Medicine should be taught in high school

I guess I'm wondering what the evidence is that supports the idea that taking half courses of antibiotics contributes more to antibiotic resistance than full courses do.
I've repeated it myself a hundred times, but when I was asked about it, I realised that I'd never actually seen the evidence.

Well if it didn't it would be a real kick in the teeth for the theory of evolution.
 
Well if it didn't it would be a real kick in the teeth for the theory of evolution.

Why?

What we're talking about is how when you take antibiotics, you don't kill off ALL the bacteria in your body, even when you take a full course. All (or most, or some) of the "survivors" will then be more inclined to be able to resist antibiotics. It makes sense that the ones left after a full course are better at resisting antibiotics than the ones left after a half course.

Of course, making sense doesn't automatically make it true.
 
NO, it shouldnt. phlebotomy certification was NOT THAT COMPLICATED but about one person in a class of 8-10 still failed. I cant imagine how many idiots would mess up more complicated things like drug interactions. hell nurses catch drug interaction problems after drs prescribe stuff all the time, having a system with multiple people checking on things like that saves people a lot of pain (and possibly deaths).
 
Why?

What we're talking about is how when you take antibiotics, you don't kill off ALL the bacteria in your body, even when you take a full course. All (or most, or some) of the "survivors" will then be more inclined to be able to resist antibiotics. It makes sense that the ones left after a full course are better at resisting antibiotics than the ones left after a half course.

Of course, making sense doesn't automatically make it true.

The way I understand it, taking a partial course of antibiotics would select for a population of bacteria which includes fully and partially resistant strains, whereas a full course only selects a smaller population of fully resistant bacteria.

Assuming that the fully resistant bacteria don't become significantly better at surviving other selection pressures, a smaller population will take longer to become the dominant strain.
 
NO, it shouldnt. phlebotomy certification was NOT THAT COMPLICATED but about one person in a class of 8-10 still failed. I cant imagine how many idiots would mess up more complicated things like drug interactions. hell nurses catch drug interaction problems after drs prescribe stuff all the time, having a system with multiple people checking on things like that saves people a lot of pain (and possibly deaths).
The point of medical education isn't to test people, its to teach them how to keep their own butts out of medical trouble, as good as possible. If people refuse to learn, its their own damn fault. Did I mention schools need to be privatized and tests need to be abolished? Well I did now.

Assuming that the fully resistant bacteria don't become significantly better at surviving other selection pressures, a smaller population will take longer to become the dominant strain.
The time it takes your average joe bacteria to double its number is 20 minutes. Whatever the disparaging quota of resistant and vulnerable bacteria is, killing *all* the vulnerable only means more Lebensraum for the resistant ones. And within two hours, your resistant strain has higher numbers than the vulnerable strains.

Bacteria are very extreme when it comes to showing how evolution works.

Luckily, without antibiotics, civilization is not going to crumble. What's going to be used instead, is phage therapy. Bacteriophages are virae that kill bacteria, but are harmless to humans. (edit: Perhaps, maybe. Beware of the Androphage superstrains!)
 
The bacteria-resistance info is more complicated than you guys are making it out to be.

If a strain of bacteria is highly sensitive to an antibiotic and the antibiotic can eradicate all bacteria, no resistance will develop.

If the bacteria is sensitive enough that the course of antibiotics can kill off enough so that the immune system can take care of the rest then no resistance will develop.

If the bacteria are not completely killed by a full course and the immune system cannot eradicate them completely -- they become colonizers -- then a full course of antibiotics is more likely to produce resistance than a half course because it puts more pressure on those colonizing bacteria. But the reason the full course is prescribed (with this full knowledge) is to beat the infection back to a level so that the body can do most of the rest -- colonizers are better than pathogens running wild for the person infected.

Then we have to throw in plasmids, which just adds another wrinkle.

As to what constitutes a full course and what a half course, well those are just made up periods of time. When antibiotics are tested, we have to decide on an experimental paradigm, so we have to choose a number of days to give the antibiotic. Ever notice that the course is generally either seven or ten or fourteen days? That is because that is what the studies called for, so the practice simply continues. It is usually overkill.

When dealing with a strain of bacteria that is easy to kill with a "full course" of antibiotics, taking a lesser amount puts pressure on the organisms to develop resistance. In that case, a full course is better than a half course (because full course with our immune system can eradicate the infection). But when we're talking about bacteria that we cannot clear completely (and staph aureus is a good exmaple) then a full course of antibiotics will be more likely to produce resistance.

It all depends on what kind of organism is under discussion. No blanket statement can be made about half-course/full-course and resistance.
 
It's two things that speak against the theory.

I simply don't buy that in any one instance, the full course can kill all bacteria (with the help of the immune system) while the half course couldn't (with the help of the immune system)

You aren't dying when you're doing the half course. You get better, because the immune system has the pathogens under control. Cleaning up is just aftermath. Of course you're still somewhat vulnerable to relapse, which may well be the true reason why you're supposed to take the full couse.

But regardless of me being right about this or not, if you add in the plasmids to the calculation, and the probiotic flora (which is in some cases itself acting pathogenic) in and on the body that will also more than likely develop resistance, which it can share via the plasmids, even over the species barrier. And this probiotic flora cannot be realistically killed because it is almost constantly replenished externally. This alone speaks even more strongly against your theory.

Selection pressure creates selection. You are assuming that "too much selection pressure causes extinction" but the reality of multiple-antibiotics-resistant strains of bacteria proves you wrong. These bacteria didn't occur because someone took an insufficient quantity of antibiotics, they've always been there. The antibiotics - of a full course or a half course - simply removed all the others, and the resistant strains replaced their Lebensraum with ease.
 
Knowing nothing is sometimes better than knowing too little.

I know many people who have read a paperback bestseller or two about psychology etc., and then they make far-reaching conclusions about people whom they dislike, based on the far too little that they know about the subject.
 
I simply don't buy that in any one instance, the full course can kill all bacteria (with the help of the immune system) while the half course couldn't (with the help of the immune system)

Who said it couldn't? The problem arises when half a course or irregular administration of antibiotics results in organisms sticking around longer and making resistance more likely.

This whole thing is just a numbers game. In fact, there seems to be a sweet spot where resistance is more likely to happen -- it isn't as though whole course/half course is the real issue.

The real issue is how effective the antibiotic course is in eradicating organisms. If it is highly effective then you can't get resistance because all the organisms are gone in that particular body. If they aren't very effective, then resistance won't develop very easily because it won't matter much if the organisms are affected by the antibiotic or not. Any bacteria that develop resistance may be able to stick around longer than the others, but since there are always many other factors at play to kill them (immune system, bacteriophages, other bacteria, etc.) the resistant strains are no more likely to make than the non-resistant strains.

In scenario number one (which does happen) there are no bacteria left to be able to produce variability. In scenario number two there are plenty of bacteria to produce plenty of variability but it doesn't matter much if resistance develops.

Resistance does develop in scenario number three -- where there is a strong selection pressure and there are enough bacteria left around to produce lots of variable strains in which a resistant strain is one possibility. That can happen most easily if you have a highly sensitive bacterium and apply only a relatively mild pressure that works but does not eradicate them all (only taking part of a course of antibiotics) or if you have a bacterium that is not going to be completely eradicated by the antibiotic but is still placed under significant pressure. Resistance is likely to develop only if there are still quite a few bacteria left around to produce a significant degree of variability. If there are only a few bacteria floating around and they are kept in check by the immune system at a very low number, then they are simply not going to produce many copies, so there is less chance of new mutations resulting in resistant strains. With this scenario, the limiting factor is the host's life. The number of possible mutations is a product of the number of organisms and time. Eventually resistance should develop in every case where bacteria are not eradicated completely except for the fact that hosts don't live forever. The bacteria in them usually die with the host (many can survive through other means, though). If there are many bacteria left around and the selection pressure is high, then resistance is going to develop. The speed of development depends on the number of bacteria produced in general. It's jsut a numbers game.

So, I'm afraid it just isn't as simple as half-course/whole-course and you've got an answer. It depends on what type of organism you speak of.

You aren't dying when you're doing the half course. You get better, because the immune system has the pathogens under control. Cleaning up is just aftermath. Of course you're still somewhat vulnerable to relapse, which may well be the true reason why you're supposed to take the full couse.

Dying, not dying doesn't matter for the most part. That is a host response and the bacteria don't care. The important matter is the number of organisms left over by a half course vs a full course. It depends on what antibiotic, what organism, and the hosts immune system. There are simply too many factors at play that no one can predict in all cases what will happen.

Besides if half a course is just as effective as a full course, then half a course should produce precisely the same pressure as a full course and exactly the same amount of resistance.

But regardless of me being right about this or not, if you add in the plasmids to the calculation, and the probiotic flora (which is in some cases itself acting pathogenic) in and on the body that will also more than likely develop resistance, which it can share via the plasmids, even over the species barrier. And this probiotic flora cannot be realistically killed because it is almost constantly replenished externally. This alone speaks even more strongly against your theory.

First of all this isn't my theory. This is all just basic evolutionary theory.

As to the other flora, yes, that is a huge problem. The existence of plasmids and the natureal flora in our bodies is one of the reasons why we are going to lose the battle against resistance. It really is just a matter of time. The solution is not half-courses of antibiotics, however. That won't solve anything. Half courses are still going to produce resistance over time.

We're going to lose. That's all she wrote. It's basic biology.

Selection pressure creates selection. You are assuming that "too much selection pressure causes extinction" but the reality of multiple-antibiotics-resistant strains of bacteria proves you wrong. These bacteria didn't occur because someone took an insufficient quantity of antibiotics, they've always been there. The antibiotics - of a full course or a half course - simply removed all the others, and the resistant strains replaced their Lebensraum with ease.

Multi-resistant strains of bacteria prove nothing of the sort. What they prove is that there are multi-resistant strains of bacteria. There are many resons why we have all these different strains, but it is not because drug companies and doctor's promote taking full courses of antibiotics to treat disease and yell at people if they only take half-courses. It is the antibiotics themselves that promote resistance whatever the course.

We do not know if these multi-resistant strains have always been there or if they developed by means of new mutations. Both are possibilities. It is very likely that they were always around at a low level and not particularly selected for. But there is no reason to expect that they would continue to harbor resistances if the presence of resistance did not provide a selective advantage. Other things do kill bacteria after all. Those resistant strains could just as easily be killed off by some weird contingency.
 
Ich said:
We're going to lose. That's all she wrote. It's basic biology.

Even if antibiotics are used very, very sparingly?

I know in areas where antibiotics are user with a lot of caution, resistance in some species is going down. And I read a while back that in households where no one took antibiotics for a few years, resistance goes down to almost nothing in every member of the household. (the flipside being that when one member takes them, every member in the household carries resistant bacteria for over a year).

And I can't believe I'm on W's side, but I think in hospitals maybe alternating phage therapy with antibiotics could reverse what's happening there, too, maybe?

The real issue is how effective the antibiotic course is in eradicating organisms. If it is highly effective then you can't get resistance because all the organisms are gone in that particular body. If they aren't very effective, then resistance won't develop very easily because it won't matter much if the organisms are affected by the antibiotic or not.

The other thing that I'm wondering about (because I've never seen it proven...although I might have just missed it) is...when you have a species of bacteria that you're carrying as flora, and it makes the transition for whatever reason to "infection causing pathogen" for a while...when you get well...do you go back to just carrying that species as flora? Ever? Sometimes? What percentage of the time? And how much do we know about antibiotics affecting that outcome?

Besides if half a course is just as effective as a full course, then half a course should produce precisely the same pressure as a full course and exactly the same amount of resistance.
Perhaps on the pathogen causing your infection, but a full course might create more resistance in other organisms you're carrying as normal flora at the moment?
 
Last edited:
The other thing that I'm wondering about (because I've never seen it proven...although I might have just missed it) is...when you have a species of bacteria that you're carrying as flora, and it makes the transition for whatever reason to "infection causing pathogen" for a while...when you get well...do you go back to just carrying that species as flora? Ever? Sometimes? What percentage of the time? And how much do we know about antibiotics affecting that outcome?

I'd of thought so. Aren't some illnesses caused by bacteria being transferred to the wrong place in the body? I.e. what is harmless in one area can be pathogenic in another.
 
Ivor said:
I'd of thought so.
If that's true (and I'm not saying it is) then a longer course would have to cause more resistance than a shorter course. I can't logically see a way out of that.
But if a longer course causes you to *totally and completely clear* all species affected by the drug, then a longer course would be less harmful when it comes to antibiotic resistance.
I'm just not sure how often either actually happen. Or how many species are effected in what ways, in what degrees, at different lengths of treatment.

Aren't some illnesses caused by bacteria being transferred to the wrong place in the body? I.e. what is harmless in one area can be pathogenic in another.
Well, there are some areas (like your blood) where you're in deep doodoo if any bacteria show up. When you're talking about areas that aren't usually sterile, it's sort of a sliding scale, I think. It's just sort of a roll of the dice if being colonized in that area will be problematic. That kind of stuff is very complex and not well understood.
 
Even if antibiotics are used very, very sparingly?

I know in areas where antibiotics are user with a lot of caution, resistance in some species is going down. And I read a while back that in households where no one took antibiotics for a few years, resistance goes down to almost nothing in every member of the household. (the flipside being that when one member takes them, every member in the household carries resistant bacteria for over a year).

If we use them more sparingly then we can get quite a bit more time out of them. That's why we need to stop the over-prescription of the dang things. People using them for viral infections is very counter-productive. I would also support more research into how long a course is really necessary for each situation. Unfortunately we don't know enough and still go by these made-up guidelines for how long to treat certain infections.

And I can't believe I'm on W's side, but I think in hospitals maybe alternating phage therapy with antibiotics could reverse what's happening there, too, maybe?

If you could get it to work and not scare the bejessus out of every doctor, nurse and phlebotomist in the place.



The other thing that I'm wondering about (because I've never seen it proven...although I might have just missed it) is...when you have a species of bacteria that you're carrying as flora, and it makes the transition for whatever reason to "infection causing pathogen" for a while...when you get well...do you go back to just carrying that species as flora? Ever? Sometimes? What percentage of the time? And how much do we know about antibiotics affecting that outcome?

I don't know absolutely since I'm not in infectious disease, but I would lay lots of money on "they go back to just being flora". I'm pretty sure that information is out there.


Perhaps on the pathogen causing your infection, but a full course might create more resistance in other organisms you're carrying as normal flora at the moment?

It's possible. That is why I mentioned the issue of plasmid transfer in that population up above. It is a real issue. There is a sense in which we are screwed if we do and screwed if we don't. You can say "people don't die if they use only a half course of antibiotics", but that is true only of simple easy to treat infections that people usually don't die of anyway, like strep throat and ear infections. But if you have meningitis, do you want a partial course of treatment?

And if you have strep throat and your doctor gives you half the recommended dose of antibiotic and you get post-streptococcal glomerluonephritis or rheumatic fever are you going to sue him for malpractice because he was trying to save resistance in your gut flora but caused your kidney failure or heart malfunction?
 
If that's true (and I'm not saying it is) then a longer course would have to cause more resistance than a shorter course. I can't logically see a way out of that.
But if a longer course causes you to *totally and completely clear* all species affected by the drug, then a longer course would be less harmful when it comes to antibiotic resistance.
I'm just not sure how often either actually happen. Or how many species are effected in what ways, in what degrees, at different lengths of treatment.


Anytime a group of bacteria is not completely eradicated by an antibiotic, then a longer course of treatment (if that antibiotic affects that bacteria strongly) will produce resistance more easily.

The real question then becomes -- to what degree do our normal flora play into the issue of plasmid transfer of resistance genes. I don't know the complete answer to that.
 
Ich said:
If you could get it to work and not scare the bejessus out of every doctor, nurse and phlebotomist in the place.
Didn't Russia do a lot of research in this area already?
I was under the impression (possible incorrectly) that they figured it out and had quite a bit of success over there with phage therapy.

I don't know absolutely since I'm not in infectious disease, but I would lay lots of money on "they go back to just being flora". I'm pretty sure that information is out there.
That's my "gut feeling", as well...I've just never seen it studied.
IF they do usually just go back to flora, I can't see how a shorter course is more harmful than a longer course. It seems like the opposite should be true.

It's possible. That is why I mentioned the issue of plasmid transfer in that population up above. It is a real issue. There is a sense in which we are screwed if we do and screwed if we don't. You can say "people don't die if they use only a half course of antibiotics", but that is true only of simple easy to treat infections that people usually don't die of anyway, like strep throat and ear infections. But if you have meningitis, do you want a partial course of treatment?
I think meningitis is rare enough to where we could always use the most powerful method available there.

And if you have strep throat and your doctor gives you half the recommended dose of antibiotic and you get post-streptococcal glomerluonephritis or rheumatic fever are you going to sue him for malpractice because he was trying to save resistance in your gut flora but caused your kidney failure or heart malfunction?
Well, I personally wouldn't. But then again I was a chronic GAS carrier for a long time as a kid, and I never cleared it, no matter how much antibiotics I took. The "could you sue your doctor, and what about worst case scenarios?" question is also the reason why some docs give antibiotics for viral infections, from what I understand, since they're thinking that a bad virus can turn into a secondary bacterial infection, which can be deadly, so why not go ahead and assume it's already happening and give antibiotics as a form of prevention.

I'd personally trade a very slight risk of a bad complication of strep throat for an increased chance of being able to keep a limb if I got some horrible necrotizing skin infection.

But that's just me.
 
Anytime a group of bacteria is not completely eradicated by an antibiotic, then a longer course of treatment (if that antibiotic affects that bacteria strongly) will produce resistance more easily.

The real question then becomes -- to what degree do our normal flora play into the issue of plasmid transfer of resistance genes. I don't know the complete answer to that.

I don't know either.
But I do know that quite a bit of the time, the resistance genes are transferred across species. Distant, basically unrealted species.
Which makes me think there's a lot of that going on.
 
Didn't Russia do a lot of research in this area already?
I was under the impression (possible incorrectly) that they figured it out and had quite a bit of success over there with phage therapy.

I don't keep up on that sort of thing, but a promising line of study should be kept open.


That's my "gut feeling", as well...I've just never seen it studied.
IF they do usually just go back to flora, I can't see how a shorter course is more harmful than a longer course. It seems like the opposite should be true.

The course is usually chosen to try and keep the infection at bay. Staph is esecially hard to kill, so courses are often quite long. We're basically operating in the dark, but I think most ID types like to use the shortest course they think they can get away with. But there is just no way for us to know how much antibiotic is the right amount for each and every person in each and every situation.


I think meningitis is rare enough to where we could always use the most powerful method available there.

Yeah, but that was just an example. Replace it with pneumonia in you or your 68 year old grandmother for a more common scenario.


Well, I personally wouldn't. But then again I was a chronic GAS carrier for a long time as a kid, and I never cleared it, no matter how much antibiotics I took. The "could you sue your doctor, and what about worst case scenarios?" question is also the reason why some docs give antibiotics for viral infections, from what I understand, since they're thinking that a bad virus can turn into a secondary bacterial infection, which can be deadly, so why not go ahead and assume it's already happening and give antibiotics as a form of prevention.

I'd personally trade a very slight risk of a bad complication of strep throat for an increased chance of being able to keep a limb if I got some horrible necrotizing skin infection.

But that's just me.

See if you can follow this line of relatives -- my wife's sister's husband's mother successfully sued her doctor because he did not insist that she have a mamogram before the guidelines ever surfaced for them and she got breast cancer.

People will sue doctors over anything when they are pissed. For things they do, things they don't do. It's a jungle out there. And that is one very, very big part of the problem.
 
Ich said:
The course is usually chosen to try and keep the infection at bay. Staph is esecially hard to kill, so courses are often quite long. We're basically operating in the dark, but I think most ID types like to use the shortest course they think they can get away with. But there is just no way for us to know how much antibiotic is the right amount for each and every person in each and every situation.
I guess I was thinking more of the run-of-the-mill "bacterial infection" you'd see a GP for. Those situations where the common person is told "NEVER JUST STOP TAKING YOUR ANTIBIOTICS AS SOON AS YOUR START FEELING WELL".

Those are the situations (the sinus infection, upper respiratory, etc.) where I'm not at this moment convinced the 2 week course is necessarily the way to go to keep bacterial resistance at bay.
If I end up needing antibiotics myself, I'll take the full course. But I've got the idea stuck in my head that it might not be 'the truth' necessarily.


People will sue doctors over anything when they are pissed. For things they do, things they don't do. It's a jungle out there. And that is one very, very big part of the problem.
Yeah...that does suck.
 
People will sue doctors over anything when they are pissed. For things they do, things they don't do. It's a jungle out there. And that is one very, very big part of the problem.

[derail]

Something that amazes me is that no one has sued a doctor for removing their foreskin when they were an infant. Given the victim culture in the US I'd have thought they would stand a good chance of winning.

[/derail]
 
I guess I was thinking more of the run-of-the-mill "bacterial infection" you'd see a GP for. Those situations where the common person is told "NEVER JUST STOP TAKING YOUR ANTIBIOTICS AS SOON AS YOUR START FEELING WELL".

Those are the situations (the sinus infection, upper respiratory, etc.) where I'm not at this moment convinced the 2 week course is necessarily the way to go to keep bacterial resistance at bay.
If I end up needing antibiotics myself, I'll take the full course. But I've got the idea stuck in my head that it might not be 'the truth' necessarily.

Those are almost all over-treated. Those two-week courses, like the seven day courses and the the ten day courses are all made up time periods because the drug trials have to have some set time period for statistical purposes. They always choose a time period that will work for most people but not so long so as to produce increased toxicity, so that the drug looks good. As a consequence the time period is almost always overkill. Then the FDA approves the drug for the treatment of x for two weeks. So, to avoid lawsuits docs use the drug for the treatment of x for 2 weeks.

Some people do relapse if they stop their antibiotics too soon and that is the main thing the docs are trying to prevent. Plus, intermittent dosing and infections that continue for a long period (or set up colonization) are one of the set-ups for resistance development. It's not the only set-up, just one of them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom