Medicine should be taught in high school

I asked you to define your term, Ichne and you are offended? You made a rash claim that length of treatment was arbitrary which denies the fact it is evidence based.

arbitrary
1. Determined by chance, whim, or impulse, and not by necessity, reason, or principle: stopped at the first motel we passed, an arbitrary choice.
2. Based on or subject to individual judgment or preference: The diet imposes overall calorie limits, but daily menus are arbitrary.

1. Determined or marked by whim or caprice rather than reason: capricious, whimsical. See surprise/expect.
2. Based on individual judgment or discretion: discretionary, judgmental, personal, subjective. See opinion, surprise/expect.

arbitrary, lacking any natural basis or substantial justification.

Irrational; capricious.

The term arbitrary describes a course of action or a decision that is not based on reason or judgment but on personal will or discretion without regard to rules or standards.

An arbitrary decision is one made without regard for the facts and circumstances presented, and it connotes a disregard of the evidence.
I really don't understand why you would make the claim that the recommended length of a course of antibiotics was arbitrary and then act as if I had no reason to ask you to either clarify what you meant or back up your claim.
 
Kelly, it is you who needs to read the posts. I have answered your question over and over and I do understand what it is. You just don't like my answer because it doesn't fit in your fixed box: "must see study". I can't help you. Believe what you want. Enough is enough.
 
Kelly, it is you who needs to read the posts. I have answered your question over and over and I do understand what it is. You just don't like my answer because it doesn't fit in your fixed box: "must see study". I can't help you. Believe what you want. Enough is enough.

Yeah...I'm bad about the whole "wanting evidence" thing.
I'm not good at "just believing" people.
 
I asked you to define your term, Ichne and you are offended? You made a rash claim that length of treatment was arbitrary which denies the fact it is evidence based.

arbitraryI really don't understand why you would make the claim that the recommended length of a course of antibiotics was arbitrary and then act as if I had no reason to ask you to either clarify what you meant or back up your claim.

Jesus H. Christ, Skeptigirl, I made no such claim. I am not saying that there is no evidence behind the actual length of time used for antibiotic courses. What I said was that the course lengths we use are human inventions designed for convenience of administration and testing. That is all. It wasn't some grandiose claim, just a simple observation made by virtually everyone who prescribes a course of antibiotics. It is arbitrary. We all know the length is arbitrary. There is no evidence showing that in every single individual 10 days is better than 9.3 or 8.2. You know that humans vary. You know that in every study ever conducted there is a range of responses. That is why we offer statistical ranges in all papers.

Do you want me to prove to you that the sky is blue next? What is the friggin' point of this?
 
Not in the ordinary sense of the word "arbitrary." Accept it, you are wrong.
Nor would you expect there to be; if you knew anything about drug development.


Look, I have made it abundantly clear what I meant and outlined it in several posts. I have not left the definition hanging in the breeze unqualified. I even outlined why those sorts of time periods were chosen both by the drug companies and physicians involved in the studies, event though they were not absolutely precise time periods. I

As a physician who has been involved in drug studies I do know something about drug development. As a physician who uses these drugs I do know what I'm talking about.

I do not expect the drugs to be absolutely precise. For the fourth friggin' time I introduced this to demonstrate that the original proposer was not completely and utterly wrong. I was piecing out what was correct in what he said and what was wrong. Skeptigirl seemed to think I was saying something different from what I actually said. If you have not read the whole series of posts and seen, in context, what was communicated then I don't see your point.

I didn't make a big deal out of this. Others did. It isn't even an interesting point to make.
 
My interpretation (acting under the assumption that Ichneumonwasp, Skeptigirl and JJM all know what they are talking about)...

The available information is not arbitrary - for example, a 5-day course cures 80%, a 7-day course cures 92% and a 10-day course cures 95%. But the choice of which cure rate is the desirable choice is arbitrary in that it depends upon characterististics of the illness being treated, value judgements as to the goals of treatment, and other variables.

Does that work?

Linda
 
That is part of what I was saying (though, of course, the precise number of days depends on which antibiotic and which infection with which we deal). But the other part is that those numbers -- five day, seven day, ten day-- are arbitrary, human-chosen numbers. It might be more accurate to use 12.4 days, for instance, for a particular antibiotic. It isn't practical to use that sort of number, so we pick ten or fourteen days which is easier for us.

I never said, nor implied, that we chose the courses willy-nilly for no particular reason. The underlying point was that we choose the number of days for a course of antibiotics based on a balance between efficacy and side effects (as with all drug treatments), but we end up choosing a number of days that is convenient for testing and convenient for people to remember.

The ultimate point that I was making was that the original proposer implied that we use more antibiotics than we need for infections, so we should only take partial courses. I disagreed with him, but tried to point out that because of the fact we have chosen these arbitrary time periods that work for a population of folks, there are some people who do get what amounts to overkill with their antibiotic course -- so he was right to a limited extent (some people get more than what they absolutely need). I did not advocate that we change anything based on this information, just that reality is what it is.

I still do not understand why this minor point is so controversial.
 
I still do not understand why this minor point is so controversial.

I suspect it is similar to the use of "random" when describing evolution through natural selection.

I imagine you'd get a similar response if you pointed out that b.i.d or t.i.d dosing is arbitrary.

Linda
 
Last edited:
So it sounds like the prescribed duration of antibiotics is a process control issue with crappy feedback and a lot of noise.

What is needed is better feedback. A possible application for nano-scale sensor technology?
 
My interpretation (acting under the assumption that Ichneumonwasp, Skeptigirl and JJM all know what they are talking about)...

The available information is not arbitrary - for example, a 5-day course cures 80%, a 7-day course cures 92% and a 10-day course cures 95%. But the choice of which cure rate is the desirable choice is arbitrary in that it depends upon characterististics of the illness being treated, value judgements as to the goals of treatment, and other variables.

Does that work?

Linda
It does, for me.
 
I suspect it is similar to the use of "random" when describing evolution through natural selection.

I imagine you'd get a similar response if you pointed out that b.i.d or t.i.d dosing is arbitrary.

Linda

It did begin to seem eerily similar. I'm glad you stepped in. I feared this was going to turn into another dictionary war. I always find those sorts of discussions tedious because words are not writ in stone but share family resemblances and carry many connotations. I am sorry if I did not make myself clear, but I thought I had both at the beginning and in the way I discussed it afterwards.

And, yes, very much so with the dosing schedules. These are all arrived at for ease of administration. Granted, the differences between dosing schedules are based on elimination half-lifes, so again, they are not wholly arbitrary, but there is an arbitrary component to it. In my own field the dosing schedule info becomes even more complicated since the duration of action of a drug in the brain is not necessarily tied to its elimination half-life. If it were, we wouldn't be able to get away with once daily dosing of Depakote for migraine prophylaxis or once daily dosing of Keppra for seizures even though we shouldn't by looking simply at the half-life of these drugs.

Ivor the Engineer said:
So it sounds like the prescribed duration of antibiotics is a process control issue with crappy feedback and a lot of noise.

What is needed is better feedback. A possible application for nano-scale sensor technology?

Yeah, basically. It's the best we can do for now. Technology will probably change some of this in the future, but we're still probably a long way off.
 
My interpretation (acting under the assumption that Ichneumonwasp, Skeptigirl and JJM all know what they are talking about)...

The available information is not arbitrary - for example, a 5-day course cures 80%, a 7-day course cures 92% and a 10-day course cures 95%. But the choice of which cure rate is the desirable choice is arbitrary in that it depends upon characterististics of the illness being treated, value judgements as to the goals of treatment, and other variables.

Does that work?

Linda
Exactly.
 
This was the original question:
Has it ever been tested or 'proven' that taking a half course of antibiotics contributes to resistance more than a full course?

I ask because someone asked me about that a couple of weeks ago. Her doctor told her to only take her antibiotics till she started feeling well again, which surprised me.:confused:
And it was posted after a link to this: The Problem of Antimicrobial Resistance; NIH.
The advantage microbes gain from their innate adaptability is augmented by the widespread and sometimes inappropriate use of antibiotics. A physician, wishing to placate an insistent patient who has a virus or an as-yet undiagnosed condition, sometimes inappropriately prescribes antibiotics. Also, when a patient does not finish taking a prescription for antibiotics, some bacteria may remain. These bacterial survivors are more likely to develop resistance and spread. Hospitals also provide a fertile environment for antibiotic-resistant germs as close contact among sick patients and extensive use of antibiotics select for resistant bacteria. Scientists also believe that the practice of adding antibiotics to agricultural feed promotes drug resistance.
Emphasis mine. And while I tried to explain the reasons for this, kelly seems to think it needs a clinical trial or something. It is basic biology. You don't need a clinical trial to understand how eliminating an entire population of organisms vs leaving behind those that were the last to die and thus the most resistant is a greater risk for developing antibiotic resistance.

The issue of the remaining organisms in your body which were not targets of the antibiotic being exposed to more antibiotic vs less is a factor for increasing resistance. There is direct relationship between the amount of exposure and amount of resistance developing. Which is why the provider needs to be conservative in prescribing. And for the same reason, we use research to find the shortest amount of time needed to cure most infections.

But leaving some bacteria behind when you could have eliminated all the population is why there is a basic tenant of having a patient complete the prescribed course of antibiotics.

There are two separate issues and for whatever reason, some people are having a hard time seeing that:

Less antibiotics, yes, noble goal, less resistance overall, over time.

But once you commit to treat an infection, then not finishing that course of antibiotics is more likely to leave that pathogen behind with resistance beginning to accumulate.
 
Erm, back to teaching stuff in classrooms, should my teacher really be telling the students to paint iodine on their feet instead of taking iron supplements for low iron levels? I might have a really bad cold, but this advice seems to be the worst she has given to us yet.

hooray for teachers teaching this awesome medical stuff to students :(
And yeah, remember, she is preparing us to work in hospitals and health clinics.
 
Erm, back to teaching stuff in classrooms, should my teacher really be telling the students to paint iodine on their feet instead of taking iron supplements for low iron levels? I might have a really bad cold, but this advice seems to be the worst she has given to us yet.

hooray for teachers teaching this awesome medical stuff to students :(
And yeah, remember, she is preparing us to work in hospitals and health clinics.

I gotta say, now I understand why you were crabby in the Cold FX thread. And that it's impressive that you've managed to stick it out this long. But something needs to be done about this. You mentioned something about complaining once you have the piece of paper in your hot little hands. Whatever I can do to help, I'd be happy to try.

Linda
 
Exactly Skeptigirl. This is the calibre of teaching we get at this school. We get told horrible advice with no reason as to why it would ever work. And yeah, apparently the hospitals use homeopathy regularly for patients (she said the tinctures like belladonna that used are the same as homeopathic remedies), and flower remedies are capable of changing the water you drink because it changes the shape of water molecules.

I can only guess that the IO in IOdine means she thinks there is iron in it. She doesn't know a thing about basic chemistry.

The last email that was read to us by the same teacher just last week as factual was about how people have died from drinking coke from coke cans poisoned at the warehouse with rat pee.

Thank you Linda. I may need some help in a few months on addressing this and saving more students from my fate.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom