Medicine should be taught in high school

skeptigirl said:
In addition, while in many cases an infection only ends when the pathogen is eliminated, there are times when the disease process ends but the bacteria, including known pathogens, remain. So taking an incomplete course of antibiotics may make you well while not eliminating the carrier state while a complete course might have eliminated the carrier state.
Can you find a link on how often the carrier state is eliminated with a complete course compared to a incomplete course? Some kind of "compare and contrast" research?
I'm thinking specifically of research in people who don't relapse, since, obviously the bacteria weren't eliminated if there's a relapse.
But in people who do recover, I'm wondering how much we know about a return to the carrier state in them.

So for example, the kids with ear infections whose parents aren't as good about getting the kids to swallow the drug, or whose parents repeatedly stop meds when the kids look OK end up with high rates of antibiotic resistant ear infections.
Can you find a link on that, too?
Not that I'm doubting it, but I'd like to see it for myself, and pass it on next time the subject is brought up somewhere.
 
You are being a tad ridiculous kelly. I am not going to spend more time proving to you how antibiotic resistance occurs and what happens when you don't take a complete course of antibiotics unless you can find something which contradicts what I very carefully explained in my post.

Find something that says what I posted is wrong and I'll see.
 
You're the one that state it as a truth, so I assumed you were familiar with the research that demonstrated it.
I actually think it probably exists somewhere, but when I was asked about it, I realised I'd never seen it. And once I started thinking about it, I realised that there was a chance that pathogenic bacteria go back to a carrier even after a full course of antibiotics quite often, even if their numbers are very small for a while during and post recovery.
I don't know if they do or not. I just think it's an interesting question.
 
You are being a tad ridiculous kelly.

Your comments about ear infections are pretty much BS, I guessed you wouldn't have anything to back them up with. So you call someone ridiculous, to avoid backing up your points. Typical woo tactic.

http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/content/abstract/112/3/527
Objective. Several studies have demonstrated that acute otitis media (AOM) in children can be managed without antibiotics. Because children with AOM have traditionally been treated with antibiotics in the United States, there are concerns that parents may not be comfortable with their children being treated with pain control alone. Recently, Cates in England showed that antibiotic usage for AOM could be decreased by prescribing a safety-net antibiotic prescription (SNAP) to be filled if symptoms do not resolve with observation after 48 hours. It is not clear whether a SNAP will be acceptable to parents in other settings such as the United States. The objective of our study was to determine whether parents in the United States find a SNAP for AOM acceptable and whether antibiotic usage could be decreased by its use.

http://www.aafp.org/afp/20000401/2051.html
Compounding the dilemma is the less than robust effect of antibiotics on acute otitis media. Extensive research during the past two decades has led to doubts about the use of antibiotics for treatment of otitis media. Some physicians' organizations no longer recommend the routine use of antibiotics in uncomplicated acute otitis media.

You seem to be running on out of date knowledge, and just making stuff up. But nice try.


Find something that says what I posted is wrong and I'll see.

What a load of crap. If you want to sound like you know something, be prepared to back it up. This tactic of yours is BS. And you are dumb enough to try and sell it to a bunch of skeptics? Good luck with that.
 
Last edited:
For the record, current medical procedure is to avoid antibiotics unless they are sure there is bacteriological infection. Which is not common. Ear infections are most often from a virus, not bacteria, and they get better on their own More info at links provided.
 
Now you are both being absurd. I went to a lot of trouble to post what I did.

Apparently, you don't get the science and you need something more basic. Claiming that means I haven't proven something is very naive. I realize you are missing the concepts involved here but it's (rule 8) that you put that on my shoulders as if I didn't "prove" something. The fact you lack the background to understand what I posted doesn't go to the credibility of your claims. It goes to the rudeness of your posts.

Maybe If I feel like it later I'll explain what you are misinterpreting about the ear infections, robinson. But in brief, just because you don't treat all of them doesn't mean you never treat any of them.
 
skeptigirl said:
Now you are both being absurd. I went to a lot of trouble to post what I did.
I actually already know a bit about how resistance works, so I don't really need a primer on it. Your links are irrelevant to my questions.

Have you ever seen the actual research that shows how often bacteria go back to a carrier/flora state after a full course of antibiotics compared to a shortened course?
 
Ok. I'm going to explain what I'm thinking.

Even when you take antibiotics, it's still your own immune system that does most of the work to get rid of the excess of whatever bacteria is making you sick. It's your own phagocytes that gobbel them up. Obviously, your immune system is also capable of ignoring this bacteria a lot of the time, too.
(assuming this is a species that can be either flora or pathogen).
Nobody really knows WHAT your immune system does to keep things in check when you're not "sick" with these bacteria. We know there's some small immune response at play, because as people get older, they carry different species for shorter and shorter periods of time. But it can't be a heavy sterilizing immune response, either. It's some kind of mysterious immunological limbo. It's like your immune system mostly has those bacteria on "ignore", but there are a few phagocytes floating around at a low level slowly eliminating different species is a very laid back kind of way.

So....after an infection...how do you know they don't just go back into "ignore" mode for a while? If your immune system isn't out to totally clear that species, no amount of antibiotics is going to make that happen. And if your immune system *is* out to totally clear that species, taking a shorter course won't matter, short of your immune system possible failing, and a resulting relapse. And if THAT's how it works, then taking longer courses of antibiotics IS going to result in more antibiotic resistance than a shorter course. (Minus situations where there's an actual relapse).

Am I making sense? Are any of my facts wrong?
 
Ok. I'm going to explain what I'm thinking....Am I making sense? Are any of my facts wrong?
Within the context of not understanding what you think you understand, yes, and yes.

I have now walked my dogs, ie taken a break, and can get back to this. And I do want to say I didn't think you were being rude, but robinson's post was. Mimicking a skeptic's challenge for someone to support their claims is not something that one simply applies to every situation.

I was about to say, while I'm sure there is some older research looking at incomplete treatment and it's affect on drug resistance, that stuff is so basic now no one is likely to be doing any clinical trials on short course vs long course affects on antibiotic resistance. That stuff is 30+ years old.

The second thing is you are asking questions which contradict your saying you understand the basics. Because if you understood the basics you'd know all about colonization with pathogens (for example typhoid and MRSA) and the fact that almost all otitis media infections, most pneumonias, most if not all UTIs, most of the bacterial meningitises, and most if not all blood infections are caused by bacteria commonly present in much of the population much of the time. (The exceptions are health care associated bacterial infections spread by health care workers and relatively few true pathogens like mycoplasma pneumonia.) So to ask for some study that proves under treating an infection might end the disease process yet leave the pathogen is, I'm sorry to say, ludicrous. That's like asking for a study that proves a hammer broke the window you just broke with a hammer.

In addition, you claim I didn't answer your question, but I did. You just want the hammer study in addition to the mechanisms by which drug resistance develops.

That said, I'll address your last post.

Even when you take antibiotics, it's still your own immune system that does most of the work to get rid of the excess of whatever bacteria is making you sick. It's your own phagocytes that gobbel them up. Obviously, your immune system is also capable of ignoring this bacteria a lot of the time, too.
(assuming this is a species that can be either flora or pathogen).
This is false. Antibiotics directly kill the pathogens or disease causing organism. Only vaccines involve the immune system in destroying organisms.

There is another whole subject of toxins which is a separate issue. In the case of toxins, we do occasionally give antitoxins. And antitoxins do involve the immune system. Toxin producing pathogens can produce disease symptoms just from the toxin. But other bacteria cause disease by their actual presence in the tissues. And even when a toxin is involved, the antibiotic usually still has to kill the organism before it will stop producing the toxin.

Sometimes when antibiotics do kill organisms, the ruptured bacteria spill more toxins into the system. That can cause people to get worse before they get better. That's why for some diseases we give antitoxin in addition to other treatment. Tetanus, diphtheria and botulinum antitoxins are routinely used. An antitoxin is an antibody with the ability to neutralize a specific toxin. And while it can kill some bacteria, antitoxins are not considered antibiotics in the usual sense.

Nobody really knows WHAT your immune system does to keep things in check when you're not "sick" with these bacteria. We know there's some small immune response at play, because as people get older, they carry different species for shorter and shorter periods of time. But it can't be a heavy sterilizing immune response, either. It's some kind of mysterious immunological limbo. It's like your immune system mostly has those bacteria on "ignore", but there are a few phagocytes floating around at a low level slowly eliminating different species is a very laid back kind of way.
Again, this is just not true. We have an intricate knowledge of the immune system. It isn't that the organisms are on ignore. Certain body sites have normal flora. The immune system has no reason to attack the bacteria in your GI tract but that doesn't mean the general mechanisms by which this occurs are not understood.

So....after an infection...how do you know they don't just go back into "ignore" mode for a while? If your immune system isn't out to totally clear that species, no amount of antibiotics is going to make that happen. And if your immune system *is* out to totally clear that species, taking a shorter course won't matter, short of your immune system possible failing, and a resulting relapse. And if THAT's how it works, then taking longer courses of antibiotics IS going to result in more antibiotic resistance than a shorter course. (Minus situations where there's an actual relapse).
You are confusing disease here with the presence of organisms which are not causing disease. And part of the problem is you have to consider a number of factors, not just the cultures.

For a healthy, non-pregnant person, the space behind the eardrum (the middle ear) is not normally full of bacteria. The bladder and blood are normally sterile. The lungs are relatively free of bacteria. In persons with chronic health problems, indwelling catheters, and other conditions such as pregnancy, there are times when the body tolerates bacteria in greater numbers in some of these locations. In those cases the immune system does not react to a certain level of bacterial growth. It is similar to a process of attenuation. A lot of disease symptoms are caused in part by the immune system.

When conditions arise causing bacteria to grow in locations bacteria don't normally grow, they generally cause symptoms and we refer to that as an infection. Pregnancy, advanced age, and certain chronic health conditions sometimes allow bacteria in abnormal locations but which do not cause symptoms. In these cases there is some research seeking to distinguish colonization from infection.

Example: Quantitative Sputum Culture and Gram Stain: Pulmonary Infection vs. Colonization.

And then you have the pathogens which cause disease by various mechanisms from producing toxins to invading normally sterile tissues to evading the normal immune defenses.

So typically it isn't that your body goes back on 'ignore', more likely what you are talking about if you stop an infection but leave the bacteria is that you kill all the bacteria in the location it is causing disease in. You do kill all the bacteria in the bladder, or in the middle ear or in the lungs. In doing so you may not kill all the bacteria in the gut and that may be a simple matter of the bacteria in the gut not stimulating an immune response. Or it may be that the dose of antibiotic getting to that body site is lower. It can be that your immune system doesn't assist, but that is not always the main factor involved.

As far as not killing all of a certain bacteria species your belief that, "no amount of antibiotics is going to make that happen" is completely false. If you complete a course of antibiotics it may not sterilize every part of your body (in particular the gut) but quite often it does kill every single bacteria of susceptible species. If you gave the right drugs in the right amount for the right amount of time, you could sterilize your body of bacteria including the skin. We couldn't eliminate all viruses.

Then after you stop the drug, the bacteria are re-introduced. If you cultured your house you'd find plenty of bacteria there which are currently living on your body. It doesn't take long to restore order from these sources, such as kissing, your toothbrush, the doorknobs, and so on.

Skin is not sterilized because there is no blood supply. But you can use topical antibiotics on the skin. Your mouth is pretty hard to sterilize but again, with the right drugs you could. And if some organism has led to an abscessed tooth, you can certainly kill all of that species in your mouth. More than likely however, you are going to kill all the organisms within reach of a good blood supply.

I explained the reasons in my previous post why not finishing a course of antibiotics increases the risk of drug resistance developing. The reason you don't get it is these false assumptions you've described here.

Cumulative mutations is one reason. Surely you understand that concept. And the mechanism of normal bacteria invading abnormal locations on your body is the other issue you didn't seem to understand. Incompletely treating the infection in one's bladder, middle ear, a wound, bloodstream, or any other normally bacteria free site is the other problem you seem to be ignoring.

If you don't finish the course of antibiotics, just what is it you think happens? If the infection was cured, then you completed the course. So what you are really asking then is do providers prescribe the correct number of days of treatment? For that there are plenty of studies which lead to current guidelines.

If you don't finish the course, then your infection is going to rebound. Do that one or more times and those cumulative mutations will add up to drug resistance. How are you picturing the person getting better without finishing the course of treatment? Do you think we just extend antibiotic courses willy nilly?
 
Last edited:
Are you and I even speaking the same language, skeptigirl?
I'm apparently doing a terrible job of articulating my thoughts. Or something.
Ok...

skeptigirl said:
while I'm sure there is some older research looking at incomplete treatment and it's affect on drug resistance, that stuff is so basic now no one is likely to be doing any clinical trials on short course vs long course affects on antibiotic resistance. That stuff is 30+ years old.

So you couldn't find anything?

skeptigirl said:
The second thing is you are asking questions which contradict your saying you understand the basics. Because if you understood the basics you'd know all about colonization with pathogens (for example typhoid and MRSA) and the fact that almost all otitis media infections, most pneumonias, most if not all UTIs, most of the bacterial meningitises, and most if not all blood infections are caused by bacteria commonly present in much of the population much of the time

Now what did I say that gave you the impression that I thought otherwise?

So to ask for some study that proves under treating an infection might end the disease process yet leave the pathogen is, I'm sorry to say, ludicrous. That's like asking for a study that proves a hammer broke the window you just broke with a hammer.

Let me show you how this is done:

I'm not going to just make the claim "You are incorrect" and hope you just believe in me like Jesus that I know what I'm talking about.

http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/picrender.fcgi?artid=228329&blobtype=pdf

As expected from the observation of a relatively
high proportion of persistent colonizations, no correlation was found between episodes of AOM and the
acquisition of new strains of H. influenzae, nor was any direct relation between antimicrobial therapy and the
elimination of nasopharyngeal colonization with a particular strain of H. influenzae observed
.

As expected from the observation of a relatively high proportion
of persistent colonizations, no correlation was found between
episodes of AOM and the acquisition of new strains of
H. influenzae, nor was there observed any direct relation be-
tween antimicrobial therapy and the elimination of nasopharyngeal
colonization with the particular strain of H. influenzae
that was supposed to be the causative agent
.
The present data
also suggest that endogenous reinfections of the nasopharyngeal
mucosa might contribute to the increased colonization
periods.

There was no significant correlation between the
acquisition of a new strain of H. influenzae and AOM (x2 with
continuity correction 5 0.09; P 5 0.76). Similarly, antibiotic
treatment of AOM did not result in the clear-cut elimination of
the H. influenzae nasopharyngeal colonization
on the basis of
the same 175 observations

Groeneveld et al. (12), studying the presence of H. influenzae
in sputum samples, suggested that there is a coincidence of
endogenous or exogenous reinfection by NTHI with exacerbations
of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Some of these
patients were persistently infected with the same NTHI strain
for periods of up to 23 months. Groeneveld et al. (12) also
noted that antibiotic treatment, although obviously relieving
the symptoms, was not effective in eradicating NTHI from
patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. In our
study, 42% (54 of 128) of the strains represented by a unique
DNA fingerprint reappeared on one or several occasions in the
same individual, regardless of antimicrobial therapy

Ludicrous, huh? Ok.

skeptigirl said:
Antibiotics directly kill the pathogens or disease causing organism.
They work in tandem with the immune system.
Only vaccines involve the immune system in destroying organisms.

WHAT?
Can you expand on what you mean there???

I have to be grossly misunderstanding you.


Again, this is just not true. We have an intricate knowledge of the immune system. It isn't that the organisms are on ignore. Certain body sites have normal flora. The immune system has no reason to attack the bacteria in your GI tract but that doesn't mean the general mechanisms by which this occurs are not understood.

A lot about the immune system is understood, but the immune response to nasopharyngeal colonizing bacteria is not well understood. If you want to argue this, I'll find some links.
If you complete a course of antibiotics it may not sterilize every part of your body (in particular the gut) but quite often it does kill every single bacteria of susceptible species.

I'll refer you to the link above about nasopharyngeal clearance.

I explained the reasons in my previous post why not finishing a course of antibiotics increases the risk of drug resistance developing. The reason you don't get it is these false assumptions you've described here.

I know you are but what am I? :p
If you don't finish the course of antibiotics, just what is it you think happens?

Your humoral and/or cell mediated immune system finishes the job off.

If the infection was cured, then you completed the course.

I have no idea what you could be meaning there.
For that there are plenty of studies which lead to current guidelines.

I think that might be pure assumption on your part. I'm with Ick for the moment.

If you don't finish the course, then your infection is going to rebound.

I'm starting to think you're serious.
You do know that the human immune system can deal with bacterial infections on it's own, don't you? We don't always "need" antibiotics?

How are you picturing the person getting better without finishing the course of treatment?
This is insane, skeptigirl.
You really don't believe the human immune system can kill bacteria without vaccines, do you? You were totally serious when you said that.

I'm speechless.

Do you think we just extend antibiotic courses willy nilly?

Ich said earlier that the idea is to avoid toxicity, and the length is sort of arbitrarily determined. That sounds right to me, although I confess, I'm not sure exactly how it works.
 
Last edited:
I'll go ahead and address this:

me said:
Nobody really knows WHAT your immune system does to keep things in check when you're not "sick" with these bacteria.

skeptigirl said:
Again, this is just not true. We have an intricate knowledge of the immune system. It isn't that the organisms are on ignore. Certain body sites have normal flora. The immune system has no reason to attack the bacteria in your GI tract but that doesn't mean the general mechanisms by which this occurs are not understood.

http://www.journals.uchicago.edu/JID/journal/issues/v192n3/34243/34243.web.pdf

The marked reduction in the incidence of invasive
pneumococcal disease after the first few years of life is
related to several factors, including age-related changes
in susceptibility to infection with Streptococcus pneumoniae
[1]. The reason for this reduction in susceptibility
is thought to relate to the maturation of the immune
system and, at the same time, natural exposure to the
pneumococcus. Despite the latter assumption, relatively
few data exist on immune responses to the pneumococcus
after natural exposure
.

And here:

http://iai.asm.org/cgi/content/full/68/3/1569#B9

INTRODUCTION

The upper airway rapidly becomes colonized with bacteria after birth. Although the majority of members of the normal flora are nonpathogenic, potential pathogens such as Streptococcus pneumoniae and Moraxella catarrhalis initiate colonization early in life in a manner similar to nonpathogens and continue to colonize the host throughout childhood. By 6 months of age, more than one-third of children will have been colonized with S. pneumoniae and more than one-half will have been colonized with M. catarrhalis (10). Between 6 and 12 months of life, approximately one-fourth of children will be colonized monthly with one or both of these pathogens (10). Typically, the pathogens remain in the airway for several months before disappearing or are replaced by a different strain of the same pathogen (1, 13, 18, 22). The host factors responsible for elimination of the pathogen are not well understood. However, experience with another airway pathogen, nontypeable Haemophilus influenzae, suggests that the local immune response may play a role in controlling the trafficking of the organisms (9, 14).

There are "clues" about what might be going on, but no one really knows for sure.

More on clearance after antibiotics:

http://www.journals.uchicago.edu/JID/journal/issues/v191n11/34202/34202.html
Otitis media represents a vast disease burden and is the leading indication for the administration of antibiotics in children [1]. Various studies have linked pneumococcal nasopharyngeal colonization with increased risk of acute and recurrent otitis media [25]. In this issue of The Journal of Infectious Diseases, Libson et al. [6] extend these observations to show that children in whom pneumococci have been eradicated from the middle ear yet who continue to harbor pneumococci in the nasopharynx at the end of antibiotic treatment are at increased risk of subsequent episodes of otitis media. This study strengthens the argument, as pointed out by the authors, that the impact that antibiotics have on nasopharyngeal carriage should be considered during the evaluation of new and existing drugs. To date, few studies of new or existing drugs have evaluated their impact on nasopharyngeal carriage. Most drugs that are used to treat upper respiratory tract infections have little ability to eradicate colonization in the nasopharynx and are therefore likely to select resistant strains in the flora, either by selection of spontaneous mutants harbored in small numbers among the susceptible flora or by enhancement of the proportion of preexisting resistant strains in the carried population [79]. Thus, isolates from both the nasopharynx and the middle ear in patients with recurrent otitis media show increased antibiotic resistance [10]. Fluoroquinolones are used to eradicate nasopharyngeal carriage of meningococci, but an initial study in children showed only a 55% reduction and not an eradication of nasopharyngeal carriage of pneumococci, despite 10 days of treatment with these drugs [11]. The relationship between carriage and otitis media is complex, and host susceptibility and concurrent viral infection [12] are probably critical to the pathogenesis of both acute and recurrent otitis media.
 
Skeptigirl said:
A partial course of antibiotics can leave any number of partially resistant strains around primed for full resistance the next time.

Thanks for clearing up any potential misconceptions my post may have created.

One of the points I wanted to get across, though, was that the person who originally brought up the discussion (can't even remember who it was) is not totally out in left field (just mostly), so I tried to put the discussion into a broader context. Since we just make up the time course for the administration of antibiotics it may be that partial courses are fine for some people. If you can eliminate the organisms quickly (if they are highly sensitive to the antibiotic and the antibiotic is cidal), then what we call a partial course might be OK some of the time.

The problem with the real world is that we don't know who can clear their infections quickly and who cannot. I didn't mean my post to sound like we should all go around taking partial courses of antibiotics, but only that there is a situation in which that might be appropriate. We just can't know when it is appropriate, so the over-kill that we generally use is a much better course of action.
 
Selection pressure. The higher and more prolonged the selection pressure, the more likely is that traits become widespread that negate the selection pressure.

There's not just the pathogenic bacteria in the bodies. taking a full course of antibiotics will increase the selection pressure on all bacteria in (and possibly, on) the body.

That just isn't true for some bacteria and the antibiotics used. As skeptigirl pointed out, bacteria INSIDE the skin are never supposed to be there, and a treatment for an internal or blood infection is all about killing every last bacteria, including the drug resistant strains. This is accomplished by both the antibacterial agent and the host immune response. It is very unusual for a bacteria to multiply inside an organ or the blood stream. Especially in the brain.

I'm sort of dragging together multiple strains that have come up in this thread. I think part of the confusion that results from a partial understanding of Medicine speaks to the topic. Self medication with antibiotics is a terrible problem. Even up to date Doctors struggle with the changing nature of disease, resistant strains, and possible reactions to medications.

It is not going to be taught in high school.

bacteria, unlike humans, can change their genetic makeup through bacterial sex. Plasmid rings can cross species barriers. This means, by making your own probiotic bacterial flora resistant to antibiotics by taking the full course, you are also making the pathogenic bacteria resistant in the long run, even if these pathogenic bacteria are not of the same type as your probiotic flora. (Though they often are)

This is true, but not for all antibiotics, or all treatments with them.

Expected result: Any resistance to antibiotics will be increased proportionally to the amount of antibiotics taken.

Example: The most drug-resistant bacteria are found in hospitals where they come in constant contact with antibiotics.

Conclusion: taking the full course of antibiotics will lead to more resistant strains in future infections than taking only partial courses. The hypothesis that taking the full course will destroy *all* bacteria and thus also destroy the resistant ones is deeply flawed.

Again, it isn't that simple. In cases where a broad spectrum antibiotic is used, yes, but not always. There are two very different situations being discussed here. Internal bacterial infection, a serious and life threatening
condition, in which antibiotics are going to save your life. Usually from injury, surgery, or medical procedures which invade the flesh somehow. The body can be overwhelmed by both toxins, tissue death, and bacteria. Antibiotics allow the body to win the war, which is to the death in many cases. The goal is to destroy ALL bacteria. Period.

Stopping a treatment before the war is over may lead to a drug resistant strain, in which case you die. Unless your own body can defeat the invasion, in which case you live. While you are fighting, more and more resistant bacteria are left, until they all die. If the drug resistant bacteria win, you are a dead body full of very deadly critters. And any blood or tissue, or even contact with your body, can spread disease, very bad disease.

Mt best friend died from this very situation. I know a lot about it.

And I apologize for being rude to skeptigirl, but ignorance sometimes pisses me off.

Then there are the myriad external infections, which occur at the interface of us and the world. Mouth, nose, eyes, ears, lungs, urinary tract, vagina, ass, gut, and skin. (Glands, hairs, pores, wounds, nails, lips).

And despite the claim that this is old news, there is very much research and double blind trials being done now on antibiotic resistance, the effectiveness of antibiotics, a multitude of issues, all very much important.

For example
http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1572-0241.2000.03349.x

Making dumb claims and not being able to back them up, is dumb.

That being said, skeptigirl is making some good points. But some of it is deeply flawed.
 
Good sources, as always

There are "clues" about what might be going on, but no one really knows for sure.

True, but there are a few Medical Heritics out there that know a lot more than you will find in Medical Journals.
 
Can you give some examples relating to possible life or death scenarios? For some reason I am envisioning things like people just walking straight into a bonfire, off a cliff, or wading in to the ocean over their head, breathing,...or even waking up with their arm asleep in bed and then rolling over onto that 'dead' arm..... and they'll be better off because they know nothing?

Healthfraud is rife with this. The people who sell herbal remedies usually only tell the customer half the story: they'll supply links to research that show the product 'might' work. They omit mentioning that clinical trials show the product does not actually work, and may be dangerous.

An example is antioxidant supplements. All the medical research shows that they have no benefit, and actually increase the chance of getting cancer.

The public knows that antioxidants mop up oxidants, which is 'enough information to be dangerous', because they then think they will get rid of oxidants in the body, which are assumed to be harmful. What gets overlooked (and the sellers of antioxidants are not interested in discussing) is that these antioxidants are not going to get into the cellular regions where oxidants are stored; they are going to float around in the rest of the body instead. Further, since the body uses oxidants such as peroxide to destroy threats such as bacteria, viruses, and tumour cells, antioxidant supplements can be expected to neutralize the immune system.

This is actually observed: antioxidant supplements are positively correlated with increased cancer, particularly leukemia. This is consistent with what somebody would expect if they know a lot about antioxidants and the immune system, but people whose education about antioxidants is limited to reading the brochure provided by the supplement salesman know 'enough to be dangerous.' Specifically, to themselves.

And then there's Kava, creatine, &c. Everybody read the brochure in the store display, and knows enough to want to buy the product, but nobody's read the FDA warnings on their website to know they *don't* want to buy the product because it doesn't work and is a health risk.
 
And I apologize for being rude to skeptigirl, but ignorance sometimes pisses me off.


Now now, robinson, that doesn't sound like a proper apology.

Oh, and :rolleyes:

Making dumb claims and not being able to back them up, is dumb.


How about that. Know what else could be considered 'dumb'? Proclaiming oneself to be good natured and skeptical, while providing plenty of evidence to the contrary.

Just sayin'.

Oh, and :rolleyes:


So do you want a discussion, or are we all too dumb?
 
Anti-oxidants could be an entire topic.

Agreed. I was recently privileged to have dinner with Dr. Art Grollman, and we talked antioxidants for about an hour.

I had my laptop at the restaurant, and there was an open wirless router nearby, so we were able to go straight to the papers in question and discuss them line by line. Plus: Grollman personally knows some authors, so it was good to be exposed to the authentic interpretation.

Chinese restaurant, so meanwhile, we ate greasy fried food we knew was totally unhealthy.

Gives perspective.
 
Yes, antibiotic overuse in animals can be a problem, but its not that significant... animals are not fed the latest-and-greatest antibiotics that are used on humans.

Wrong. It is a huge problem. Factory animals HAVE to be fed antibiotics all the time, because antibiotic resistant strains are endemic at this point. Pus from teat infections is in every drop of milk commercially produced. If they stop using antibiotics infections would cripple the industry.

From the National Institute of Health: http://www.niaid.nih.gov/factsheets/antimicro.htm

Also, when a patient does not finish taking a prescription for antibiotics, some bacteria may remain. These bacterial survivors are more likely to develop resistance and spread.

So, if you do take antibiotics properly, it should kill all the bacteria its targeted against. No survivors means no chance of passing on resistance to future bacteria. Its only when some microbes are left to survive (because the patient stopped drugs early) that resistance is passed on.

This is true for the TARGETED bacteria, but the problem is all the other ones. Bacteria that used to be no problem, can now kill you. From that website, it is clear that this is indeed the case.

Take a minute to read, emphasis is mine.
http://www.niaid.nih.gov/factsheets/antimicro.htm
Over time, some bacteria have developed ways to circumvent the effects of antibiotics. Widespread use of antibiotics is thought to have spurred evolutionarily adaptations that enable bacteria to survive these powerful drugs. Other microbes such as viruses, fungi, and parasites have developed resistance as well. Antimicrobial resistance provides a survival benefit to microbes and makes it harder to eliminate infections from the body. Ultimately, the increasing difficulty in fighting off microbes leads to an increased risk of acquiring infections in a hospital or other setting.

Diseases such as tuberculosis, gonorrhea, malaria, and childhood ear infections are now more difficult to treat than they were just a few decades ago. Drug resistance is an especially difficult problem for hospitals harboring critically ill patients who are less able to fight off infections without the help of antibiotics. Heavy use of antibiotics in these patients selects for changes in bacteria that bring about drug resistance. Unfortunately, this worsens the problem by producing bacteria with greater ability to survive even in the presence of our strongest antibiotics. These even stronger drug-resistant bacteria continue to prey on vulnerable hospital patients.

To help curb this problem, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) provides hospitals with prevention strategies and educational materials to reduce antibiotic resistance in health care settings. According to CDC statistics

* Nearly 2 million patients in the United States get an infection in the hospital each year
* About 90,000 of those patients die each year as a result of their infection, up from 13,300 patient deaths in 1992
* More than 70 percent of the bacteria that cause hospital-acquired infections are resistant to at least one of the antibiotics most commonly used to treat them
* People infected with antibiotic-resistant organisms are more likely to have longer hospital stays and require treatment with second- or third-choice medicines that may be less effective, more toxic, and more expensive

In short, antimicrobial resistance is driving up health care costs, increasing the severity of disease, and increasing the death rates from certain infections.

Hospital Staph is a killer. Every worker in a Hospital knows this. My best friend warned me for years to avoid a certain hospital if possible because of a serious, yet hidden, Staph problem they have. This superbug Staph killed people there like crazy, yet was not reported as the cause of death, for obvious reasons.

By terrible chance he ended up there for emergency surgery, he got the Staph, he died a week later, not from the surgery, but from Staph, which not even the most powerful antibiotics could stop.

Nightmare. True horror.

Why superbugs? Because bacteria transmit their immunity to antibiotics to other bacteria.

Even across species.

And it is not just the antibiotics, the use of antibacterial soap has led to selection of bacteria that can survive ordinary hand washing now. Stronger measures have to be used to kill just ordinary Hospital germs on skin and instruments, as well as clothing, bedding, and even in the air itself.
 
Last edited:
Anti-oxidants could be an entire topic.

I included creatine in the above list of examples that 'don't work', but creatine probably does have some benefit. It's just that the risks are not discussed by the salespeople.

But that's one of the few. Most of the rest have a lot of trouble coming up with persuasive evidence for claims of efficacy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom