Medicine should be taught in high school

Kelly: "How can the survivors of a full course not pop out more resistant at the end compared to those that survive a partial course?"

I think you acknowledged an answer up there somewhere but in case not, the answer is still in odds. The odds are the full course isn't leaving more survivors, despite your article on the H-flu. The odds are the partial course is almost certainly leaving survivors.
 
Kelly: How often eradication of the sensitive species is achieved is the relevant question. If a return to colonization happens more frequently than eradication, then longer courses will create more resistance.

This goes back to what I said in post 240. What is this person taking the antibiotic for? For an infection. I asked you earlier, what do you think is the result of just stopping the treatment? You seem to think nothing happens except the remaining bacteria are more or less resistant. But that isn't what happens. The infection you were treating relapses most of the time.

Even if you had colonization, the bacteria causing the active infection are much more of a concern. So you are talking about leaving partially treated organisms in the midst of an infection. They are growing more rapidly than merely a benign colony.
 
Kelly: Hey, I was just asking you to back up your claim. I'd be happy with some little observational study or anything other than your own assumptions.

A study of what??????????? Basic infectious disease principles? You just don't seem to get that. It is the basic concepts here you are missing, not the lack of a study or a citation.
 
Kelly 1) how resistant are the survivors of a partial course compared to a full course
2) and is it worth it to risk creating greater resistance for a small chance of total elimination?


See post 242.

This is your disconnect again. Is what worth it? Treating the infection you are treating? If it wasn't then why are you treating it in the first place?

Why would you only half treat it and why do you think that has no consequences?
 
skeptigirl said:
For an infection. I asked you earlier, what do you think is the result of just stopping the treatment? You seem to think nothing happens except the remaining bacteria are more or less resistant. But that isn't what happens. The infection you were treating relapses most of the time.

See...I just don't buy that the infection "usually relapses".
Are you talking about stuff like upper respiratory infections, UTIs, OM, etc?
The more benign infections...or just the invasive infections?
Are you talking about only in the elderly or immunocompromised, or also in the "healthy"?

ETA:

Multiquote, Skeptigirl...it's useful. :)
 
It looks like this -->
multiquote_off.gif


So, there is no basic science, no core experiments to point to? What about the H Pylori studies, experiments, that whole issue? It is ongoing, and seems very much to reflect the questions raised.
 
See...I just don't buy that the infection "usually relapses".
Are you talking about stuff like upper respiratory infections, UTIs, OM, etc?
The more benign infections...or just the invasive infections?
Are you talking about only in the elderly or immunocompromised, or also in the "healthy"?
I am talking about bacterial infections which a course of antibiotics are indicated.

I am definitely not talking about viral URIs for which physicians over prescribe.

The OM issue is another case and too complicated to apply here since there are some OMs which do need treatment and some which there are recommendations not to treat. We'd have to clarify that before using OM as an example. I brought it up just to illustrate a concept.

So how many UTIs do you know of which spontaneously resolved? How many cases of impetigo? How many cases of bacterial pneumonias?

If your argument is antibiotics are over prescribed, then we agree. If you really think bacterial infections are not serious or dangerous and the immune system can handle them, I suggest you look at history before WWII when the use of penicillin dramatically increased.

ETA:

Multiquote, Skeptigirl...it's useful. :)
I don't know what you mean by this. If you are referring to the last couple of posts, I got tired of answering the same things over and over. I just picked a few out to address to try to get to the actual issue that was preventing you from understanding what I was saying. And it appears to have worked.
 
Last edited:
She must have me on ignore. :(

Multiquote, it looks like this -->
multiquote_off.gif

Until you click it, then it looks like this -->
multiquote_on.gif


It is right next to the quote button, lower left hand corner. If you click it, you can quote and respond to multiple postings at once. When you are ready to respond, hit quote for the final posting. They all get quoted at once.
 
Last edited:
So how many UTIs do you know of which spontaneously resolved? How many cases of impetigo? How many cases of bacterial pneumonias?

You want to hear anecdotes? Seriously?
I can provide them, but I'm not sure that's really a great way of determining the actual frequency of an occurrance.

If your argument is antibiotics are over prescribed, then we agree. If you really think bacterial infections are not serious or dangerous and the immune system can handle them, I suggest you look at history before WWII when the use of penicillin dramatically increased.
That's not what I'm saying. Even 'minor' bacterial infections can turn deadly. Sometimes they last a long time without antibiotics.
Most of the more minor ones will resolve on their own, though. (As far as I know. I'm open to evidence that I'm incorrect.)
It's just risky sometimes, because it doesn't always go like that.
 
You want to hear anecdotes? Seriously?
I can provide them, but I'm not sure that's really a great way of determining the actual frequency of an occurrance.
What, no research?


That's not what I'm saying. Even 'minor' bacterial infections can turn deadly. Sometimes they last a long time without antibiotics.
Most of the more minor ones will resolve on their own, though. (As far as I know. I'm open to evidence that I'm incorrect.)
It's just risky sometimes, because it doesn't always go like that.
You are claiming that the full course of antibiotics can just be stopped whenever. Now you say maybe not. Which is it? What constitutes a minor infection? I don't prescribe antibiotics for minor infections except the topical generic equivalent of Neosporin. If you have an anecdote of a UTI resolving spontaneously, I'd want to see the initial and post infection cultures. Otherwise all you have is someone who thinks they had a UTI.

So which infections are you arguing can be half treated in order to decrease the risk of antibiotic resistance in this scenario of yours?

Adverse outcomes of untreated ASB:
premature or low-birth weight infant, early pregnancy loss, pyelonephritis during pregnancy (20-30-fold) compared with women without bacteriuria, hypertension. Rx decreases risk of pyelonephritis to 1-4% and improves fetal outcomes. Screening urine cx at end of 1st trimester recommended based on clinical outcomes and cost effectiveness. Rx all that meet lab definition.

Perinatal Risk for Mortality and Mental Retardation Associated with Maternal Urinary-Tract Infections
KEY POINTS

* Analyses of National Collaborative Perinatal Project (NCPP) data from the 1970s and Medicaid data from the 1990s support an association between third trimester maternal urinary tract infection (UTI) and mental retardation or developmental delay.

* The NCPP data support an association between third trimester maternal UTI and fetal death.

* OBJECTIVE We analyzed the relationship between fetal exposure to maternal urinary tract infections (UTIs) and mental retardation or developmental delay and fetal death.

* STUDY DESIGN A retrospective cohort design was used to explore the risk for fetal death and mental retardation or developmental delay associated with exposure to maternal UTI during pregnancy....

...* RESULTS There was an increased relative risk (PR) for mental retardation or developmental delay in the third trimester of pregnancy (RR=1.40; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.01-1.95) in the NCPP, and there was a similar risk in the Medicaid data. The third trimester relative hazard for fetal death associated with maternal UTI was 2.23 (95% CI, 1.40-3.55).

Impetigo
Many cases of impetigo can be prevented by the application of antibiotic ointments to areas of minor skin trauma. Left untreated impetigo may resolve on its own, however, it may continue to spread
impetigo3.jpg


Bacterial pneumonia is a relatively common acute condition, treatable for the most part with antibiotics. If left untreated in susceptible individuals, such as the elderly, pneumonia can lead to death.
 
When we're talking about "Half treatment" means stopping to take the antibiotic medication when the symptoms of the infection disappear, rather than stubbornly taking the full course.

We're questioning whether the common wisdom theory of the increased rate of creation of resistant bacterial strains is faciliated by this strategy, as opposed to the full course.

We are not discussing whether or not untreated infections can be dangerous. DUH.
 
You are just defining 'arbitrary' differently than I am, precise as in, to "the minute", or precise as in, will be effective in some acceptable % like 98% of the time? And arbitrary as in 7 days or 8 days or 3 days compared to 10? Maybe 7 is arbitrary within 5 to 9 days, but certainly in blocks of time it is not. Is it practical to study blocks of treatment times in hours? days? and for each infection and population studied? No.

Of course it isn't practical to adjust time periods to the minute. But that was part of my point that I mentioned more than once. The issue is that the time period for treatment is arbitrary (because of several constraints), so there are some people who will naturally be able to kill off all bacteria using what we would call a partial course. You're the one who misinterpreted what I wrote and tried to make a much bigger deal out of it than I.

But at the same time, for this person who was going to be OK on day 6, are you suggesting people just arbitrarily stop antibiotics? It isn't arbitrary just because 48 or 72 hour blocks of time were the most practical way to determine the standard course of treatment.

No, of course not. In previous posts I thought I made it abundantly clear that this is just an issue of the time period being arbitrary so the original person who started this discussion is not completely out in left field in his/her assertions. They're just mostly wacky.

I'm not advocating anything. In fact, I have tried to make it clear that taking a full course is the best way to go about it in most cases because partial courses lead to resistance development, and I thought I laid out the reasons why. You even quoted that post as to why there is a problem, but you seem to think that I am advocating some other position -- even when I explicitly stated that I was not. I was and still am trying to point out that this is not a cut and dried simple issue -- just use a full course and everything will be OK. There is a small kernel of truth in the original poster's first pronouncements, however much the real information has been distorted and turned into bad policy. I think it is important that we not lose sight of the real biology.

The whole issue of resistance development, however, is very complicated and the one issue that still bothers me is the development of resistance (usually through plasmid transfer) in gut (and sometimes skin) flora. People who need to use long courses of antibiotics often end up creating or being colonized by multiresistant strains of Enterococcus, Klebsiella, or Serratia (amongst others). Those organisms develop their resistance through long course treatment with antibiotics not because we stop and start them willy-nilly. As long as we can keep these people isolated this is only a problem for them and not for the general public.

The disconnect here is the belief that there is no reason to urge patients to finish a course of an antibiotic. When they are supposed to stop taking it and how they are supposed to know hasn't been addressed.

First of all, I do not now, nor have I ever, urged anyone to stop taking a full course. And I have addressed when people are to know -- they can't. I specifically said that is one of the issues in dealing with this. No one can know when they have taken enough antibiotic to treat fully whatever infection they might have, but there are times when the full course is overkill in some people. That's just the nature of how the process works. When you use overkill to take care of the infecting organisms then that is a good thing (as far as that bacterium is concerned). There is no possibility of resistance forming in organisms that are wiped from the body. The problem doesn't potentially arise there, though. The problem might arise in other bacteria when we use broad spectrum antibiotics, especially those that affect gram negatives and which have some gut penetrance (I'm not aware of this being that much of a problem for the oropharyngeal flora). The original poster wasn't wrong in saying that a full course of antibiotics can be a problem. He just got the emphasis wrong. He seemed to think that not treating an infection is the right way to go because resistance is forming in the original infecting organisms. But that doesn't seem to be the case. Resistance may simply form in the other bacteria that we need to live when they are exposed to antibiotics. And it is clear that a full course of antibiotics is more likely to produce this effect.

Again, I'm not advocating that we not fully treat infections. I'm saying that treatment does not occur in a vacuum and that this is not a simple issue. We are not simple structures. We are colonies and treatment of one part has effects in other parts of our bodies. That is what medicine is all about and why teaching it in high school and expecting people to be able to diagnose themselves and make good decisions is a very bad idea. There is nothing inherently difficult in medicine. Frankly, it is pretty intellectually boring once you get the hang of it. It is in the system interactions that the real work takes place -- and this issue fits nicely into those systems problems despite the fact that some people think this is a separate issue from the OP.

Resistance does develop in our colonizing bacteria, and it develops because of the antibiotics that we use in full course. You cannot simply think about the infecting organisms to get a full picture of this process. You've got tho think about the colonizers in us -- that are part of who and what we are. Thankfully this is not a problem for most people, but it is an issue in two populations -- folks in nursing homes and in other long-term care facitilies where antibiotics are commonly used and where plasmids are more easily transferred from one person to another.


You say bacteria don't work on a schedule, I beg to differ, they most certainly do.

I didn't say that. I said they don't work on three day, seven day, ten day, or fourteen day schedules. We work on those schedules. Please do not put words in my mouth that I did not speak, or write.

The factors which go into determining dose and the length of treatment are infection site (can affect peak drug concentrations and the resulting half life as well as the typical extent of infection), the antibiotic's mechanism of action, and the rate of reproduction of the organisms. The simplest example is the most common mechanism of action, that of preventing the production of a new cell wall forming thus killing dividing organisms. Length of treatment is simple. How long will it take for the last bacteria to divide and die? That is a known measurable quantity.

If you are treating TB which is an extremely slow growing organism, for example, Treatment length from some infections can sometimes be prescribed as 48 hours after all symptoms abate but again, that isn't practical if the patient isn't reliable nor in cases where symptoms are not an accurate measure of the absence of infection, so a standard length of treatment is more practical.

But this discussion really is missing the point which I think is the reason there is so much misunderstanding going on. Kelly's question and the discussion is whether or not treating an infection incompletely leads to more risk of antibiotic resistance or not. Treatment length is not determined with the main goal of preventing antibiotic resistance, it is determined by the clinical outcome. And that is determined by research, not by just arbitrarily rolling dice. And a lot of research has gone on looking at shortening antibiotic courses, sometimes with failure, (A Meta-analysis of Randomized, Controlled Trials Comparing Short- and Long-Couse Antibiotic Therapy for Urinary Tract Infections in Children), and sometimes with success, (Optimal duration of antibiotic therapy for uncomplicated urinary tract infection in older women: a double-blind randomized controlled trial.). If the length of treatment really were as arbitrary as you implied, then you are saying it isn't evidence based. But since it is evidence based, then stopping treatment prematurely means a larger % of cases will be incompletely treated. And that increases the risk of antibiotic resistance.

Getting back to kelly's question, if you can treat an infection successfully with a short course of treatment, you may also expose less bacteria which are not your intended targets to a small enough dose of antibiotic that you do not reach a threshold which induces antibiotic resistance. While true, that is not always the case and it doesn't change what I said about increasing the risk of drug resistance when you partially treat an infection.

I need to digress here and then get back to the above. Considering how frequently doctors prescribe antibiotics needlessly for respiratory viruses, I can see where it probably has been a common experience for many people to stop antibiotics and seeing no relapse, think nothing happened when they did not follow that urging to not stop treatment mid-course.

I have not been discussing that scenario. I am discussing people who are prescribed the correct drug for the standard course for a bacterial infection. So in this discussion of stopping treatment, I am talking about stopping an antibiotic before the infection is cured, or at least before the standard course is finished which assumes then that a significant risk of not being cured exists. So in this scenario if patients stopped taking antibiotics before the prescribed time, then a good percentage of them would relapse. And relapse of a partially treated bacterial infection is a BIG risk factor for developing antibiotic resistance. I hope at least that issue is not in question though I get the impression kelly can't accept that basic well known fact without some research. And it is this fact that I find seeking a citation to be absurd.

We also got into a side track about eliminating all of the bacteria of the same strain as was causing the infection or just the bacteria actually in the infected site. Kelly posted research that H-flu carrier state was not eliminated with the usual course of treating OM caused by H-flu. There are other bacteria, research I cited, which are eliminated by a full course of antibiotics. This only goes to show how many factors are involved in infection and drug resistance.

Given that there are multiple factors involved in the development of antibiotic resistance, it is important to notice when someone is using the words 'can', 'may', 'might', 'more likely', and so on. I will again clarify what I have tried to in my last several posts. If you don't take the full course of antibiotics prescribed for a bacterial infection, there is a greater risk of antibiotic resistance developing from the cumulative mutations which increase with exposure to antibiotics.

Here is why: Those mutations may not have been sufficient to allow the bacteria to fully resist the current antibiotics. So the full course would have eliminated the bacteria leaving behind no partially resistant organisms ready to mutate further the next time.

Are all partially resistant bacteria eliminated with every full course of antibiotics? No and I did not say that. Antibiotic resistance is not currently preventable, we can only delay and contain it. Are you better off stopping antibiotics you started if it is determined you didn't have a bacterial infection after all? Yes, and hopefully that is after a minimal exposure so there is less chance of resistant mutations occurring.

But the scenario in the question was stopping a course of antibiotics before the prescribed time. If you want to strictly look at numbers and odds, you can expect that to lead to infections being partially treated more often than with completed courses of therapy. Thus you can expect cumulative mutations to occur more often which increases the rate of drug resistance developing.

O.K., I think you are missing the point and reading into what other people are writing. I don't know anyone, aside from the original person who brought up this issue, who is advocating partial course treatment. And I think that includes Kelly. She is raising some very interesting issues that you seem to be missing. We all know that partial treatment leaving behind colonizers is more likely to result in resistance. The issue that Kelly has raised, and I think it is a very good one, is that when we treat we do not kill every organism in our bodies (I'm not talking about infecting organisms but our native floras). We couldn't survive if we did. If we had great antibiotics that could not affect our native flora, then none of this would be an issue. With TB treatments, for the most part, we don't have to worry about resistance forming in anything but the TB bug. But when we treat a UTI from entercoccus we must always be concerned about the rest of the enterococci in our body and whether or not the antibiotic is affecting them and potentially resulting in resistance. That simply is more likely to occur when more selection pressure is applied.

I haven't seen anyone advocate anything (again, except for the originating poster). We are simply discussing this as the very big problem that it is. And Kelly has been asking what I consider to be very good questions about it. I don't really see a solution, which is why I said that I think we are screwed in many situations. The only real solution that I have seen advocated is treatment with bacteriophages. I think that is an interesting idea, but I don't know enough about the long-term potential consequences to discuss it rationally.

People tend to make a bigger deal out of this than they should, I think, because I suppose they think there are some outrageous superbugs that are going to take over everyone's body and be untreatable in some super contagion. That is not the real situation. This is a problem mostly for those folks who take antibiotics frequently. Those bugs usually don't spread very easily outside their bodies -- again this is why I said this isn't a problem for most folks.
 
When we're talking about "Half treatment" means stopping to take the antibiotic medication when the symptoms of the infection disappear, rather than stubbornly taking the full course.

We're questioning whether the common wisdom theory of the increased rate of creation of resistant bacterial strains is faciliated by this strategy, as opposed to the full course.

We are not discussing whether or not untreated infections can be dangerous. DUH.


Disappearance of symptoms is not a good guide. There is nothing in the symptoms (many of which arise from the immune response) that will tell you when the infecting organisms have been eradicated. Actually stopping the medication when symptoms disappear is the reason why we see resistance forming in partial treatments most of the time.

Common sense, I'm afraid, is not the way to go here. What we really need is individual markers of bacterial load so that we can guide treatment individually. That would help to limit antibiotic exposure. We just aren't there yet.
 
skeptigirl said:
You are claiming that the full course of antibiotics can just be stopped whenever.
No, I'm not.
Show me where I said that.
Now you say maybe not. Which is it?
Huh?
What constitutes a minor infection?
Sinus infections, OM, mild bronchitis, some skin infections, etc.

So which infections are you arguing can be half treated in order to decrease the risk of antibiotic resistance in this scenario of yours?
What I said was that without evidence I don't believe that without full treatment most infections usually relapse.

Again you post links totally irrelevant to the discussion at hand.
 
We are all talking about different things in this thread. It is making it hard to discuss the issues.

Ichne: It would help if you could quantify the 'arbitrary' range you are referring to. Saying I put words in your mouth when I am trying to resolve the different definitions we are both working with doesn't help matters. I can't read your mind.

You'll have to site specific examples since it would obviously vary. In other words are you claiming that in infection X where the standard Rx is for 7 days that you believe some people are fully treated in 2 days and some in 7? If that is the case then do you have any research backing that up? I do not believe that is the case and so far I have cited studies while you cited hallway medicine.

Kelly: If you aren't arguing people should stop antibiotic courses part way through, then what are you arguing? Are you simply saying that less exposure leads to less resistance? Well that's a no brainer. But it is a completely different issue than whether finishing a prescribed course is an important recommendation to follow. Because in the latter case, assuming the Rx is appropriate (again over prescribing is a different issue) then stopping a prescribed course prematurely will more often than not increase the risk of antibiotic resistance.

You need to consider the result of leaving some vs leaving no partially resistant 'targeted' organisms. Completing the course is going to have different effects on non-targeted organisms. But on the targeted organisms, the whole point of completing treatment is to not leave behind partially resistant organisms.

You seem to me to be arguing one would be better off not completing treatment because the surviving organisms would be less resistant than those surviving a full course of treatment. But the point is you want the full treatment course to not leave any targeted organisms behind.

Think of your question a different way. What is the difference in treating a person with twice as long of a course of antibiotics and treating a person two separate times? The more exposure, the more likely it is going to eventually result in drug resistance, especially in non-targeted organisms. That is a given.

BUT you aren't looking at a couple additional factors. That is you are targeting an organism. You are taking the antibiotic with the goal of not leaving those organisms behind with accumulated mutations which are therefore primed to develop increasing resistance. If you don't leave any of those partially resistant organisms, you have unexposed organisms the next time you treat. So the more often you can kill all antibiotic susceptible organisms the less often you will have mutations accumulating.

Obviously for those organisms which are not all destroyed, you will have accumulating mutations leading to resistance. And that is why providers should be very conservative in prescribing antibiotics. But once prescribed, not completing the course is not better because in addition to leaving behind non-targeted organisms you also leave behind targeted ones.

Then there is a third factor you are not looking at. Say you were comparing one doubled treatment course with those two separate courses of treatment. Yes, the remaining survivors which weren't killed are going to be even more resistant. That is true in both cases.

But in between two separate courses of treatment you gave those organisms a reprieve. You gave them a chance to rebuild their numbers. And they rebuilt them with what are now all partially resistant members. Had you treated for double the time, you might have eliminated all the organisms. By stopping and restarting, they not only regrouped, instead of some organisms having some resistant mutations, now millions have those changes. That is what happens when you allow an infection to relapse instead of completing treatment. Now since most all the organisms in the infection have some mutations, you have millions of chances for the additional mutations which would confer complete resistance to occur in any one of them.

You are only looking at one factor, increasing exposure leading to increasing resistance. That just isn't the only factor involved in the reason for completing a (properly prescribed) course of antibiotics.
 
Last edited:
Again you post links totally irrelevant to the discussion at hand.
Studies looking at optimal treatment length are going to be based on cure vs relapse. How is that not evidence you need X number of days of treatment or you risk relapse? What outcome do you think they are looking at?

Are you arguing relapse is not a contributing factor to antibiotic resistance?
 
Last edited:
skeptigirl said:
Kelly: If you aren't arguing people should stop antibiotic courses part way through, then what are you arguing?
I've explained myself several times in this thread already. Here are a couple of example:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2864473&postcount=112
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2865074&postcount=118

Please...please either read my posts or put me on ignore or something.

Are you simply saying that less exposure leads to less resistance? Well that's a no brainer.
That's not what blutoski says. He says it's a matter of population density and how that affects information exchange. (unless I was misunderstanding him).
Which changes things.

But on the targeted organisms, the whole point of completing treatment is to not leave behind partially resistant organisms.
Well, the evidence is conflicting there. I haven't seen anything where there's a greater than 50% chance of total eradication of the target organism. But the evidence is all over the place. I guess the frequency of total eradication is going to change from year to year, too, since resistance is always in a state of flux.
Either way...blutoski was saying it wasn't a matter of eradication. It's about reducing the population density. When they get "scattered out" they can't swap genes as easily. (again, unless I'm misunderstanding.) So it doesn't matter so much if a species is or isn't totally cleared.
(This is just addressing the issue of resistance. Relapse is a separate issue alltogether.)

You seem to me to be arguing one would be better off not completing treatment because the surviving organisms would be less resistant than those surviving a full course of treatment. But the point is you want the full treatment course to not leave any targeted organisms behind.
Again, I'm not convinced that usually happen even with a full course.
(I can feel a reference war coming on. Sigh. )
And what you're arguing is different from what Blutoski is saying.
But in between two separate courses of treatment you gave those organisms a reprieve. You gave them a chance to rebuild their numbers. And they rebuilt them with what are now all partially resistant members. Had you treated for double the time, you might have eliminated all the organisms. By stopping and restarting, they not only regrouped, instead of some organisms having some resistant mutations, now millions have those changes. That is what happens when you allow an infection to relapse instead of completing treatment. Now since most all the organisms in the infection have some mutations, you have millions of chances for the additional mutations which would confer complete resistance to occur in any one of them.

I hear what you're saying, but again, I've not seen evidence that most less-than-complete courses actually result in an actual relapse of "infection".
But I can see an greatly, greatly increased chance of recolonization with the target organism, which in the grand scheme of things with resistant organisms in the community, would be just as bad.

skeptigirl said:
Studies looking at optimal treatment length are going to be based on cure vs relapse. How is that not evidence you need X number of days of treatment or you risk relapse? What outcome do you think they are looking at?

Are you arguing relapse is not a contributing factor to antibiotic resistance?

You posted pictures of impetigo and worst case scenarios of UTIs in pregnant women, not information on optimal treatment length for preventing relapse!
 
We are all talking about different things in this thread. It is making it hard to discuss the issues.

Yes, that's pretty much what my long post was trying to tell you.

Ichne: It would help if you could quantify the 'arbitrary' range you are referring to. Saying I put words in your mouth when I am trying to resolve the different definitions we are both working with doesn't help matters. I can't read your mind.

You'll have to site specific examples since it would obviously vary. In other words are you claiming that in infection X where the standard Rx is for 7 days that you believe some people are fully treated in 2 days and some in 7? If that is the case then do you have any research backing that up? I do not believe that is the case and so far I have cited studies while you cited hallway medicine.

I'm sorry, but what is the point of quantifying anything? I find this request extraordinarily bizarre. I didn't make any quantitative statement in the first place, and I have no intention of doing so now. There wouldn't be any point to it. You obviously misunderstood my point and made a big deal out of a small observation, thinking that I was advocating a position that I was not. I specifically stated more than once that there is no way to tell how long a course any one person actually needs. You seem to agree, "since it will obviously vary". There are no consequences arising from that observation. It was merely illustrative of the original poster's "kernel of truth" that required further explication. People vary. Some infections are treatable in shorter courses than we employ because we use arbitrary lengths of time that are convenient for us and for testing purposes. Sometimes the antibiotic course is overkill. There is no big underlying truth beneath it. He was correct about that. It is OK to tell people so when they get something right. He was simply wrong about advocating short course therapy. Let it go.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom