No, I spent a couple of hours reading all kinds of research on eradication vs. reduction or recolonization asymptomatically. The H. influenzae study was just the first one I found.
There are a whole spectrum of effects found. Most of the studies I was able to locate were on OM, too. It's the most studied of all the infections it seems when it comes to eradication vs. a return to flora/colonization.
I'm not sure what these articles are supposed to demonstrate in regards to the question of not completing a course of antibiotics causing increased risk of resistance developing.
Nasopharyngeal Carriage of Streptococcus pneumoniae at the Completion of Successful Antibiotic Treatment of Acute Otitis Media Predisposes to Early Clinical Recurrence This article argues for eliminating the NP strep when treating OM. It doesn't argue one should expect not to eliminate carriage. This is just research which adds to the decision of evaluating the outcome when looking at how long and with what should we treat OM.
Our findings showed that clinical recurrence of AOM caused by S. pneumoniae occurs in the vast majority of patients as a result of nasopharyngeal colonization with this pathogen, despite its eradication from the MEF, at the completion of successful antibiotic treatment for the initial episode of AOM. These findings underline the importance of the drug-pathogen interaction in the nasopharynx as well as in the middle ear. We believe that this relationship should be taken into consideration when the true efficacy of an antibiotic drug in the treatment of AOM is established. A drug that fails to reduce nasopharyngeal colonization with S. pneumoniae at the completion of successful antibiotic treatment of AOM will be associated with an increased rate of clinical recurrence of AOM (most instances of which are true bacteriologic relapses) caused by S. pneumoniae.
In conclusion, we have established the etiological role that nasopharyngeal colonization with S. pneumoniae at the completion of a successful antibiotic treatment of AOM plays in subsequent early clinical recurrence of AOM. We therefore believe that the concept of drug efficacy in the treatment of AOM may be broadened to include nasopharyngeal eradication of S. pneumoniae. Although it is likely that other nasopharyngeal pathogens play a role in the clinical recurrence of AOM, this is yet to be established.
The other two articles have interesting information but I see no relationship to stopping a course of antibiotics short of the evidence based standard length of time. Nor do either support the contention NP carriage is always going to occur after treating OM. Again, this just has nothing to do with stopping a course of antibiotics midway.
A lot of bladder infections are with e-coli. When you treat them you don't expect to sterilize the gut as well. But if you stopped treatment before the evidence based time you would be leaving resistant bacteria in the bladder. Yes, with completing treatment you may increase the resistance in the e-coli that might cause the next infection, but stopping treatment is going to assure you leave resistant bacteria in the bladder.
Originally Posted by skeptigirl
Those are not third and forth issues. Your 'third' issue is the whole point of completing treatment of the targeted organism. Determining the optimal length of treatment would have an outcome measure of 'no relapse'.
You don't think a relapse of "illness" is a different issue from a return to the floral state for the targeted organism?
There is no one size fits all answer here. You are looking at complex treatment algorhythms as if there is a single one for everything. It doesn't work that way.
You need the bladder to be cleared of infection unless there is a permanent indwelling catheter or some other medical condition in which case eliminating bacturia is impractical.
You treat some cases of OM (young infant, and cases not resolving on their own) but typically a viral URI precedes the onset. So leaving bacteria in the NP is not always going to be a risk for relapse. But the young kid in daycare is going to have another URI. You may decide to try eliminating NP carriage or you may use other options like tubes. I wouldn't extend treatment to eliminate NP carriage more than once unless it resulted in a long period free of OM. There needs to be more research on that one and on the best way to eliminate NP carriage.
Each situation has many factors to consider. And sometimes treatment outcome is going to include eliminating the bacteria in the NP, sometimes it isn't. The standard is to use the least amount of antibiotic that is required.
Originally Posted by skeptigirl:
It is a separate issue here whether and for how long antibiotics should be prescribed. If you assume the answer is yes and the length of treatment evidence based, then just who is it you are thinking about in your scenario? It only leaves a patient who you can assume is likely to relapse. If you want to argue they may or may not relapse, then you are arguing a different question about whether the recommended length of treatment is correct.
"The answer is yes" to what question???
I think the guidelines are probably primarily based on reducing the chance of relapse to as small of a chance as possible...not a length of time where the scales tip at the 50% probability mark.
You keep saying you understand what I have said, but here you don't.
Question: is there an advantage in stopping a course of antibiotics short of the specified time?
Different question: Should the antibiotic be prescribed?
AND Is the length of the prescription the optimum length?
Are you are arguing the prescriptions are possibly wrong, or are you saying we should study only partially treating infections?
The prescriptions are evidence based and we know what the outcomes are for partially treating. Drug resistance is greater and the outcomes are often worse. Again, this is all evidence based. Obviously the evidence is never complete. Adjustments are made as new evidence comes in. Stopping treatment midway is not a good thing to do. You seem to think you need a study to tell you that.
I suggest you change your question to a more logical one, are current treatment courses optimum length? Because that's really the bottom line here. You don't trust standard medical practices. You have indicated that repeatedly and this is a continuation of your usual position.
Originally Posted by skeptigirl:
Once more, the concept you are not getting here and which you keep claiming requires a study is that by not completing a correctly prescribed course of antibiotics it means by definition you are not eliminating the target organisms.
So if the infection was healed, and the person is well, but the organism goes back to flora or isn't totally eradicated, you think the treatment was a total failure? Even thought the person is well again?
No, again find where I said that. There is an end point for whatever you are treating and those endpoints differ. If the study above is showing leaving NP carriage behind is a risk for relapse, you might try making your endpoint elimination of NP carriage in a child having a second or third case of OM. If it turns out that for kids in daycare, there is so much NP carriage it is a waste of time, they just get reinfected from the other kids, you consider ear tubes. It's like I said, there are some complex treatment algorithms. There is no one size fits all.
Originally Posted by skeptigirl:
What this is saying is half of H-flu and 75% of M catarrhalis were cured by the children's immune systems, not the antibiotics. However, 80% of the Strep pneumoniae needed the antibiotic to be cured in 7 days.
So again, leaving the argument aside about whether one should wait a few days and see if the OM resolves on it's own first or treating it at the onset, once you do decide to treat it, you are really treating only the S pneumoniae.
Are you equating "cured" with "total and complete clearance from not just the ear but also the nose and throat of the organism that was causing the OM "?
Complex treatment algorithms, no one size fits all. How old is the kid, are they in daycare, do they have other health problems, do we need to culture, how many relapses in the past, is the parent getting the med into the kid reliably, can the parent handle the upset baby with ear pain, can the parent stay home from work, what is the current standard?