[Merged]Peer-reviewed technical paper to appear in mainstream journal

Or for the two word version:

Chaos Theory.
I was going to bring that up, but I avoid it because people used to always think of the dude from Jurassic Park or they would ask something to the effect of "Is that like in that one movie...the Butterfly Effect", and then my head would explode.

But yes, you nailed it. There is no way to predict any complex system.
 
I was going to bring that up, but I avoid it because people used to always think of the dude from Jurassic Park or they would ask something to the effect of "Is that like in that one movie...the Butterfly Effect", and then my head would explode.

But yes, you nailed it. There is no way to predict any complex system.

For those that do think of the dude from Jurassic Park the Butterfly Effect....

The Basics of Chaos Theroy is that unless you know the exact state of a system you cannot accurately predict any future state, and the further into the the future your pediction is, the greater the diversion from your prediction the result is likely to be.

The secondary part is used with Hisenberg's Uncertainty Princple, which states that you cannot know both the position and the momentum of a particle at a single moment of time.

Between them they create the essense that since it impossible to predict the future without knowing the pressent, and since we can't know the present without altering it into an uinknowable state, it is impossible to predict the future.

Looking at the WTC as an example, the theory tells us that without knowing exactly how every partof the tower was positioned and moving at the time of the collapse, that any model of the collapse will divert from what we saw IRL as the collapse model proceeds, and that as the collapse proceeds, that diverson will grow larger.

Or in simple terms, it's impossible to exactly model the WTC collapses.
 
Take 100 numbered balls and throw them into the air and note the position of ball number 73. Now repeat. Did ball number 73 end up in the same place? Why not? If you can answer this you should be able to figure out why you can't model the collapse.

That is an experiment that can be replicated. Using impact damage and fire to destroy a steel-frame high-rise the way WTC 1 and 2 were has not been duplicated. Until someone can give me their technique/method on how to do this your belief must be considered pseudoscience.

you mean dumb like someone who suggests that we are claiming that "explosives destroy steel frame buildings" is a fairy tale? You mean that kind of dumb.

No, debunkers are not dumb like that, we reserve that kind of unique stupidity for idiot truthers.

TAM:)

Then please specify which beliefs the 9/11 Truth Movement holds that you would consider comparable to magic or fairy tales.

Hmm... the fairy tale part, is that despite having no proof, you and your debunker mates have concocted an infinitely elaborate, contrived, nonsensical explanations of how the evil hijackers brought down the towers on 9/11. And your fellow debunkers are still working on WTC7 some six years and counting.
 
That is an experiment that can be replicated. Using impact damage and fire to destroy a steel-frame high-rise the way WTC 1 and 2 were has not been duplicated. Until someone can give me their technique/method on how to do this your belief must be considered pseudoscience.



Then please specify which beliefs the 9/11 Truth Movement holds that you would consider comparable to magic or fairy tales.

Hmm... the fairy tale part, is that despite having no proof, you and your debunker mates have concocted an infinitely elaborate, contrived, nonsensical explanations of how the evil hijackers brought down the towers on 9/11. And your fellow debunkers are still working on WTC7 some six years and counting.

Whew! I had to unbuckle the belt on that one! I might need a doctor.
 
Problem is, truthers are too stupid to understand this. Might as well try to teach a lizard to recite the Gettysburg Address.

That is an experiment that can be replicated. Using impact damage and fire to destroy a steel-frame high-rise the way WTC 1 and 2 were has not been duplicated. Until someone can give me their technique/method on how to do this your belief must be considered pseudoscience.
And along comes tanabear to prove my point!
 
Mathematics is not a way of experimentation. Did we come of age during the time of Pythagoras or Plato? If the world of reality does not conform to the world of mathematics, so much the worse for reality.

If the mathematics matches the observed phenomena of WTC 1 and 2 then why can't computers model the collapse? Why doesn't NIST show the visualizations?

The parallel I was attempting to show was that even an eminent scientist like Einstein still needs to have his theories subjected to the experimental method. If Einstein doesn't get a pass, neither does NIST.
I was thinking about this when I saw your posts:
You have no clue what you are talking about.
You never took a physics class.
You forgot all your geometry.
If I say calculus, you say, "what?".
You are not going to be an engineering student.
Your first years in college you did not exempt the final in calculus.
Your first years in college you did not exempt the final in physics.
Your first years in college you did not exempt the final in chemistry.
You think Joule is a name.
You think Momentum is a rapper from Detroit
You have no idea what gravity is, or how to represent it in an equation of energy.
The heat energy of 10,000 gallons of fuel is equal to 315 tons of TNT.
The primary energy in CD is gravity.
The primary energy source in the failure of the WTC, was fire.
The secondary energy source in the failure of the WTC was gravity.
The tertiary energy source for the failure of the WTC was aircraft impact.
The secondary energy source for CD is explosives.
The fires were hundreds of time more energy than explosives used in CD!

But those are not all true, are they? Just thinking about stuff; Why you fail to understand aircraft impacts of 2,840,000,000 joules, and 4,380,000,000 joules, and fires caused the WTC tower to fall?

Have you any experience using physics? Why does it appear you have no clue what you are talking about? Good luck in college.

Great posts, have no idea what you are talking about, but you got me thinking.
"Common sense is the collection of prejudices acquired by age eighteen."
- Albert Einstein

 
That is an experiment that can be replicated. Using impact damage and fire to destroy a steel-frame high-rise the way WTC 1 and 2 were has not been duplicated. Until someone can give me their technique/method on how to do this your belief must be considered pseudoscience.

There are only two ways to do this:

1) Mathematically
2) Build a new WTC Tower and crash a plane into it.

Since you reject 1, and no one in their right mind is going to perform 2 just for your viewing pleasure, you're stuck in your fantasy.

Then please specify which beliefs the 9/11 Truth Movement holds that you would consider comparable to magic or fairy tales.

First you're going to need to define what "the Truth Movement" actually believes. Was it LIHOP or MIHOP? Was it Bush, Cheney and the PNAC or those pesky Jews? Was it thermite or bombs? Was it a missile or plane? Was it commando hijackers or remote controls? Was nukes or was it space beams? Were the claimed hijackers fake, or are they still alive? What exactly does the "Truth Movement" believe because so far from what I have seen if we got 3 of you in a room togther we'd have 10 different versions.

Hmm... the fairy tale part, is that despite having no proof, you and your debunker mates have concocted an infinitely elaborate, contrived, nonsensical explanations of how the evil hijackers brought down the towers on 9/11. And your fellow debunkers are still working on WTC7 some six years and counting.

except for the confessions, the bodies, the ID's located in the wreckage, the eyewittness testimony from onboard the planes and on the ground, the trail of money, the trail left by the hijackers of their actions in the US and back to Germany and Afghanistan, the phone calls home, e-mails between conspirators, their friends and family statements, their martyrdom tapes, the work of 7,000 FBI agents whoo sorted through the evidence of the case, the conviction of one of the conspirators and another 6 indited and ready for trial.

But hey why bother looking at any of that, right?
 
That is an experiment that can be replicated. Using impact damage and fire to destroy a steel-frame high-rise the way WTC 1 and 2 were has not been duplicated. Until someone can give me their technique/method on how to do this your belief must be considered pseudoscience.


Replication is one thing. Corroboration is something else entirely.

Say Bush tosses a 100 dice into the air, counts up the results and jots down their position on the ground. Sure, you could replicate the event, but the chances you're going to get the same results is statistically nil.

Does that mean there's something suspicious about Bush's toss?

The collapse could be modeled, although it would be at an extremely low resolution, compared to the actual event, and the results will be guaranteed to differ so greatly from what was observed on 9/11 that the model would be utterly useless.

Is this really that difficult for you to understand?
 
Last edited:
That is an experiment that can be replicated. Using impact damage and fire to destroy a steel-frame high-rise the way WTC 1 and 2 were has not been duplicated. Until someone can give me their technique/method on how to do this your belief must be considered pseudoscience.

Two planes crashing into 100+ story buildings is "an experiment that can be replicated. Using impact damage and fire to destroy a steel-frame high-rise."

Absolute insanity. It is stunning that Twoofers have sunk to this level of idiocy.

"Until someone can give me their technique/method on how to do this your belief must be considered pseudoscience."

Shall we crash a 757 into the Aon building in Chicago? Give me a billion dollars and a billion dollars worth of insurance, Tanabear. Absolute insanity.
 
CHF and Dave Rogers:

I think we all know what NIST intended with its FAQ on the collapse time, but I believe the way it was worded only confuses people and opens the door for quote-miners like Jones.

I suspect that NIST scientists weren't savvy enough to realize that any collapse time they quoted would be taken as gospel, and, if not clearly stated, used as grist for the truther's mill.

I believe the 9/11 Commission Report has the same problem with its throw-away statement on collapse times, but at least that Report was not written by technical specialists, so perhaps they have an excuse for being sloppy on that one.

i found Dr. Shyam Sunder's interview alot more confusing when he talked about the collapse times.
i find the NIST FAQ far more clear and correct than the words of the lead investigator from NIST :confused:

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/wtc/cons-flash.html

or did the tower collapse in only 11 and 9 seconds?
because then, i only saw slowed down videos.....

ETA : or did NIST got confused by the Seismic data? and when yes, why?
 
Last edited:
Dictator Cheney:

Yes, I agree that Dr. Sunder's comment about the collapse times of WTC 1 & 2 leaves a lot to be desired. Momentum transfer takes time! And I have written to NIST about its past statements on the collapse times and asked that NIST scientists and engineers stop saying that WTC 2 collapsed in "about 9 seconds". So far NIST has not replied to my e-mails and, as with my previous attempts to communicate with NIST's PR people, they appear to have no interest in debating technical issues with me. But I guess that's NIST's prerogative.....

Indeed, I am very familiar with government agencies ignoring complaints from concerned citizens. Here in Canada I reported a case of scientific fraud to NSERC, the agency that was paying for the research. Those guys simply bounced my complaint back to the university who did the research. The university in question immediately carried out a whitewash "inquiry" through the professor's "union" - otherwise known as the Faculty Association - and concluded that the professor had done nothing wrong! (It was the professor's post-doc that perpetrated the fraud by the way!)

Thus I am always left wondering: who is going to "police the police"!

So, DC, when Pomeroo suggests to critics of the NIST Report that they should be writing to NIST to ask them about their concerns, I suspect that if you try to do this you will discover, as I have, that you are wasting your time.
 
Dictator Cheney:

Yes, I agree that Dr. Sunder's comment about the collapse times of WTC 1 & 2 leaves a lot to be desired. Momentum transfer takes time! And I have written to NIST about its past statements on the collapse times and asked that NIST scientists and engineers stop saying that WTC 2 collapsed in "about 9 seconds". So far NIST has not replied to my e-mails and, as with my previous attempts to communicate with NIST's PR people, they appear to have no interest in debating technical issues with me. But I guess that's NIST's prerogative.....

Indeed, I am very familiar with government agencies ignoring complaints from concerned citizens. Here in Canada I reported a case of scientific fraud to NSERC, the agency that was paying for the research. Those guys simply bounced my complaint back to the university who did the research. The university in question immediately carried out a whitewash "inquiry" through the professor's "union" - otherwise known as the Faculty Association - and concluded that the professor had done nothing wrong! (It was the professor's post-doc that perpetrated the fraud by the way!)

Thus I am always left wondering: who is going to "police the police"!

So, DC, when Pomeroo suggests to critics of the NIST Report that they should be writing to NIST to ask them about their concerns, I suspect that if you try to do this you will discover, as I have, that you are wasting your time.

thank you

a very good answer i think :)

while i stll suspect atm that NIST somehow got confused by the Seismic data.
thats the only way i can imagen they got it wrong.
and it is totaly beyond me how a man like Dr. Sunder can say 9 and 11 second collapses like it is the most normal thing on the world.

i suggest Dr. Sunder should read the NIST faq :P
 
Dictator Cheney:

Yes, I agree that Dr. Sunder's comment about the collapse times of WTC 1 & 2 leaves a lot to be desired. Momentum transfer takes time! And I have written to NIST about its past statements on the collapse times and asked that NIST scientists and engineers stop saying that WTC 2 collapsed in "about 9 seconds". So far NIST has not replied to my e-mails and, as with my previous attempts to communicate with NIST's PR people, they appear to have no interest in debating technical issues with me. But I guess that's NIST's prerogative.....
Are you assuming that you are the only person that is sending the NIST e-mails regarding 9/11? Send a letter, fewer people are using it and it's more likely to be read. Be sure to list your qualifications, as they will probably weigh it's importance based on that. The address is:
NIST
100 Bureau Drive
Stop 1070
Gaithersburg, MD 20899-1070
 
There are only two ways to do this:

1) Mathematically
2) Build a new WTC Tower and crash a plane into it.
Let's not forget that part of #2 is to build a minimum of a 120 story building covering 15 acres to house the experiment so they could create the environmental conditions that were present that day. When we talk about the money that would be involved, the twoofers are quick to point out the money spent on the war that they say should be spent on programs here.
 
Last edited:
I was thinking about this when I saw your posts:
You have no clue what you are talking about.
You never took a physics class.
You forgot all your geometry.
If I say calculus, you say, "what?".
You are not going to be an engineering student.
Your first years in college you did not exempt the final in calculus.
Your first years in college you did not exempt the final in physics.
Your first years in college you did not exempt the final in chemistry.
You think Joule is a name.
You think Momentum is a rapper from Detroit
You have no idea what gravity is, or how to represent it in an equation of energy.
The heat energy of 10,000 gallons of fuel is equal to 315 tons of TNT.
The primary energy in CD is gravity.
The primary energy source in the failure of the WTC, was fire.
The secondary energy source in the failure of the WTC was gravity.
The tertiary energy source for the failure of the WTC was aircraft impact.
The secondary energy source for CD is explosives.
The fires were hundreds of time more energy than explosives used in CD!

But those are not all true, are they? Just thinking about stuff; Why you fail to understand aircraft impacts of 2,840,000,000 joules, and 4,380,000,000 joules, and fires caused the WTC tower to fall?

Have you any experience using physics? Why does it appear you have no clue what you are talking about? Good luck in college.

Great posts, have no idea what you are talking about, but you got me thinking.

James Prescott Joule?
 
That is an experiment that can be replicated. Using impact damage and fire to destroy a steel-frame high-rise the way WTC 1 and 2 were has not been duplicated. Until someone can give me their technique/method on how to do this your belief must be considered pseudoscience.

It wouldn't really be accurate unless it was full of furniture & people as the towers were on 9/11. You should be able to find plenty of truthers to volunteer for that job, though, since they're so sure that the buildings won't collapse.
 
Collapst time? Watch the videos, and then read NIST, or just pay attention. 9/11 truth cherry picks, as if they are dolts who want to mislead others.

NIST estimated the elapsed times for the first exterior panels to strike the ground after the collapse initiated in each of the towers to be approximately 11 seconds for WTC 1 and approximately 9 seconds for WTC 2. These elapsed times were based on: (1) precise timing of the initiation of collapse from video evidence, and (2) ground motion (seismic) signals recorded at Palisades, N.Y., that also were precisely time-calibrated for wave transmission times from lower Manhattan (see NCSTAR 1-5A).
More data can give you an idea of time. But watching the video will show you how long it took. It seem different parts of the WTC had different collapse times. Who knew?

The seismic spikes for the collapse of the WTC Towers are the result of debris from the collapsing towers impacting the ground. The spikes began approximately 10 seconds after the times for the start of each building’s collapse and continued for approximately 15 seconds. There were no seismic signals that occurred prior to the initiation of the collapse of either tower. The seismic record contains no evidence that would indicate explosions occurring prior to the collapse of the towers.
James Prescott Joule?
OMG, it is a name! I was using it as unit of energy! I am always learning..
Baited, hooked, and cooked. "Et tu, Brute?" (on learning u r not studying debunkers, you are just a truther)
 
Last edited:
Collapst time? Watch the videos, and then read NIST, or just pay attention. 9/11 truth cherry picks, as if they are dolts who want to mislead others.


More data can give you an idea of time. But watching the video will show you how long it took. It seem different parts of the WTC had different collapse times. Who knew?



OMG, it is a name! I was using it as unit of energy! I am always learning..
Baited, hooked, and cooked. "Et tu, Brute?" (on learning u r not studying debunkers, you are just a truther)

but its the LEAD investigator, the chief, you told me i should accepts as fact what the chiefs say, even if they cannot back it up :boggled:
you are a very confusing teacher beachnut.
 
Take 100 numbered balls and throw them into the air and note the position of ball number 73. Now repeat. Did ball number 73 end up in the same place? Why not? If you can answer this you should be able to figure out why you can't model the collapse.

Excellent analogy then next he should try 10,000 balls or a 100,000 balls.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom