[Merged]Peer-reviewed technical paper to appear in mainstream journal

That is an experiment that can be replicated. Using impact damage and fire to destroy a steel-frame high-rise the way WTC 1 and 2 were has not been duplicated. Until someone can give me their technique/method on how to do this your belief must be considered pseudoscience.

I think pseudoscience is becoming the new catch phrase of the "truth" movement replacing faster than freefall.

BTW Do you think it would be possible to recreate the exact same collisions and effects.
 
Last edited:
Collapst time? Watch the videos, and then read NIST, or just pay attention. 9/11 truth cherry picks, as if they are dolts who want to mislead others.
We count the east penthouse collapse as part of the collapse time for WTC 7. Shouldn't we also count the collapse of the spires as part of the tower collapse time? Just asking questions. :p
 
We count the east penthouse collapse as part of the collapse time for WTC 7. Shouldn't we also count the collapse of the spires as part of the tower collapse time? Just asking questions. :p

I think we should, yes. But 9/11 conspiracy advocates tend to develop sticky Caps Lock buttons when I do.
 
Update on Bentham -- No News

I'm back in town again, wanted to follow up.

I've received no correspondence of any kind from Bentham since the initial acknowledgment from Mr. Alam. Certainly none from their technical staff.

I'll get out a reminder tomorrow.

So far, their behavior is continuing to trend unprofessionally. If this persists, I have a pretty good idea how Dr. Jones's article pa$$ed their peer review proce$$. But time will tell.
 
I'm back in town again, wanted to follow up.

I've received no correspondence of any kind from Bentham since the initial acknowledgment from Mr. Alam. Certainly none from their technical staff.

I'll get out a reminder tomorrow.

So far, their behavior is continuing to trend unprofessionally. If this persists, I have a pretty good idea how Dr. Jones's article pa$$ed their peer review proce$$. But time will tell.

Mackey,

Do you think it likely that the journal would have published a "truther" paper, with all the implications that comes along with it (assuming their claims are all rubbish), for just another $600 bucks. I mean at some point the decision was made to publish the article. Now this very well could be a garbage journal, but would they seriously sink so low as to publish an article that is linked to a loose organization that blames the government for 9-11, all based on lies, just for another $600 bucks?!?!?! If I was running a similar scam journal I would have to consider if publishing the article would cost me more than $600 in losses due to the attention such article could possibly bring (other future authors may decide against publishing there).

I don't buy into it. I could see them publishing other rubbish that doesn't carry such stigma just for money (technical articles with major flaws); but, not a 9-11 piece for propaganda (with is essentially what it is, assuming it is all rubbish).

Do you think it to be more likely that one or more of the decision makers already believe in the woo? I find this more likely, especially considering the large review board.
 
Do you think it likely that the journal would have published a "truther" paper, with all the implications that comes along with it (assuming their claims are all rubbish), for just another $600 bucks. [...]

Do you think it to be more likely that one or more of the decision makers already believe in the woo? I find this more likely, especially considering the large review board.

I'm hoping to get some answers from them so I don't have to speculate.

However, since you asked, my guess is one of the following:

1. They honestly have no idea who Dr. Jones or his friends are, didn't read the paper too carefully, and published it anyway. They wanted the fee and to boost their article count and, hopefully, exposure. Recall that the Truth Movement is not nearly so popular or famous as they like to think.

2. Or, Dr. Jones supplied the reviewers, and the editors didn't vet them properly, or check on their recommendations. The website's submission process encourages submitters to suggest reviewers, only requiring that they are "from different institutions." None of the submitters have any institution, I believe. I actually find this to be more plausible.

But, again, this is idle speculation. I could be wrong, and I hope I am. Still, thus far it does not look good at all.
 
Do you think it likely that the journal would have published a "truther" paper, with all the implications that comes along with it (assuming their claims are all rubbish), for just another $600 bucks. I mean at some point the decision was made to publish the article. Now this very well could be a garbage journal, but would they seriously sink so low as to publish an article that is linked to a loose organization that blames the government for 9-11, all based on lies, just for another $600 bucks?!?!?! If I was running a similar scam journal I would have to consider if publishing the article would cost me more than $600 in losses due to the attention such article could possibly bring (other future authors may decide against publishing there).

If the business model of the journal is to make money out of authors by charging them to publish material of such poor quality that reputable journals won't touch it, I suspect they'll have considered the impact on their business of publishing material of such poor quality that reputable journals won't touch it. Basically, when you know you're the last resort of the desperate, it doesn't matter how much distance you come last by.

Dave
 
I'm hoping to get some answers from them so I don't have to speculate.

However, since you asked, my guess is one of the following:

1. They honestly have no idea who Dr. Jones or his friends are, didn't read the paper too carefully, and published it anyway. They wanted the fee and to boost their article count and, hopefully, exposure. Recall that the Truth Movement is not nearly so popular or famous as they like to think.

2. Or, Dr. Jones supplied the reviewers, and the editors didn't vet them properly, or check on their recommendations. The website's submission process encourages submitters to suggest reviewers, only requiring that they are "from different institutions." None of the submitters have any institution, I believe. I actually find this to be more plausible.

But, again, this is idle speculation. I could be wrong, and I hope I am. Still, thus far it does not look good at all.

I agree, and find both of your suggestions/speculations plausible, if not likely. I did find it very amusing that they were allowed to choose their own reviewers. Seems like that automatically brings into it a bias.

I have not seen this happen much in the medical world, although my involvement in research is limited (I have contributed to a few routine papers that were published, but little else). Is it common practice in the engineering, or pure science world to allow one to choose their own "Peer reviewers"?

TAM:)
 
Allowing someone to choose the reviewers gets rid of independence which I believe is a major component of true peer review. While I have no experience with peer review in technical fields I doubt any journal respected in it field would allow this practice.
 
Actually it is quite normal and legitimate to REQUEST particular reviewers for a submitted paper. If done properly, such a request need not imply that an author is attempting to bypass a fair review process. On the contrary, this approach can save the journal the trouble of figuring out who the relevant "experts" might be. And the journal is not obliged to use the requested reviewers - the editors may opt to use one that has been requested by the submitter and one that is selected by the journal.
 
Apollo has a different experience than me. In my limited experience in engineering, the journal editors always select the reviewers. Maybe the difference is in science vs. engineering, or how narrow the subject matter is.
 
Actually it is quite normal and legitimate to REQUEST particular reviewers for a submitted paper. If done properly, such a request need not imply that an author is attempting to bypass a fair review process. On the contrary, this approach can save the journal the trouble of figuring out who the relevant "experts" might be. And the journal is not obliged to use the requested reviewers - the editors may opt to use one that has been requested by the submitter and one that is selected by the journal.

Exactly.

It would be nice if the editor-in-chief knew who the world experts were in every conceivable subdiscipline. It would also be nice if unicorns scattered gold bricks over my sofa cushions every Tuesday. I suspect I'll see the second before I see the first.

It's fairly common to allow authors both to suggest reviewers and to suggest people to exclude from reviewing (on the grounds of personal animosity of something like that). It's not just common, but standard and recommended practice at promotion/tenure time. It's unheard of to allow authors to pick reviewers.

Even the mighty NSF accepts this : from their current grant proposal guide (Jan 2008):

c. List of Suggested Reviewers or Reviewers Not to Include (optional)

Proposers may include a list of suggested reviewers who they believe are especially well qualified to review the proposal. Proposers also may designate persons they would prefer not review the proposal, indicating why. These suggestions are optional. GPG Exhibit II-2 contains information on conflicts of interest that may be useful in preparation of this list.

The cognizant Program Officer handling the proposal considers the suggestions and may contact the proposer for further information. However, the decision whether or not to use the suggestions remains with the Program Officer.

Is there anyone who wants to suggest that the NSF is not respected?
 
In terms of animosity, isn't scientific peer-review anonymous? It is in my field (humanities).
 
Last edited:
In terms of animosity, isn't scientific peer-review anonymous? It is in my field (humanities).

Not always. Some fields (and some journals) demand that papers be written "anonymously" for review, but many don't, simply because it doesn't work. For example, there are only about four or five groups working in experimental high energy particle physics, because there are only about five machines out there capable of doing the work. So when you get to the section that says "We used the Wotsamatta U. Shopvac 3300 to test our conjecture," you know instantly that the paper is by Dr. Niedermeyer and his group at Wotsamatta.

For NSF-style project proposals, anonymous review isn't possible, since the qualifications of the proposing researcher are among the criteria. (This is true for the humanities as well; the NEH grant reviews are not done anonymously.)

So a lot of groups have just said "the hell with it; why pretend?"
 
Let's not forget that part of #2 is to build a minimum of a 120 story building covering 15 acres to house the experiment so they could create the environmental conditions that were present that day. When we talk about the money that would be involved, the twoofers are quick to point out the money spent on the war that they say should be spent on programs here.

Don't forget what the statistical error on a single measurement is.

In other words, tanabear: You can't just do the experiment once. In order to get a decent sample size, you'd have to destroy say ... 10+ WTC complexes per degree of freedom.

Good luck with your science.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom