[Merged]Peer-reviewed technical paper to appear in mainstream journal

It would be unfortunate because Alam isn't listed as an editor, and if he really isn't involved in editorial decisions and/or lacks expertise in civil engineering, he shouldn't be the one responding.

Isn't that like saying that the judge's secretary shouldn't answer the phone because she doesn't have a legal degree? Most of the questions that a journal gets do not require editorial expertise (I bet the biggest one is "why won't the page download?"). Most of the questions that a journal PUBLISHER get probably don't even apply to a specific journal, let alone a specific editor.
 
So why did you think that the info your provided was relevant, then? All it said was that some people in Pakistan think 9/11 was an inside job. So what? Some people in America think that 9/11 was an inside job.

Not to the same degree, I assure you.

Twoofism runs deep in much of Muslim world - not among everyone, of course, but by a far higher percentage of the population than in the West.

Frankly, I'm amazed that the TM doesn't translate their crap into Arabic or Urdu and market it to the Middle East and Pakistan.

In fact, they probably wouldn't have a hard time getting it taught in schools. I'm serious.
 
Perhaps I should have made myself clearer in my first post; I didn't mean to imply that I'm sure that this is the case. I just feel that the matter warrants further investigation.

Questioning this guy's motivations before even knowing what his position in the journal's staff is, especially with nothing but pure speculation, strikes me as very premature and makes you look desperate. Let's not go this route, okay?
 
Some thoughts about SJ et al's. new paper:

No one has commented, as far as I know, on the fact that Jones' paper has "Fourteen Points"

Why 14?

I suspect this is Jones' little inside joke because of the other famous "14 Points"; namely those of Woodrow Wilson first pronounced I believe in Jan 1918.

WW's 14 points were both a statement of war aims and also terms for the surrender of the enemy - Germany.

Could Jones, with his very own 14 points, be alluding to WW's original 14 points and the fact that he (Jones) is stating his personal "war" aims and his requirements for the "surrender" of his enemies: FEMA, NIST, the US Government....

I think so, because the fact that Jones has 14 points is obviously quite contrived. Some of the points are in fact very silly: Consider these three:

No. 2: The Towers survived the jet impacts... we know that!

No. 4: The Towers had massive columns... we know that!

No. 8: The fires did not melt steel.... we know that!

Yet Jones put these points in to get to his target of 14 points, just like Woody!

But what is MOST interesting is that Jones totally AVOIDS many other points about the destruction of the Twin Towers that would have been much more worthy of debate:

* The loss of thermal insulation was/was not a factor in the collapse mechanism

* Creep buckling of the columns was/was not a factor in the collapse mechanism

* Collapse initiation did/did not involve inward bowing of perimeter columns

* The elastic strain absorbing capacity of the buildings was/was not exceeded

On these important points Jones et al. remain strangely silent ......
 
See, I was going to say that I can understand why Dr. Jones would want to publish in a paper that would be accessible by the majority of folks in the "Truth Movement", but I was wondering why legitimate open journals, as opposed to vanity publications, would charge the author instead of simply having some advertising to cover their expenses.

I thought it might be some sort of academic faux-pas to have advertisers, and that might explain it. But apparently that isn't the case here. So what is the deal?

It's not actually unusual for respectable journals to incur page charges, even open access ones. Atmospheric Chemistry & Physics, which is my main stomping ground, is a good example. The reason they get to charge a lot (and they do) is because they have the prestige that comes with high editorial standards and the resulting high impact rating (average number of cites per article). All of these mean that scientists are very keen to get themselves published there and are more than willing to pay for the pleasure. Even so, despite being produced by the European Geosciences Union and a number of influential scientists, it was free to publish there initially for a couple of years while it was getting established.

On the other hand, its Bentham counterpart, The Open Atmospheric Science Journal, is a bit poor on all of these fronts. The fact that it has so far attracted 9 papers since it began last year says it all. Given that there are infinitely more prestigious journals in the field that will publish work for free (they make their money on subscriptions), this is hardly surprising. I can only assume that it's the same story for the structural engineers.
 
Some thoughts about SJ et al's. new paper:

No one has commented, as far as I know, on the fact that Jones' paper has "Fourteen Points"

Why 14?

I suspect this is Jones' little inside joke because of the other famous "14 Points"; namely those of Woodrow Wilson first pronounced I believe in Jan 1918.

WW's 14 points were both a statement of war aims and also terms for the surrender of the enemy - Germany.

Could Jones, with his very own 14 points, be alluding to WW's original 14 points and the fact that he (Jones) is stating his personal "war" aims and his requirements for the "surrender" of his enemies: FEMA, NIST, the US Government....

I think so, because the fact that Jones has 14 points is obviously quite contrived. Some of the points are in fact very silly: Consider these three:

No. 2: The Towers survived the jet impacts... we know that!

No. 4: The Towers had massive columns... we know that!

No. 8: The fires did not melt steel.... we know that!

Yet Jones put these points in to get to his target of 14 points, just like Woody!

But what is MOST interesting is that Jones totally AVOIDS many other points about the destruction of the Twin Towers that would have been much more worthy of debate:

* The loss of thermal insulation was/was not a factor in the collapse mechanism

* Creep buckling of the columns was/was not a factor in the collapse mechanism

* Collapse initiation did/did not involve inward bowing of perimeter columns

* The elastic strain absorbing capacity of the buildings was/was not exceeded

On these important points Jones et al. remain strangely silent ......


Good catch, A20; I'm a bit embarrassed that I didn't notice that.:o
 
I suspect this is Jones' little inside joke because of the other famous "14 Points"; namely those of Woodrow Wilson first pronounced I believe in Jan 1918.

Well spotted.

But what is MOST interesting is that Jones totally AVOIDS many other points about the destruction of the Twin Towers that would have been much more worthy of debate:

* The loss of thermal insulation was/was not a factor in the collapse mechanism

* Creep buckling of the columns was/was not a factor in the collapse mechanism

* Collapse initiation did/did not involve inward bowing of perimeter columns

* The elastic strain absorbing capacity of the buildings was/was not exceeded

On these important points Jones et al. remain strangely silent ......
But those are all legitimate engineering issues that one might look at in order to explain how/why the WTC collapsed.

Jones, meanwhile, is hoping to one day prove that the WTC collapsed because of something he found in a dust sample.
 
Last edited:
Jones is a Mormon and there are either 13 or 14 articles of faith in the Mormon church. (depending on who you ask. There seems to be a scism regarding the acual number).
 
"Fourteen Points"

Why 14?

I suspect this is Jones' little inside joke because of the other famous "14 Points"; namely those of Woodrow Wilson first pronounced I believe in Jan 1918.

WW's 14 points were both a statement of war aims and also terms for the surrender of the enemy - Germany.

Could Jones, with his very own 14 points, be alluding to WW's original 14 points and the fact that he (Jones) is stating his personal "war" aims and his requirements for the "surrender" of his enemies: FEMA, NIST, the US Government....


If this is indeed the case, then either Jones is using an extraordinarily subtle and complex metaphor, or he's confused about 20th century history.

Wilson's Fourteen Points were not surrender terms being demanded of the enemy; they were surrender terms being offered. These terms were fair and generous to the Central Powers, so much so that copies of the Fourteen Points were dropped behind enemy lines as propaganda. ("Look how fair a deal you'll get, if you surrender.") The main goal, however, appeared to be a genuine desire on Wilson's part to untangle and defuse Europe, resolving several longstanding disputes over territory and sovereignity, and establishing various economic freedoms whose infringement by one power or another had been root causes of conflict.

The contempt of the European leaders for this plan set the stage, instead, for many more decades of chaos and blood in Europe. Clemenceu's adept comment, "God Himself had only ten...," is arguably the most destructive witticism in human history.

So, how does any of that relate to 9/11 conspiracy? Jones's 14 points are presented as points of fact, not of principle. The number coincides, but the analogy is strained.

Apollo20's assessment of Jones's points (and omissions) themselves are spot on.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Ahem.

Bentham publishes the book on spam.

Description
Authored by a former spammer, this is a methodical, technically explicit expose of the inner workings of the SPAM economy. Readers will be shocked by the sophistication and sheer size of this underworld.

From the Author: 'You may hate spam and think all spammers are evil, but listen to my story and see why I do this and more importantly, HOW.'

For most people, the term 'SPAM' conjures up the image of hundreds of annoying, and at times offensive, e-mails flooding their inbox every week. But for a few, SPAM is a way of life that delivers an adrenaline rush fueled by cash, danger, retribution, porn and the avoidance of local, federal, and international law enforcement agencies. 'Inside the SPAM Cartel' offer readers a never-before seen view inside this dark sub-economy. You'll meet the characters that control the flow of money as well as the hackers and programmers committed to keeping the enterprise up and running. You may disagree with their objectives, but you can't help but to marvel at their ingenuity and resourcefulness in defeating spam filters, avoiding being identified, and staying one step ahead of the law.

Contents
Who I am and why I SPAM: How SPAM works and Revenue behind it: The art of SPAMMING: Spam and Phishing: Legal Efforts against SPAM: Analyzing SPAM: Statistics behind SPAM: The future of SPAM
 
So why did you think that the info your provided was relevant, then? All it said was that some people in Pakistan think 9/11 was an inside job. So what? Some people in America think that 9/11 was an inside job... You don't know what Mr Alam believes, or even if he's a Muslim. That you assume to know (or presume) based purely on his nationality is inappropriate, unnecessary and, yes, racist.


The important point was not merely that conspiratorial beliefs exist there, but rather that they are not a minority view. If it is true that they are not the minority view, then the probability of this paper having found an illegitimately sympathetic reception there is appreciably higher than it is for many other counties. Seemingly this assessment is correct, and as I understand it, nothing further than this is being claimed.
 
Last edited:
Some thoughts about SJ et al's. new paper:

No one has commented, as far as I know, on the fact that Jones' paper has "Fourteen Points"

Why 14?


1+4=5, 14-5=11. 5+4 (from 14) =9. Thus it means 9/11. coincidence? yeah right. Do the math, 911 was an inside job.
 
Jones is a Mormon and there are either 13 or 14 articles of faith in the Mormon church. (depending on who you ask. There seems to be a scism regarding the acual number).

I'm having trouble understanding why the number of points he chose should be conceived of as symbolic.
 
Some thoughts about SJ et al's. new paper:

No one has commented, as far as I know, on the fact that Jones' paper has "Fourteen Points"

Why 14?

I suspect this is Jones' little inside joke because of the other famous "14 Points"; namely those of Woodrow Wilson first pronounced I believe in Jan 1918...


So if Jones with his 14 points is the Wilson in this discussion, who's going to play Clemenceau and complain that 'God only needed 10'?
 
It's not actually unusual for respectable journals to incur page charges, even open access ones. Atmospheric Chemistry & Physics, which is my main stomping ground, is a good example. The reason they get to charge a lot (and they do) is because they have the prestige that comes with high editorial standards and the resulting high impact rating (average number of cites per article). All of these mean that scientists are very keen to get themselves published there and are more than willing to pay for the pleasure. Even so, despite being produced by the European Geosciences Union and a number of influential scientists, it was free to publish there initially for a couple of years while it was getting established.

On the other hand, its Bentham counterpart, The Open Atmospheric Science Journal, is a bit poor on all of these fronts. The fact that it has so far attracted 9 papers since it began last year says it all. Given that there are infinitely more prestigious journals in the field that will publish work for free (they make their money on subscriptions), this is hardly surprising. I can only assume that it's the same story for the structural engineers.


Welcome, Spud1k, and thanks for the information!
 
Hmmm. Apparently the TRUTH and mathematics are not compatible. Mr.D, rwguinn, I stand corrected. Please prepare the Punishment Chambers for one more occupant.
 
Is the food so you can go away, lock yourself up, eat mushrooms, and think up insane ideas on 9/11? Oh, the next false flag operation. Woo woo, the train for Happy Dale left with Jones almost 4 years ago.

Woo woo! :D
Thanks for the laugh! :)

So from what I read here after a brief look is Jones is another one of those fear mongering people like Alex Jones is? The whole business of "get a bunker and some oats" is new to me. He always seemed so keen on maintaining a somewhat professional-front. :boxedin:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom