[Merged]Peer-reviewed technical paper to appear in mainstream journal

Here's an interesting commentary about Bentham...

Chris Reed, Distinguished Professor of Chemistry (University of California, Riverside), offers the following modest proposal on CHMINF-L:

Colleagues:
In last week's interesting CHMINF-L discussion on Nature's proliferation of new journals, faculty habits, and the serials market, I saw no mention of an ongoing parallel onslaught by Bentham. In the past month, I have received no less that three invitations to join the editorial boards of new Bentham journals -- "Current this", "Frontiers of that" -- none in areas of my real expertise.

The same old tactics are being used: exploiting a faculty weakness for seeing one's name in print, offering a career advance by having Editorial Board appointments on one's CV at promotion time, flattering authors with invitations to contribute papers in special issues, etc. All this effectively silences faculty from speaking out, or even caring about, the issues librarians understand so well. It is one of the reasons I am advocating that promotion policies at the University of California specify that appointments to the editorial boards of low quality, overpriced journals should count against promotion. The idea may not be so outrageous in five or ten years time.

...

PS. In case you are wondering, yes, I did hit the delete key on those Bentham invitations.


Here is another:

http://www.library.yale.edu/~llicense/ListArchives/0804/msg00027.html
 
Last edited:
Sizzler, $600 is the difference between me eating and not eating. Maybe for YOU it is nothing, but not for many of us here. Should you care to give me the $600, as it means nothing to you, I will be happy to refute Jones' incompetent rambling letter.


Maybe if you had the same enthusiasm making money as you do debunking the wooo you would be able to eat. Your statement is very telling of the cult that is debunkers.
 
You did indeed say that, and you said it right here.

Those experiments have been conducted, and they are Bazant & Zhou (2002), Bazant & Verdure (2003), Bazant, Le, Benson, and Greening (in press), and Seffen (2008). And the answer is Yes.

This is what I wrote in the post you linked to,

"First, someone needs to demolish a building(i.e. a steel-frame high-rise) with fire and impact damage the way WTC 1,2 and 7 were destroyed. The collapse must mirror the dynamics of the actual collapse of those buildings. That would falsify my belief that those buildings must have been destroyed by explosive charges. Where can I see experimental verification? Words on paper don't count."

So where did I say that I require a plane to impact the building? I merely stated, "fire and impact damage." As I stated in a previous post, one can use other means to simulate the impact damage from the plane.

Bazant, Greening, and Benson have written papers. I'm referring to an actual experiment that can verify their hypothesis. Einstein had his theory of general relativity, but it still needed to be proven via the experimental method. So in steps Sir Arthur Eddington to prove that Einstein is correct. He conducts an experiment to see how much light is bent by the sun during a solar eclipse in 1919. If the experimental method is good enough for Einstein, then it is good enough for Bazant, Greening and Benson.
 
This is what I wrote in the post you linked to,

"First, someone needs to demolish a building(i.e. a steel-frame high-rise) with fire and impact damage the way WTC 1,2 and 7 were destroyed. The collapse must mirror the dynamics of the actual collapse of those buildings. That would falsify my belief that those buildings must have been destroyed by explosive charges. Where can I see experimental verification? Words on paper don't count."

So where did I say that I require a plane to impact the building? I merely stated, "fire and impact damage." As I stated in a previous post, one can use other means to simulate the impact damage from the plane.

Ah, I see. You're merely nitpicking that your previous post didn't actually specify an aircraft collision, even though it did specify a skyscraper. Nonetheless, you said you demanded to see it in full-scale. That's the whole point. You require someone to destroy a skyscraper for you.

If you understood the physics, you'd accept that this is unnecessary.

Bazant, Greening, and Benson have written papers. I'm referring to an actual experiment that can verify their hypothesis. Einstein had his theory of general relativity, but it still needed to be proven via the experimental method. So in steps Sir Arthur Eddington to prove that Einstein is correct. He conducts an experiment to see how much light is bent by the sun during a solar eclipse in 1919. If the experimental method is good enough for Einstein, then it is good enough for Bazant, Greening and Benson.

Mathematics is a way of experimentation.

The mathematics happens to match observed phenomena in both WTC 1 and WTC 2. This is not, therefore, prediction of a previously unobserved natural behavior. For that reason, the actual collapses are sufficient. There is no parallel between this result and the predictions of general relativity.
 
http://www.bentham.org/open/tociej/index.htm
The Open Civil Engineering Journal
Aims & Scope

The Open Civil Engineering Journal is an Open Access online journal, which publishes research articles, reviews, and letters in all areas of civil engineering.

The Open Civil Engineering Journal, a peer-reviewed journal, aims to provide the most complete and reliable source of information on recent developments in civil engineering. The emphasis will be on publishing quality articles rapidly and freely available to researchers worldwide.

Yes, but,...

as a review article, it's terrible. Bad to the point of being deceptively misleading, since it leaves out whole areas of the literature it is attempting to "review."

It is, to quote the journal, neither "complete" nor "reliable"; it is about as far from a "quality" article as it's possible to get without the actual manuscript being received in crayon.
 
I know exactly how much a NASA engineer makes and I can spare $600, but your proposal is ludicrous.

I quite agree. For the record, while I would be loathe to characterize $600 as "chump change," I could certainly afford the fee. What I'm not sure I could afford is the terrible, terrible hit my professional credibility would take if I were to take that "letter" seriously enough to respond to it. The effect would be that I would actually lend more credibility to Jones and his incompetent theories than I would garner myself.



The basic error with this "letter" of Dr. Jones's is that (a) it is terribly written, and (b) it is a procedural mistake. It isn't a ground-breaking result that demands scientific challenge. It's an embarrassment that should be quietly disposed of. Publishing a rebuttal would only accentuate the problem.

Nailed it in one, you did.

I'm trying to help a fledgling publisher avoid a minefield that they seem to have accidentally stepped in.

I'm still on the fence about "accidental" -- I don't know whether Bentham is a vanity journal or not. God knows there's enough minor journals that I don't know about that are just strugglingly legitimate.

My hope is that this style of peer review doesn't point the way for Bentham down the path to the Dark Side.
 
I'm still on the fence about "accidental" -- I don't know whether Bentham is a vanity journal or not. God knows there's enough minor journals that I don't know about that are just strugglingly legitimate.

My hope is that this style of peer review doesn't point the way for Bentham down the path to the Dark Side.

LasL's last post, especially the link he didn't directly quote, might clear that up for you.

They're unprofessional charlatans from their very core - to wit, they invite people with no experience whatsoever in the relevant fields to be on the editorial board of their journals.
 
Here's an interesting commentary about Bentham...




Here is another:

http://www.library.yale.edu/~llicense/ListArchives/0804/msg00027.html

Very interesting...the light is beginning to fall upon the shadows...

From the above link...

Not only does Bentham spam for authors. They are also spamming for editors.

I was particularly pleased with the following:

Based on your record of contributions in the field of Education, I would like to invite you to submit to me your CV with current list of publications so that we may consider you as a possible *Editorial Board Member* for the journal.

Since I my record in the field of Education is nil, I feel particularly well-qualified. I have never written a thing in an Education journal.

priceless.

TAM:)
 
Last edited:
Look here....

http://gunther-eysenbach.blogspot.com/2008/03/black-sheep-among-open-access-journals.html

My first spam award goes to Bentham Publishers, a "publisher" of "over 200" author-pays open access journals. In the past couple of months I have received no less than 11 emails from Bentham, all mostly identical in text and form, all signed by "Matthew Honan, Editorial Director, Bentham Science Publishers" or "Richard Scott, Editorial Director, Bentham Science Publishers", "inviting" me to submit research articles, reviews and letters to various journals (I got one email per journal!), including "The Open Operational Research Journal", "Open Business Journal", "Open Management Journal", "Open Bioinformatics Journal", "Open Ethics Journal", "Open Analytical Chemistry Journal" and so on - all of them sent to me "because of your eminence in the field" (wow, I didn't know I was so eminent in so many fields! As an aside, the claim that "this is no spam because you are eminent" defies any commonly accepted definition of spam - a message is spam if it is bulk and unsolicited, whether the recipients are all Nobel prize winners or not is irrelevant).

All pleas and begging from my side to stop the spamming, as well as clicking on any "unsubcribe" links did not stop the spam plague from Bentham.

The bulk email "invites" me to submit articles and to pay for publication - "modest open access publication costs are usually covered by the author's institution or research funds.".

or here

http://www.freelists.org/archives/neuroling/10-2007/msg00000.html
http://www.daniel-lemire.com/blog/archives/2008/03/05/spam-journals-or-open-journals/
 
Last edited:
LasL's last post, especially the link he didn't directly quote, might clear that up for you.

It's certainly suggestive.

They're unprofessional charlatans from their very core - to wit, they invite people with no experience whatsoever in the relevant fields to be on the editorial board of their journals.

May I nitpick? (How would you stop me?)

They invite people with no experience whatsoever to apply for consideration to be possible members of the editorial board.

This might simply be an attempt to get the widest possible coverage for their journals, esp. from people who would not otherwise be "in the know" and on the standard distribution lists.

Or it might be blatant spam for a vanity journal. I'm still not yet ready to make the ignorance vs. evil declaration.
 
Last edited:
LasL's last post, especially the link she didn't directly quote, might clear that up for you.


It may also shed some light on the "suspiciously large" editorial board that R. Mackey mentioned earlier in this thread.
 
Last edited:
I was originally thinking that bad mouthing this so called "Journal" would be in bad taste and make us realists look like we are desperate and/or nervous about a truther paper getting accepted. I tell you, I changed my mind quick after reading the endless sites showing what type of a racket this company is.

Dr. Jones knows the idiots of the world (his followers) will not do any research on the contents of what he wrote, nor will they be interested in validity of their peer review process.
 
Or it might be blatant spam for a vanity journal. I'm still not yet ready to make the ignorance vs. evil declaration.

Well, maybe. But when they're sending invitations to the same people to be on journals covering topics as disparate as "Education" and "Sleep", the needle's swinging quite heavily towards spam.
 
To be fair, Open Access journals are a good idea in theory. The troubles can come from Open access depreciating the value of the content. As well, this OA group appears to be of a "spamming" nature wrt obtaining professors to add to its lists for contributors and editors. Sort of stacking the resume of the journal.

TAM:)

Edit:

This guy,

http://www.richardpoynder.co.uk/

apparently a journalist who has focused on OA journals, is the guy who sent out the warning about Bentham's solicitation practices.

here is the letter he sent out...

ear All,

I would be grateful if anyone could help me. I am interested in an Open
Access publisher called Bentham Science Publishers
(http://www.bentham.org/). I have been contacted by a number of researchers
who say that the company is bombarding them with invitations to contribute
papers to its journals. Apparently requests by the recipients to remove them
from Bentham's mailing list have little or no effect.

I have tried to make contact with a number of people in the company
including Richard Scott, who is most often the person whose name appears at
the bottom of the invitation letters, and was until recently listed as the
editorial director of the company on its web site
(http://www.bentham.org/Contact.php). I also copied into my emails Bentham's
US contact Richard Morrissey, and Matthew Honan, who earlier this year was
also described as the company's editorial director
(http://www.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/2008/01/bentham-oa-publishing-program.html). Likewise I copied in Professor Thomas Salt, since he too has signed
some of the offending emails in his capacity as Editor-in-Chief of a Bentham
journal called Current Neuropharmacology. Tom Salt appears to be based in
the Department of Visual Science at the Institute of Ophthalmology in
London.

Despite all my attempts to make email contact with the company and its
representatives, however, the only response I have received has come from
someone called Mahmood Alam who seems to be based in Pakistan. He informed
me that Richard Scott was too busy to speak with me, but invited me to email
my questions to him. After I sent some questions through to Mahmood Alam,
however, he failed to answer them.

I have also tried calling the telephone numbers listed on the Bentham web
site, but have only been able to get through to voice mail messages. The
number listed for Richard Morrissey simply invites callers to email him (the
address given is the one that I have failed to get any response from).

I would be most grateful if anyone who has any knowledge of Bentham, or any
experience of publishing with the company, or editing any of its journals,
or anyone who regularly reads any of the Bentham journals, could contact me
on: richardpoynder1 -- o2.co.uk.

Thank you.

Richard Poynder
www.richardpoynder.co.uk

https://arl.org/lists/sparc-oaforum/Message/4293-P.txt

I wonder if he would be interested as to the type of content one of the Bentham OA journals is publishing?

TAM:)
 
Last edited:
Edit:

This guy,

http://www.richardpoynder.co.uk/

apparently a journalist who has focused on OA journals, is the guy who sent out the warning about Bentham's solicitation practices.

I wonder if he would be interested as to the type of content one of the Bentham OA journals is publishing?

TAM:)

I'm sure he'd be fascinated. You should contact him and refer him to this thread.
 
A little off topic, but this concept of OA has me wondering.

I mean in principle, it is a good idea, free journals for the readers.

However, if the only source of revenue for the OA company is the fee paid by the author for the published articles, is that not a conflict of interest in terms of having the articles properly reviewed.

I mean, is there not an incentive for them to have very loose standards, so as to maximize their revenue???

Thoughts??

TAM:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom