[Merged]Peer-reviewed technical paper to appear in mainstream journal

The difference is a Review Paper is intended to be a review of a particular subject -- finding and synthesizing a number of papers, from different authors and backgrounds, into a single collective result. A good Review Paper is actually quite useful. Sometimes one digs up very old or obscure, but valuable, papers. Other times one can use them to chart the state of the art. Finally, the best review paper can actually propose a hypothesis of its own, combining other researchers' limited perspectives of seemingly non-overlapping problems into a single, unified approach.

A Letter is a bit vague. Some journals call this a "Rapid Communication." It's intended to be a less thorough paper in response to brand new results or in a rapidly evolving field, and as such is generally more thesis than hypothesis, inviting follow-up. Often a "Letter" will be revised or added to by the original authors. Bazant and Zhou is one example of this, originally submitted only days after September 11th, and then given some stout appendices later with more thorough calculation and reasoning.

Dr. Jones's paper is neither.
 
Did anyone also notice what they charge to advertise?
Dang....they have 200 of these journals. You wonder if that pays for advertisements across the board or in specific journals? You realize that if they charged $600 dollars per contributor and published 5 every quarter in 200 journals they would make (5*600)200=X. Then calculate X*4 and you get what this company would potentially make before factoring in advertisements. This could potentially be among the most profitable journal publishers. Specifically when you factor in an extremely low overhead of publishing to the web as oppposed to print.
 
Last edited:
Thanks Mackey. When I heard it was to be an Article in a Peer Reviewed Journal I was think a real research article in a major Journal. I guess that was putting the bar a little high for him.

Do you think that any real Journal would be interested in a paper refuting the collapse as a CD? If so, perhaps one of our engineers might like to submit and see what happens.
 
Over at 911Blogger several of the comments to Professor Jones' post have mentioned a similar idea. They seem to think that because Jones has framed his "letter" as points where he and NIST agree, his work is somehow immune from criticism by us because any such criticism would also be directed at NIST. This is, of course, untrue. But the obsession with being debunked is strong among the members of the "truth movement", and I can only speculate why. I wonder if this is a result of having so many of their other claims dismantled that they seek "debunk-proof" methods (such as publishing in a "peer-reviewed journal"). The logical question is why they don't just research their claims first; then the rate of debunking would decrease significantly.
 
Do you think that any real Journal would be interested in a paper refuting the collapse as a CD? If so, perhaps one of our engineers might like to submit and see what happens.

I don't think that result on its own is sufficiently interesting from a scientific standpoint. If you demonstrated techniques for CD in very tall structures, or something about building kinetics like Dr. Seffen did, that might be worth publishing with the CD story as a footnote. Otherwise, there's just not enough content there, in my opinion.
 
Mackey:

Keep us all posted on your communications with the editor.

Thanks.

Eagerly waiting.
 
I don't think that result on its own is sufficiently interesting from a scientific standpoint. If you demonstrated techniques for CD in very tall structures, or something about building kinetics like Dr. Seffen did, that might be worth publishing with the CD story as a footnote. Otherwise, there's just not enough content there, in my opinion.

I figured that would be the likely answer.

It would be safe to say that the title to this thread is a little wrong thopugh. It would seem that Jones' work was not a "Technical Paper", and the Journal doesn't appear to be a "Mainstream Journal" either unless that term is used to me any non-CT one.
 
It may also shed some light on the "suspiciously large" editorial board that R. Mackey mentioned earlier in this thread.

Good God, is there anyone they didn't add to their editorial board? I should e-mail them to see if I can get on it.

http://www.bentham.org/open/tociej/EBM.htm

Editorial Advisory Board:

A.O. Abd El Halim (Canada)
H. Akbari (USA)
A. Altunkaynak (Turkey)

E. Artioli (Italy)
C.A. Balaras (Greece)
J.M.C. Ballarín (Spain)
A.C. Bagtzoglou (USA)
C. Bartuli (Italy)
C. Basaran (USA)
B. Basu (Ireland)
R.C. Batra (USA)
A. Bayraktar (Turkey)
M.G.H. Bell (UK)
B. Bernard (Canada)
P. Birkle (México)
D.G. Blumberg (Israel)
P. Boisse (France)
M. Bojic (Serbia)
F.A. Bombardelli (USA)
J.M. Cabrero (Spain)
G. Campione (Italy)
J.R. Casas (Spain)

H. Ceylan (Turkey)
N. Challamel (France)
T.H.T. Chan (Hong Kong)
J.-H. Chang (Taiwan)
G.Z. Chen (UK)
C.G. Chiorean (Romania)
E.M.N. Chirwa (South Africa)
T. Chmielewski (Poland)
P.C. Chu (USA)
Y.H. Chui (Canada)
R. Clarke ( West Indies)
A.B. Climent (Spain)
P. Clouston (USA)
M.E. Conti (Italy)
L. Damkilde (Denmark)
J.P. De Lima (Portugal)
L.R. Dharani (USA)
L. Di Palma (Italy)
S. Dimova (Italy)
J.G. Duan (USA)
Q. Duan (USA)
D. Edwards (UK)
U. Eicker (Germany)
L. Elefteriadou (USA)
A. Elghazouli (UK)
M. Enoch (UK)
A. Fam (Canada)
M.J. Friedel (USA)
M.I. Friswell (UK)
E. Gal (Israel)
L. Gambarotta (Italy)
L. Gardner (UK)
K. Goulias (USA)
M. Hadi (Australia)
S.M. Hassanizadeh (The Netherlands)
S. Hess (UK)
B. Heydecker (UK)
C.-H. Huang (Taiwan)
G. Huang (Canada)
J.- S. Hwang (Taiwan)
R.L. Hwang (Taiwan)
S. Ivorra (Spain)
A.W. Jayawardena (Hong Kong)
M.K. Jha (USA)
S. Kalogirou (Cyprus)
J.J. Kaluarachchi (USA)
A. Kaveh (Iran)
R. Kianoush (Canada)
G.T. Kleinheinz (USA)
P. Kotronis (France)
M. Krommer (Austria)
G.S. Kumar (India)
A.S.K. Kwan (UK)
M. Lachemi (Canada)
D. Lam (UK)
C.-G. Lee (Canada)
C.-H. Lee (Taiwan)
G.C. Lee (USA)
H.-K. Lee (S. Korea)
J.K. Levy (USA)
R.W. Lewis (UK)
A. Li (China)
Z. Li (USA)
Y.-G. Li (China)
S. Liao (China)
K.-L. Lin (Taiwan)
J.W.V. Lindt (USA)
B.P.Y. Loo (Hong Kong)
G. Lyberatos (Greece)
L.S.V. Lyroudia (UK)
O. Manca (Italy)
H. Mang (Austria)
G. Maier (Italy)
E.C. Marcet (Spain)
T. Marhaba (USA)
G. De Matteis (Italy)
R. Melnik (Canada)
A.M. Memari (USA)
G. Milani (Italy)
A. Mittal (India)
K. Mizumura (Japan)
A. Montanari (Italy)
K.N. Moutsopoulos (Greece)

K.W. Mui (China)
R. Munter (Estonia)
D. Nguyen (France)
J. Niu (Hong Kong)
S. Okamoto (Japan)
H. Ouyang (UK)
K. Palanivelu (S. Korea)
X.G. Qi (China)
P. Qiao (China)
H.S. Rao (India)
P.F. Ricci (USA)
A. Riccio (Italy)
F. Rigas (Greece)
R. Rolfes (Germany)
H. Rubin (Israel)
M. Saje (Slovenia)
M.P. Saka (Turkey)
H. Sayilkan (Turkey)
P. Schleppi (Switzerland)
Y. Shindo (Japan)
H.-Y. Shu (Taiwan)
S.P. Simonovic (Canada)
V.P. Singh (USA)
V. Sladek (Slovakia)
I.F.C. Smith (Switzerland)
S. Sritharan (USA)
M.G. Stewart (Australia)
W.G. Strupczewski (Poland)
I. Takewaki (Japan)
A. Tena-Colunga (Mexico)
T. Tingsanchali (Thailand)
E. Turco (Italy)
D.V. Val (Israel)
J.D. Valiantzas (Greece)
L.S. Vamvakeridou-Lyroudia (UK)
P.C.G. da S. Vellasco (Brazil)
S.P. Verevkin (Germany)
C.M. Wang (Singapore)
Q. Wang (Canada)
S. Wang (Australia)
L. Wang (Hong Kong)
Y.T. Wang (USA)
J.L. Wegner (Canada)
T.S.W. Wong (Singapore)
F. Wu (China)
J.-S. Wu (Taiwan)
Z.Y. Wu (USA)
B. Xu (China)
C.-L. Yang (USA)
D.-X. Yang (China)
Y.B. Yang (Taiwan)
B. Young (Hong Kong)
Y. Xiao (USA)
E.K. Zavadskas (Lithuania)
Z. Zembaty (Poland)
J.Z. Zhai (USA)
X.P. Zhou (China)
E. Zhu (China)
 
I gave two quotes from the Popular Mechanics article where the term "pancake" was used. Here they are:

"Unable to absorb the massive energy... [snip]


You left out the first sentence. Was that on purpose?

Popular Mechanics said:
Once each tower began to collapse, the weight of all the floors above the collapsed zone bore down with pulverizing force on the highest intact floor. Unable to absorb the massive energy, that floor would fail, transmitting the forces to the floor below, allowing the collapse to progress downward through the building in a chain reaction. Engineers call the process "pancaking," and it does not require an explosion to begin, according to David Biggs, a structural engineer at Ryan-Biggs Associates and a member of the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) team that worked on the FEMA report.

"When you have a significant portion of a floor collapsing, it's going to shoot air and concrete dust out the window," NIST lead investigator Shyam Sunder tells PM. Those clouds of dust may create the impression of a controlled demolition, Sunder adds, "but it is the floor pancaking that leads to that perception."

So Shyam Sunder, despite being part of the NIST, which ruled out the "pancake collapse theory", is now inexplicably supporting the "pancake collapse theory" because he used the word "pancaking". How does that work? Have you considered that you might be entirely mistaken about what the "pancake collapse theory" is? Describing the progression of the global collapse as "pancaking" does not mean that one is advancing the "pancake collapse" theory of FEMA.

tanabear said:
So what theory did Popular Mechanics advance for the destruction of the towers, the Pancake Collapse Theory or the Pile-Driver Theory?

There's no such thing as the "Pile-Driver Theory". When global collapse began the entire upper block (the floors above the impact region where the columns failed) was no longer supported, so it fell as a single mass, sequentially crushing each of the intact floors below it and adding the mass of each crushed floor to itself as it progressed downwards. This is often described as "pancaking", and is how tall buildings collapse. It is not a "theory", and it is exactly what PM described above.

NIST also describes this as "pancaking":

NIST NCSTAR 1-3C Sect 3.5.3 said:
Exterior panels from WTC 1 were analyzed to determine if different failure mechanisms were observed for those panels above the impact region and those located below. There were 64 observations from the 12 panels at or below the 95th floor and 74 from the remaining 11panels above the 95th floor. Figure 3-15 spatially displays this information for WTC 1 near the impact region of the north face. Both pictorially and statistically, below the impact zone, the majority of floor truss connectors were observed to be either bent down or completely missing. Failure of the gusset plate welded to the top truss chord was again almost exclusively observed regardless of location. This may be a result of overloading the lower floors as the floors above were "pan-caking." Again, the data for Type B and Type D floor truss connectors was too limited to define any sort of pattern.

NCSTAR 1-3C

Okay, that is what I meant too.

No it isn't. Read it again.

That is what I wrote in a previous post. "The initiation has been theorized either to be truss failure or column failure."

FEMA's "pancake collapse theory" is this: truss connection failures from thermal deformation of floors in the impact region, where the fire was, caused individual floors to detach from the columns and collapse on the floors below, at some point overloading one of them to the point where global collapse was initiated with a "pancake" phenomenon. The theory was never given any sort of official name, but the vague term "pancake collapse theory" has stuck.

NIST showed that this theory was incorrect, because the weight of only a few floors detaching and collapsing in the impact region was determined to not be enough to initiate a "pancake collapse", and because the truss connections were actually observed not to fail but rather to stay connected to the perimeter columns, so that when thermal deformation of the floor trusses made entire floors sag, it actually pulled the perimeter columns inwards to the point where they could no longer support the mass of the floors above (the upper block).

tanabear said:
However, your statement that NIST was not tasked with modeling the global collapse is your opinion. They wrote that one of the goals of their investigation was to determine

"why and how the WTC 1 and 2 (the WTC towers) collapsed after the initial impact of the aircraft, and why and how WTC 7 collapsed;"

They theorized as to "why", inward bowing of the perimeter columns, but not "how" the buildings collapsed. As well, they are still working on WTC7.

They know how the building collapsed. They were not tasked with modeling the entire collapse, and so they didn't. WTC7 has nothing to do with this thread.
 
So what's the betting that a new 'truther' will emerge with the tired old arguments and eventually it'll get around to us asking why the experts in the 'truth' movement haven't had any of their work peer reviewed to which the response will now be "Oh yes they have!" and the argument will then descend into a rehash of this thread.

We've seen it before with the whole Architects and Structural Engineers argument. We ask why there aren't any and then the 'truth' movement throws up A&E911'truth' which is then found to be seriously flawed in both it's membership and it's claims, but that doesn't matter to 'truthers' as all they need is for it to exist because then they can cite it and watch the debate descend into a rehash of every other thread regarding the flaws in A&E911'truth'.

The 'truth' isn't about the truth, it's about winning an argument by attrition. Say something is true enough times, regardless of the repeated arguments countering it, and it will become accepted as 'truth' by those eager to believe.
 
Last edited:
Did anyone also notice what they charge to advertise?

See, I was going to say that I can understand why Dr. Jones would want to publish in a paper that would be accessible by the majority of folks in the "Truth Movement", but I was wondering why legitimate open journals, as opposed to vanity publications, would charge the author instead of simply having some advertising to cover their expenses.

I thought it might be some sort of academic faux-pas to have advertisers, and that might explain it. But apparently that isn't the case here. So what is the deal?
 
Last edited:
I agree. This is why I'm still holding out some optimism. It is possible that the Bentham folks really do want to be a quality journal. If so, they will demonstrate it by responding to professional criticism and applying a high standard of quality.

For the record, Mahmood Alam is the gentleman who responded to my e-mail. It would be unfortunate if he was the real brains behind the operation and all the other professors were simply window-dressing, but so far I have no evidence that this is taking place. I give Mr. Alam credit for acknowledging my letter quickly, that's a good start.

Mahmood Alam responded to me as well. He called me "dear Professor", eventhough I had made no mention of my profession or education in the initial e-mail I sent them.
 
Last edited:
Mahmood Alam responded to me as well. He called me "dear Professor", eventhough I had made no mention of my profession or education in the initial e-mail I sent them.

I think that's just good PR. The British -- especially the ex-British former colonials --- are often VERY title conscious and will get deeply offended if you don't call them by their proper title. But they get less annoyed if you "promote" them by using a title they don't have. Since a lot of the correspondants any journal gets are "professors," it's a safe bet --- the professors will be mollified and the mere lecturers will be flattered.
 
volatile,

Maybe the issue is that Jones can NO LONGER write publishable research. Perhaps he had some sort of brain damage, maybe a silent stroke, maybe Alzheimer's. Because as poor as his published work generally was, it just was not this bad.

-Ben
 
volatile,

Maybe the issue is that Jones can NO LONGER write publishable research. Perhaps he had some sort of brain damage, maybe a silent stroke, maybe Alzheimer's. Because as poor as his published work generally was, it just was not this bad.

This I generally doubt. I'm sure Dr. Jones is familiar with the idea of co-authors. If his ideas were sound, he would be able to get someone to help him whip them into chape. If his ideas had gone completely round the bend, he would be unlikely to come up with the cunning plan of a vanity journal....
 
This I generally doubt. I'm sure Dr. Jones is familiar with the idea of co-authors. If his ideas were sound, he would be able to get someone to help him whip them into chape. If his ideas had gone completely round the bend, he would be unlikely to come up with the cunning plan of a vanity journal....

I agree. So what is going on here? It doesn't matter if he's evil, if he's convinced or if he's just seeking legitimisation; he's going about achieving any of these goals the wrong way.

How can someone clearly capable of writing real papers and getting them published in real journals, and who must, by his profession, know and understand publishing and peer-review, have sunk to such depths of ineptitude?
 
Last edited:
For the record, Mahmood Alam is the gentleman who responded to my e-mail. It would be unfortunate if he was the real brains behind the operation and all the other professors were simply window-dressing, but so far I have no evidence that this is taking place.


Why would that be unfortunate? If Mr. Alam spots a business opportunity (low-cost scientific publishing, possibly motivated by the idea that scientists in the Third World can access more information for free) and hires appropriate experts to help him run it while he manages the "business" aspect of it, I don't see that as a bad thing.

If I decided that what my hometown really needed was a good Thai restaurant, so I decided to start one and hired the best cooks I could find in Bangkok -- does the fact that I myself can't boil an egg detract from my idea?
 
I agree. So what is going on here? It doesn't matter if he's evil, if he's convinced or if he's just seeking legitimisation; he's going about achieving any of these goals the wrong way.
How can someone clearly capable of writing real papers and getting them published in real journals, and who must, by his profession, know and understand publishing and peer-review, have sunk to such depths of ineptitude?


Not if he's an attention whore that wants the spotlight like he had in the early 'Cold fusion' days. Just my $.02
 
I agree. So what is going on here? It doesn't matter if he's evil, if he's convinced or if he's just seeking legitimisation; he's going about achieving any of these goals the wrong way.

How can someone clearly capable of writing real papers and getting them published in real journals, and who must, by his profession, know and understand publishing and peer-review, have sunk to such depths of ineptitude?

Well,.... staring into my magic eight-ball,.... I suspect that he's sufficiently delusional that he has to get The Truth out anyway he can. It's the same reason anyone publishes in a vanity journal; the idea that getting your name and ideas in press trumps the channels you use. And he's failed miserably at all the conventional channels.

Alternatively, this is just another scheme to milk the Truthers for more support. He knows that his audience will not be aware of the subtle differences between real and vanity journals, and he hopes that enough people will cite his vanity article to keep his gravy train alive.

I really suspect a bit of both....
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom