[Merged]Peer-reviewed technical paper to appear in mainstream journal

Not if he's an attention whore that wants the spotlight like he had in the early 'Cold fusion' days. Just my $.02

But he'd get more attention by pitching a revised version of this limp-wristed 'paper' to a decent journal. I'm sure it'd be possible to put together a sensible and interesting critique of NIST that was as short on conspiracy claims as this effort is published in a real journal.

That's what I mean about ineptitude. If the plan is to be an attention-whore, there are a trillion better ways than vanity publication in an obscure, badly-regarded on-line journal. And he must know that, as someone with previous experience of real publishing.
 
How can someone clearly capable of writing real papers and getting them published in real journals, and who must, by his profession, know and understand publishing and peer-review, have sunk to such depths of ineptitude?

It all makes sense only if Jones knows that he's full of it.

There is only one reason why Jones went through with this pathetic exersize: to allow the TM to - finally! - brag about having a peer-reviewed paper. That's it.

Just read his comments on 911 blogger and you'll see that he seems more concerned with putting the JREFers in their place than with actually exposing a conspiracy to the scientific/engineering community.

What was actually "reviewed" isn't nearly as important as the fact that something was reviewed. I suspect this is why he has so far played it safe with "things we agree on" rather than "here's what I think happened." Even then he could only get it published in a second-rate on-line journal that is only a few months old.

At least this is a tacit admission by Jones that his "Journal of 911 Studies" was a complete crock.
 
Last edited:
Well,.... staring into my magic eight-ball,.... I suspect that he's sufficiently delusional that he has to get The Truth out anyway he can. It's the same reason anyone publishes in a vanity journal; the idea that getting your name and ideas in press trumps the channels you use. And he's failed miserably at all the conventional channels.

Alternatively, this is just another scheme to milk the Truthers for more support. He knows that his audience will not be aware of the subtle differences between real and vanity journals, and he hopes that enough people will cite his vanity article to keep his gravy train alive.

I really suspect a bit of both....

This is what doesn't make sense for me - he's removed nearly all the conspiracy stuff from this letter. It's vapid, empty and, well, safe. With some work, something along these general lines could get published. If he wants to "get the truth out there", and believed in the veracity of his ideas, why did he choose to water his "truth" down to homoeopathic levels?

And if he's patsying Truthers, again, why the content and why the location? It is, as I said, inept, whatever his motive might be. I can't get my head around it.

We're both published academics (in different fields, of course, and my career is very, very nascent), so all these issues are glaringly obvious to us. Why weren't they to Jones?
 
Last edited:
It all makes sense only if Jones knows that he's full of it.

There is only one reason why Jones went through with this pathetic exersize: to allow the TM to - finally! - brag about having a peer-reviewed paper. That's it.

What was actually "reviewed" isn't nearly as important as the fact that something was reviewed. I suspect this is why he has so far played it safe with "things we agree on" rather than "here's what I think happened."

Just read his comments on 911 blogger and you'll see that he seems more concerned with putting the JREFers in their place than with actually exposing a conspiracy to the scientific/engineering community.

Good point. I guess I'm trying to put myself in his shoes to some extent - if I REALLY believed (however erroneously) that 3,000 people were murdered by my own government, and that I had the technical expertise to be able to prove it, how would I act?

It certainly wouldn't be the way Jones is.
 
But he'd get more attention by pitching a revised version of this limp-wristed 'paper' to a decent journal. I'm sure it'd be possible to put together a sensible and interesting critique of NIST that was as short on conspiracy claims as this effort is published in a real journal.

That's what I mean about ineptitude. If the plan is to be an attention-whore, there are a trillion better ways than vanity publication in an obscure, badly-regarded on-line journal. And he must know that, as someone with previous experience of real publishing.
If it was totally wrong and you knew it would you pitch it to real scrutiny? I think he hopes no one that will challenge him in the real world will ever read it. He's looking for more attention from the only people that are paying attention in the first place.
 
If it was totally wrong and you knew it would you pitch it to real scrutiny? I think he hopes no one that will challenge him in the real world will ever read it. He's looking for more attention from the only people that are paying attention in the first place.

So you're going with "conman" rather than "deluded"? It does seem to fit his behaviours better...
 
This is what doesn't make sense for me - he's removed nearly all the conspiracy stuff from this letter. It's vapid, empty and, well, safe. With some work, something along these general lines could get published. If he wants to "get the truth out there", and believed in the veracity of his ideas, why did he choose to water his "truth" down to homoeopathic levels?

And if he's patsying Truthers, again, why the content and why the location? It is, as I said, inept, whatever his motive might be. I can't get my head around it.

Ya know what's really sad? We see on 911 blogger exactly why he's done it the way he has.

Even after watering down the "truth" to JAQ-off levels, publishing in a no-name journal, and doing away with his microspheres (at least in this paper)....his stupid followers are still overjoyed!

This publication has probably bought Jones another year or two worth of credibilty with the legions of single white males wearing creepy black 9/11 t-shirts.

I suspect that's all he wanted out of this.
 
Why would that be unfortunate? If Mr. Alam spots a business opportunity (low-cost scientific publishing, possibly motivated by the idea that scientists in the Third World can access more information for free) and hires appropriate experts to help him run it while he manages the "business" aspect of it, I don't see that as a bad thing.


It would be unfortunate because Alam isn't listed as an editor, and if he really isn't involved in editorial decisions and/or lacks expertise in civil engineering, he shouldn't be the one responding.
 
Ya know what's really sad? We see on 911 blogger exactly why he's done it the way he has.

Even after watering down the "truth" to JAQ-off levels, publishing in a no-name journal, and doing away with his microspheres (at least in this paper)....his stupid followers are still overjoyed!

This publication has probably bought Jones another year or two worth of credibilty with the legions of single white males wearing creepy black 9/11 t-shirts.

I suspect that's all he wanted out of this.


You're right. It's a tragedy, but a revealing one. If he believed in this stuff, he'd get it published somewhere rigorous, and would still have the same reaction from his goons. I think his choice of journal is symptomatic of a lack of confidence in even his own words.

I mean, I cannot for the life of me understand why someone who professes absolute belief in a murdering conspiracy of his countrymen is content to act in such a banal way. I also can't understand why anyone believes this crapoloa after more than a cursory glance, and I guess I never will.
 
And if Jones is still reading this, could he please include the complete quote from NIST, not just the part where NIST state "...we are unable to provide a full explanation of the total collapse". He repeats this quote mine twice in his little paper.

Here is the full quote. Free for all to use.

NIST said:
NIST carried its analysis to the point where the buildings reached global instability. At this point, because of the magnitude of deflections and the number of failures occurring, the computer models are not able to converge on a solution. Your letter contends that NIST's report violates the Information Quality Standard of "utility". NIST believes that the report has utility. In fact, the codes and standards bodies are already taking actions to improve building and fire codes and standards based on the findings of the WTC Investigation. As we mentioned previously, we are unable to provide a full explanation of the total collapse.

Be honest Jones. Wasn't it the magnitude of deflections and the number of failures occurring, that prevent the computer models from being able to converge on a solution, and NIST from claiming they can provide a full explanation of the collapse?
 
Last edited:
I'm hesitant to mention this, as it could be construed as stereotyping, but I feel it's a legitimate issue in this case.

From a segment by NPR's intelligence correspondent, Mary-Louise Kelly, describing a visit to a Pakistani madrassa (religious school):

But [headmaster Sami] Ul-Haq did offer up some thoughts distinctly at odds with the U.S. world view. . . . he argued that the U.S.-led invasion of Afghanistan was illegitimate because -- he claims -- the Sept. 11 attacks were not the work of al-Qaida. . . .

This is not a minority view in Pakistan. Over two weeks -- and dozens of interviews -- I met only a handful of people who say they believe the U.S. account of what happened on Sept. 11. From taxi drivers to senior government officials, the far more common view is that Israeli or U.S. intelligence orchestrated the attacks.


I've also heard Kelly this issue on one of NPR's talk shows; she stated that she had met with a large group of Pakistani academics (who of course ought to know better) who were all thoroughly convinced that the attacks had been staged. I think this is the audio, but I can't be certain, as the sound is out on my computer here at work.
 
I don't think that kind of borderline racist ad-hominem is necessary, or justified, Spit. There's plenty wrong here without resorting to lazy stereotypes.
 
Erm, do you feel that Kelly's reports are "borderline racist" and stereotyping?

No, but the allegation that because this Journal is published in Pakistan automatically means that the Editor-in-Chief is a credulous dupe is.

Where this journal is published, and the nationality of its founder, is irrelevant.
 
I don't think that kind of borderline racist ad-hominem is necessary, or justified, Spit. There's plenty wrong here without resorting to lazy stereotypes.

Not sure its racist; The world (or at least parts of it) blames all Islam for 9/11 and those who know themselves to be innocent of that crime will of course be drawn to the belief that nobody in their camp would have done such a thing.

Most Islamic people, indeed even most fundamentalist Islamic people, do not condone terroristic murder to advance their cause, and indeed rightly see it as doing actual DAMAGE to that cause.

Can't say I wouldn't be tempted to adopt that position were I in their shoes.

-Ben
 
Not sure its racist; The world (or at least parts of it) blames all Islam for 9/11 and those who know themselves to be innocent of that crime will of course be drawn to the belief that nobody in their camp would have done such a thing.

Most Islamic people, indeed even most fundamentalist Islamic people, do not condone terroristic murder to advance their cause, and indeed rightly see it as doing actual DAMAGE to that cause.

Can't say I wouldn't be tempted to adopt that position were I in their shoes.

-Ben

Whilst that may, or may not, be true, you do not know that Alam shares this position, or even if he's a Muslim. Spitfire seemed to bring up this info because he felt it was relevant - and it is only relevant if you assign these beliefs to Alam or his co-workers based on the singular fact that they are from Pakistan. Ergo, it is racist.

Guys, we don't need to go down this route. The paper and the journal are shoddy enough without the need for these types of claims, which are the every definition of ad hominems.
 
No, but the allegation that because this Journal is published in Pakistan automatically means that the Editor-in-Chief is a credulous dupe is.


Where did I say any of this? Frankly, you're really jumping to conclusions here.


Where this journal is published, and the nationality of its founder, is irrelevant.


The issue, as I see it, is how this junk paper made it into a supposedly peer-reviewed journal. I think that potential political bias of the editorial staff and/or peer reviewers is a perfectly legitimate avenue of inquiry.
 
Last edited:
Whilst that may, or may not, be true, you do not know that Alam shares this position, or even if he's a Muslim. Spitfire seemed to bring up this info because he felt it was relevant - and it is only relevant if you assign these beliefs to Alam or his co-workers based on the singular fact that they are from Pakistan. Ergo, it is racist.

Guys, we don't need to go down this route. The paper and the journal are shoddy enough without the need for these types of claims, which are the every definition of ad hominems.


Perhaps I should have made myself clearer in my first post; I didn't mean to imply that I'm sure that this is the case. I just feel that the matter warrants further investigation.
 
Where did I say any of this? Frankly, you're really jumping to conclusions here.

So why did you think that the info your provided was relevant, then? All it said was that some people in Pakistan think 9/11 was an inside job. So what? Some people in America think that 9/11 was an inside job.

If you think this is relevant at all, you want to confer the stereotypical view of the opinions of Pakistanis onto Mr Alam, simply because he also happens to be Pakistani. That's textbook racist ad hominem.

You don't know what Mr Alam believes, or even if he's a Muslim. That you assume to know (or presume) based purely on his nationality is inappropriate, unnecessary and, yes, racist.
 
Perhaps I should have made myself clearer in my first post; I didn't mean to imply that I'm sure that this is the case. I just feel that the matter warrants further investigation.

Well, I don't, really. Mr Alam (as we've already discussed) probably had nothing to do with the peer-review or the decision to publish in the first place. His nationality is basically irrelevant to the (lack of) quality of his journal or Jones' paper. To pretend otherwise gives the Truthers easy ammo, their favourite kind.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom