Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't the NIST collapse time refer to the time it took for the first debris to hit the ground - as opposed to the entire collapse itself which was largely obscured by dust?
Absolutely! They say:
"NIST estimated the
elapsed times for the first exterior panels to strike the ground after the collapse initiated in each of the towers to be approximately 11 seconds for WTC 1 and approximately 9 seconds for WTC 2. These elapsed times were based on: (1) precise timing of the initiation of collapse from video evidence, and (2) ground motion (seismic) signals recorded at Palisades, N.Y., that also were precisely time-calibrated for wave transmission times from lower Manhattan (see NCSTAR 1-5A)."
So they are clearly referencing the exterior panels. The problem is that those exterior panels shear off the building and do in fact fall without resistance from the rest of the building! But they fail to make this clear. Instead they say:
“… the structure below the level of collapse initiation offered minimal resistance to the falling building mass at and above the impact zone. The potential energy released by the downward movement of the large building mass far exceeded the capacity of the intact structure below to absorb that energy through energy of deformation."
With regard to certain of the exterior panels, the rest of the building appears to offer NO RESISTANCE because they were truly free falling.
This is demonstrated very clearly in a video, taken from ground level within a block of the collapse. I will have to find it. It is hand held amateur footage. The key is just before the cameraman turns to run, there is at least a half a second of footage of a HUGE exterior panel smashing to the ground, well before the bulk of the building. In addition there are smaller bits of debris also falling at “free fall speed” and hitting the ground long before the bulk of the building.
NIST’s calculation, therefore, is incredibly conservative, if anything. The problem is that alleged experts publishing in alleged “Mainstream Woornals” do not hesitate to mislead their audience.
/any help you all can offer finding that video would be much appreciated. I do recall that early on, it briefly showed a victim of falling debris laying in the street (I don’t know if this helps).