Medicine should be taught in high school

Wiki sucks. But it shows they are different. How did you miss that?

Superglue: ethyl-2-cyanoacrylate

Medical glue: 2-octyl cyanoacrylate or n-butyl-cyanoacrylate

You guys are too funny. It's like saying dihydrogen monoxide is the same as hydrogen monoxide. Just try using HO in place of H20 to wash your dishes. I'd love to see you try :D

Uh, how do we post a spoiler thingy? Aw heck...

HO isn't a stable compound... can't wash anything in it.

Or if you take aspirin and compare it to what you'll get just out of the tree. One will cause ulcers, while the other is safer to use.

I'd feel more comfortable using the actual medical glue over buying the compound you find on the store shelf for non-skin uses.

Still, I'll also refrain from giving medical advice to people altogether. What if you superglue some awful gross stuff into your wound? Try getting the superglue off. I'd rather a doctor glue my wound. I'll use a bandage until I get to the doc, I don't go off in the wild and face any horrible bleeding to death instances. How would you superglue a big wound that would cause you to bleed to death anyways. I'll stick to bandages, thank you. More removeable.
 
Last edited:
Wiki sucks. But it shows they are different. How did you miss that?

I didn't miss it. In fact, unlike you, I read the entry. Maybe if you bothered to read stuff, you wouldn't be so confused.


Wiki-
The use of cyanoacrylate glues in medicine was considered fairly early on. Eastman Kodak and Ethicon began studying whether the glues could be used to hold human tissue together after surgery. In 1964, Eastman submitted an application to use cyanoacrylate glues to seal wounds to the United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Soon afterward Dr. Harry Coover's glue did find use in Vietnam—reportedly in 1966, cyanoacrylates were tested on-site by a specially trained surgical team, with impressive results. In an interview with Dr. Coover by the Kingsport Times-News, Coover said that the compound demonstrated an excellent capacity to stop bleeding, and during the Vietnam War, he developed disposable cyanoacrylate sprays for use in the battlefield.
“ If somebody had a chest wound or open wound that was bleeding, the biggest problem they had was stopping the bleeding so they could get the patient back to the hospital. And the consequence was—many of them bled to death. So the medics used the spray, stopped the bleeding, and were able to get the wounded back to the base hospital. And many, many lives were saved. ”

—Dr. Harry Coover

The original Eastman formula was not FDA approved for medical use, however, because of a tendency to cause skin irritation and to generate heat. In 1998 the FDA approved 2-octyl cyanoacrylate for use in closing wounds and surgical incisions. Closure Medical have developed medical cyanoacrylates such as Dermabond, Soothe-N-Seal and Band-Aid Liquid Adhesive Bandage.

See? Isn't that interesting? I thought so. And it also means my buddies at NASA lied to me man. How unfair. Oh cruel world....
 
The biggest difference between hardware store superglue and Dermabond?

That's right: price

;)
 
Now, I've only had intro o chem under my belt, but wouldn't two chemicals where the active groups are the same and the only difference is the ethyl vs octyl group, have less of a chemical difference than, say, H2O vs HO?
 
The removing superglue page:

http://www.supergluecorp.com/removingsuperglue.html

Eyelid
In the event that eyelids are stuck together or bonded to the eyeball, wash thoroughly with warm water and apply a gauze patch. The eye will open without further action within 1-4 days. To our knowledge there has never been a documented case of adhesive in the eye causing permanent damage. Do not try to force eyes open.
 
Now, I've only had intro to chem under my belt, but wouldn't two chemicals where the active groups are the same and the only difference is the ethyl vs octyl group, have less of a chemical difference than, say, H2O vs HO?

Indeed. Very astute, and very on topic. For those who discount Wiki as a source, there is info here
http://www.straightdope.com/mailbag/msuperglue.html
explaining how it was modified for skin use, etc
Although cyanoacrylate glues were useful on the battlefield, the FDA was reluctant to approve them for civilian use. In part, this was due to a tendency of the early compounds (made from "methyl-2-cyanoacrylate") to irritate the skin as the glue reacted with water and cured in the skin, releasing cyanoacetate and formaldehyde. A compound called "butyl-2-cyanoacrylate" was developed to reduce toxicity, but suffered from brittleness and cracking a few days after application. Finally an improved cyanoacrylate glue was developed for medical applications called "2-octyl-cyanoacrylate." This compound causes less skin irritation and has improved flexibility and strength--at least three times the strength of the butyl-based compound (reference 2). As a result, in 1998 the FDA approved 2-octyl cyanoacrylate for use in closing wounds and surgical incisions, and in 2001 approved it for use as a "barrier against common bacterial microbes including certain staphylococci, pseudomonads, and Escherichia coli" (reference 2). This latest incarnation was marketed under the name Traumaseal as well as the more popular Dermabond.

The biggest difference between hardware store superglue and Dermabond?

That's right: price

;)

:i:
 
While I do agree that legalizing narcotics would eliminate eliminate the black market, is it really a good idea to legalize ALL drugs? What about anti-biotics (where the misuse can accelerate the appearance of drug-resistant strains.)

Antibiotics-Abuse is already now a problem. If people are properly taught that antibiotics WILL make the strains in their body immune, and mean that they will not work in the case of an emergency, and that they WILL damage probiotics, that they WILL damage mitochondria permanently, then they'll know better. That's what education is about.

I wasn't suggesting that we shouldn't educate people about antibiotics. I was referring to your argument that drugs should be available without a prescription.

Yes, people do misuse antibiotics (they don't follow doctor's advice and stop taking prescribed ones too soon, for example. And some IV drug users to use antibotics incorrectly to sterilize their equipment.) But that problem will likely get worse from people trying to 'cure' themselves when they get sick. (Regardless of how well we educate people some will misdiagnose themselves.)
 
You don't use antibiotics to sterilize drug equipment, you use disinfectants.

But the amount of antibiotics that humans use is irrelevant when you notice how much animals get fed with the stuff, all the time.

As an individual, not taking the antibiotics full course absolutely doesn't lead to the creation of more resistant strains than abstaining from taking the full course. Its about selective pressure - You won't be able to kill all bacteria, ever, no matter how many antibiotics you take. But the more you take the more you create an environment of prolonged selective pressure. The longer you take em the more resistant your bacteria will become.

Who created this stupid myth? My bet is the pharma industry who doesn't like people rationizing their own antibiotics.
 
You don't use antibiotics to sterilize drug equipment, you use disinfectants.

But the amount of antibiotics that humans use is irrelevant when you notice how much animals get fed with the stuff, all the time.

As an individual, not taking the antibiotics full course absolutely doesn't lead to the creation of more resistant strains than abstaining from taking the full course. Its about selective pressure - You won't be able to kill all bacteria, ever, no matter how many antibiotics you take. But the more you take the more you create an environment of prolonged selective pressure. The longer you take em the more resistant your bacteria will become.

Who created this stupid myth? My bet is the pharma industry who doesn't like people rationizing their own antibiotics.


How are you distinguishing between not taking the full course and abstaining from taking the full course?
 
You don't use antibiotics to sterilize drug equipment, you use disinfectants.
I'm going by memory, but I remember reading an article which pointed out that detroit was one of the bigger problem areas for drug resistance, because heroin users were using antibiotics (somehow) to sterilize their equipment. Sadly, I can't remember all the details (and I can't find any references to the article).

But the amount of antibiotics that humans use is irrelevant when you notice how much animals get fed with the stuff, all the time.
Yes, antibiotic overuse in animals can be a problem, but its not that significant... animals are not fed the latest-and-greatest antibiotics that are used on humans.

As an individual, not taking the antibiotics full course absolutely doesn't lead to the creation of more resistant strains than abstaining from taking the full course. Its about selective pressure - You won't be able to kill all bacteria, ever, no matter how many antibiotics you take. But the more you take the more you create an environment of prolonged selective pressure. The longer you take em the more resistant your bacteria will become.
Just out of curiosity, where exactly are you getting your information? Although I'm not a doctor, I have taken several biology courses at the university level, and although it was a few decades ago, it does seem to conflict with what I've learned.

From the National Institute of Health: http://www.niaid.nih.gov/factsheets/antimicro.htm

Also, when a patient does not finish taking a prescription for antibiotics, some bacteria may remain. These bacterial survivors are more likely to develop resistance and spread.

So, if you do take antibiotics properly, it should kill all the bacteria its targeted against. No survivors means no chance of passing on resistance to future bacteria. Its only when some microbes are left to survive (because the patient stopped drugs early) that reistance is passed on.

Who created this stupid myth? My bet is the pharma industry who doesn't like people rationizing their own antibiotics.

Well, the U.S. government seems quite convinced.
 
As well as the larger healthcare field - not just in America but in other countries, as well.

Has it ever been tested or 'proven' that taking a half course of antibiotics contributes to resistance more than a full course?

I ask because someone asked me about that a couple of weeks ago. Her doctor told her to only take her antibiotics till she started feeling well again, which surprised me.:confused:
 
I'm going by memory, but I remember reading an article which pointed out that detroit was one of the bigger problem areas for drug resistance, because heroin users were using antibiotics (somehow) to sterilize their equipment. Sadly, I can't remember all the details (and I can't find any references to the article).

This is common. There is a widespread belief among the public that antibiotics are effective against all microbes. It's a problem for healthare providers, because there is pressure to overprescribe, since patients often demand antibiotics when it's not indicated.




From the National Institute of Health: http://www.niaid.nih.gov/factsheets/antimicro.htm

Also, when a patient does not finish taking a prescription for antibiotics, some bacteria may remain. These bacterial survivors are more likely to develop resistance and spread.

So, if you do take antibiotics properly, it should kill all the bacteria its targeted against. No survivors means no chance of passing on resistance to future bacteria. Its only when some microbes are left to survive (because the patient stopped drugs early) that reistance is passed on.

Yep. The reason is that antibiotic resistance isn't 'evolved' from selective pressure through genetic mutation - it's passed from cells that have the resistance to those that don't. (see: "plasmids") If you take the full course, the antibiotics will kill off the non-resistant ones, and this will relieve the immune system enough for it to take care of the resistant ones.

If the course isn't completed, or the dose is too low, the resistant ones are provoked to distribute the plasmids, and then all the bacteria in your body have resistance ongoing, since they will pass it on to their daughters. Future antibiotics will not be very effective.

The two main reasons we have runaway resistance are:

  • incomplete courses - patients 'know better' than the instructions on the bottle
  • antimicrobial soaps/gels &c - consumers 'know better' than microbiologists, who publish their research showing how dangerous these products are.
    [/quote]

    The extra problem with the soaps/gels is that these are often the antimicrobials used in hospitals, and the doses are so low and prolonged that it pretty much guarantees a high risk of infection if the consumer is in hospital.

    The point is: both of these problems are caused by the consumer and patient ignoring well-publicised advice.


    This is also a good example of 'a little knowledge being dangerous'. Segnosaur knows enough about adaptation to have developed his own model of how resistance is produced in bacteria. Unfortunately, this is incorrect. Plasmid propagation is a completely different mechanism of resistance development in bacterial populations that is covered in university courses. Along with a million other details that are important in understanding bacterial resistance. eg: why are beta-lactams so obsolete, but others remain stolidly effective? when is the correct time to deploy broad-spectrum? &c.

    Quantity-wise, there is simply too much to know about health - and such rapid change in each field to keep on top of - to be able to manage without referring to specialised experts in each field.
 
blutoski said:
If the course isn't completed, or the dose is too low, the resistant ones are provoked to distribute the plasmids, and then all the bacteria in your body have resistance ongoing, since they will pass it on to their daughters. Future antibiotics will not be very effective.

What I'm wondering is...
Suppose you have an upper respiratory infection with nontypeable h. influenzae. At the same time you're also carrying many other potentially pathogenic bacteria, only at that time, they're behaving as normal flora. When you complete your full course of antibiotics, do the other types of bacteria you're carrying as normal flora develop resistance? Does the, say, streptococcus pneumoniae you're colonized with become more resistant as a result of a full course of antibiotics or a half course?
Has this actually been tested?

ETA:
Another question for anyone with an answer...
Suppose you're colonized with a bacteria, then, for whatever reason it goes nuts and becomes an actual "infection", and you take antibiotics to help you recover. Do you always totally clear that type of bacteria, or does it sometimes/usually go back into a state of asymptomatic carriage in, say, your nose or throat?
 
Last edited:
What I'm wondering is...
Suppose you have an upper respiratory infection with non type able h. influenza. At the same time you're also carrying many other potentially pathogenic bacteria, only at that time, they're behaving as normal flora. When you complete your full course of antibiotics, do the other types of bacteria you're carrying as normal flora develop resistance? Does the, say, streptococcus pneumonia you're colonized with become more resistant as a result of a full course of antibiotics or a half course?
Has this actually been tested?

I doubt it has been researched.

Another question for anyone with an answer...
Suppose you're colonized with a bacteria, then, for whatever reason it goes nuts and becomes an actual "infection", and you take antibiotics to help you recover. Do you always totally clear that type of bacteria, or does it sometimes/usually go back to to a state of asymptomatic carriage in, say, your nose or throat?

Damn good questions. But you are asking about issues that are not simple, nor welcomed. Symptoms are caused by germs, kill the germs, symptoms go away, good health returns. What you are talking about is Orthomolecular Medicine, which is at odds sometimes, with the current paradigm that germs cause illness.
 
:( Can you imagine what I'm going through right now, seriously. My teacher is even diffusing fraccin oils, and they caused me to break out BAD. She did at least agree to stop diffusing them for now. I am clearing up again after a week of no *#$&#(&$ oil diffusion.

Not only that, but with the other students coming out of the high school program already prepped for the crap, I'm on my own. I bite my tongue all day long. I paid 12 grand for this. The curriculum is great, but the teachers have their own ideas.

What would you do? My tongue is and jaw is paying the price. I only have 6 weeks left though.

How long should we wait for things to change so most of the population isn't actually taught such horrendous things in the classroom as impressionable students?

And we wonder why people are so misinformed?
From your description, I'd be having a cow over it. Are you getting support from the principal or the school district? I'm sure any teacher here getting that far off the curriculum would not be tolerated.

When my son was in grade school I tried to get the teacher's interested in subjects like infectious disease prevention and in advertising campaigns that promoted false junk like Airborne. They were just not interested. The health text book had the usual crap on the food pyramid and a bit on not smoking. The rest was so blah I can't even recall what else was in the text. But there was nothing about the simple basics of real health like preventing the spread of infection beyond a reference to hand washing.

And there seems to either be total lack of awareness of how useful it might be to teach kids about advertising and its affects on anything from health to other consumer issues, or there is some political risk of broaching the subject. I think it was the former. I really seem to be in the minority with my concern that the public is so stupid on average when it comes to total lack of awareness about advertising gimmicks and influence.

Critical thinking and skepticism are all part of the same skill set used to recognize false information anywhere, whether it be the aspartame Internet rumor nonsense or advertising Airborne. Why this isn't a priority in school curriculums defies logic.
 
What I'm wondering is...
Suppose you have an upper respiratory infection with nontypeable h. influenzae. At the same time you're also carrying many other potentially pathogenic bacteria, only at that time, they're behaving as normal flora. When you complete your full course of antibiotics, do the other types of bacteria you're carrying as normal flora develop resistance? Does the, say, streptococcus pneumoniae you're colonized with become more resistant as a result of a full course of antibiotics or a half course?
Has this actually been tested?

ETA:
Another question for anyone with an answer...
Suppose you're colonized with a bacteria, then, for whatever reason it goes nuts and becomes an actual "infection", and you take antibiotics to help you recover. Do you always totally clear that type of bacteria, or does it sometimes/usually go back to to a state of asymptomatic carriage in, say, your nose or throat?
Ignore robinson, he doesn't know what he's talking about. ;)

Yes, drug resistant genes develop in any bacteria, pathogen or not, target bacteria or not. And those antibiotic resistant genes can then find their way into pathogens including completely different species and this has been researched.

There has been a lot of research on whether one should strive to eliminate the carrier states of some pathogens such as MRSA. In some cases it does little to impact the cases of disease so it is not recommended and in other cases it might be useful such as before surgery. If the patient is returning to an environment where the microbe is common, eliminating carriers is not useful. When MRSA was more rare, eliminating the carrier state was more commonly done.

You measure the effect of eliminating carriers vs the risk/cost in each case. It is commonly researched to keep recommendations current.
 
Last edited:
Ignore robinson, he doesn't know what he's talking about. ;)

Yes, drug resistant genes develop in any bacteria, pathogen or not, target bacteria or not. And those antibiotic resistant genes can then find there way into pathogens including completely different species and this has been researched.

For the record, I'm not suggesting people take half courses of antibiotics.

But has it ever been tested and proven that a half course is worse for antibiotic resistance than a full course?
Since even with a full course, obviously most of "your" bacteria end up surviving?
 
But has it ever been tested and proven that a half course is worse for antibiotic resistance than a full course?

Staph and Strep are rampant and dangerous, in Hospitals, where full the full course of an antibiotic is assured. Eliminating all but the most hardy of any organism assures a very resistant strain will evolve.

Resistance of Streptococcus pneumoniae to penicillin and other beta-lactams is increasing worldwide. The major mechanism of resistance involves the introduction of mutations in genes encoding penicillin-binding proteins. Selective pressure is thought to play an important role, and use of beta-lactam antibiotics has been implicated as a risk factor for infection and colonization. Streptococcus pneumoniae is responsible for pneumonia, bacteremia, otitis media, meningitis, sinusitis, peritonitis and arthritis.

http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/eid/vol6no5/diekama.htm
 
Last edited:
Community-acquired (CA) methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) infection among individuals without healthcare-associated (HA) risk factors was first recognized about a decade ago. It has now emerged as an epidemic that is responsible for rapidly progressive, fatal diseases including necrotizing pneumonia, severe sepsis and necrotizing fasciitis.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=AbstractPlus&list_uids=17146447
Penicillin-resistant pneumonia (or pneumococcus, caused by Streptococcus pneumoniae) was first detected in 1967, as was penicillin-resistant gonorrhea. Resistance to penicillin substitutes is also known as beyond S. aureus. By 1993 Escherichia coli was resistant to five fluoroquinolone variants. Mycobacterium tuberculosis is commonly resistant to isoniazid and rifampin and sometimes universally resistant to the common treatments. Other pathogens showing some resistance include Salmonella, Campylobacter, and Streptococci.

In November 2004, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) reported an increasing number of Acinetobacter baumannii bloodstream infections in patients at military medical facilities in which service members injured in the Iraq/Kuwait region during Operation Iraqi Freedom and in Afghanistan during Operation Enduring Freedom were treated. Most of these showed multidrug resistance (MRAB), with a few isolates resistant to all drugs tested.
http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5345a1.htm
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom