[Merged]Peer-reviewed technical paper to appear in mainstream journal

Welcome to the real world T.A.M !!
People do lie and do bads things to maximize profit.
Now take that lesson and go with it.
 
A little off topic, but this concept of OA has me wondering.

I mean in principle, it is a good idea, free journals for the readers.

However, if the only source of revenue for the OA company is the fee paid by the author for the published articles, is that not a conflict of interest in terms of having the articles properly reviewed.

I mean, is there not an incentive for them to have very loose standards, so as to maximize their revenue???

Thoughts??

TAM:)

In my opinion, there are competing motives here, namely profit and prestige. I can imagine a good open source journal, which can charge more for each publication, but publishes less. If this journal accepts too many bad papers, its stature will decline, and competent researches will tend not to publish there. These competing forces make it hard to predict what will happen with any certainty.
 
However, if the only source of revenue for the OA company is the fee paid by the author for the published articles, is that not a conflict of interest in terms of having the articles properly reviewed.

I mean, is there not an incentive for them to have very loose standards, so as to maximize their revenue???

That's one reason that it's very rare for OA journals to charge authors' fees. As I said, outside of the biology journals -- which have been used to page charges for years, so there's nothing novel or shocking there -- very few OA journals make these charges.

Instead, it's (mostly) the Google model. If you want to access the paper, look at the ads. In many regards, a scientific journal is an advertiser's dream; it's readership will have very specific focused interests and typically have grant money to burn.

Of course, there's a potential conflict of interest THERE, too, as a journal that gets most of its money from Microsoft ads might not want to accept an article entitled "Yet another fundamentally unfixable flaw in Vista security." Since I don't think any business model is entirely free from conflicts of interest, I have to file that under the heading of "pobody's nerfect."

A lot of journals also have other revenue streams, such as subsidies from the professional organization with which they are affiliated, or direct subsidies from foundations and national agencies. I even know some that are run from traditional (book) publishing houses, as a loss leader to bring in new "book" authors. One of my publishers, for example, will sell bound copies of its E-papers for a "moderate" fee -- but still enough to pay for a lot of bandwidth. And, of course, e-publishing is so much cheaper than traditional paper publishing that the companies can make a little revenue go a very long way.
 
I mean, is there not an incentive for them to have very loose standards, so as to maximize their revenue???

Thoughts??


It certainly seems like a model that would require stronger principles on the part of the publisher to uphold properly.

Also, given the stories about Bentham's potential spamming, I have to wonder how S.Jones heard about this publisher...
 
To be fair, Open Access journals are a good idea in theory. The troubles can come from Open access depreciating the value of the content. As well, this OA group appears to be of a "spamming" nature wrt obtaining professors to add to its lists for contributors and editors. Sort of stacking the resume of the journal.

I agree. This is why I'm still holding out some optimism. It is possible that the Bentham folks really do want to be a quality journal. If so, they will demonstrate it by responding to professional criticism and applying a high standard of quality.

For the record, Mahmood Alam is the gentleman who responded to my e-mail. It would be unfortunate if he was the real brains behind the operation and all the other professors were simply window-dressing, but so far I have no evidence that this is taking place. I give Mr. Alam credit for acknowledging my letter quickly, that's a good start.
 
It certainly seems like a model that would require stronger principles on the part of the publisher to uphold properly.

Also, given the stories about Bentham's potential spamming, I have to wonder how S.Jones heard about this publisher...
I think with the proper editor and writers, this could make a good 60 minutes type story.

Vanity press lowers standards; tick, tick, tick

Bad to turn down a paper, the company looses money. They can shotgun the paper to 20 reviewers, the 3 or 4 that pass it, become the peer review group; cash check, publish paper. FAST TRACK your paper with .6k.

Who is disparate enough to pay 600 bucks? Jones! Funny if the movement dries up before he gets some paid speaking events to pay for their Holiday Inn Express and earn back the 600 bucks.
 
There are a tonne of scientists that would pay $600 to have their articles published. It is how scientists climb the ranks, gain prestige, etc...

With prestige and fame come more grants, more research, more publishing, and so on, and so on...

TAM:)
 
LasL's last post, especially the link he didn't directly quote, might clear that up for you.

They're unprofessional charlatans from their very core - to wit, they invite people with no experience whatsoever in the relevant fields to be on the editorial board of their journals.

Beyond the fact that the article was a joke, the Journal is Spam. for profit. on line... garbage, just like your article.

And another complete debunking. In what, Jones? 24 hours?

Now we absolutely dismantled your "Woournal's" "put option" garbage article in about 6 hours.... but this was over the weekend.... so I'll call it a tie.

Congrats on getting published though..... tee hee hee!!
 
I kind of figured the journal would have this tid bit...

Manuscripts must be submitted by one of the authors of the manuscript, and should not be submitted by anyone on their behalf. The principal/corresponding author will be required to submit a Covering Letter along with the manuscript, on behalf of all the co-authors (if any). The author(s) will confirm that the manuscript (or any part of it) has not been published previously or is not under consideration for publication elsewhere. Furthermore, any illustration, structure or table that has been published elsewhere must be reported, and copyright permission for reproduction must be obtained.

http://www.bentham.org/open/tociej/MSandI.htm

So I will assume then that the article they submitted to this journal is (A) not published in any other journal (including JONES) and not under consideration elsewhere.

TAM:)
 
Did someone say conflict of interest?

Once the paper is accepted for publication, the author will receive by email an electronic invoice. The fee form is also available on the Web site at www.bentham.org/open/feeform Submissions from the Editorial Board Members of the journals will receive a special discount of 50% on the total publication fee. Submissions by authors from developing countries will receive a discount of 30% on the total publication fee charge.
Emphasis mine.

Sadly, there are legitimate arguments to be made for journals to push publication costs back in the direction of the funding agencies (via the researchers) and away from the subscribers. Too bad this is starting to look like more of a moneymaking scheme than anything.
 
Wow....I think I'm beginning to understand why Jones picked this journal to submit his JAQ-off piece.

Seems like they're pretty much accepting anything.
 
whois

Domain ID:D24662417-LROR
Domain Name:BENTHAM.ORG
Created On:11-Apr-2000 10:11:39 UTC
Last Updated On:17-Nov-2007 08:31:20 UTC
Expiration Date:11-Apr-2010 10:11:39 UTC
Sponsoring Registrar:Abacus America Inc dba Names4Ever (R14-LROR)
Status:OK
Registrant ID:PRPKY
Registrant Name:Dr. Mark Dekker/Dr. Mansoor Alam www.bentham.org
Registrant Organization:Bentham Science Publishers Ltd www.bentham.org
Registrant Street1:P.O Box. 1673, 1200 BR
Registrant Street2:
Registrant Street3:
Registrant City:Hilversum
Registrant State/Province:--
Registrant Postal Code:00000
Registrant Country:NL
Registrant Phone:+1.31356257290
Registrant Phone Ext.:
Registrant FAX:
Registrant FAX Ext.:
Registrant Email:[email protected]
Admin ID:PJ5TQ
Admin Name:Dr. Mark Dekker/Dr. Mansoor Alam www.bentham.org
Admin Organization:Bentham Science Publishers Ltd www.bentham.org
Admin Street1:P.O Box. 1673, 1200 BR
Admin Street2:
Admin Street3:
Admin City:Hilversum
Admin State/Province:--
Admin Postal Code:00000
Admin Country:NL
Admin Phone:+1.31356257290
Admin Phone Ext.:
Admin FAX:
Admin FAX Ext.:
Admin Email:[email protected]
Tech ID:PEVSK
Tech Name:Dr. Mansoor Alam
Tech Organization:Bentham Science Publishers Ltd
Tech Street1:PO Box 927010
Tech Street2:
Tech Street3:
Tech City:Hilversum
Tech State/Province:--
Tech Postal Code:786786
Tech Country:NL
Tech Phone:+1.920214965253
Tech Phone Ext.:
Tech FAX:
Tech FAX Ext.:
Tech Email:[email protected]
Name Server:NS1.SECURE.NET
Name Server:NS2.SECURE.NET
 
Last edited:
Why did Jones, who can obviously write publishable research (he does have a PhD, after all), who understands publishing and who watered down his claims so much as to make them extraordinarily subtle (for the most part), not send this to a real journal? I mean, if he honestly thought it was legitimate, worthwhile and publishable, he'd have submitted it somewhere sensible off the bat. It's as if he knows exactly what level of crap he's pushing or something, but is too embarrassed to admit it to himself.

He must have realised what an illegitimate vanity journal this was (or, if we're being charitable, would be perceived as), so why pick it? With a little care and a little savvy, he could have gotten something along the same lines published somewhere sensible. Mackey's pointed out several legitimate areas suggesting routes of further inquiry into NIST, and a real paper exploring those in any depth would be publishable.

So what's he up to? If he's deliberately trying to get "in the literature" for credibility purposes, he's gone about it the wrong way. If he really, genuinely believes in the conspiracy theories and he's legitimately interested in researching the issues he purports to be interested in, he's going about it the wrong way. Hell, even if he knows everything he writes is a crock and he's pushing some ideological, egotistical or financial scam, he's going about it the wrong way. He just seems so... inept. This is clumsy, stupid, fool-hardy, immature, naive and silly. What the hell is he playing at?
 
Last edited:
I've wondered that myself for years.

The fact is, there are lots of papers that dispute NIST. Published. In real journals, big famous ones even. Cited, influential, filled with useful information and new perspectives.

The major difference between these other researchers and Dr. Jones, as far as I can tell, is that these folks know that a problem with NIST !=> explosives brought down the Towers. That is about the absolute last thing one would propose as an explanation. See Dr. Irfanoglu, Dr. Astaneh-Asl, Dr. Lane, Dr. Usmani, or Dr. Quintiere for details, just to name a few.
 
This is clumsy, stupid, fool-hardy, immature, naive and silly. What the hell is he playing at?


Perhaps Stephen Jones is secretly conducting an experiment where he's testing how far he can completely sucker people into absolutely nothing. If there's anything that proves the truthers are complete suckers, it's the 100% support this is getting over at 911Blogger.

The only rational explanation, in my mind, is that Jones knows that the entire 9/11 Truth Movement is a fraud and is milking it for all it's worth. If the truthers are naive enough to think that donating to Ron Paul's retirement fund or Alten's book sales is "activism," then why not con them into believing that he's a world-renowned physicist? I'm sure his speaking fees will increase now that he's "Peer-reviewed & Published" Steven Jones.

Agree with it or not, so far it's working on the absent-minded truthers.
 
Last edited:
There's another incongruity with Dr. Jones's approach.

Suppose you're a researcher. You want to publish a result, but you don't think it's quite good enough for the ASCE or J.Apl.Phys yet. What do you do? Do you submit it to a third-rate journal from Pakistan?

No, not usually. Usually what you do is write and present a conference paper.

Conference papers are generally reviewed with much less scrutiny and insistence on iron-clad results. They allow more speculation and work-in-progress. As it should be. The Conference is an opportunity to discuss your method with other scientists and get useful suggestions. These papers are also a well-established stepping stone to a polished journal paper, which then becomes (after review and acceptance) authoritative in the field.

Why are these people not appearing at conferences? I do about six a year, was at one just last week. That is what a normal researcher would do. That's what I and all of my colleagues do.

Of course, if they pull this unverified thermite nonsense, they'll be laughed out of town, but I trust Dr. Jones and company have enough decorum, integrity, and sense to present only that which they can support.
 
Last edited:
Okay, for those of us whose Journal knowledge extends to being able to find the articel we want, what is the difference between a Review Paper and a Letter?
 
Did anyone also notice what they charge to advertise?
Ads are placed on the Bentham OPEN home page. Up to three ad banners can be placed in rotation at any time.

CENTRAL BANNER
468 x 60
Most prominent position on site.
Repeated on all subsequent page views.
$5000 per 3 months
minimum 3 months

LEFT HAND BANNER
150 x 294
Repeated on all subsequent page views $2000 per 3 months
minimum 3 months

LEFT HAND BANNER
150 x 294
For specific OA journal home page $800 per 3 months
minimum 3 months

RIGHT HAND BANNER
150 x 294
For specific OA journal home page $800 per 3 months
minimum 3 months
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom