Ok. I'm going to explain what I'm thinking....Am I making sense? Are any of my facts wrong?
Within the context of not understanding what you think you understand, yes, and yes.
I have now walked my dogs, ie taken a break, and can get back to this. And I do want to say I didn't think you were being rude, but robinson's post was. Mimicking a skeptic's challenge for someone to support their claims is not something that one simply applies to every situation.
I was about to say, while I'm sure there is some older research looking at incomplete treatment and it's affect on drug resistance, that stuff is so basic now no one is likely to be doing any clinical trials on short course vs long course affects on antibiotic resistance. That stuff is 30+ years old.
The second thing is you are asking questions which contradict your saying you understand the basics. Because if you understood the basics you'd know all about colonization with pathogens (for example typhoid and MRSA) and the fact that almost all otitis media infections, most pneumonias, most if not all UTIs, most of the bacterial meningitises, and most if not all blood infections are caused by bacteria commonly present in much of the population much of the time. (The exceptions are health care associated bacterial infections spread by health care workers and relatively few true pathogens like mycoplasma pneumonia.) So to ask for some study that proves under treating an infection might end the disease process yet leave the pathogen is, I'm sorry to say, ludicrous. That's like asking for a study that proves a hammer broke the window you just broke with a hammer.
In addition, you claim I didn't answer your question, but I did. You just want the hammer study in addition to the mechanisms by which drug resistance develops.
That said, I'll address your last post.
Even when you take antibiotics, it's still your own immune system that does most of the work to get rid of the excess of whatever bacteria is making you sick. It's your own phagocytes that gobbel them up. Obviously, your immune system is also capable of ignoring this bacteria a lot of the time, too.
(assuming this is a species that can be either flora or pathogen).
This is false. Antibiotics directly kill the pathogens or disease causing organism. Only vaccines involve the immune system in destroying organisms.
There is another whole subject of toxins which is a separate issue. In the case of toxins, we do occasionally give antitoxins. And antitoxins do involve the immune system. Toxin producing pathogens can produce disease symptoms just from the toxin. But other bacteria cause disease by their actual presence in the tissues. And even when a toxin is involved, the antibiotic usually still has to kill the organism before it will stop producing the toxin.
Sometimes when antibiotics do kill organisms, the ruptured bacteria spill more toxins into the system. That can cause people to get worse before they get better. That's why for some diseases we give antitoxin in addition to other treatment. Tetanus, diphtheria and botulinum antitoxins are routinely used. An antitoxin is an antibody with the ability to neutralize a specific toxin. And while it can kill some bacteria, antitoxins are not considered antibiotics in the usual sense.
Nobody really knows WHAT your immune system does to keep things in check when you're not "sick" with these bacteria. We know there's some small immune response at play, because as people get older, they carry different species for shorter and shorter periods of time. But it can't be a heavy sterilizing immune response, either. It's some kind of mysterious immunological limbo. It's like your immune system mostly has those bacteria on "ignore", but there are a few phagocytes floating around at a low level slowly eliminating different species is a very laid back kind of way.
Again, this is just not true. We have an intricate knowledge of the immune system. It isn't that the organisms are on ignore. Certain body sites have normal flora. The immune system has no reason to attack the bacteria in your GI tract but that doesn't mean the general mechanisms by which this occurs are not understood.
So....after an infection...how do you know they don't just go back into "ignore" mode for a while? If your immune system isn't out to totally clear that species, no amount of antibiotics is going to make that happen. And if your immune system *is* out to totally clear that species, taking a shorter course won't matter, short of your immune system possible failing, and a resulting relapse. And if THAT's how it works, then taking longer courses of antibiotics IS going to result in more antibiotic resistance than a shorter course. (Minus situations where there's an actual relapse).
You are confusing disease here with the presence of organisms which are not causing disease. And part of the problem is you have to consider a number of factors, not just the cultures.
For a healthy, non-pregnant person, the space behind the eardrum (the middle ear) is not normally full of bacteria. The bladder and blood are normally sterile. The lungs are relatively free of bacteria. In persons with chronic health problems, indwelling catheters, and other conditions such as pregnancy, there are times when the body tolerates bacteria in greater numbers in some of these locations. In those cases the immune system does not react to a certain level of bacterial growth. It is similar to a process of attenuation. A lot of disease symptoms are caused in part by the immune system.
When conditions arise causing bacteria to grow in locations bacteria don't normally grow, they generally cause symptoms and we refer to that as an infection. Pregnancy, advanced age, and certain chronic health conditions sometimes allow bacteria in abnormal locations but which do not cause symptoms. In these cases there is some research seeking to distinguish colonization from infection.
Example:
Quantitative Sputum Culture and Gram Stain: Pulmonary Infection vs. Colonization.
And then you have the pathogens which cause disease by various mechanisms from producing toxins to invading normally sterile tissues to evading the normal immune defenses.
So typically it isn't that your body goes back on 'ignore', more likely what you are talking about if you stop an infection but leave the bacteria is that you kill all the bacteria in the location it is causing disease in. You do kill all the bacteria in the bladder, or in the middle ear or in the lungs. In doing so you may not kill all the bacteria in the gut and that may be a simple matter of the bacteria in the gut not stimulating an immune response. Or it may be that the dose of antibiotic getting to that body site is lower. It can be that your immune system doesn't assist, but that is not always the main factor involved.
As far as not killing all of a certain bacteria species your belief that, "no amount of antibiotics is going to make that happen" is completely false. If you complete a course of antibiotics it may not sterilize every part of your body (in particular the gut) but quite often it does kill every single bacteria of susceptible species. If you gave the right drugs in the right amount for the right amount of time, you could sterilize your body of bacteria including the skin. We couldn't eliminate all viruses.
Then after you stop the drug, the bacteria are re-introduced. If you cultured your house you'd find plenty of bacteria there which are currently living on your body. It doesn't take long to restore order from these sources, such as kissing, your toothbrush, the doorknobs, and so on.
Skin is not sterilized because there is no blood supply. But you can use topical antibiotics on the skin. Your mouth is pretty hard to sterilize but again, with the right drugs you could. And if some organism has led to an abscessed tooth, you can certainly kill all of that species in your mouth. More than likely however, you are going to kill all the organisms within reach of a good blood supply.
I explained the reasons in my previous post why not finishing a course of antibiotics increases the risk of drug resistance developing. The reason you don't get it is these false assumptions you've described here.
Cumulative mutations is one reason. Surely you understand that concept. And the mechanism of normal bacteria invading abnormal locations on your body is the other issue you didn't seem to understand. Incompletely treating the infection in one's bladder, middle ear, a wound, bloodstream, or any other normally bacteria free site is the other problem you seem to be ignoring.
If you don't finish the course of antibiotics, just what is it you think happens? If the infection was cured, then you completed the course. So what you are really asking then is do providers prescribe the correct number of days of treatment? For that there are plenty of studies which lead to current guidelines.
If you don't finish the course, then your infection is going to rebound. Do that one or more times and those cumulative mutations will add up to drug resistance. How are you picturing the person getting better without finishing the course of treatment? Do you think we just extend antibiotic courses willy nilly?