

http://killtown.blogspot.com/2005/12/scott-forbes-interview.html

In short, Forbes worked in the South Tower and speaks of a powerdown on the top part of the building prior to 911.

At that time I emailed Forbes, just to make sure Killtown hadn't quotemined or taken Forbes out of context. In the reply Forbes made clear that he stood by what he had expressed in that interview, but he refrained from drawing any conlusions based on the background of this powerdown.

Forbes wrote in his reply:

Scott Forbes said:
We were told by the PANYNJ that the power down was necessary for recabling. I have no more information other than that.

At the time I sent an email to the PANYNJ, but I never got a reply (which isn't surprising, I couldn't find any obvious email-address so I basically mailed those on top of the list on the homepage).

So my question is, has anyone heard anything more about this event? Im thinking like we did with the airphones-issue...

And to be perfectly clear, no I don't think the powerdown was made as a part of a conspiracy to plant bombs all over the WTC1, 2 and 7.
(And please, don't derail the thread with random comments on Killtown)
 
Oh, I got merged!

Anywhoo - since the last post of that thread in -06 - has anything new surfaced? If I knew what address to send it I might file a FOIA for the information regarding this particular power-down, if only to lay this fork of the conspiracy-tree to rest.
 
Last edited:
Oh, I got merged!

Anywhoo - since the last post of that thread in -06 - has anything new surfaced? If I knew what address to send it I might file a FOIA for the information regarding this particular power-down, if only to lay this fork of the conspiracy-tree to rest.

There was a poster here a few months ago who said he saw Scott Forbes at a Truther meeting in London. I don't know if it was true, but the poster (mjd1982 ?) said Forbes didn't want to talk about the power down any more because he was worried about loosing his job.

It was in a thread which had way too many occurrences of the word "propitious". Something to do with PNAC as well.


ETA Found it! "The 9/11 Conspiracy Facts" was the name of the thread from nearly a year ago. Scott Forbes shows up in London somewhere around page 50: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2763121#post2763121
 
Last edited:
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0EIN/is_2001_June_18/ai_75610255

NEW YORK--(BUSINESS WIRE)--June 18, 2001

"Once the cable installation is complete later this summer, we will be able to deliver network and communications services within days - an amazing capability through the use of this air-blown fiber process."

And look they claim it would only take days to wire the building...

- "They can get connected in days. With traditional copper cable, it can take
weeks for vendors to install a new connection."
 
Last Child, the cable installation they are speaking of is network and communication cables. You do not need to shut down electricity for this type of an upgrade.
 
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0EIN/is_2001_June_18/ai_75610255

NEW YORK--(BUSINESS WIRE)--June 18, 2001

"Once the cable installation is complete later this summer, we will be able to deliver network and communications services within days - an amazing capability through the use of this air-blown fiber process."

And look they claim it would only take days to wire the building...

- "They can get connected in days. With traditional copper cable, it can take
weeks for vendors to install a new connection."

Umm... but weren't Forbes talking about power cables?
 
Oh, I got merged!

Anywhoo - since the last post of that thread in -06 - has anything new surfaced? If I knew what address to send it I might file a FOIA for the information regarding this particular power-down, if only to lay this fork of the conspiracy-tree to rest.

Many people work weekends in the city. A power-down of the sort (initially) described by Forbes would have impacted thousands of tenant employees. You'd think that he'd provide, oh, maybe ONE other person to corroborate his story.

Which is but one of the many, many reasons his story is clearly fiction. See this thread, for starters.

Towards the end, someone actually reaches Forbes, who in turn provides the email address of an individual he says will corroborate his tale. Oops. The person never responded to an inquiry and Forbes wasn't heard from again.

Just compare what Forbes said in his Killtown interview with his intial claims on the matter. Not so consistent.

His early statement that "watching (9/11) events unfold
I was convinced immediately that something was happening related to the
weekend work" makes his agenda pretty clear. And yet he still looks foir cover under the familiar "just asking questions" umbrella.

This loser has zero credibility
 
Does anyone know how and where to file for a FOIA with the PA? NIST and NTSB have a dedicated FOIA-page, but so far I haven't found any similary on the PA site.
 
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0EIN/is_2001_June_18/ai_75610255

NEW YORK--(BUSINESS WIRE)--June 18, 2001

"Once the cable installation is complete later this summer, we will be able to deliver network and communications services within days - an amazing capability through the use of this air-blown fiber process."

And look they claim it would only take days to wire the building...

- "They can get connected in days. With traditional copper cable, it can take
weeks for vendors to install a new connection."

Are you just posting random news articles, or did you somehow think that this was related to the subject being discussed?
 
http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-14436351.html

September, 1993

The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, the World Trade Center's (WTC) owner, is expected to spend $81 million in improving the center's electrical system over a period of 10 years. The project will require extensive use of copper cabling. Copper cables can handle the higher capacity required by the highly-sophisticated electronic equipment of WTC's tenants. Moreover, such type of cables can deliver much more power reliably.


2001 wouldn’t have been ten years yet would it?
 
Last edited:
So now the new theory is that the evil NWOers used fibreoptic cable instead of traditional copper cable to rig the building, because according to the article it would take WEEKS to wire the towers with TRADITIONAL COPPER CABLE....

Am I missing something, or is this simply retarded?

Where have all the laughing dogs gone....

TAM:)
 
So now the new theory is that the evil NWOers used fibreoptic cable instead of traditional copper cable to rig the building, because according to the article it would take WEEKS to wire the towers with TRADITIONAL COPPER CABLE....

Am I missing something, or is this simply retarded?

Where have all the laughing dogs gone....

TAM:)

Well yeah you would have to be retarded not to get it. You know what else is retarded? Claiming no power-down debunks something.

Explain the retarded logic in that. Because I always thought it was the retarded debunkers who claimed no one would have the time or access to the building to wire it when they were wiring it for years.

But you should just never mind unless you can find someone to try and explain it to you. Don't hurt yourself.

Please keep in mind the Membership Agreement and do not use personal attacks to argue your point.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
Last edited by a moderator:
meh- why bother


More and more often lately I have begun writing responses to CTers only to pause before posting it, ask myself "What is the point" and simply close the window.

I'm inclined to believe (I think) MarkyX - there is simply no excuse for anyone being so utterly ignorant of 9/11 who professes interest in it. Those that continue to argue the alternative theories do so from a position of blatant dishonesty. There is nothing, at all, to be gained from trying to establish a dialogue with them (Which is not going to happen any way since they're apparently incapable of actually partaking in reason debate).
 
Well yeah you would have to be retarded not to get it. You know what else is retarded? Claiming no power-down debunks something.

It debunks the claim truthers make about "mysterious power downs".

Explain the retarded logic in that. Because I always thought it was the retarded debunkers who claimed no one would have the time or access to the building to wire it when they were wiring it for years.

Don't confuse the running of electrical wiring with the placement of shaped charges and the running of det cord. Two COMPLETELY different things.

Also, you should really try using a thesaurus if your vocabulary is that limited.
 
Well yeah you would have to be retarded not to get it. You know what else is retarded? Claiming no power-down debunks something.

Explain the retarded logic in that. Because I always thought it was the retarded debunkers who claimed no one would have the time or access to the building to wire it when they were wiring it for years.

But you should just never mind unless you can find someone to try and explain it to you. Don't hurt yourself.

Before I address your points, you should know that your post has been reported. You can be argumentative and stand by a position without being immature.

First of all, pointing out that there was no power-down debunks the claim that there was a power-down. Even you should be able to process that simple equation.

Conspiracists use the power-down claim in an attempt to counter the logical point that no one could have placed explosives in the tower while it was occupied and security cameras were on.

No one is claiming that the time wasn't there to install wires in a building. What we're saying is that no one could have placed explosives or det cord in the tower. That would involve getting the ordinance past bomb sniffing dogs, removing large wall sections off offices, placing HUGE shaped charges on columns (demolition experts have stated these charges that big would need to be carried in by fork lift), pre-weakening, replacing walls, leaving det cord running over the floors of the office... you get the picture.

Please keep it civil. Your post was offensive to a lot of people here.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom