[Merged]Peer-reviewed technical paper to appear in mainstream journal

So after sifting through 10 pages of this, I noticed two things:

Steven Jones apparently makes enough money off the twoofers to spend it on bogus papers

and

deep44 has become suspiciously quiet over the last ~5 pages.

Heh.

Actually I noticed three things: I really appreciate this forum and the people posting on it. :)
 
Last edited:
Isn't that like saying that the judge's secretary shouldn't answer the phone because she doesn't have a legal degree? Most of the questions that a journal gets do not require editorial expertise (I bet the biggest one is "why won't the page download?"). Most of the questions that a journal PUBLISHER get probably don't even apply to a specific journal, let alone a specific editor.


Just an update, I haven't heard anything further from Bentham yet.

I contacted their "contact" e-mail from their website. The publisher is a reasonable person to receive e-mail, since he knows which editor or board member should be contacted for further information. It would be unusual for the publisher to respond to technical criticism, but they're more than adequate for coordination.

And regarding your restaurant analogy, there's nothing wrong at all with setting up the business concern and hiring talent to do the technical work. But there would be a problem with you simply buying the names of technical experts, advertising their talents, and then doing all the work yourself on the cheap. That's the scenario I want to put to rest here.

If I get responses from actual scientists and academics, all is well. If I only get responses from the publisher and the rest is a dead end, then we're dealing with open fraud. So far, I remain optimistic.
 
Good God, is there anyone they didn't add to their editorial board? I should e-mail them to see if I can get on it.

http://www.bentham.org/open/tociej/EBM.htm


No doubt, you could easily get on their editorial board. You're probably over-qualified, in fact. It appears as though they will add anyone with a degree and a valid e-mail address. Or maybe just a valid e-mail address, for that matter. :)


They claim to have a law journal as well - the Bentham Open Law Journal - but it's non-existent and it hasn't a single paper (or review, or "letter" for that matter). I suspect that's because no reputable lawyer would, for a second, lend his or her good name, good reputation, or his or her actual, real life expertise to such a bogus operation in its quest to pretend to be a legitimate journal.
 
Last edited:
Some thoughts about SJ et al's. new paper:

A question for you, Dr. Greening.

I see that Professor Jones is claiming in his fourteen points that the collapse time of the Twin Towers violated the law of conservation of momentum. He seems to be strongly wedded to the conservation of momentum argument at present, and it seems surprising given how comprehensively it's been refuted. It's possible he hasn't read the Kenneth Kuttler paper, published in his own journal, that shows a conservation of momentum calculation which gives a collapse time less than was observed (or that he chose to accept Kuttler's rather absurd approach of refusing to state the collapse time and instead comparing his time with some other value), or Gregory Urich's recent submission to the same journal which shows that the collapse time was as expected after considering all likely sources of resistance. However, I know you've corresponded with Professor Jones, and I wondered whether you had specifically made him aware of your own calculations?

Dave
 
A question for you, Dr. Greening.

I see that Professor Jones is claiming in his fourteen points that the collapse time of the Twin Towers violated the law of conservation of momentum. He seems to be strongly wedded to the conservation of momentum argument at present, and it seems surprising given how comprehensively it's been refuted. It's possible he hasn't read the Kenneth Kuttler paper, published in his own journal, that shows a conservation of momentum calculation which gives a collapse time less than was observed (or that he chose to accept Kuttler's rather absurd approach of refusing to state the collapse time and instead comparing his time with some other value), or Gregory Urich's recent submission to the same journal which shows that the collapse time was as expected after considering all likely sources of resistance. However, I know you've corresponded with Professor Jones, and I wondered whether you had specifically made him aware of your own calculations?

Dave

The momentum thing has always been a particularly lame strawman that the truthers can latch onto. I often wondered if he picked that particular line because that was the exact reason the original 'faster than freefall' model was invalid, a kind of 'we DID consider momentum and still found NIST to be wrong, so we were never wrong in the first place'. His ignoring of everything that even suggests the contrary is just a career-long habit of Jones'.

Saying 'you need to consider momentum' in a mechanics model is akin to saying 'you need to use wires' when building an electronic circuit. I tried doing a version of the over-simplified 'pancake' model and after putting conservation of momentum in with perfect plastic collisions, the predicted collapse times were under 12 seconds for both towers. I'm not trying to say I have a perfect model here, that would have to include all manner of mind-boggling structural considerations, but it does give lie to the glib 'if you consider momentum, the observed collapse times were too quick' statement. If Jones wants to back that assertion up, the onus is on him to produce some serious calculations that can be validated by a third party.
 
Dave Rogers:

I HAVE told SJ about several of my papers, (several times!), especially those available on 911myths. His usual response is:

1. To claim he is NOT aware of the exsistence of these papers.

2. To request that I e-mail him the papers or a link to them.

I have provide links but always after that I am met with total silence.

The one exception is my "Aluminum in the WTC" paper which Jones has attempted to ridicule in one of his missives! Apart from that it appears that, in Jones' Universe at least, I do not exist.... He ceratinly has ignored Bazant's latest paper to which I am a co-author. A paper, I might add, that went through a VERY rigorous peer review process before it was finally accepted for publication.

It is however interesting that Jones claims to have done his very own collapse calculations, which I am yet to see, and feels comfortable making pronouncements about the WTC collapse times. If he has done any such calculations he should be in a position to report his estimates of the collapse times which I would love to hear about. Perhaps then Jones could elaborate on his claims about violations of the law of conservation of momentum......

Anyone who is at all familiar with my calculations would know that I explicitly use this law (M1V1 = M2V2) in my estimate of the collapse times. For me the real problem is that NIST claims that WTC 2 fell in "9 seconds". This is simply not true and I have written to NIST about this over the weekend to ask it to change the wording of that particular FAQ. If NIST do not change this statement then NIST will only have itself to blame when guys like Jones make mileage over the observation that the structures apparently offered very little resistance to the collapse, and guys like Jones conclude (erroneously!) that a controlled demolition was involved. The truth is that WTC 1 & 2 offered lots of resistance to the downward motion of the upper block but still collapsed in less than 15 seconds.

By the way, I am working on my own submission to the Bentham Journal,... all I need is cash contributions towards the $600 publication fee. I am planning on calling it:

"Seven Points of Agreement"

It will go something like this:

1. NIST says that there were TWO very tall towers at the WTC in New York City. I agree with NIST on this observation.

2. NIST says that A36 steel was used in the construction of these towers. I agree with this but would like to discuss the use of other steels with NIST.

3. NIST and FEMA state that TWO aircraft hit the Towers; one hitting WTC 1 and one hitting WTC 2. I agree with NIST and FEMA on this.

4. NIST claims that jet fuel from the aircraft started fires near the impact zones of WTC 1 & 2. Yes, I agree with this as do other previously published reports.

5. NIST says that WTC 7 collapsed late in the afternoon on Sept 11, 2001. I noticed that too and would like to discuss this further with NIST.

6. NIST report in NCSTAR 1-5A that black smoke poured out of some windows in the impact zones of both towers. I suspect that this was due to the fires and would like to discuss this possibility with NIST. There is much to learn here.

7. NIST and FEMA report that WTC 1 & 2 totally collapsed very rapidly within 2 hours of the aircraft impacts. Here I may be able to help since I have used state-of-the-art software (EXCEL) to calculate the collapse times.


So, guys, what do you think..............
 
I think it looks very suspicious that you mention PRECISELY 7 "Points of Agreement"!
 
By the way, I am working on my own submission to the Bentham Journal,... all I need is cash contributions towards the $600 publication fee. I am planning on calling it:

"Seven Points of Agreement"

It will go something like this:

1. NIST says that there were TWO very tall towers at the WTC in New York City. I agree with NIST on this observation.

2. NIST says that A36 steel was used in the construction of these towers. I agree with this but would like to discuss the use of other steels with NIST.

3. NIST and FEMA state that TWO aircraft hit the Towers; one hitting WTC 1 and one hitting WTC 2. I agree with NIST and FEMA on this.

4. NIST claims that jet fuel from the aircraft started fires near the impact zones of WTC 1 & 2. Yes, I agree with this as do other previously published reports.

5. NIST says that WTC 7 collapsed late in the afternoon on Sept 11, 2001. I noticed that too and would like to discuss this further with NIST.

6. NIST report in NCSTAR 1-5A that black smoke poured out of some windows in the impact zones of both towers. I suspect that this was due to the fires and would like to discuss this possibility with NIST. There is much to learn here.

7. NIST and FEMA report that WTC 1 & 2 totally collapsed very rapidly within 2 hours of the aircraft impacts. Here I may be able to help since I have used state-of-the-art software (EXCEL) to calculate the collapse times.


So, guys, what do you think..............

Professor, I was working on my own submission to that journal that had nothing to do with 9/11. The tentative title would be "Point of Agreement With Astronomers: The Sun Rises in the East". You think I can get a grant to publish this?

;)
 
For me the real problem is that NIST claims that WTC 2 fell in "9 seconds". This is simply not true and I have written to NIST about this over the weekend to ask it to change the wording of that particular FAQ.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't the NIST collapse time refer to the time it took for the first debris to hit the ground - as opposed to the entire collapse itself which was largely obscured by dust?

By the way, I am working on my own submission to the Bentham Journal,... all I need is cash contributions towards the $600 publication fee. I am planning on calling it:

"Seven Points of Agreement"

It will go something like this:

1. NIST says that there were TWO very tall towers at the WTC in New York City. I agree with NIST on this observation.

2. NIST says that A36 steel was used in the construction of these towers. I agree with this but would like to discuss the use of other steels with NIST.

3. NIST and FEMA state that TWO aircraft hit the Towers; one hitting WTC 1 and one hitting WTC 2. I agree with NIST and FEMA on this.

4. NIST claims that jet fuel from the aircraft started fires near the impact zones of WTC 1 & 2. Yes, I agree with this as do other previously published reports.

5. NIST says that WTC 7 collapsed late in the afternoon on Sept 11, 2001. I noticed that too and would like to discuss this further with NIST.

6. NIST report in NCSTAR 1-5A that black smoke poured out of some windows in the impact zones of both towers. I suspect that this was due to the fires and would like to discuss this possibility with NIST. There is much to learn here.

7. NIST and FEMA report that WTC 1 & 2 totally collapsed very rapidly within 2 hours of the aircraft impacts. Here I may be able to help since I have used state-of-the-art software (EXCEL) to calculate the collapse times.

So, guys, what do you think..............

Hmmmm.....not quite as detailed as your preview work, Mr. Greening, but still good enough for "peer-review" if Jones' paper is any indication. :D
 
Last edited:
Anyone who is at all familiar with my calculations would know that I explicitly use this law (M1V1 = M2V2) in my estimate of the collapse times. For me the real problem is that NIST claims that WTC 2 fell in "9 seconds". This is simply not true and I have written to NIST about this over the weekend to ask it to change the wording of that particular FAQ.

A good idea. NIST's only actual statement about the collapse times is "NIST estimated the elapsed times for the first exterior panels to strike the ground after the collapse initiated in each of the towers to be approximately 11 seconds for WTC 1 and approximately 9 seconds for WTC 2", a statement that doesn't actually quantify the collapse time, but what the FAQ fails to do is to knock down the strawman it sets up in its own question: "How could the WTC towers collapse in only 11 seconds (WTC 1) and 9 seconds (WTC 2)". I wonder whether the writers of the NIST report are a little too naive when faced with truther quote-mining.


By the way, I am working on my own submission to the Bentham Journal,... all I need is cash contributions towards the $600 publication fee. I am planning on calling it:

"Seven Points of Agreement"

:dl:

This really exposes the duplicity of Jones's approach. Establishing points of agreement is indeed a way of progressing a constructive debate, but it might be more conventional to establish that there are valid points of disagreement first.

Dave
 
I don't suppose there is anyone out there with $600 to spare who would be naughty enough to write a totally bogus paper to test the rigour of this journal's peer review process? I heard of people doing similar things before...
 
Firestone:

OK, I admit, WTC 7 was behind my thinking. But I also chose 7 Points because there are 7 Pillars of Wisdom; 7 Wonders of the World; 7 Days of Creation; 7 Virtues; 7 Ages of Man; 7 Metals of Alchemy; 7 Planets; 7 Last Words of Christ and, finally, because I'm only half as smart as Jones with his 14 Points!

And, yes, if Jones was charged $600 for 14 Points, I think I could request a charge of $300 for just 7 Points!
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't the NIST collapse time refer to the time it took for the first debris to hit the ground - as opposed to the entire collapse itself which was largely obscured by dust?

Absolutely! They say:

"NIST estimated the elapsed times for the first exterior panels to strike the ground after the collapse initiated in each of the towers to be approximately 11 seconds for WTC 1 and approximately 9 seconds for WTC 2. These elapsed times were based on: (1) precise timing of the initiation of collapse from video evidence, and (2) ground motion (seismic) signals recorded at Palisades, N.Y., that also were precisely time-calibrated for wave transmission times from lower Manhattan (see NCSTAR 1-5A)."

So they are clearly referencing the exterior panels. The problem is that those exterior panels shear off the building and do in fact fall without resistance from the rest of the building! But they fail to make this clear. Instead they say:

“… the structure below the level of collapse initiation offered minimal resistance to the falling building mass at and above the impact zone. The potential energy released by the downward movement of the large building mass far exceeded the capacity of the intact structure below to absorb that energy through energy of deformation."

With regard to certain of the exterior panels, the rest of the building appears to offer NO RESISTANCE because they were truly free falling.

This is demonstrated very clearly in a video, taken from ground level within a block of the collapse. I will have to find it. It is hand held amateur footage. The key is just before the cameraman turns to run, there is at least a half a second of footage of a HUGE exterior panel smashing to the ground, well before the bulk of the building. In addition there are smaller bits of debris also falling at “free fall speed” and hitting the ground long before the bulk of the building.

NIST’s calculation, therefore, is incredibly conservative, if anything. The problem is that alleged experts publishing in alleged “Mainstream Woornals” do not hesitate to mislead their audience.

/any help you all can offer finding that video would be much appreciated. I do recall that early on, it briefly showed a victim of falling debris laying in the street (I don’t know if this helps).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom