Medicine should be taught in high school

Agreed. I was recently privileged to have dinner with Dr. Art Grollman, and we talked antioxidants for about an hour. ... so meanwhile, we ate greasy fried food we knew was totally unhealthy.

Gives perspective.

Ha! How cool. Except for that fried dog you consumed. :D

What would the topic be called? You start it. I'm too busy to keep up in this topic right now, let alone a cool anti-oxidant one.
 
Are you and I even speaking the same language, skeptigirl?
I'm apparently doing a terrible job of articulating my thoughts. Or something.
Ok...
The issue under discussion is a partial course of antibiotics vs a full course. Nowhere have I said here that taking a full course of antibiotics assured elimination of a carrier state or avoided antibiotic resistance. I said a partial course was more likely to leave behind resistant bacteria. This is what I said
In addition, while in many cases an infection only ends when the pathogen is eliminated, there are times when the disease process ends but the bacteria, including known pathogens, remain. So taking an incomplete course of antibiotics may make you well while not eliminating the carrier state while a complete course might have eliminated the carrier state.
Nowhere does that say carrier states are eliminated every time you complete a full course of antibiotics.

If you had brought up this particular H-flu study and asked how it fit into the picture, I could have answered you. Each species and even strains within species have unique elements involved. You can either address the general principles of infectious disease or you can address very specific pathogens and specific situations.

All you have in this article is evidence with H-flu in this study, treating OM didn't eliminate the carrier state in any of the cases. It tells you nothing about whether or not partial antibiotic course or a full antibiotic course was more likely to induce antibiotic resistance. In this case and in many cases including the one I posted with the floroquinolones all antibiotic treatment increases the risk of drug resistant strains developing, and, being colonized with any pathogens is going to carry some risk of resistance developing with a course of antibiotics.

So getting back to the original issue, which is a worse risk factor for developing antibiotic resistance, a full treatment course or a partial treatment course, because I said in comparing the two, a partial treatment course could leave colonized bacteria while eliminating the infection, you assumed I meant every time you completed a course of antibiotics, you eliminated all bacteria. Yet I never said that. In fact, if you had bothered to read what I posted and tried to understand the multiple issues involved instead of just focusing on your quest for some magical clinical trial as if that was the only way to answer any question, you might have noticed I suggested it would take large doses of multiple antibiotics to kill most or all bacteria in one's body. Drug resistance could therefore easily develop with any single course of antibiotics. In the case of the floroquinolones, I specifically pointed that out.

But sometimes, antibiotics do eliminate carriage of some bacteria. Impact of Antimicrobial Therapy on Nasopharyngeal Carriage of Streptococcus pneumoniae, Haemophilus influenzae, and Branhamella catarrhalis in Children with Respiratory Tract Infections
We conducted a multicenter prospective study to document changes in nasopharyngeal carriage of Streptococcus pneumoniae, Haemophilus influenzae, and Branhamella catarrhalis during antibiotic therapy. A cohort of 629 children with respiratory tract infections underwent nasopharyngeal sampling before and after antibiotic treatment. Susceptibility testing, serotyping, arbitrarily primed polymerase chain reaction, and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis were used to compare pretreatment and posttreatment strains of S. pneumoniae. A significant decrease in carriage of all 3 species (especially S. pneumoniae and B. catarrhalis) was recorded. The increase in the proportion of penicillin-resistant pneumococci (PRP; 66% vs. 44%) was due to the decreased carriage of penicillin-susceptible pneumococci (71 of 629 vs. 176 of 629). The risk of PRP carriage in a given child did not increase. None of the children was found to harbor genetically related strains with increased minimum inhibitory concentrations. Given the multiple resistance of PRP, bgr-lactam antibiotic therapy also increased the incidence of macrolide-resistant strains, whereas macrolides selected both macrolide- and penicillin-resistant strains.

As to factors affecting colonization...
Many factors influence nasopharyngeal carriage rates: age, season, type of child day care, number of siblings, acute respiratory illness, diet (breast-feeding versus bottle-feeding), sleeping position. In adults, other factors are implicated: presence of children at home or at the workplace, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), obesity, immunosuppression, allergic conditions, acute sinusitis, etc.

Otitis media
A strong correlation between the nasopharyngeal flora and middle ear infections has been found. In this way, nasopharyngeal colonization by H. influenzae, S. pneumoniae and/or M. catarrhalis in the first year of life is associated with an increased risk of recurrent otitis media compared with children who remain free of colonization.10,33,46 Another important reason for the high incidence of AOM among young children in particular seems to be very heavy colonization by potential pathogens in the nasopharynx in this age group. Potential pathogens may constitute >90% of the total bacterial count.90 In contrast, among healthy children viridans streptococci are predominant.91 Data from Syrjanen et al.47 show that S. pneumoniae carriage is lower during health (13–43%) than during AOM episodes, in particular during pneumococcal AOM (97–100%). Also, it has been shown that otitis-prone children tend to be colonized more often than non-otitis-prone children.74 On the other hand, nasopharyngeal colonization with resistant bacteria is associated with an increased incidence of unresolved otitis media.

Antibiotic therapy
Antimicrobial treatment interferes with isolation rates of potential pathogens; lower isolation rates have been observed during and soon after antibiotic treatment, compared with pre-treatment rates. However, antimicrobial agents do not eradicate bacteria from the nasopharynx and the reduction in carriage is only temporary. After treatment, a rapid replacement of strains occurs with either overgrowth of more resistant strains that were masked by other organisms or by newly acquired resistant strains.22,30,77,78,97–99

Thus, antibiotics induce several changes in nasopharyngeal flora: (i) suppression of susceptible bacteria, thereby creating an ecological niche for more resistant organisms; (ii) an increase in the number of resistant bacteria; (iii) an increase in the prevalence of antibiotic-resistant viridans streptococci, which constitute a reservoir of resistance genes that can be transferred to other bacterial species, such as S. pneumoniae; and (iv) they disturb the balance between pathogenic bacteria and α-haemolytic streptococci as a result of differential antibiotic susceptibility.2,100,101

However, the effects of antibiotics appear to differ according to the drug prescribed and the bacterial species. One may expect that drugs that have most antibacterial activity and greater penetration of the nasopharynx will achieve better eradication than those with less favourable pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic properties. Antibiotics appear to be more active against M. catarrhalis and S. pneumoniae than against H. influenzae. Several studies demonstrate that H. influenzae carriage is only slightly affected by drug administration, including third-generation cephalosporins and co-amoxiclav. 77,78,98 In contrast, agents active against S. pneumoniae induced a drastic fall in the carriage of penicillin-susceptible pneumococci, thereby increasing the proportion of penicillinresistant strains after treatment (Table 5).22,30,98,102 Nasopharyngeal carriage of M. catarrhalis is significantly decreased by the most active drugs against this species.30 However, data from several studies have shown that the percentage of β-lactamase-producing strains of either M. catarrhalis or H. influenzae does not increase at the end of the treatment.30,78

Macrolides also eliminated the carriage of macrolidesusceptible S. pneumoniae but rapidly selected both macrolideresistant macrolideresistant and penicillin-resistant strains.99,102 Leach et al.97 showed prolonged carriage of S. pneumoniae after a single dose of azithromycin for the treatment of trachoma. Rates of carriage immediately before treatment and 2–3 weeks, 2 months and 6 months after treatment were 68%, 29%, 78% and 87%, respectively. Also, they showed a more rapid appearance of macrolide-resistant strains in previously colonized children than in previously uncolonized children.

Abdel-Haq et al.17 demonstrated an association between co-trimoxazole prophylaxis and nasopharyngeal colonization with both co-trimoxazole- and penicillin-resistant pneumococci. The carriage of co-trimoxazole-resistant pneumococci increased from 13% in the control group to 64% in the study prophylaxis group. Also, decreased susceptibility to penicillin increased from 7% to 82% and resistance to erythromycin increased from 0% in the control group to 36% in the prophylaxis group.

Thus, geographical variations in antimicrobial susceptibility can be explained by the general consumption of antimicrobial agents. Recent findings at an orphanage in Paris probably represent the peak of antibiotic resistance with a rate of penicillin resistance that exceeded 94%.31

The absence of resistant pneumococcal strains in The Netherlands found by Bogaert et al.29 (only 2% of the isolates were resistant to erythromycin, and no resistance to penicillin, co-trimoxazole or tetracycline was detected) may be explained by the restricted use of antibiotics compared with that
in many other countries. In contrast, the high rates of resistance to penicillin (83.5%) and co-trimoxazole (83.5%) found by Joloba et al.41 reflect the frequent prescription of these agents in Uganda (Table 6).

In conclusion, antibiotic use is the primary risk factor for carriage of resistant nasopharyngeal bacteria, particularly where exposure to low levels continues for prolonged periods. Youth has also been considered a risk factor for colonization with resistant bacteria,103 but day-care attendance and frequent use of empirical antibiotics are significant risk factors. Other factors associated with a higher risk of antibioticresistant bacterial carriage include presence of older siblings, 81,102,104,105 hospitalization and nosocomial acquisition, travel,40 winter months and urban living.28,37
You are trying to make this about taking antibiotics. The question is about not finishing the prescribed course. And you have yet to explain even an hypothesis of how that is going to result in less risk of antibiotic resistance. If you undertreat an infection, not only do you have the bacteria which weren't going to be eliminated developing resistance, you also have in addition, the bacteria which were going to be eliminated developing resistance.

So you couldn't find anything?
I did not look. And there is no reason to.

Now what did I say that gave you the impression that I thought otherwise?
You don't seem to understand the issues of colonization, carrier state, and normal bacteria which can also infect bladders, ears and multiple other sites. IN addition, you don't seem to recognize just how many factors are involved here. You seem to think that your idea of a partial course vs a full course is the variable involved in whatever it is you think is occurring. A basic understanding of the actual principles involved would show you your thinking is flawed.
Let me show you how this is done:

I'm not going to just make the claim "You are incorrect" and hope you just believe in me like Jesus that I know what I'm talking about.
I don't think you are making a case here that you know what you are talking about and I don't. On the one hand we all need sufficient evidence of any claims whether or not the person making the claims has expertise. On the other hand, I think I'd be darn careful I understood what a person was saying and that my knowledge was at least as competent as theirs before I'd make the assumption the person with an extensive background in a particular field was wrong and I was right.

I'll have to address the rest of your post later.
 
Last edited:
.... Since we just make up the time course for the administration of antibiotics it may be that partial courses are fine for some people. ....
Where did you get this idea? The length of treatment is determined by following cases, trends, community pathogens, and actual research.

Treatment guidelines are in no way a "guess". And as far as a partial course for some people, that isn't practical. How would you make that determination? Clinical guidelines are established so you prescribe the best options for the majority of people. No prescriber I know goes around adding days of treatment for insurance of success. We go by the current standards.

For example:

What is the optimal length of proton pump inhibitor-based triple therapies for H. pylori? A cost-effectiveness analysis

ICAAC: Short-Course Antibiotics Effective Against Pneumonia

How long should we treat community-acquired pneumonia?.
 
Last edited:
Where did you get this idea? The length of treatment is determined by following cases, trends, community pathogens, and actual research.

Treatment guidelines are in no way a "guess". And as far as a partial course for some people, that isn't practical. How would you make that determination? Clinical guidelines are established so you prescribe the best options for the majority of people. No prescriber I know goes around adding days of treatment for insurance of success. We go by the current standards.

For example:

What is the optimal length of proton pump inhibitor-based triple therapies for H. pylori? A cost-effectiveness analysis

ICAAC: Short-Course Antibiotics Effective Against Pneumonia

How long should we treat community-acquired pneumonia?.

Where did I get the idea? From the ID guys with whom I rotated in medical school. The lengths of time are simply made up. Everyone who works in the field with whom I have spoken about it is quite clear on that. Do you honestly think that bacteria work on seven day, three day, ten day and fourteen day schedules? No one knows the precise length of time that is necessary to treat an infection so we make up convenient time periods. Those are very human numbers. They are pretty close to what is needed, but they are not precise numbers exactly tailored through intensive evidence-based investigation. They are quick guides that ease the administration of drug studies.

I'm not implying that they are completely random, just that they are not precise and they are probably often overkill for many patients. But that is what we want for most infections. The fact that they are overkill for some people is why some folks get away with partial courses.

Drug trials generally work in arbitrary time periods. That's how they are done. People have gone back afterwards and tweaked the time periods a bit because of this fact and so some drug trials in the past few years have used shorter courses. But they all essentially work on the same paradigm.
 
Where did I get the idea? From the ID guys with whom I rotated in medical school. The lengths of time are simply made up. Everyone who works in the field with whom I have spoken about it is quite clear on that. Do you honestly think that bacteria work on seven day, three day, ten day and fourteen day schedules? No one knows the precise length of time that is necessary to treat an infection so we make up convenient time periods. Those are very human numbers. They are pretty close to what is needed, but they are not precise numbers exactly tailored through intensive evidence-based investigation. They are quick guides that ease the administration of drug studies.

I'm not implying that they are completely random, just that they are not precise and they are probably often overkill for many patients. But that is what we want for most infections. The fact that they are overkill for some people is why some folks get away with partial courses.

Drug trials generally work in arbitrary time periods. That's how they are done. People have gone back afterwards and tweaked the time periods a bit because of this fact and so some drug trials in the past few years have used shorter courses. But they all essentially work on the same paradigm.

That would depend on the particular union the bacteria are members of;)
 
skeptigirl said:
The issue under discussion is a partial course of antibiotics vs a full course.
Right. And the question of "elimination as opposed to a return to carriage" the quite relevant when it comes to whether or not a full course will create more resistance than a shorter course.

All you have in this article is evidence with H-flu in this study, treating OM didn't eliminate the carrier state in any of the cases. It tells you nothing about whether or not partial antibiotic course or a full antibiotic course was more likely to induce antibiotic resistance.

How can the survivors of a full course not pop out more resistant at the end compared to those that survive a partial course?

In this case and in many cases including the one I posted with the floroquinolones all antibiotic treatment increases the risk of drug resistant strains developing, and, being colonized with any pathogens is going to carry some risk of resistance developing with a course of antibiotics.

Right.
That's sort of my point, too.

So getting back to the original issue, which is a worse risk factor for developing antibiotic resistance, a full treatment course or a partial treatment course, because I said in comparing the two, a partial treatment course could leave colonized bacteria while eliminating the infection, you assumed I meant every time you completed a course of antibiotics, you eliminated all bacteria.

How often eradication of the sensitive species is achieved is the relevant question. If a return to colonization happens more frequently than eradication, then longer courses will create more resistance.

In fact, if you had bothered to read what I posted and tried to understand the multiple issues involved instead of just focusing on your quest for some magical clinical trial as if that was the only way to answer any question,

Hey, I was just asking you to back up your claim. I'd be happy with some little observational study or anything other than your own assumptions.
You are trying to make this about taking antibiotics. The question is about not finishing the prescribed course. And you have yet to explain even an hypothesis of how that is going to result in less risk of antibiotic resistance. If you undertreat an infection, not only do you have the bacteria which weren't going to be eliminated developing resistance, you also have in addition, the bacteria which were going to be eliminated developing resistance.

First of all, I have explained it several times in this thread. It's not my fault you're not reading my posts.
Secondly, if the bacteria that "were going to be eliminated" aren't usually eliminated, that splits the question from here into a question of
1) how resistant are the survivors of a partial course compared to a full course
2) and is it worth it to risk creating greater resistance for a small chance of total elimination?


And that's not even getting into what happens to the other floral species, and how they can horizontally transfer resistance information.

I did not look. And there is no reason to.

I'm starting to think you might be right about that. Not in the way you mean, though.

On the other hand, I think I'd be darn careful I understood what a person was saying and that my knowledge was at least as competent as theirs before I'd make the assumption the person with an extensive background in a particular field was wrong and I was right.

Well, you assumed a lot was known about the human immune response to the potentially pathogenic colonizers when they're behaving as flora.
I assumed you knew that not a lot was known, and then you provide evidence that you've never even looked into it before. In the context of you telling me that I don't know what I'm talking about.

It's getting old. You can't just go around clearly making stuff up and expecting people to continue just trusting you without evidence.
 
Last edited:
I thought the issue was teaching medicine in school. But that might just be me.

This fascinating thread does illustrate the problems with teaching advanced medicine in school, and probably even simple issues, due to the controversy surrounding medical knowledge, and the changes that take place. What was once known to be true and self evident, can be dead wrong.

Speaking of
http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/ref/10.1046/j.1523-5378.7.s1.7.x
there is a lot of stuff being studied in regards to antibiotics and other treatments, both because of the increasingly deadly problem of creating mutant strains of ordinary bacteria, and the cost of treatment.

I'd like to think that in countries that place medical efficiency before profit, means to prevent disease and treat illness are being researched and used that are not drug dependent. The Medical monopoly in the Big Brother country is unbelievable. If you actually teach the basics of Medical knowledge to bright interested young adults, they are going to start questioning stuff. At least the skeptics among them might.

They already question a lot of stuff, you start letting them see how medicine works, they might become Doctors, or they might become heretics. Especially if they grew up using alternative health and nutrition to avoid illness.

There are millions of young adults in school right now that already suspect and distrust the ruling monopoly, based on the real evidence of how deadly it can be to end up in a Hospital, and how expensive it is.

It is far cheaper to avoid getting sick than it is to treat an illness. Unless it is an inherent problem, most illness and disease can be avoided, by taking good care.

This isn't anything mysterious to learn. But it that going to be taught in school?
 
robinson said:
Unless it is an inherent problem, most illness and disease can be avoided, by taking good care.
Well...sometimes. Maybe even usually. Definitely not always, though.
 
Examples?

I avoided saying accidents and injuries, though most of those can be avoided as well.
 
Examples?

I avoided saying accidents and injuries, though most of those can be avoided as well.

There doesn't appear to be a rhyme or reason to which folks get a wacky immune reaction to measles that causes encephalitis...
Sometimes "healthy' kids who's parents do everything 'right' get bacterial meningitis (although the risk can be reduced quite a bit)...
People who've always treated their bodies very well sometimes get cancer...

I honestly can't think of any disease (or nasty complication of it) that can be prevented 100% by taking good care. I think the best you can do is reduce risk factors, but know that it's not a guarantee even then.

I guess you could say that when things should go right but they go wrong, there might be an unidentified inherent problem, but it's hard to know what's going on one way or another, really.
 
I can think of a hundred diseases you will never get, if you take care of yourself. If you exclude genetic disorders, accidents and environmental toxins, most disease is preventable.

We might not like the efforts that are required, or the conditions, but we pretty much know how to keep the human body healthy now.

I said most diseases, because obviously it isn't going to be all. Everybody will eventually get sick, if for no other reason than age.
 
I can think of a hundred diseases you will never get, if you take care of yourself.

Probably never get, or definitely never get?

Which ones? (not asking for hundreds, by the way...a few will do).
 
Take your pick. Some of these I am obviously never going to get, no matter what. :D

* AIDS
* allergies
* Alzheimer's disease
* anxiety disorders
* arthritis
* asthma
* astigmatism
* autoimmune diseases
* benign prostate hyperplasia (BPH)
* bipolar disorder (manic-depressive)
* brain cancer
* breast cancer
* cancer
* candidiasis
* cataracts
* celiac disease
* cervical cancer
* chicken pox
* chlamydia
* chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS)
* chronic illness
* cold sores
* colon cancer
* constipation
* common cold
* COPD
* cough
* Crohn's disease
* cystic fibrosis
* dementia
* diabetes
* diarrhea
* depression
* eczema
* endometriosis
* eye disorders
* fibroids
* fibromyalgia
* flu (influenza)
* food poisoning
* Gallstones
* genital herpes
* gonorrhea
* Graves' disease
* Hashimoto's thyroiditis
* hay fever
* headache
* heart disease
* hemochromatosis
* hepatitis
* herpes
* high cholesterol
* HIV
* Hodgkin's disease
* HPV (human papilloma virus)
* hypertension
* impotence
* insomnia
* irritable bowel syndrome
* jaundice
* kidney disease
* lactose intolerance
* leukemia
* liver cancer
* liver disease
* lung cancer
* lupus
* Lyme disease
* lymphoma
* meningitis
* meningococcal disease
* menopause
* mental illness
* myopia (short-sightedness)
* migraine
* multiple sclerosis
* muscular dystrophy
* narcolepsy
* Non-Hodgkin's lymphoma
* obesity
* osteoporosis
* otitis media (middle ear infection)
* ovarian cancer
* overweight
* pain
* Parkinson's disease
* pelvic inflammatory disease
* pertussis
* pregnancy
* premenstrual syndrome (PMS)
* prostate cancer
* prostate disorders
* Raynaud's Phenomenon
* SARS
* sexually transmitted diseases
* sleep disorders
* smoking
* stroke
* thrush
* thyroid disorders
* whooping cough
http://cureresearch.com/lists/condsaz.htm

I find it interesting that pregnancy is a disease.
 
Last edited:
But people who do everything right *do* get those diseases.
Just to take the last one (coz I'm lazy)

* whooping cough
How do you avoid that? Even the vaccine has at least a 15% failure rate.
Overall health doesn't prevent bad cases.

ETA:

pregnancy

Pregnancy is not a disease!!! (regardless of what my OB thinks.)

ETAA:
* flu (influenza)

The only way to prevent that for sure is death. Or living in a bubble or something absurdly extreme like that.
 
Last edited:
Adults and adolescents are the primary reservoir for pertussis. Pertussis is spread by contact with airborne discharges from the mucous membranes of infected people, who are most contagious during the catarrhal stage. Because the symptoms during the catarrhal stage are nonspecific, pertussis is usually not diagnosed until the appearance of the characteristic cough of the paroxysmal stage
Wiki

Obviously you avoid people, or wear a mask to prevent transmission when you are around kids, or hell, anybody while you have it. The obvious answer to infectious disease is to stop spreading it. This is far easier and cheaper than treating it.

I find it unbelievable that people with contagious diseases, spread by coughing, are not required to wear a mask to prevent infection from spreading.

Ever go to a Doctors office and sit in the waiting room during an outbreak of some contagious disease? If you are there for just a checkup, you are exposed to all kinds of pathogens from other people.

Yet asking a sick person to wear a mask, you would think you had insulted their ancestors or something. Madness.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom