[Merged]Peer-reviewed technical paper to appear in mainstream journal

CHF and Dave Rogers:

I think we all know what NIST intended with its FAQ on the collapse time, but I believe the way it was worded only confuses people and opens the door for quote-miners like Jones.

I suspect that NIST scientists weren't savvy enough to realize that any collapse time they quoted would be taken as gospel, and, if not clearly stated, used as grist for the truther's mill.

I believe the 9/11 Commission Report has the same problem with its throw-away statement on collapse times, but at least that Report was not written by technical specialists, so perhaps they have an excuse for being sloppy on that one.
 
Last edited:
Nor was the collapse times important to what the Commission was trying to accomplish, just like WTC 7. It's the TM that requires them to be 100% correct on every single letter they put on paper, while the TM can say whatever they want, correct or not.
 
I think we all know what NIST intended with its FAQ on the collapse time, but I believe the way it was worded only confuses peoeple and opens the door for quote-miners like Jones.

I suspect that NIST scientists weren't savvy enough to realize that any collapse time they quoted would be taken as gospel, and, if not clearly stated, used as grist for the truther's mill.

I believe the 9/11 Commission Report has the same problem with its throw-away statement on collapse times, but at least that Report was not written by technical specialists, so perhaps they have an excuse for being sloppy on that one.

$129.57

Dave
 
I think we all know what NIST intended with its FAQ on the collapse time, but I believe the way it was worded only confuses peoeple and opens the door for quote-miners like Jones.

I wonder why Jones' peer-reviewers didn't catch that....:rolleyes:
 
There's no such thing as the "Pile-Driver Theory". When global collapse began the entire upper block (the floors above the impact region where the columns failed) was no longer supported, so it fell as a single mass, sequentially crushing each of the intact floors below it and adding the mass of each crushed floor to itself as it progressed downwards. This is often described as "pancaking", and is how tall buildings collapse. It is not a "theory", and it is exactly what PM described above.

NIST also describes this as "pancaking":

NCSTAR 1-3C

No it isn't. Read it again.

FEMA's "pancake collapse theory" is this: truss connection failures from thermal deformation of floors in the impact region, where the fire was, caused individual floors to detach from the columns and collapse on the floors below, at some point overloading one of them to the point where global collapse was initiated with a "pancake" phenomenon. The theory was never given any sort of official name, but the vague term "pancake collapse theory" has stuck.

NIST showed that this theory was incorrect, because the weight of only a few floors detaching and collapsing in the impact region was determined to not be enough to initiate a "pancake collapse", and because the truss connections were actually observed not to fail but rather to stay connected to the perimeter columns, so that when thermal deformation of the floor trusses made entire floors sag, it actually pulled the perimeter columns inwards to the point where they could no longer support the mass of the floors above (the upper block).

They know how the building collapsed. They were not tasked with modeling the entire collapse, and so they didn't. WTC7 has nothing to do with this thread.

NIST wrote in their FAQ, "NIST’s findings do not support the “pancake theory” of collapse, which is premised on a progressive failure of the floor systems in the WTC towers (the composite floor system—that connected the core columns and the perimeter columns—consisted of a grid of steel “trusses” integrated with a concrete slab; see diagram below). Instead, the NIST investigation showed conclusively that the failure of the inwardly bowed perimeter columns initiated collapse and that the occurrence of this inward bowing required the sagging floors to remain connected to the columns and pull the columns inwards. Thus, the floors did not fail progressively to cause a pancaking phenomenon."

Ronald Hamburger used the term pile driver,

"Think of the impact of dropping a 25-story building straight down ... It was like a pile driver, which is why it collapsed as it did."

If NIST knows how the buildings collapsed, then why can't they model it? If NIST science is real science then it should be applicable to the real world. So give me your technique for demolishing a steel-frame high-rise with impact damage and fire. If you can't do this then NIST science is pseudoscience.
 
Tanabear you aren't fooling anybody. You know that we are talking about collapse initiation here. You want to set up a 50 ft tall house of cards, remove the support from the middle, then complain that we don't know why it collapsed because we can't model exactly what every single card did.

What you should be doing, instead of trying to instill uncertainty and doubt, is come up with YOUR technique for demolishing buildings the size of the WTC WITHOUT using impact damage and fire that fits ALL the available evidence better than the investigations already done.

Perhaps you should go to some other boards where they aren't familiar with your movement's tactics--you may have better luck.
 
there are 7 Pillars of Wisdom; 7 Wonders of the World...7 Planets



Did another planet in addition to Pluto lose its planetary status recently or is there is (dare I say it?) a new conspiracy afoot?!?
 
Last edited:
Did another planet in addition to Pluto lose its planetary status recently or is there is (dare I say it?) a new conspiracy afoot?!?

No conspiracy. Apollo is speaking of the seven classical planets - Mercury, Venus, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, the Moon, and the Sun.
 
No conspiracy. Apollo is speaking of the seven classical planets - Mercury, Venus, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, the Moon, and the Sun.


I know of the historical "7 planets" belief, of course, but I couldn't resist. ;)
 
Last edited:
Tanabear you aren't fooling anybody. You know that we are talking about collapse initiation here. You want to set up a 50 ft tall house of cards, remove the support from the middle, then complain that we don't know why it collapsed because we can't model exactly what every single card did.

What you should be doing, instead of trying to instill uncertainty and doubt, is come up with YOUR technique for demolishing buildings the size of the WTC WITHOUT using impact damage and fire that fits ALL the available evidence better than the investigations already done.

Perhaps you should go to some other boards where they aren't familiar with your movement's tactics--you may have better luck.

What does it mean when you say, "we are talking about collapse initiation?" Why can't anyone here discuss what happened after the initiation? Is it because your "sacred texts"(i.e. The NIST Report), don't allow it?

What are my movement's tactics? I seek to subject the NIST hypothesis to the experimental method. This method has been a mainstay of science since Francis Bacon and Robert Boyle. Are Randians here still stuck in the Dark Ages?

Ah, I see. You're merely nitpicking that your previous post didn't actually specify an aircraft collision, even though it did specify a skyscraper. Nonetheless, you said you demanded to see it in full-scale. That's the whole point. You require someone to destroy a skyscraper for you.

If you understood the physics, you'd accept that this is unnecessary.

Mathematics is a way of experimentation.

The mathematics happens to match observed phenomena in both WTC 1 and WTC 2. This is not, therefore, prediction of a previously unobserved natural behavior. For that reason, the actual collapses are sufficient. There is no parallel between this result and the predictions of general relativity.

If we wished to increase fidelity of the experiment it would be best to use airplanes and have buildings similar to WTC 1,2 and 7. I didn't say that I would require that right off the bat though.

Mathematics is not a way of experimentation. Did we come of age during the time of Pythagoras or Plato? If the world of reality does not conform to the world of mathematics, so much the worse for reality.

If the mathematics matches the observed phenomena of WTC 1 and 2 then why can't computers model the collapse? Why doesn't NIST show the visualizations?

The parallel I was attempting to show was that even an eminent scientist like Einstein still needs to have his theories subjected to the experimental method. If Einstein doesn't get a pass, neither does NIST.
 
If the mathematics matches the observed phenomena of WTC 1 and 2 then why can't computers model the collapse?
Because mathmatics says there's about a billion ways for the collapse to progress all the way to the ground. It is impossible to determine which one of those billion ways actually ocurred.

And as it happens, the math finds zero ways for the collapse to arrest itself.

Problem is, truthers are too stupid to understand this. Might as well try to teach a lizard to recite the Gettysburg Address.
 
...
And as it happens, the math finds zero ways for the collapse to arrest itself.
...

I can think of ONLY one.

superman.jpg
 
Because mathmatics says there's about a billion ways for the collapse to progress all the way to the ground. It is impossible to determine which one of those billion ways actually ocurred.

And as it happens, the math finds zero ways for the collapse to arrest itself.

Problem is, truthers are too stupid to understand this. Might as well try to teach a lizard to recite the Gettysburg Address.

How do you know that the math finds billions of ways for the collapse to progress to the ground? What is this math based on? If this is the case, then you should be able to show this experimentally? Or are the "debunkers" to dumb to prove what they say?
 
How do you know that the math finds billions of ways for the collapse to progress to the ground? What is this math based on? If this is the case, then you should be able to show this experimentally? Or are the "debunkers" to dumb to prove what they say?
Take 100 numbered balls and throw them into the air and note the position of ball number 73. Now repeat. Did ball number 73 end up in the same place? Why not? If you can answer this you should be able to figure out why you can't model the collapse.
 
Last edited:
Take 100 numbered balls and throw them into the air and note the position of ball number 73. Now repeat. Did ball number 73 end up in the same place? Why not? If you can answer this you should be able to figure out why you can't model the collapse.
Hell take 100 dice and throw them up in the air and record the individual numbers as they land. Now record the positions. I don't think he realizes that I can't mathematically predict which way every drop of milk will splash as I pour it in my raisin brand in the morning.
 
Nonsense. Thor or The Hulk could do it just as good as Supes, you dirty DC fan:D
Derail.

(In Simpson's Comicbook guy voice)

Yes, but the Hulk would be more likely to smash the building unless it was Maestro, the dystopian ruler of the future, who would likely enslave humanity.
 
How do you know that the math finds billions of ways for the collapse to progress to the ground? What is this math based on? If this is the case, then you should be able to show this experimentally? Or are the "debunkers" to dumb to prove what they say?

you mean dumb like someone who suggests that we are claiming that "explosives destroy steel frame buildings" is a fairy tale? You mean that kind of dumb.

No, debunkers are not dumb like that, we reserve that kind of unique stupidity for idiot truthers.

TAM:)
 
Take 100 numbered balls and throw them into the air and note the position of ball number 73. Now repeat. Did ball number 73 end up in the same place? Why not? If you can answer this you should be able to figure out why you can't model the collapse.

Hell take 100 dice and throw them up in the air and record the individual numbers as they land. Now record the positions. I don't think he realizes that I can't mathematically predict which way every drop of milk will splash as I pour it in my raisin brand in the morning.

Or for the two word version:

Chaos Theory.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom