Medicine should be taught in high school

Research on bacteria shows, with out any doubt, that which does not kill them all, makes the ones that survive much stronger.

Avoiding the use of antibiotics, in some situations, can also reduce the chances of infection by antibiotic resistant bacteria. In one study the use of fluoroquinolones are clearly associated with Clostridium difficile infection, which is a leading cause of nosocomial diarrhea in the United States and a major cause of death worldwide.
http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/eid/vol9no6/02-0385.htm
http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/eid/vol4no4/frost.htm
 
Last edited:
But is a half course definitely worse than a full course when it comes to the overall problem of antibiotic resistance?
 
....Damn good questions. But you are asking about issues that are not simple, nor welcomed. Symptoms are caused by germs, kill the germs, symptoms go away, good health returns. What you are talking about is Orthomolecular Medicine, which is at odds sometimes, with the current paradigm that germs cause illness.
Link and emphasis mine.

Riiiight, robinson, "not welcomed". :rolleyes: A century of research in infectious disease is threatened by Pauling just because he had a theory of disease based on one flawed study on vitamin C? Receiving a Nobel is hardly the only thing you need to validate your conclusions about the underlying cause of disease.

There are certainly things within one's nature and nurture which are going to predispose the person to infection and disease, but just like chiropractic medicine claims all disease is prevented if we just have spine alignments, both theories of disease are bunk! Organisms have clever little ways of defeating even the most healthy immune systems. They evolved, we evolved. The human species may be superior in terms of intelligence and technology, but we are not 'special' when it comes to resisting infectious diseases. Our immune systems are not even the most effective in the animal kingdom. I believe shark tissue resists infection more effectively than human skin and tissue, for example.
 
For the record, I'm not suggesting people take half courses of antibiotics.

But has it ever been tested and proven that a half course is worse for antibiotic resistance than a full course?
Since even with a full course, obviously most of "your" bacteria end up surviving?
Yes it has been tested as well as we know the reason drug resistance is more likely when you under-treat an infection.

Drug resistance is not necessarily an all or none phenomena. Typically as drug resistance develops the bacteria are at first still susceptible to higher or longer doses of a drug. Treating for a particular length of time kills the most susceptible first but even those with a little resistance are killed eventually. So the bacteria which survived 6 of the 7 days of treatment still die after 7 days. But if you stop treatment on day 5 or 6, the few remaining bacteria replicate with the resistance now increased. Over time, under-treating leaves increasing resistance until complete resistance occurs.
 
Staph and Strep are rampant and dangerous, in Hospitals, where full the full course of an antibiotic is assured. Eliminating all but the most hardy of any organism assures a very resistant strain will evolve....
The reasons why an organism may not be eliminated in a any setting is not simply because treatment courses are not completed. When the person's health is very poor, even a full course of antibiotics may not succeed in eliminating an infection.

Drug resistance is amplified in hospitals because of many factors. Very bad infections end up in hospitals including drug resistant ones, and very bad injuries, advanced infections, immunocompromised and people in poor health for other reasons mean we aren't simply dealing with someone who needs 10 days of an antibiotic and the bacteria will be killed.

Drug resistance also develops from widespread use of antibiotics in farming and ranching. It develops when physicians prescribe antibiotics the patient doesn't need and it develops when patients don't take the full course of drugs for a multitude of reasons.

And yes, resistance is inevitable with current treatment approaches. Multiple drug approaches such as we use with TB and HIV prevent resistance from developing and even then resistance develops.

BTW, strep is not the leading drug resistant hazard currently. Staph and enterococci are currently the two biggest problems with drug resistance in hospitals. Drug resistant TB is probably the leading problem in drug resistance worldwide. Streptococcal resistance is up and coming but vaccination is available for many strains.
 
Last edited:
Yes it has been tested as well as we know the reason drug resistance is more likely when you under-treat an infection.

Drug resistance is not necessarily an all or none phenomena. Typically as drug resistance develops the bacteria are at first still susceptible to higher or longer doses of a drug. Treating for a particular length of time kills the most susceptible first but even those with a little resistance are killed eventually. So the bacteria which survived 6 of the 7 days of treatment still die after 7 days. But if you stop treatment on day 5 or 6, the few remaining bacteria replicate with the resistance now increased. Over time, under-treating leaves increasing resistance until complete resistance occurs.

But if you follow through to day 7, most species of bacteria you're colonized with still survive, right?

Are they more antibiotic resistant after a 5 day treatment or a 7 day treatment?
 
Robinson has big words for someone with no clue about chemistry:

The original Eastman formula was not FDA approved for medical use, however, because of a tendency to cause skin irritation and to generate heat. In 1998 the FDA approved 2-octyl cyanoacrylate

That is not the formula for regular superglue. Your ignorant mind is clouded to the glaring chemical difference. The fact that there are very good reasons the Eastman formula is not approved should give you some clue though, if you want.
___________________________________________________________
skeptigirl: From your description, I'd be having a cow over it. Are you getting support from the principal or the school district? I'm sure any teacher here getting that far off the curriculum would not be tolerated.


I just got accepted by my practicum placement today. I had to go visit them before they'd accept a student from my school. I'll try to find out more about why they haven't accepted a student from my school in years (I have my suspicions). I'll also see what my preceptor thinks of the extracurricular junk we were taught and ask if there is anything I can do to take to the owners of the school. I don't know if the owners accept this extracurricular activity or not. I wanted to get my diploma before I raised a stink though. I hope to get something done about it though. I'm sure the owners don't want bad press about how the students are taught to hate the doctors they will be processing treatment orders for.
 
But if you follow through to day 7, most species of bacteria you're colonized with still survive, right?

Are they more antibiotic resistant after a 5 day treatment or a 7 day treatment?
No, each organism and site of infection affects the effect of any antibiotic course. Not all bacteria are killed by the same drugs, doses or time frames.
 
Research on bacteria shows, with out any doubt, that which does not kill them all, makes the ones that survive much stronger.

...
Unfortunately, not every prescriber is as conservative with antibiotics as they should be. But sometimes if you don't treat the patient dies so if you are claiming we should let you die and thus prevent clostridium overgrowth.... well you see where I'm going with that.
 
No, each organism and site of infection affects the effect of any antibiotic course. Not all bacteria are killed by the same drugs, doses or time frames.

Are you saying all of the bacteria that you're colonized with that are sensitive to the specific antibiotic you're on will be completely eliminated by the full course of antibiotics you take for your infection?

And the rest won't be affected at all?
 
Originally Posted by skeptigirl
No, each organism and site of infection affects the effect of any antibiotic course. Not all bacteria are killed by the same drugs, doses or time frames.


Are you saying all of the bacteria that you're colonized with that are sensitive to the specific antibiotic you're on will be completely eliminated by the full course of antibiotics you take for your infection?

And the rest won't be affected at all?
The effects vary. Yes, a full course of antibiotics for one infection will kill some normal bacteria completely. But those bacteria are common and are soon reintroduced. It is one reason for yeast over-growth as well as an upset gut when you are on antibiotics.

Most bacteria on your skin will not be affected. The antibiotic traveling in the bloodstream won't get to the skin surface.

Other times there might be some or no affect. For example, a drug readily absorbed and excreted in your urine will not necessarily get to your lower intestine in any significant amounts. Everywhere the drug goes after it is absorbed is to places in the body which don't have bacteria except for the pathogens. It might affect some bacteria because the mucus membrane has a blood supply, but the bacteria might still be unaffected for a number of reasons like the pH or mucus surrounding the bacteria.

I'm not sure what your point is? Every time you take a half course of an antibiotic is not going to absolutely produce a complete drug resistant gene. I mentioned already it is a little more gradual than that.
 
The full course is much better for producing a strain that is antibiotic resistant.

Are you sure?
Logically, I can see it...but biology with throw you for a loop every time.

Selection pressure. The higher and more prolonged the selection pressure, the more likely is that traits become widespread that negate the selection pressure.

There's not just the pathogenic bacteria in the bodies. taking a full course of antibiotics will increase the selection pressure on all bacteria in (and possibly, on) the body.

bacteria, unlike humans, can change their genetic makeup through bacterial sex. Plasmid rings can cross species barriers. This means, by making your own probiotic bacterial flora resistant to antibiotics by taking the full course, you are also making the pathogenic bacteria resistant in the long run, even if these pathogenic bacteria are not of the same type as your probiotic flora. (Though they often are)

Expected result: Any resistance to antibiotics will be increased proportionally to the amount of antibiotics taken.

Example: The most drug-resistant bacteria are found in hospitals where they come in constant contact with antibiotics.

Conclusion: taking the full course of antibiotics will lead to more resistant strains in future infections than taking only partial courses. The hypothesis that taking the full course will destroy *all* bacteria and thus also destroy the resistent ones is deeply flawed.

Unless someone here shows me a convincing study to the opposite end, and I mean a carefully designed RCT, not a dumbass population based study (HOSPITALS, Jebus!) I conclude that the idea that taking partial courses of antibiotics will somehow result in more resistant strains than taking the full course is at the very best a medical urban myth, and attribute assertions to the contrary despite lack of evidence to retardation.

Discussion: What remains to be investigated is *why* this urban myth came into being, or maybe: who paid money for it?

Edit: In regards to this thread, which is still about medical education, the high incidence of drug-resistant bacterial strains in hospitals is one more reason the current health care system needs to be fundamentally revised. Herding masses of people, especially sick people, into a tight confined space like a hospital, is an extremely dumb idea. Promoting self-treatment, or assistance at home, may turn out to be vastly superior in the long run.
 
Last edited:
'W', your claims are dubious and you cite no sources. Why should anyone believe you know what you are talking about?

You are one of those people I think the OP had in mind. A little more medical education in high school might have done you some good.

There's a wealth of research on the Internet on the mechanisms of developing antibiotic resistance. Why not read a bit and report back to us with some links?
 
Last edited:
skeptigirl said:
Yes, a full course of antibiotics for one infection will kill some normal bacteria completely. But those bacteria are common and are soon reintroduced.
Does it sometimes just reduce the amount of some species greatly? And then after the antibiotics are stopped, they recover?

Everywhere the drug goes after it is absorbed is to places in the body which don't have bacteria except for the pathogens. It might affect some bacteria because the mucus membrane has a blood supply, but the bacteria might still be unaffected for a number of reasons like the pH or mucus surrounding the bacteria.

But obviously the drug has to get to places without pathogens, or it wouldn't kill normal flora, too.

I'm not sure what your point is? Every time you take a half course of an antibiotic is not going to absolutely produce a complete drug resistant gene. I mentioned already it is a little more gradual than that.

I guess I'm wondering what the evidence is that supports the idea that taking half courses of antibiotics contributes more to antibiotic resistance than full courses do.
I've repeated it myself a hundred times, but when I was asked about it, I realised that I'd never actually seen the evidence.
 
'W', your claims are dubious and you cite no sources. Why should anyone believe you know what you are talking about?
I don't care if you believe me. I don't care if you believe I know what I'm talking about. Look it up for yourself!
You are one of those people I think the OP had in mind. A little more medical education in high school might have done you some good.
You may have missed that I'm the OP.
There's a wealth of research on the Internet on the mechanisms of developing antibiotic resistance. Why not read a bit and report back to us with some links?
The mechanism can be intuitively understood by anyone who doesn't think the world was created 6000 years ago. Selective pressure.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom